AP BIOLOGY · UNIT 7 · NATURAL SELECTION

How we know, and who is related to whom

Rocks, bones, limbs and DNA sequences tell the same story when read apart. Date a fossil from the atoms left in it, find the same bones in a wing and a flipper, count differences between sequences, then draw the tree those data support and say what would make you redraw it.

AP Biology 7.6 to 7.95 lessons10 chaptersdry lab

Start learningRun the dry labTeach it

Every living thing sits at the tip of one tree. This guide is how we know its shape: from four living apes into their arm bones and their DNA, back down the tree to the ancestors they share, then forward as a river splits one population in two.
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Ten chapters and a dry lab. The evidence first: kinds of data (chapter 1), fossils and their ages (2), bones (3), molecules (4) and what every eukaryote shares (5). Then the trees those data build: reading one (6), trees and time (7), building one from traits (8) and from DNA (9). Last, evolution happening now (10). Make each prediction before you open the answer or run a tool.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1Five kinds of data, one story
  2. 2Reading the rocks
  3. 3Same bones, different jobs
  4. 4Sequences remember ancestors
  5. 5What every eukaryote shares
  6. 6Read a tree by its nodes
  7. 7When did they split?
  8. 8From a table to a tree
  9. 9Trees are hypotheses
  10. 10Evolution has not stopped

7.6.A Evidence from many disciplines

Five kinds of data, one story

Fossils, anatomy and DNA were studied by different people with different methods. If all three give the same branching order for a group, that agreement is...

  • Evolution is supported by evidence from many disciplines, each with its own methods.
  • Geographical data: where species live, and where their fossils are found.
  • Geological data: rock layers and the fossils in them. Physical data: dating rocks by radioactive decay.
  • Biochemical data: DNA and protein sequences. Mathematical data: allele frequencies that change over generations, and the counting used to build trees.

The detail

  • Geographical: species on islands resemble species on the nearest mainland more than species on islands with a similar climate far away. The finches of the Galápagos are most like birds of South America.
  • Geological: layers of sedimentary rock are laid down one on another, so lower layers are older. The fossils in them appear in a consistent order, simple forms of a group before later, more varied ones.
  • Physical: radioactive isotopes decay at fixed rates, so rocks and once-living material can be given ages in years (chapter 2).
  • Biochemical: almost all living things use DNA, the same genetic code and the same kinds of molecules, and close relatives have more similar sequences (chapter 4).
  • Mathematical: counting allele frequencies over generations shows evolution as a number (the population genetics guide), and counting changes on possible trees chooses between them (chapter 8).

How we know

  • Darwin had the geographical and geological data. The biochemical data came a century later, from molecules he never knew existed, and they fit the same tree.

Nobody watched whales lose their legs. So how can anyone claim to know it happened? The answer is the same as in a court case with no witness: several independent pieces of evidence, each gathered a different way, all pointing to the same history.

For evolution the evidence comes from many disciplines. Geographical data come from where species live: island species resemble those of the nearest mainland. Geological data come from rocks: layers stack up over time, and their fossils appear in order. Physical data come from radioactive decay, which gives rocks an age in years. Biochemical data come from comparing DNA and proteins. Mathematical data come from counting: allele frequencies that shift from one generation to the next, and the number of changes a tree needs.

Tap each card to see one example of each kind. Then ask what each method could not tell you on its own, and which other kind fills the gap. The rest of this guide takes them one at a time: fossils and their ages, bones, molecules, cells, and the trees built from all of them.

  • Five kinds of data: geographical, geological, physical, biochemical, mathematical.
  • Independent methods that agree give strong support.
Watch out "Evolution is only a theory" mixes two meanings of the word. In science a theory is a broad explanation that is supported by many lines of evidence and makes predictions that can be tested, as the theory that germs cause disease is.
GeographicalGeologicalPhysicalBiochemicalMathematical

Tap a card.

Five kinds of data, one example each. Tap a card to read what it shows and what it could not show by itself.

7.6.B Fossils and how they are dated

Reading the rocks

Carbon-14 has a half-life of about 5,730 years. A bone has one quarter of the carbon-14 of living tissue. About how old is it?

  • A fossil is the preserved remains or traces of an organism that lived in the past. Together, fossils make the fossil record.
  • Fossils are dated by the age of the rocks they are found in: lower layers of sedimentary rock are usually older.
  • They are dated by the decay of isotopes, including carbon-14, which decays at a fixed rate measured as a half-life.
  • They are dated by geographical data: where the fossil was found, and which dated layers its rock matches.
  • Fossils of extinct organisms show features shared with extant ones, as transitional forms do.

