AP BIOLOGY · UNIT 5 · HEREDITY

Peas, chance and family trees

A friar counting peas worked out the rules of inheritance before anyone had seen a chromosome. Follow the alleles through his crosses, use two rules of probability to predict any cross, test real counts against a ratio with chi-square, and read a family tree.

AP Biology 5.33 lessons8 chaptersdry lab

Start learningRun the dry labTeach it

One pea cross from start to finish. Follow the two alleles from the parents into their gametes, into the F1, and through a Punnett square to the three to one of the F2.
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Eight chapters and a dry lab: one gene (chapters 1 to 3), the rules of chance (4), two genes (5), testing counts against a ratio (6), and family trees (7 and 8). Make each prediction before you open the answer.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1The words for what is inherited
  2. 2Two alleles in, one allele out
  3. 3Predict the offspring with a square
  4. 4“And” multiplies, “or” adds
  5. 5Two genes, each going its own way
  6. 6Close enough, or too far to be chance?
  7. 7A family tree is data
  8. 8Read the pattern, then give the chance

5.3.A Genes, alleles and traits

The words for what is inherited

  • A gene is a length of DNA at one place, its locus, on a chromosome. Different versions of a gene are alleles.
  • An organism’s genotype is the set of alleles it inherited for one or more genes: homozygous (two the same) or heterozygous (two different) for each gene.
  • Its phenotype is the observable expression of the traits it inherited.
  • A dominant allele shows in a heterozygote. A recessive allele shows only in a homozygote.
  • A cross runs from the P generation (true-breeding parents) to the F1 and the F2.

The detail

  • Gregor Mendel, a friar, crossed garden peas (Pisum sativum) and published his results in 1866. He followed seven traits, each with two clear forms, such as yellow or green seeds.
  • You are diploid: you have two alleles of each gene, one on each chromosome of a homologous pair.
  • By convention a capital letter is the dominant allele and a small letter the recessive one.
  • For many genes a recessive allele makes no working protein, and one working copy makes enough to give the trait.
  • True-breeding plants are homozygous, so bred with their own kind they always give offspring like themselves.

Watch out

  • Dominant does not mean common, strong or better, and recessive does not mean rare or harmful. Dominant only describes what shows in a heterozygote.
  • There is no “gene for yellow seeds”. There is a gene for seed color, and its Y allele makes the seed yellow.

In 1866 a friar named Gregor Mendel published eight years of crosses between garden pea plants, Pisum sativum. He followed seven traits, each with two clear forms: seeds yellow or green, seeds round or wrinkled, flowers purple or white. Nobody had yet seen a chromosome, but the rules he found are the ones chromosomes follow. First, the words.

A gene is a length of DNA at one place, its locus, on a chromosome. Different versions of the same gene are alleles. The seed color gene in peas has an allele for yellow seeds (Y) and one for green (y). A diploid organism has two alleles of each gene, one on each chromosome of a homologous pair.

The set of alleles an organism inherited, for one gene or for several, is its genotype. If the two alleles of a gene are the same, the organism is homozygous for that gene (YY or yy). If they differ, it is heterozygous (Yy). The phenotype is the observable expression of those traits: a yellow seed, a purple flower.

A dominant allele shows its effect with one copy or with two. A recessive allele shows only when there is no dominant allele beside it. So YY and Yy seeds are both yellow, and only yy is green. For many genes the reason is simple: the recessive allele makes no working protein, and one working copy makes enough.

Crosses are described in generations. The parents you choose are the P generation; Mendel used true-breeding parents, which are homozygous. Their offspring are the F1 generation, and the offspring of F1 plants are the F2 generation.

Remember it The generations of a cross: Parents First, Second Follows

  • ParentsP generationthe true-breeding plants you cross
  • FirstF1 generationtheir offspring
  • SecondF2 generationthe offspring of two F1 plants
  • A gene is a place on a chromosome; an allele is a version of it.
  • Genotype: the alleles inherited. Phenotype: the observable expression of the traits.
  • A dominant allele shows in a heterozygote; a recessive allele only in a homozygote.
Watch out Dominant does not mean common, strong or better, and recessive does not mean rare or harmful. Dominant only describes what shows in a heterozygote. A recessive allele does not fade away either: it is still there in a heterozygote and can show again in a later generation.

Two yellow-seeded pea plants are crossed, and some of their offspring have green seeds. What must be true of both parents?

Yya pair of homologouschromosomescentromereallele Yallele ythe gene: one placeThe gene is the place.The alleles are its versions.YYYYhomozygousboth alleles the sameYyYyheterozygoustwo different allelesyyyyhomozygousboth alleles the sameGenotype: the alleles an organism has for a gene.ABO blood groupgenotypea scar from a cutenvironmentadult heightgenotypeenvironmentBar lengths show the idea, not measurements.
  1. A pair of homologous chromosomes. The gene is one place, its locus, on the chromosome. Each chromosome carries one allele of it, here Y and y.
  2. The two alleles make the genotype. Two the same is homozygous. Two different is heterozygous.
  3. The phenotype is what can be observed. Some traits follow the genotype alone, some the environment, and many both.
YYYYYyYyyyyyplentyenoughnone that worksworking proteinfaulty proteinyellowyellowgreen
  1. Three genotypes of the seed color gene: two homozygous and one heterozygous.
  2. The gene makes a protein. A Y allele makes a working one, and one working copy makes enough to give the trait.
  3. The phenotypes: YY and Yy are both yellow, so Y is dominant. Only yy is green.

