7.6.A Evidence from many disciplines
Five kinds of data, one story
Fossils, anatomy and DNA were studied by different people with different methods. If all three give the same branching order for a group, that agreement is...
Strong support. Rocks, bones and sequences are read with different tools by different people, and none of them is built from the others' results. If evolution had not happened, there would be no reason for all three to give the same order. It is still not proof: new evidence can always change a detail, which is how science works.
- Evolution is supported by evidence from many disciplines, each with its own methods.
- Geographical data: where species live, and where their fossils are found.
- Geological data: rock layers and the fossils in them. Physical data: dating rocks by radioactive decay.
- Biochemical data: DNA and protein sequences. Mathematical data: allele frequencies that change over generations, and the counting used to build trees.
The detail
- Geographical: species on islands resemble species on the nearest mainland more than species on islands with a similar climate far away. The finches of the Galápagos are most like birds of South America.
- Geological: layers of sedimentary rock are laid down one on another, so lower layers are older. The fossils in them appear in a consistent order, simple forms of a group before later, more varied ones.
- Physical: radioactive isotopes decay at fixed rates, so rocks and once-living material can be given ages in years (chapter 2).
- Biochemical: almost all living things use DNA, the same genetic code and the same kinds of molecules, and close relatives have more similar sequences (chapter 4).
- Mathematical: counting allele frequencies over generations shows evolution as a number (the population genetics guide), and counting changes on possible trees chooses between them (chapter 8).
How we know
- Darwin had the geographical and geological data. The biochemical data came a century later, from molecules he never knew existed, and they fit the same tree.
Nobody watched whales lose their legs. So how can anyone claim to know it happened? The answer is the same as in a court case with no witness: several independent pieces of evidence, each gathered a different way, all pointing to the same history.
For evolution the evidence comes from many disciplines. Geographical data come from where species live: island species resemble those of the nearest mainland. Geological data come from rocks: layers stack up over time, and their fossils appear in order. Physical data come from radioactive decay, which gives rocks an age in years. Biochemical data come from comparing DNA and proteins. Mathematical data come from counting: allele frequencies that shift from one generation to the next, and the number of changes a tree needs.
Tap each card to see one example of each kind. Then ask what each method could not tell you on its own, and which other kind fills the gap. The rest of this guide takes them one at a time: fossils and their ages, bones, molecules, cells, and the trees built from all of them.
- Five kinds of data: geographical, geological, physical, biochemical, mathematical.
- Independent methods that agree give strong support.
Tap a card.