The detail

  • Relative age: in undisturbed sedimentary rock, each layer was laid on the one below, so a fossil in a lower layer is older than one above it. This gives an order, not a number of years.
  • Age in years: a radioactive isotope decays at a fixed rate. After one half-life, half of it is left; after two, a quarter; after three, an eighth.
  • Carbon-14 (half-life about 5,730 years) is taken up by every living thing and stops being replaced at death. It dates once-living material up to about 50,000 years old; after that too little is left to measure.
  • Older rock is dated with isotopes that decay far more slowly. Potassium-40, about a tenth of which decays to argon-40, has a half-life of about 1.25 billion years, and it is measured in volcanic rock, such as a layer of ash.
  • Fossils sit in sedimentary rock, which cannot be dated this way, so a fossil between two dated ash layers is given an age between theirs.
  • Geographical data: a layer can be traced or matched from one site to another, and carries its date with it.

Example to reason with

  • Tiktaalik, found in 2004 on Ellesmere Island in Arctic Canada and described in 2006, is about 375 million years old. It had scales and gills like a fish, and a flat head, a neck and fins with sturdy, limb-like bones like a four-limbed animal. The team chose where to dig by looking for rocks of the right age and of the kind laid down by streams.

A fossil forms when the remains of an organism, or its traces, are buried and preserved in rock. Fossils of extinct species and of extant ones together make the fossil record. A fossil is only evidence once you know how old it is.

The first clue is the rock. Sedimentary rock is laid down layer on layer, so in rock that has not been folded or overturned, a lower layer is older. Order the fossils in the cliff before you read on. That gives an order, not an age in years.

For years, use a clock built into atoms. A radioactive isotope decays at a fixed rate, measured by its half-life. Carbon-14 has a half-life of about 5,730 years. A living thing keeps taking it in; after death the carbon-14 decays and is not replaced, so the fraction left gives the time since death, up to about 50,000 years. Older rocks need slower clocks, such as potassium-40, with a half-life of about 1.25 billion years, measured in layers of volcanic ash above and below a fossil.

Use the tool to date three finds. For each, choose the isotope first, then read the age from the curve. One of them cannot be dated with carbon-14 at all.

  • Lower layers are older: an order, not an age.
  • Each half-life halves what is left: 1/2, 1/4, 1/8.
  • Carbon-14 for the last 50,000 years; slower isotopes, in volcanic rock, for older layers.
Watch out Carbon dating does not date dinosaurs. The last dinosaurs other than birds died out about 66 million years ago, more than a thousand times longer than carbon-14 can measure. Their bones are dated from the isotopes in volcanic layers around them.
volcanic ash,dated 380 millionyears (potassium-40)Fossils inventedfor this figure.
A cliff of sedimentary rock with one dated layer of volcanic ash. Put the five fossils in order, oldest first, and say what the ash tells you about each.
11/21/41/81/1600015,730211,460317,190422,920528,650Time (half-lives)Time (years)Fraction of the isotope remaining1 half-life,5,730 years2 half-lives,11,460 years3 half-lives,17,190 years16 of 64 atomsare still carbon-14 11/21/41/81/1600015,730211,460317,190422,920528,650Time (half-lives)Time (years)Fraction remaining1 half-life,5,730 years2 half-lives,11,460 years3 half-lives,17,190 years16 of 64 atomsare stillcarbon-14
Drive the curve: choose an isotope, move the sample along the fraction remaining and read the age. Then date three finds, choosing the isotope first.

7.6.B Homologous and vestigial structures

Same bones, different jobs

A bat's wing and a whale's flipper hold the same set of bones in the same order. The best explanation is that...

  • Homologous structures are built on the same plan in different species, even when they do different jobs: the forelimbs of humans, bats, whales and horses hold the same bones in the same order.
  • Vestigial structures are reduced remnants of structures that are fully formed in related species. They are homologies too.
  • Similar jobs done by structures of different origins are analogous, not evidence of shared ancestry for that structure (speciation guide).

The detail

  • The shared plan: one upper arm bone, two forearm bones, a block of wrist bones, a row of palm bones, then the digits. Tap a bone in the figure to light it in all four limbs.
  • A designer starting from scratch would not build a wing, a paddle and a leg from the same parts. Evolution modifies what an ancestor already had.
  • A whale has small pelvic bones inside its body wall, attached to no leg. A python has a pair of tiny spurs near its vent, the last of its hind-limb bones. Both are homologous with the hips and legs of four-limbed relatives.
  • "Vestigial" does not mean useless. Whale pelvic bones anchor muscles used in mating. The point is that the structure is reduced from what an ancestor had, and its plan matches that ancestor's.

Watch out

  • A bird's wing and an insect's wing both fly, but one is a forelimb full of bones and the other a thin fold of cuticle with no bones. As wings they are analogous: flight evolved separately. Switch the figure to compare them.

Your arm, a bat's wing, a whale's flipper and a horse's front leg grasp, fly, swim and run. Inside, they are built from the same bones in the same order. Structures built on a plan inherited from a common ancestor are homologous structures. The plan makes sense only if all four limbs came from one ancestor, an early four-limbed animal, and each lineage then modified it for its own way of life.