5.3.A The law of segregation

Two alleles in, one allele out

  • Mendel crossed true-breeding purple-flowered and white-flowered peas: a monohybrid cross. Every F1 plant was purple; in the F2, white came back in about a quarter.
  • The law of segregation: the two alleles of a gene separate into different gametes, so each gamete carries one.
  • The reason is meiosis: the two alleles sit on homologous chromosomes, which separate in meiosis I.
  • Fertilization fuses two haploid gametes, restores the diploid number, and gives the zygote a new combination of alleles.

The detail

  • Mendel counted 705 purple-flowered and 224 white-flowered plants in the F2: close to 3 to 1.
  • White had not been blended away in the F1. It was hidden, whole, and came back unchanged.
  • A heterozygote makes two kinds of gamete in equal numbers, half with each allele.
  • Which two gametes meet at fertilization is chance, so every offspring is a fresh draw.

Links across the course

  • Meiosis (5.1 and 5.2) is where the homologous chromosomes pair and separate. Mendel described its result before anyone had watched it.

Watch out

  • A gamete never carries both alleles of a gene, and never carries none. It carries exactly one.

Mendel began with one trait at a time. He crossed true-breeding purple-flowered peas with true-breeding white-flowered ones, a monohybrid cross. Every F1 plant had purple flowers. White seemed to have gone. Then he let the F1 plants pollinate themselves, and in the F2 white came back: he counted 705 purple and 224 white, close to 3 to 1.

White had not been blended away. It had been hidden, whole, in the F1 and came back unchanged. Mendel’s explanation is the law of segregation: each plant has two alleles of the gene, and the two separate when gametes form, so each gamete carries only one. A Pp plant makes gametes with P and gametes with p in equal numbers.

Meiosis explains why. The two alleles of a gene sit at the same locus on the two chromosomes of a homologous pair. In meiosis I the homologous chromosomes separate and go to different cells, and the alleles go with them.

Then fertilization puts two alleles together again. It usually fuses two haploid gametes, which restores the diploid number of chromosomes and gives the zygote a combination of alleles that neither parent had. Which gametes meet is chance, and that chance is where the 3 to 1 comes from.

  • Segregation: the two alleles of a gene separate into different gametes.
  • It happens because homologous chromosomes separate in meiosis I.
  • Fertilization restores the pair and makes new combinations of alleles.
Watch out A ratio is a prediction about chance, not a promise. Four seeds from a Pp × Pp cross need not be three purple and one white, any more than four coin flips must give two heads.

Which event in meiosis does the law of segregation describe?

Mendel’s flower color cross from the P generation to the F2. Before each caption appears, say where the P and p alleles are about to go.
Making a cross in a pea plantStigmaAnther: pollen grainshold the male gametesOvary: ovuleshold the female gametesA pea flower pollinatesitself: pollen lands on itsown stigmaPollen donorReceiving floweranthers removedpollen carried acrossP generationYYyellow seeds×yygreen seedscrossF1 generationYyall yellow seedsself-pollinateF2 generationpollen from the F1 plantYyYyYYYyYyyy3 yellow : 1 green1 YY : 2 Yy : 1 yy
  1. A pea flower makes both kinds of gamete. Pollen forms in the anthers and holds the male gametes. The ovules in the ovary hold the female gametes.
  2. Left alone, a pea flower pollinates itself: its pollen reaches its own stigma.
  3. For a cross, the anthers are removed from the receiving flower, and pollen is carried from the donor to its stigma.
  4. Cross two true-breeding parents (the P generation), here for seed color. Every seed of the F1 generation has one allele from each parent.
  5. Let the F1 plants self-pollinate to make the F2 generation. The Punnett square shows every way their gametes can combine.

5.3.A Punnett squares and the test cross

Predict the offspring with a square

  • A Punnett square puts one parent’s gametes along the top and the other’s down the side. Each box is one equally likely offspring.
  • Pp × Pp gives a genotypic ratio of 1 PP : 2 Pp : 1 pp and a phenotypic ratio of 3 purple : 1 white.
  • A monohybrid cross shows which allele is dominant: the trait in every F1 plant.
  • A test cross with a homozygous recessive reveals an unknown genotype.

The detail

  • A square works backward as well: from the offspring you can deduce the genotypes of the parents.
  • The trait that vanishes in the F1 and returns in a quarter of the F2 is the recessive one.
  • In a test cross the recessive parent adds only recessive alleles, so the offspring show the other parent’s gametes directly.
  • All offspring dominant: the unknown parent was homozygous. Half and half: it was heterozygous.

Try it

  • On the tool, cross two heterozygotes and predict before you fill the square. Then breed 30 offspring a few times and watch the counts scatter around 3 to 1.

Watch out

  • The genotypic ratio (1 : 2 : 1) and the phenotypic ratio (3 : 1) describe the same offspring. Read the question to see which one it asks for.

A Punnett square turns the law of segregation into a prediction. Write one parent’s gametes along the top and the other’s down the side, then fill each box with the two alleles that meet there. Every box is equally likely, because each kind of gamete is equally likely.

For Pp × Pp the four boxes are PP, Pp, Pp and pp. Count them two ways. By genotype: 1 PP : 2 Pp : 1 pp, the genotypic ratio. By what you would see: 3 purple : 1 white, the phenotypic ratio. They are different ratios for the same offspring, and mixing them up is one of the most common ways to lose a point.