Some homologies are leftovers. A whale has small pelvic bones buried in its body wall, attached to no leg, and a python has two tiny spurs near its vent, the last of its hind-limb bones. A vestigial structure is a reduced remnant of a structure that was fully formed in an ancestor. Look at the second figure and answer its question before you read on.

Not every likeness is a homology. A bird's wing and an insect's wing both fly, but they share no plan at all: their likeness comes from doing the same job, not from an ancestor. Structures like these are called analogous, and the speciation guide explains how they arise.

Remember it Two words that start the same

  • HomeHomologoussame origin, any job: inherited
  • VanishingVestigiala reduced remnant of an ancestor's structure
  • Homologous: same plan, same origin, different jobs. Homologies, vestigial ones included, are evidence of common ancestry.
  • Vestigial: a reduced remnant, still built on the ancestor's plan.
  • Same job, different origin: analogous, not evidence of shared ancestry.
Watch out A whale's flipper and a penguin's are often called analogous. As forelimbs they are homologous: both hold the bones of a four-limbed ancestor's arm. Only their flipper shape evolved separately. Say at which level you are comparing.
HumangraspingBatflyingWhaleswimmingHorserunningHumerusRadius and ulnaCarpalsMetacarpalsPhalangesBirdwing: flyingInsectwing: flyingbones inside,feathers outsideno bones:cuticle and veinswings evolvewings evolvevertebratesarthropodscommon ancestor: no wings

Tap a bone, or a name, to light that bone in all four limbs.

pelviswhalepelvisthigh bonefour-limbedrelativespurthigh bonepythonpelvisthigh bonelizard
Why would a whale have these? Each remnant sits beside the working structure in a relative.

7.6.B DNA and protein sequences

Sequences remember ancestors

A protein differs at 1 amino acid between species P and Q, and at 45 between P and R. Then...

  • Comparing DNA nucleotide sequences and protein amino acid sequences gives evidence for evolution and common ancestry.
  • After two lineages split, mutations build up separately in each. The longer ago they split, the more differences in the same gene.
  • Counting the differences between species' sequences ranks how closely they are related.
  • Nearly all life uses DNA and the same genetic code, which points to one common ancestor of all of it.

The detail

  • Many base changes do not change the amino acid, because most amino acids have more than one codon. So DNA sequences differ more than the proteins they code for.
  • Base sequences sort out close relatives; amino acid sequences, which change more slowly, reach further back.
  • The figure's 18 bases are invented to show the method. Real comparisons use thousands of bases, or whole genomes, and give the same pattern.

Example to reason with

  • Cytochrome c, a protein every aerobic cell uses, is 104 amino acids long in humans. A chimpanzee's is identical, a rhesus monkey's differs at one position, and a yeast's at more than 40.

How we know

  • Different genes and different proteins give largely the same branching order, and it matches the order of fossils in the rocks. That agreement between independent data is chapter 1's point.

Every living thing keeps its genes in DNA, and almost all of them read it with the same genetic code. A shared code with so many arbitrary details is hard to explain unless all of life inherited it from one ancestor. The sequences themselves hold the details of who is related to whom.

When one species splits into two, each new lineage copies its own DNA, and mutations build up separately in each. So the longer ago two species shared an ancestor, the more differences between the same gene in each. Compare one gene across species, count the differences, and rank them. Tap a species in the figure, count the pink cells, and watch where its branch joins.

The same goes for proteins, compared amino acid by amino acid. Switch the figure to amino acids and some differences vanish: many base changes leave the amino acid the same. That is why DNA is used for close relatives and proteins for distant ones.

  • Fewer differences: a more recent common ancestor.
  • DNA changes faster than protein, so it separates close relatives.
  • The same genetic code in nearly all life points to one ancestor.
Watch out "Nearly all" is deliberate. Mitochondria and a few organisms read a handful of codons differently. Those small variations are themselves inherited, and they fit the tree.
positions 1 to 18HumanATGGCCTACGTGAACTTCMetAlaTyrValAsnPheChimpanzeeATGGCCTACGTGAATTTCMetAlaTyrValAsnPheMouseATGGCTTACATGAATTTTMetAlaTyrMetAsnPheChickenATGGCATTTGTAGATTTTMetAlaPheValAspPheFrogATGACGCATATAGATCTTMetThrHisIleAspLeueach bracket: one codon, one amino acidthe same stretch, as six amino acidsThe treeHumanChimpanzeeMouseChickenFrogCompare a species:its branch joins herebase differences from human
Compare:

Tap a species to show its sequence under the human one. Count the pink differences, then watch where its branch joins the tree.

A made-up 18-base stretch of one gene, built the way real comparisons turn out. Real ones use thousands of bases and give the same pattern.

7.7.A Common ancestry of eukaryotes

What every eukaryote shares

A newly found single-celled organism has genes interrupted by introns, which a spliceosome cuts out of its RNA before translation. What would you predict about where its DNA is kept?

  • All eukaryotes share structural and functional features that point to one common ancestor.
  • Membrane-bound organelles: a nucleus, mitochondria, endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi.
  • Linear chromosomes, with ends, in the nucleus.
  • Genes that contain introns, stretches cut out of the RNA before it is translated.
  • A complex feature built the same way in every eukaryote is far more likely to have been inherited once than to have evolved again and again.

The detail

  • An amoeba, a yeast, an oak and you are all eukaryotes. Your cells, its cells and theirs build these features from the same kinds of molecules and work them the same way.
  • Introns are removed by a large RNA and protein machine, the spliceosome, found across eukaryotes.
  • Mitochondria have their own DNA and ribosomes like a bacterium's: the evidence that they began as bacteria living inside another cell, in the Unit 2 guide on compartments and origins.

Watch out

  • These features are typical of eukaryotes, not found only in them. A few bacteria, such as the one that causes Lyme disease and the soil bacteria Streptomyces, have linear chromosomes.
  • Some bacteria carry a few introns that cut themselves out without a spliceosome. Genes interrupted by introns and cut out by a spliceosome are the eukaryote feature.

A bacterium is a single cell with its DNA loose in the cytoplasm, usually in one loop. A cell of yours is built very differently, and so is a cell of an amoeba, a yeast or a leaf. Look at the three cells in the figure, then at the bacterium beside them. What do the three share that the bacterium lacks?

Three things. Membrane-bound organelles: a nucleus that holds the DNA, mitochondria, and a system of internal membranes. Linear chromosomes: DNA in separate strands with two ends, not one closed loop. And genes that contain introns: stretches of a gene that are transcribed and then cut out of the RNA before translation.

Each of these is complex, and each is built and worked in much the same way in every eukaryote, from yeast to oak. It is far more likely that they arose once, in a common ancestor of all eukaryotes, and were inherited, than that they arose many times in the same form. The course asks you to predict with this: give an organism one of these features and say what else its cells probably have, and why.

Remember it Evidence for one eukaryote ancestor

  • ManyMembrane-bound organellesnucleus, mitochondria, ER, Golgi
  • LittleLinear chromosomesstrands with two ends
  • InterruptionsIntronscut out of the RNA by a spliceosome
  • Membrane-bound organelles, linear chromosomes, genes with introns: shared by all eukaryotes.
  • Shared complex features point to one ancestor.
  • Say "typical of eukaryotes", never "only in eukaryotes".
Watch out "Single-celled" does not mean "prokaryote". Amoebas, yeasts and many algae are single eukaryotic cells, with every feature in this chapter.
amoebayeastplant cellbacterium

Find what the three cells share, then tap it.

An amoeba, a yeast and a plant cell, with a bacterium beside them. Find what the three share that the bacterium lacks, then tap it to name it. Not to scale.

7.9.A, 7.9.B Reading phylogenetic trees and cladograms

Read a tree by its nodes

On a tree, species X is drawn next to species Y at the tips, but X's branch joins Z's at a more recent node. X is more closely related to...

  • Phylogenetic trees and cladograms show hypothetical evolutionary relationships among lineages, and they can be tested.
  • The tips are the groups compared, extant or extinct. Each branch is a lineage. Each node is the most recent common ancestor of the groups that branch from it.
  • A tree shows speciation that has happened: each node is a split of one lineage into two.
  • One tree can be drawn in many styles: diagonal or square-cornered, upright or on its side.

The detail

  • The root is the common ancestor of everything on the tree.
  • A node is a hypothesis: an ancestor that must have existed to explain the split, though no fossil of it may ever be found.
  • To find the most recent common ancestor of two tips, follow their branches back until they first meet.
  • A trait that arose in an ancestor is inherited by all its descendants, so the groups beyond a node share what arose before it.

Try it

  • Tap the parts of the tree in the second figure, then spin it. Then answer the questions in the tool: it scores you.
  • Find the odd one out in the five trees of the third figure.

A tree of life is drawn from evidence, so it is a hypothesis: the best explanation so far of how a set of lineages are related, and one that new evidence can test. Both kinds you will meet, the cladogram and the phylogenetic tree, are read the same way; chapter 7 shows how they differ.

The tips are the groups being compared, living or extinct. Each line is a lineage. Each fork is a node: the most recent common ancestor of the groups that branch from it, the point where one lineage split into two. So a tree is also a record of speciation that has already happened.

Read it by the nodes. Follow two tips back until their lines meet: the more recent that node, the closer the relatives. Every node can be spun like a hanging mobile, so the order of the tips across the page means nothing, and neither does which tip is drawn at the top.