A monohybrid cross also tells you which allele is dominant. Cross two true-breeding parents that differ, and the trait that every F1 plant shows is the dominant one. The trait that vanishes in the F1 and returns in about a quarter of the F2 is recessive.

A purple-flowered plant could be PP or Pp, and you cannot tell by looking. A test cross finds out: cross it with a white-flowered plant, pp. The recessive parent gives every offspring a p, so the offspring show which alleles the purple parent passed on. All purple: it was PP. About half purple and half white: it was Pp.

A square works backward as well. From the offspring you can deduce the parents, which is how the genotypes of real plants, animals and people are worked out.

  • Each box of a Punnett square is one equally likely offspring.
  • Pp × Pp: genotypes 1 : 2 : 1, phenotypes 3 : 1.
  • Test cross: unknown × homozygous recessive. Any recessive offspring means the unknown parent was heterozygous.
Watch out A genotypic ratio and a phenotypic ratio are not the same thing. 1 : 2 : 1 counts genotypes; 3 : 1 counts what you can see. Say which one the question asks for.

A purple-flowered pea of unknown genotype is test crossed with a white-flowered plant. Of 40 offspring, 21 are purple and 19 are white. What was the genotype of the purple parent?

Pp × Pp gives 3 purple : 1 white. Predict the offspring if one of the two parents were PP instead.

P generationfemale parentYYyellow seedsmale parentyygreen seedsxF1 offspringmale gametes, in pollenfemale gametesyyYYyellowgreenP generationfemale parentYYyellow seedsmale parentyygreen seedsxF1 offspringmale gametes, in pollenfemale gametesyyYYYyYyYyYyyellowgreen
  1. Each parent makes gametes by meiosis, one allele of each gene in each. The female parent's go down the side of the Punnett square, the male parent's along the top.
  2. Each cell joins one gamete from each parent: a possible offspring, every cell as likely as the next. The F1: genotypes all Yy; phenotypes all yellow.
Pick the two parents’ genotypes, predict the offspring, fill the square, then breed 30 and see how a real sample scatters around the prediction.

5.3.A The rules of probability

“And” multiplies, “or” adds

  • A Punnett square is a picture of chance. Two rules of probability give the same answers without drawing one.
  • Multiplication rule: if A and B are independent, P(A and B) = P(A) × P(B).
  • Addition rule: if A and B are mutually exclusive, P(A or B) = P(A) + P(B).
  • Each fertilization is independent of the last, so the chance is the same for every offspring.
  • For several genes on different chromosomes, work out one gene at a time, then multiply.

The detail

  • A probability is a fraction from 0 (never) to 1 (always).
  • Independent events do not affect each other: which allele the egg carries tells you nothing about the sperm.
  • Mutually exclusive events cannot both happen: one offspring cannot be both AA and aa.
  • Both rules are printed on the AP equations and formulas sheet, so learn when to use each, not the symbols.

Examples

  • Aa × Aa, the chance of aa: 1/2 × 1/2 = 1/4 (an a from one parent and an a from the other).
  • The chance of Aa: 1/4 + 1/4 = 1/2 (A from the mother and a from the father, or the other way around).
  • AaBbDd × AaBbdd, the chance of an offspring that shows A, is bb and is Dd: 3/4 × 1/4 × 1/2 = 3/32.

Watch out

  • Chance has no memory. A couple’s earlier children do not change the chance for the next one.

A Punnett square is a picture of chance: each box is as likely as the next. Two rules of probability give the same answers without a drawing, and they keep working when a square would need hundreds of boxes. Both are printed on the AP equations and formulas sheet.

The multiplication rule is for “and”. If two events are independent, the chance that both happen is the product of their chances: P(A and B) = P(A) × P(B). In the cross Aa × Aa, the egg carries a with chance 1/2 and the sperm carries a with chance 1/2, and the two do not affect each other. So the chance of an aa offspring is 1/2 × 1/2 = 1/4.

The addition rule is for “or”. If two events are mutually exclusive, the chance that one or the other happens is the sum of their chances: P(A or B) = P(A) + P(B). An Aa offspring can be made two ways: A from the mother and a from the father (1/4), or a from the mother and A from the father (1/4). It cannot be both at once, so the chance of Aa is 1/4 + 1/4 = 1/2.

Each fertilization is independent of the one before. If the chance of aa is 1/4, it is 1/4 for the first offspring, the fifth and the tenth, whatever the earlier ones were.

The rules earn their place when a cross has several genes. If the genes are on different chromosomes they are inherited independently (chapter 5), so treat each gene as its own small cross and multiply.

Example In the cross AaBbDd × AaBbdd, what is the chance of an offspring that shows the dominant A trait, is bb and is Dd?
  1. Aa × Aa: shows A (AA or Aa) with chance 3/4.
  2. Bb × Bb: bb with chance 1/4.
  3. Dd × dd: Dd with chance 1/2.
  4. All three, so multiply: 3/4 × 1/4 × 1/2 = 3/32.
And the chance that it is homozygous at the first gene, AA or aa? Those are mutually exclusive, so add: 1/4 + 1/4 = 1/2.