  • A node is the most recent common ancestor of what branches from it.
  • Read by nodes, not by who sits next to whom.
  • Trees are hypotheses that can be tested.
Watch out Humans did not evolve from chimpanzees. Both are tips: they share an ancestor that lived about 6 to 7 million years ago, and both lineages have changed since. A species at the left or bottom of a tree is not more primitive either; every living tip has evolved for exactly as long as every other.
four limbsamnionhair and milk sharkfroglizardmousehuman hair and milkamnionfour limbsrootnodeterminal branch
  1. Each feature draws a loop round the animals that have it. The loops nest, and each one is a clade (made-up simplified data).
  2. Redraw each loop as a fork: the bottom of the loop becomes the node where that group split off. The loops fade.
  3. The finished cladogram. A pink mark shows where a feature arose, and the nodes stand for hypothetical common ancestors.
cladeGibbonOrangutanGorillaHumanChimpanzeerootnodeterminal branchclosestrelativesChimpanzeeHumanGorillaOrangutanGibbonstillclosestspun at every node: same relationships

Tap a part of the cladogram, or spin it.

froghumanlizardcrocodilebirdbirdcrocodilelizardhumanfrogfroghumanlizardcrocodilebirdfroghumanbirdcrocodilelizardlizardcrocodilebirdhumanfrog

Tap the tree you think is different.

Five trees of the same five species. Four are one tree, swung at its nodes and drawn in other styles; one is a different tree. Find it.
SharkPerchFrogMouseLizardBird
Answer questions about a cladogram of six vertebrates: its root, its nodes and who shares the most recent common ancestor with whom.

7.9.A Cladograms, phylogenetic trees and time

When did they split?

  • A cladogram shows the order of branching only: no time scale, and no amount of difference between groups.
  • A phylogenetic tree also shows the amount of change over time: its branch lengths mean something.
  • A tree's time scale is calibrated by fossils of known age or by a molecular clock.
  • A molecular clock assumes differences in a sequence build up at a roughly steady rate, so a count of differences can be turned into time.

The detail

  • Calibrate the clock with a pair of species whose split is dated by fossils. In the film, 15 differences built up in 30 million years: 15 ÷ 30 = 0.5 differences per million years.
  • A pair with no fossil date that differs at 6 sites then split about 6 ÷ 0.5 = 12 million years ago.
  • The rate is counted across both lineages together: the differences between two living species are the changes in one lineage plus the changes in the other.
  • The clock gives an estimate. Generation time, population size and selection can all change how fast a lineage gathers differences.

Watch out

  • On a cladogram, a longer line is only a drawing choice. Read a length as time only when the tree has an axis.

Two sequences differ at 12 sites. The clock for this gene is 1 change per 2 million years, counted across both lineages together. The split was about...

Look at the first figure: the same five species drawn twice. Which drawing could tell you when two of them split? Only the one with an axis. A cladogram shows the order of branching and nothing more. A phylogenetic tree also shows the amount of change over time, so the length of a branch means something.

To give a tree a time scale, it must be calibrated. Fossils of known age fix some of the nodes: a fossil 30 million years old of one lineage means the split was at least that long ago. A molecular clock does the rest. Mutations build up in a gene at a roughly steady rate, so once the rate is known from a fossil-dated pair, the differences between any other pair can be turned into years.

Step through the graph, then play the film and change its settings. Notice that the clock gives an estimate, not a date: a lineage with short generations, for example, collects changes faster.

  • Cladogram: order only. Phylogenetic tree: order plus change or time.
  • Calibrated by fossils or a molecular clock.
  • Time = differences ÷ rate.
Watch out Trees are not "measured by fossils" alone. Fossils calibrate some nodes; for the rest, and for lineages with few fossils, the molecular clock carries the dates.
CladogramABCDEPhylogenetic treeABCDE403020100Millions of years agoSpecies and dates invented for this figure.
The same five species, drawn twice. Which drawing can tell you when two lineages split?
1020304051015200millions of years since the splitdifferences in 30 basesfossil-dated pairsmolecular clockundated: about 12faster: about 6
  1. Two pairs of species whose split is dated from fossils: 5 differences at 10 million years and 15 at 30 million (made-up numbers).
  2. The differences grow steadily with time, so a straight line through the points is the molecular clock.
  3. A pair with no fossil date differs at 6 places. Read across to the clock, then down: about 12 million years.
  4. If this pair's lines collected changes twice as fast, the same 6 differences would mean about 6 million years. The clock gives an estimate, not a date.
Two lineages collect changes. Calibrate the clock from a fossil-dated pair, date a second pair, then change the settings and see how the same differences give a different date.

7.9.A Building a cladogram from shared derived characters

From a table to a tree

In a table, every species in the group has trait 1 and so does the out-group. Trait 1 is...

  • Traits gained or lost during evolution can be used to build trees and cladograms.
  • The out-group is the lineage least closely related to the rest. Its states are taken as the ancestral ones.
  • A shared derived character arose in a common ancestor and is present in more than one of its descendant lineages. These are the traits that group species.
  • Where the data clash, the tree that needs the fewest changes is preferred.