Remember it Which rule: listen for the word

  • AndMultiplyboth happen: independent events
  • OrAddeither happens: mutually exclusive events
  • Independent events, “and”: multiply.
  • Mutually exclusive events, “or”: add.
  • Several genes: one gene at a time, then multiply.
Watch out Chance has no memory. Each fertilization is a new draw from the same gametes, so a couple’s earlier children do not change the chance for the next child.

Two parents are both heterozygous (Aa) for a recessive trait. Their first two children both show the trait. What is the chance that their third child shows it?

In the cross AaBb × AaBb, with the genes on different chromosomes, what is the chance of an aabb offspring?

A coin and a die: heads and a 4die123456headsH 1H 2H 3H 4H 5H 6tailsT 1T 2T 3T 4T 5T 6heads: 1/2a 4: 1/6both: 1/2 of 1/6 = 1/121 box in 12gamete of parent 1gamete of parent 2offspringAaAa1/2A1/2a1/2AAA1/41/2aAa1/41/2AAa1/41/2aaa1/4Two paths give Aa: 1/4 + 1/4 = 1/2Three genes, one at a timethe crossoffspring wantedchanceAaAadominant A3/4BbBbbb1/4DdddDd1/2all three together:3/41/41/2= 3/32
  1. And: multiply. Heads is 1/2 and a 4 is 1/6. For both to happen, take a half of a sixth: 1 of the 12 equally likely outcomes.
  2. Or: add. Each path through the tree is 1/2 of 1/2, so 1/4. Two different paths give a heterozygote, and either will do: 1/4 + 1/4 = 1/2.
  3. Several genes. Genes that assort independently are separate events. Work out each gene by itself, then multiply: 3/4 of 1/4 of 1/2 is 3/32, with no square of 64 boxes.
Three tasks: coins and dice, one gene as a tree of chances, then a cross of several genes worked one gene at a time. Every question is made fresh, so yours will differ from your neighbor’s.

5.3.A The law of independent assortment

Two genes, each going its own way

  • A dihybrid cross follows two genes at once.
  • The law of independent assortment: the alleles of one gene are passed into gametes independently of the alleles of another. It applies to genes on different chromosomes.
  • The reason is meiosis: each pair of homologous chromosomes lines up on its own at metaphase I.
  • YyRr makes four kinds of gamete in equal numbers. YyRr × YyRr gives 9 : 3 : 3 : 1; the test cross YyRr × yyrr gives 1 : 1 : 1 : 1.

The detail

  • Mendel crossed true-breeding round yellow peas with wrinkled green ones. Every F1 seed was round and yellow.
  • His F2 gave 315 round yellow, 108 round green, 101 wrinkled yellow and 32 wrinkled green seeds: all four combinations, close to 9 : 3 : 3 : 1.
  • 9 : 3 : 3 : 1 is two 3 : 1 ratios multiplied: 3/4 × 3/4 = 9/16 show both dominant traits, and 1/4 × 1/4 = 1/16 show neither.
  • A pea has seven pairs of chromosomes, and Mendel’s seven genes are not one to a pair. The seed color and seed shape genes are on different chromosomes.

Links across the course

  • Genes close together on one chromosome do not assort independently. They are genetically linked, which is 5.4.

Watch out

  • A gamete gets one allele of each gene: YR, Yr, yR or yr. Never Yy or Rr, and never one letter alone.

A dihybrid cross follows two genes at once. Mendel crossed true-breeding peas with round yellow seeds and true-breeding peas with wrinkled green seeds. Every F1 seed was round and yellow. The question was the F2: would round stay with yellow and wrinkled with green, as they came from the parents, or would the two traits part company?

They parted. Mendel counted 315 round yellow, 108 round green, 101 wrinkled yellow and 32 wrinkled green seeds. All four combinations appeared, in a ratio close to 9 : 3 : 3 : 1. This is the law of independent assortment: the alleles of one gene are passed into gametes independently of the alleles of another.

Meiosis explains it, for genes on different chromosomes. At metaphase I each pair of homologous chromosomes lines up at the middle of the cell on its own, facing the poles one way or the other, whatever the other pairs do. A YyRr plant can send Y with R and y with r, or Y with r and y with R. Both arrangements are equally likely, so it makes four kinds of gamete, YR, Yr, yR and yr, in equal numbers.

Cross two YyRr plants and a 4 by 4 Punnett square has 16 equally likely boxes: 9 yellow round, 3 yellow wrinkled, 3 green round and 1 green wrinkled. The rules of chapter 4 give the same thing faster. Each gene alone gives 3 : 1, so 3/4 × 3/4 = 9/16 show both dominant traits, 3/4 × 1/4 = 3/16 show one or the other, and 1/4 × 1/4 = 1/16 show neither. In the test cross YyRr × yyrr the recessive parent adds only yr, so the offspring show the four gametes of the other parent: 1 : 1 : 1 : 1.

The law has a limit. A pea has seven pairs of chromosomes, and Mendel’s seven genes are not one to a pair, but the seed color and seed shape genes are on different chromosomes. Two genes close together on the same chromosome tend to be inherited together, and their ratios are not Mendel’s. That is genetic linkage, in 5.4.