Building one by hand

  • Find the out-group, the species that lacks the derived characters the others share.
  • Count how many species have each derived character.
  • Draw a fork for each character, the one shared by most species nearest the root: it arose first. A character that only one species has arose on that species' own branch and groups no one.
  • Mark each character on the branch where it arose. Every species beyond that mark has it.

The tool's own numbers

  • With the five made-up beetles, the tree that pairs Bramble with Pebble (the spotted pair) and Ember with Lantern (the horned pair) needs 5 changes, one for each trait.
  • The tree that pairs Bramble with Ember and Pebble with Lantern needs 7: spots and horns must each arise twice.

Watch out

  • A loss counts as a change too. A cave fish that has lost its eyes has a derived character, "no eyes", compared with an out-group that has them.

A cladogram is built from a table: species in rows, traits in columns. First comes the out-group, the lineage least closely related to all the rest. It shows which state of each trait is the older, ancestral one. The other state is derived, whether it was gained (horns) or lost (eyes).

A shared derived character is one that arose in a common ancestor and is found in more than one of its descendant lineages. Those are the traits that tell you who is grouped with whom. The trait shared by most species arose first, nearest the root; one shared by few arose later, near the tips.

Sometimes two traits will not fit on one tree: one of them must have arisen twice, or been lost. Then count the changes each possible tree needs, and prefer the tree that needs the fewest. This rule is called parsimony: the simplest explanation of the data is the most likely. In the tool, the tree that pairs the spotted beetles together and the horned beetles together needs 5 changes; pair them the other way and it needs 7. Build both and count.

Remember it Building a cladogram, in order

  • OldOut-groupfind the least related lineage first
  • ShipsShared derived charactersthe traits that group species
  • CarryCounthow many species have each one
  • DustDrawa fork for each, most shared nearest the root
  • The out-group shows the ancestral states.
  • Shared derived characters group species; traits everyone has, or only one species has, do not.
  • Prefer the tree needing the fewest changes.
Watch out A trait every species has, the out-group included, is not a shared derived character of the group. It arose before the group did, so it groups no one inside it.
site123456OOrangutanAATCGAHHumanGTTAAACChimpanzeeGTCCAGGGorillaAACCGAdiffers from the orangutansites 4 and 6: no helpTree 1OHCG7 changesTree 2OHGC10 changesTree 3OCGH9 changesfewest changes
  1. A made-up stretch of six sites in one gene. Pink marks where a species differs from the orangutan, the out-group.
  2. Three trees could join the human, chimpanzee and gorilla. Sites 4 and 6 differ in only one species, so they cost one change on every tree and cannot choose between them.
  3. Count the changes each tree needs to explain all six sites. Tree 1 needs 7, tree 2 needs 10 and tree 3 needs 9.
  4. The tree that explains the data with the fewest changes is preferred: tree 1, with the human and chimpanzee as closest relatives.
Traits12345MossBramblePebbleEmberLanternMade-up beetles and data, for teachingMossout-groupBramblePebbleEmberLantern2324351Mossout-groupBrambleEmberPebbleLanternThis tree: 7 changes
  1. The table gives each beetle's traits (made up for teaching). Moss is the out-group: its states are taken as the ancestral ones.
  2. One tree, with a bar on each branch where a trait changes: 7 changes. Can you find a tree that needs fewer?
Join the beetles into a tree, mark where each trait changes, and watch the count. Can you find the tree that needs only 5 changes?
23 5frogout-grouplizardbirdmousebat1wingsbird · bat4feathersbird23 5frogout-grouplizardbirdmousebatThe loops crosswings: the bird and the bat????????????mouse2frog1
  1. Graft: each evidence card draws a loop round the organisms that share its trait, and each loop is a clade. The frog is the out-group.
  2. Wings groups the bird and the bat, but that loop would cross two loops already drawn. A tree can hold only one: which would you keep?
  3. Mystery branch: the frog, then the mouse, were guessed. The ringed node is where the mouse and the mystery last shared an ancestor, so the mystery is on its other branch, in the shaded clade.

7.9.A, 7.9.B Molecular data and revising trees

Trees are hypotheses

Two plants look alike and were classed together. Their DNA shows each is closer to a different-looking plant. Biologists most likely...

  • Trees and cladograms can be built from morphological similarities of living or fossil species, and from DNA and protein sequence similarities.
  • Molecular data typically give more accurate and reliable evidence than morphological traits.
  • Trees are hypotheses that are constantly revised on new evidence.

Why molecules usually win

  • A gene gives hundreds or thousands of characters, one at every site. A body gives a few dozen at most.
  • Each base is compared with no judgment about which features count, so anyone counting gets the same answer.
  • Similar body traits can evolve separately in lineages that face similar conditions, and then they mislead. Thousands of sites are much less likely to all mislead in the same way.

The tool's own numbers

  • The six beetles' five traits alone leave five trees tied on 6 changes.
  • With the six DNA sites added, one tree wins with 13 changes. It puts Cinder with Bramble and Pebble, so the horn and the black body each evolved twice.