Steps
  1. Write both parents’ genotypes.
  2. Write each parent’s gametes: one allele of each gene, so a YyRr parent gives YR, Yr, yR and yr.
  3. Put one parent’s gametes along the top and the other’s down the side, and fill in the square.
  4. Count the phenotypes, remembering that a dominant allele shows.
  • Independent assortment holds for genes on different chromosomes.
  • Each pair of homologous chromosomes lines up on its own at metaphase I.
  • YyRr × YyRr: 9 : 3 : 3 : 1. YyRr × yyrr: 1 : 1 : 1 : 1.
Watch out A gamete carries one allele of each gene. The gametes of a YyRr plant are YR, Yr, yR and yr: never Yy or Rr, which would be two alleles of one gene and none of the other.

A plant YyRr is crossed with a plant yyrr. What proportion of the offspring are yellow and round?

A test cross YyRr × yyrr should give four kinds of offspring in equal numbers. In one experiment, two of the four kinds are far more common than the other two. What would that suggest?

YyRrEach pair lines up at the equator.Which partner faces which pole is chance.poleequatorone wayYyRrYRyrgametesor the other wayYyrRYryRgametesBoth ways are equally likely:four kinds of gamete, in equal numbers.YyRr × YyRrYRYRYrYryRyRyryreggsspermYYRRYYRrYyRRYyRrYYRrYYrrYyRrYyrrYyRRYyRryyRRyyRrYyRrYyrryyRryyrr9 yellow, round3 yellow, wrinkled3 green, round1 green, wrinkled9 : 3 : 3 : 1
  1. In meiosis I each pair of homologous chromosomes lines up at the middle of the cell, and the partners go to opposite poles.
  2. The pairs line up either way around, independently. Two equally likely ways give four kinds of gamete: YR, yr, Yr and yR.
  3. A YyRr × YyRr cross: put each parent’s four kinds of gamete along the sides of a 4 by 4 square.
  4. Fill in the 16 genotypes, each equally likely.
  5. Read off the phenotypes: 9 : 3 : 3 : 1.
Two pairs of chromosomes, one carrying Y and y, the other R and r. Before the pairs line up, list the gametes a YyRr cell can make.
P generationfemale parentYYRRyellow, roundmale parentyyrrgreen, wrinkledxF1 offspringmale gametes, in pollenfemale gametesyrYRyellow roundyellow wrinkledgreen roundgreen wrinkledP generationfemale parentYYRRyellow, roundmale parentyyrrgreen, wrinkledxF1 offspringmale gametes, in pollenfemale gametesyrYRYyRryellow roundyellow wrinkledgreen roundgreen wrinkled
  1. Each parent makes gametes by meiosis, one allele of each gene in each. The female parent's go down the side of the Punnett square, the male parent's along the top.
  2. Each cell joins one gamete from each parent: a possible offspring, every cell as likely as the next. The F1: genotypes all YyRr; phenotypes all yellow round.
Choose two parents for the seed color and seed shape genes. Predict the ratio, fill the 16 boxes, then breed a sample.

5.3.A The chi-square test

Close enough, or too far to be chance?

  • Real counts never match a ratio exactly. A chi-square test asks whether the difference is small enough to be chance.
  • The null hypothesis: there is no significant difference between the observed counts and the counts the ratio predicts.
  • Chi-square is the sum of (o − e)² ÷ e over every kind of offspring, with o the observed and e the expected count.
  • Degrees of freedom: the number of possible outcomes minus one. Look up the critical value at p = 0.05.
  • Chi-square above the critical value: reject the null hypothesis. At or below it: fail to reject.

The detail

  • Expected counts come from the ratio: the total number counted times each fraction.
  • The formula and the table of critical values are on the AP equations and formulas sheet.
  • Mendel’s two-gene F2: chi-square is 0.47, below 7.81 for 3 degrees of freedom. Fail to reject: the counts fit 9 : 3 : 3 : 1.
  • His flower color F2: chi-square is 0.39, below 3.84 for 1 degree of freedom. Fail to reject: the counts fit 3 : 1.

When to use it

  • Chi-square is for counts in categories: how many of each kind. It is used well beyond genetics.
  • It is not the test for means or measurements, and it needs the counts themselves, not percentages.

Watch out

  • Fail to reject is not the same as proving. It means these counts give no reason to doubt the ratio.
  • The null hypothesis is the one tested: the counts fit. It is not your own hunch that something differs.

Mendel expected 9 : 3 : 3 : 1 and counted 315, 108, 101 and 32. From 556 seeds the ratio predicts 312.75, 104.25, 104.25 and 34.75. Nobody counts three quarters of a seed, and chance decides which gametes meet, so real counts never match exactly. When is a difference small enough to blame on chance? A chi-square test answers that, in five steps.

1. State the null hypothesis, in terms of the cross. The null hypothesis says there is no significant difference between the observed counts and the counts expected from 9 : 3 : 3 : 1: any difference is due to chance. 2. Work out the expected counts: the total times each fraction of the ratio, so 556 × 9/16 = 312.75 and so on.

3. Calculate chi-square: for each kind of offspring take (o − e)² ÷ e, where o is the observed count and e the expected, then add them up. The further the counts are from the prediction, the bigger the sum. 4. Find the degrees of freedom: the number of possible outcomes minus one, so 3 for four kinds of seed. 5. Compare with the critical value for those degrees of freedom at p = 0.05, from the table on the equations sheet.

If chi-square is above the critical value, a difference this big would come about by chance less than 5 percent of the time, and you reject the null hypothesis. If it is at or below the critical value, you fail to reject it. Mendel’s seeds give 0.47, far below 7.81: fail to reject. His flower color count, 705 purple and 224 white against 3 : 1, gives 0.39 with 1 degree of freedom, below 3.84: fail to reject again.

Critical values of chi-square, as on the AP equations sheet
Degrees of freedom1234
p = 0.053.845.997.819.49
p = 0.016.639.2111.3413.28

Chi-square is for counts in categories: how many of each kind. It is used well beyond genetics, for example to ask whether animals choose between two habitats at random. It is not the test for means or measurements, such as the heights of two groups of plants, and it needs the counts themselves, not percentages. Now test an ear of corn of your own in the dry lab.

Remember it The five steps: Hungry Elves Cook Delicious Cakes

  • HungryHypothesisstate the null: the counts fit the ratio
  • ElvesExpectedtotal × each fraction of the ratio
  • CookCalculatethe sum of (o − e)² ÷ e
  • DeliciousDegrees of freedompossible outcomes minus one
  • CakesComparewith the critical value at p = 0.05
  • Null hypothesis: no significant difference between observed and expected counts.
  • Chi-square = the sum of (o − e)² ÷ e; degrees of freedom = outcomes minus one.
  • Above the critical value: reject. At or below: fail to reject.
Watch out Fail to reject is not the same as proving. It means these counts give no reason to doubt the ratio; a bigger sample might. And the null hypothesis is the one tested, that the counts fit the ratio. It is not your own prediction that something differs. Never write “accept”.

An ear of corn has 290 purple and 110 yellow kernels. Tested against 3 : 1, chi-square is 1.33 with 1 degree of freedom, and the critical value is 3.84. What do you conclude?

Which of these sets of data could be tested with chi-square?

Do the counts fit the ratio?expected from 9 : 3 : 3 : 1observed in 556 seeds312.75315roundyellow104.25108roundgreen104.25101wrinkledyellow34.7532wrinkledgreenkind of seedoe(o − e)² / eround yellow315312.750.016round green108104.250.135wrinkled yellow101104.250.101wrinkled green3234.750.218sum = chi-square0.47024681012chi-square valuecritical value 7.81fail to rejectthe nullreject thenull hypothesis0.47Two genes: 315, 108, 101 and 32 seedsdegrees of freedom = 4 kinds − 1 = 3, p = 0.05024681012chi-square valuecritical value 3.84fail to rejectthe nullreject thenull hypothesis0.39One gene: 705 purple and 224 white flowersdegrees of freedom = 2 kinds − 1 = 1, p = 0.05
  1. Mendel’s 556 seeds: the expected counts from 9 : 3 : 3 : 1 against the counts he observed.
  2. Chi-square is the sum of (o − e)² ÷ e over the four kinds of seed: 0.47.
  3. With 3 degrees of freedom and p = 0.05 the critical value is 7.81. 0.47 is below it, so you fail to reject the null hypothesis.
  4. His flower color F2 against 3 : 1 gives 0.39. Two kinds of plant, so 1 degree of freedom and a critical value of 3.84: fail to reject.

5.3.A Pedigrees

A family tree is data

  • A pedigree follows one trait through a family. Squares are males, circles are females, and a filled symbol shows the trait.
  • You cannot cross people, so you read the pattern instead.
  • Unaffected parents with an affected child: the allele is recessive, and both parents are heterozygous.
  • Affected parents with an unaffected child: the allele is dominant, and both parents are heterozygous.
  • Once you know the pattern, deduce each person’s genotype. A carrier has one recessive allele and does not show the trait.

The detail

  • A line across joins two parents, and lines down lead to their children. Generations are numbered I, II, III from the top.
  • A recessive trait can skip a generation, hidden in carriers. A dominant trait does not: every affected person has an affected parent.
  • Work from the people you are sure of. Anyone who shows a recessive trait is homozygous recessive.
  • Where a person could be either of two genotypes, write both, for example A_.

Try it

  • On the tool, test each idea against the family and see which members rule it out. Cases 1 and 3 are autosomal.
  • The film’s last two clues and the tool’s case 2 are about genes on the X chromosome, which is 5.4.

Watch out

  • A pattern that fits is not proof. A small family may fit more than one pattern, so say “consistent with” unless the tree rules the others out.

You cannot cross people and count a hundred offspring. What you have instead is a family tree, a pedigree, and it is data to be read like any table. Squares are males and circles are females. A filled symbol means the person shows the trait. A line across joins two parents, lines down lead to their children, and the generations are numbered I, II, III from the top.

Two patterns settle whether the allele behind a trait is dominant or recessive. If two unaffected parents have an affected child, the allele is recessive: it was hidden in both parents, so both are heterozygous. If two affected parents have an unaffected child, the allele is dominant: each parent must also carry a hidden recessive allele to have passed on.

Other signs point the same way but prove less. A recessive trait can skip a generation, carried unseen. A dominant trait does not skip: every affected person has an affected parent.

Once you know the pattern you can deduce genotypes, person by person. Start with the people you are sure of. Everyone who shows a recessive trait is homozygous recessive, aa. Each of their parents and each of their children must have at least one a. An unaffected person with one recessive allele is a carrier. Where the tree leaves two possibilities, write both: A_ means AA or Aa.

Remember it Two clues that settle it

  • QuietUnaffected parents, affected childrecessive: both parents are carriers
  • LoudAffected parents, unaffected childdominant: both parents are heterozygous
  • Unaffected parents, affected child: recessive.
  • Affected parents, unaffected child: dominant.
  • A carrier has one recessive allele and does not show the trait.
Watch out A pattern that fits is not proof. A small family may fit more than one pattern of inheritance, so say “consistent with” unless the tree rules the others out.