Example to reason with

  • The figwort family of flowering plants was built on the structure of its flowers. In 2001, chloroplast DNA showed its members spread across several lineages, and the family was broken up. You do not need its names, only what it shows.

A tree can be built from what organisms look like, alive or as fossils, or from their DNA and protein sequences. When the two disagree, the sequences usually win. A gene gives a character at every site, hundreds or thousands of them, each compared without judgment. A body gives a few features, and similar features can evolve separately in lineages that live in similar ways.

Build the beetles again in the tool, now with six DNA sites added. With the traits alone, five trees tie. With the DNA, one tree wins, and it says two of the traits evolved twice. Then step through the figure: a family of flowering plants that was grouped by its flowers, and what happened when its DNA was compared.

That is science working. A tree is a hypothesis: the best explanation of the evidence so far. It makes predictions that new evidence can test, and trees are constantly revised as new fossils are found and new genes are sequenced.

  • Built from body structure or from sequences.
  • Molecular data are usually more accurate and reliable.
  • Trees are revised on new evidence.
Watch out A tree in a textbook is not a fact to memorize. It is the current best hypothesis, and the one in next year's edition may differ.
Traits and DNA sites12345abcdefMossACGTACBrambleGCGTCCPebbleGTATCCCinderGTATCCEmberACGCACLanternACGCATMade-up beetles and data, for teachingMossout-groupBramblePebbleCinderEmberLanternbc5f2abced2ae341Mossout-groupBramblePebbleCinderEmberLanternThis tree: 16 changes
  1. The table gives each beetle's traits (made up for teaching). Moss is the out-group: its states are taken as the ancestral ones.
  2. One tree, with a bar on each branch where a trait changes: 16 changes. Can you find a tree that needs fewer?
The same job with six DNA sites added. Two of the traits mislead: does the tree with the fewest changes change?
grouped by flower structuregrouped by chloroplast DNAfoxglovesnapdragonplantainmonkeyfloweryellow rattlebroomrapemulleinfigwortmintonce in the figwort familythe figwort family today
  1. Grouped by flower structure: six plants with similar flowers sit together as the figwort family (a simplified sketch).
  2. Grouped by chloroplast DNA instead. The same plants now fall into several different clades, with other plants between them.
  3. Only a small group is still the figwort family. The look-alike flowers evolved separately in different lineages, so the old family had no single common ancestor of its own.

7.8.A Continuing evolution

Evolution has not stopped

A hospital uses one antibiotic heavily for five years. The share of infections resistant to it most likely...

  • All species have evolved and continue to evolve.
  • Genomic changes over time: sequences measured in a population change from one generation to the next.
  • Continuous change in the fossil record, where layers are complete enough to follow a lineage.
  • Evolution of resistance to antibiotics, pesticides, herbicides and chemotherapy drugs.
  • Pathogens that evolve and cause emergent diseases.

Examples to reason with

  • Genomes: a long-term experiment begun in 1988 keeps 12 populations of E. coli, started from one ancestor, and freezes a sample every few hundred generations. By about generation 31,500, one population could grow on citrate when oxygen was present, which E. coli normally cannot. In 2022 the populations reached 75,000 generations, their genomes sequenced along the way.
  • Fossils: cores drilled from the ocean floor hold the shells of tiny plankton, layer on layer, and in some lineages the shape of the shell can be followed changing gradually over millions of years.
  • Antibiotics: resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) was first reported in 1961, about two years after the antibiotic methicillin came into use in Britain.
  • Herbicides: the first weed found resistant to glyphosate was a ryegrass in Australia, reported in 1996.
  • Chemotherapy: a tumor is a population of cells that vary. A drug kills the susceptible cells, and any resistant ones grow back, which is one reason cancers are often treated with more than one drug.
  • Emergent disease: two related influenza viruses in one host cell can swap gene segments (the Unit 6 guide). The 2009 pandemic influenza carried segments that came from pig, bird and human influenza viruses.

Watch out

  • The pesticide case in the natural selection guide, DDT and mosquitoes, works the same way as the antibiotic case: the chemical selects resistance that is already there.

Everything so far has been about the past. Evolution is also happening now, in every population, and in some it is fast enough to watch. The course names four kinds of evidence. Genomes change over time: sequence a population today and again in some generations, and allele frequencies have shifted. The fossil record shows continuous change where layers are complete enough to follow one lineage.

Resistance evolves: to antibiotics in bacteria, to pesticides in insects, to herbicides in weeds and to chemotherapy drugs in the cells of a tumor. In each case the chemical is the selective pressure. It does not cause the resistance; it kills the susceptible individuals and leaves those that already carried it to reproduce. Play the film and watch it happen on a plate.

Pathogens evolve and cause emergent diseases: a virus or bacterium that changes until it can infect a new host, or spread in a new way, gives a disease that was not there before. Tap the four cards in the figure, then choose one and say how you would test it: the skill this topic asks for is proposing a new investigation.