In a pedigree, two affected parents have an unaffected daughter. What does that show about the trait?

A family tree for one conditionmalefemaleaffectedopen = unaffectedIIIIIItwo unaffectedparentsaffected daughterNnNnnnN_N_affected daughter
  1. The key: squares are males, circles are females, filled symbols show the trait. A line across joins two parents, and lines down lead to their children.
  2. Two unaffected parents (generation I) have an affected daughter (generation II). The allele was hidden in both parents.
  3. Deducing the genotypes: a recessive trait needs nn in the daughter and one n from each parent, so both parents are Nn.
Four small families, one clue lit up in each. The first two are this chapter’s; the last two are about genes on the X chromosome, a preview of 5.4.
IIIIII121234512IIIIII121234512malefemaleaffectedcousins married
  1. A condition no one in the family had heard of appears in a daughter. Her parents are first cousins. Squares are men, circles women; a filled symbol is affected. Roman numerals number the generations.
  2. Look first at I-1, I-2 and II-4, ringed: they rule out at least one way of inheriting. Which patterns could give this tree, and which are ruled out?
Three made-up families and made-up traits. Test each pattern of inheritance against the tree, see who rules it out, then deduce the genotypes. Cases 1 and 3 are autosomal.

5.3.A From data to a pattern, and a prediction

Read the pattern, then give the chance

  • Counts from a cross, or a pedigree, can often show the pattern of inheritance: dominant or recessive, and autosomal or not.
  • Autosomal: males and females are affected alike. A different pattern in the two sexes points to a sex-linked gene.
  • Two traits that stay together more often than 9 : 3 : 3 : 1 allows point to genetically linked genes.
  • With the pattern known, the rules of probability give the chance for the next offspring.
  • Two carriers: each child has a 1/4 chance of the recessive trait. An unaffected child of two carriers is a carrier with chance 2/3.

The detail

  • An autosome is any chromosome that is not a sex chromosome.
  • In a table of counts: 3 to 1 in the F2, the same in both sexes, means one autosomal gene with the common trait dominant.
  • Sex-linked and genetically linked genes are explained in 5.4. Here, learn the signs in the data that would make you suspect them.

Examples

  • Phenylketonuria (PKU) is one real autosomal recessive condition, used here as a worked example. The figure and the tool show it; its details are not for the exam.
  • An unaffected child of two carriers is AA, Aa or Aa: three equally likely outcomes, two of them carriers, so 2/3.

Watch out

  • The 2/3 is not the 1/2 of the whole square. Once you know the child is unaffected, the aa box is ruled out and three boxes remain.

Everything so far comes together when you are handed data and asked what is going on. Whether the data are counts from a cross or a pedigree, ask two questions. Is the allele dominant or recessive? And is the gene autosomal, on a chromosome that is not a sex chromosome?

For counts: a trait that vanishes in the F1 and returns in a quarter of the F2 is recessive, and if males and females show it equally the gene is autosomal. For a pedigree, use the two clues of chapter 7, then check both sexes. Two other patterns are worth recognizing now and are explained in 5.4. If males and females are not affected alike, suspect a sex-linked gene. If two traits stay together far more often than 9 : 3 : 3 : 1 allows, suspect genetically linked genes, close together on one chromosome.

With the pattern known, the rules of chapter 4 predict the next offspring. Take one real autosomal recessive condition as a worked example, phenylketonuria (PKU), in which an enzyme that converts the amino acid phenylalanine to tyrosine does not work. Two unaffected parents who have a child with the condition must both be carriers, Aa. For each child they have, the chance of aa is 1/2 × 1/2 = 1/4.

Now a harder one. Their next child is unaffected. What is the chance that this child is a carrier? Not 1/2. An unaffected child is not aa, so only three equally likely outcomes are left, AA, Aa and Aa, and two of the three are carriers: 2/3.

Example A woman’s brother has an autosomal recessive condition; she and her parents do not. Her partner is a known carrier. What is the chance that their first child has the condition?
  1. Her parents are both Aa, and she is unaffected, so she is a carrier with chance 2/3.
  2. If she is a carrier, the chance of an aa child with a carrier partner is 1/4.
  3. Both must be true, so multiply: 2/3 × 1/4 = 1/6.
  • From data: dominant or recessive, then autosomal or not.
  • Sexes not affected alike: suspect sex-linked. Two traits traveling together: suspect linked genes.
  • Two carriers: 1/4 affected. An unaffected child of two carriers: 2/3 a carrier.
Watch out The 2/3 is not the 1/2 of the whole square. Once you know a child is unaffected, the aa box is ruled out, and two of the three boxes that remain are Aa.

Two unaffected parents have a child with an autosomal recessive condition, then a second child who is unaffected. What is the chance that the second child is a carrier?

A man shows an autosomal recessive trait (aa). His partner is thought to be AA. Predict how the chance of a child with the trait changes if she is in fact a carrier, Aa.

LIVER CELLBLOODthe enzymephenylalaninetyrosineOH addedLIVER CELLBLOODfaulty enzymelittle tyrosinephenylalanine builds upLIVER CELLBLOODa diet low inphenylalaninethe same faulty enzymeless builds uptwo carrier parents:Nn × NnNNNNNnNnnNNnnnnnNnNneggsspermNN: not a carrierNn: a carrier, no PKUnn: has PKUEach child has a 1 in 4 chance of PKU.
  1. A worked example, PKU. In a person with a working allele, an enzyme in liver cells converts phenylalanine to tyrosine.
  2. In a person with two recessive alleles the enzyme does not work, and phenylalanine builds up.
  3. A diet low in phenylalanine gives the body less to build up. The genotype is the same, and the phenotype changes.
  4. Two carrier parents, written here as Nn: the square shows the four equally likely outcomes for each child.
parentsmotherAacarrier, no PKUfatherAacarrier, no PKUxchildrenspermeggsAaAano PKUPKUcarrierparentsmotherAacarrier, no PKUfatherAacarrier, no PKUxchildrenspermeggsAaAaAAAaAaaano PKUPKUcarrier
  1. Each parent makes gametes by meiosis, one allele of each gene in each. The mother's go down the side of the Punnett square, the father's along the top.
  2. Each cell joins one gamete from each parent: a possible offspring, every cell as likely as the next. The children: genotypes 1 AA : 2 Aa : 1 aa; phenotypes 3 without PKU : 1 with PKU.
The same cross on the tool, with the alleles written A and a. Predict, fill the square, then have 30 children a few times: each one is a new 1 in 4.

02Dry lab: Count the kernels

Every kernel on an ear of corn is one offspring of the same two parents, so one ear is a whole cross you can count. Count the kernels, choose the ratio you expect, and use a chi-square test to decide whether the ear fits it. Then try the two mystery ears.

EAR 1: F2, TWO GENESpurplesmooth11purplewrinkled5yellowsmooth4yellowwrinkled0
The bench: an ear of corn from a cross for two genes, its first row counted. Every kernel is one offspring. Count each kind, choose the ratio you expect, and test the counts against it with chi-square.
Your questionDo the kernels on an ear of corn fit the ratio that Mendel's laws predict for its cross? Decide which ratio you expect before you count.
What you can changeThe ear: an F2 ear for one gene, an F2 ear for two genes, a test cross ear and two mystery ears. Every ear you pick is a new set of kernels from the same cross, so counting a second ear of one kind is how you repeat. You also choose the ratio to test.
What to recordFor each ear: the count of each kind of kernel, the null hypothesis, the expected counts, chi-square, the degrees of freedom, the critical value at p = 0.05, and your decision to reject or fail to reject. The ears are drawn and their counts simulated, to show the method.

Find out

  • One gene. Count an F2 ear for one gene: the first row by hand, then let the counter finish. Test your counts against the ratio you expect, one step at a time.
  • Two genes. Count an F2 ear for two genes and a test cross ear for two genes. Which ratio does each one fit, and how many degrees of freedom does each test have?
  • Repeat. Pick a fresh ear of one kind two or three times. Does chi-square come out the same each time? Does your decision?
  • The mystery ears. Test mystery ear 1 against both one-gene ratios, and mystery ear 2 against both two-gene ratios. What cross could have made ear 1?
  • Back to Mendel's laws. Use your chi-square values to explain why the two-gene F2 ear came out close to 9 : 3 : 3 : 1, and what it means that mystery ear 2 fits neither two-gene ratio.

Record

  • For each ear: the number of each kind of kernel, the ratio you tested, and the null hypothesis in words.
  • Expected count = total kernels × that kind's share of the ratio. Chi-square = the sum of (o − e)² ÷ e over every kind.
  • Degrees of freedom = the number of kinds of kernel minus one. The critical value at p = 0.05, and your decision: reject or fail to reject the null hypothesis.
  • One sentence for each ear on what the decision means for its cross. Download the CSV to keep your table.

An F2 ear for one gene has 200 kernels, and purple is dominant to yellow. Before you count, what do you expect?

Mystery ear 1 has purple and yellow kernels in close to equal numbers. Which cross is the most likely to have made it?

You test mystery ear 2 against 1 : 1 : 1 : 1 and chi-square comes out far above the critical value. What should you conclude?

Back to Mendel's laws

Use your counts and chi-square values to explain why the two-gene F2 ear came out close to 9 : 3 : 3 : 1, and what it means that mystery ear 2 fits neither two-gene ratio.

03Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in. It opens on biologybybradford.com, so it needs the internet.

Exam practice

Exam questions on 5.3, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

04Downloads

This file is the guide, saved to run without the internet.

Saved from biologybybradford.com/guides/ap-biology-unit-5-mendelian-genetics, where the guide is kept up to date with the notes, the revision sheet and, for the teacher, the lesson plans and slides.

05Teacher resources

The guide as three one-hour lessons: what each covers, its focus and the chapters it uses.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1One gene and the rules of chance 5.3.A60 min Genes and alleles, genotype and phenotype, the law of segregation, Punnett squares and test crosses, and the multiplication and addition rules of probability 1, 2, 3, 4
2Two genes and a test of fit 5.3.A60 min The law of independent assortment for genes on different chromosomes, the dihybrid cross, and the chi-square test of cross data against a predicted ratio 5, 6, dry lab
3Family trees as data 5.3.A60 min Pedigrees as data: deducing genotypes and whether an allele is dominant or recessive, and predicting the chance of a genotype or phenotype in the next child 7, 8

The revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTICE AND REVIEW

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for Unit 5

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.