  • All species continue to evolve.
  • Four kinds of evidence: genomes, fossils, resistance, emergent diseases.
  • A drug selects resistance; it does not cause it.
Watch out Bacteria do not become resistant because the antibiotic changes them, or because they "get used to" it. The resistance arose by mutation, or by a gene passed from another cell, before or during treatment, and the antibiotic selected it.
Watch antibiotic courses select the few resistant bacteria on a plate, then change how many start out resistant and whether each course is finished.
Genomes changeFossils showcontinuous changeResistance evolvesEmergent disease

Tap a card.

Four kinds of evidence that evolution continues, one case each. Tap a card to read the case and what was measured.

02Dry lab: Grow a tree

Six made-up fish, a table of body traits and a stretch of DNA. Choose the data, let the bench score every possible tree, and see which tree needs the fewest changes.

THE TREESIX MADE-UP FISH105trees to tryRiver fishout-groupNorth lakeNorth caveSouth lakeSouth caveMarshtree–/105changes–fewest–trees tied–
The bench: six made-up fish, River fish the out-group. Grow tries all 105 possible trees, counting the changes each needs, and keeps the one that needs the fewest. Does the winner change when you count other traits, the DNA, or a loss as half a change?
Your questionDoes the tree you get depend on the data you choose? Build it from body traits, then from DNA, then from both. Do the two pale cave fish come out as each other's closest relatives every time?
What you can changeThe data (traits, DNA or both), which traits are counted, a trait of your own, and whether the loss of a structure counts as a whole change or half. The bench counts the changes each of the 105 possible trees needs.
What to recordFor each run: the data you used, the fewest changes, how many trees tied on it, and whether the cave fish are together. Change one thing at a time. The bench gives the same answer for the same data every time, so the experiment is in your choice of data.

Find out

  • Traits against DNA. The bench opens counting both. Grow the tree and record it. Then count the traits alone, then the DNA alone. Which runs put the two cave fish together, and which put each beside its own lake fish?
  • Which data do you trust? Compare the fewest changes and the number of trees tied on the traits and on the DNA. Which run gives one clear winner? Say why the DNA might be the more reliable evidence here.
  • A trait only one fish has. Make a trait of your own that only the Marsh fish has. What does it do to every tree's score, and can it change the winner?
  • The rule matters too. With the traits only, let a loss count half a change. Does the winning tree move? What does that tell you about how a tree depends on the choices a biologist makes?

Record

  • For every run: the data (traits, DNA or both), which traits were counted, the rule for a loss, the fewest changes, how many trees tied, and whether the cave fish came out together.
  • Change one thing at a time and keep the rest fixed.
  • The bench counts changes by a fixed rule, so the same data always give the same answer. There is no scatter to average: repeat a run only to check you recorded it correctly.
  • End with a claim about which tree is the better hypothesis, the evidence from your table, and one new piece of evidence that could change it.

Five traits leave five trees tied, each with the two cave fish together. The DNA gives one tree, with the cave fish apart. What best explains the difference?

You add a trait that only the Marsh fish has. What does it do to the scores?

A team sequences a second, longer gene from the six fish, and it puts the two cave fish together after all. What should they do?

Claim and evidence

The five body traits grouped the two cave fish together; the DNA did not. Make a claim about which cladogram is the better hypothesis, and support it with evidence from your results.

03Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in. It opens on biologybybradford.com, so it needs the internet.

Exam practice

Exam questions on 7.6 to 7.9, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

04Downloads

This file is the guide, saved to run without the internet.

Saved from biologybybradford.com/guides/ap-biology-unit-7-evidence-and-phylogeny, where the guide is kept up to date with the notes, the revision sheet and, for the teacher, the lesson plans and slides.

05Teacher resources

The guide as five one-hour lessons: what each covers, its focus and the chapters it uses.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1Evidence and fossils 7.6.A, 7.6.B60 min The kinds of data that give evidence for evolution, the order of rock layers, and dating fossils by radioactive decay, choosing the right isotope 1, 2
2Homology, molecules and the eukaryotes 7.6.B, 7.7.A60 min Homologous and vestigial structures, comparing sequences to rank relatives, and the features every eukaryote shares, used to predict and justify 3, 4, 5
3Reading trees 7.9.A, 7.9.B60 min Reading phylogenetic trees and cladograms by their nodes, rotating trees, and the difference between a cladogram and a tree with a time scale 6, 7, 8
4Building and revising trees, and the lab 7.9.A, 7.9.B60 min Building a cladogram from shared derived characters and an out-group, the tree needing fewest changes, building from DNA and revising trees, with the dry lab 8, 9, dry lab
5Evolution is still happening 7.8.A60 min Evolution as an ongoing process: genomic change, continuous fossil change, resistance to drugs and chemicals, and emergent diseases, then proposing a new investigation 10

The revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTICE AND REVIEW

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for Unit 7

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.