8.6.A Ecosystem diversity and resilience
Fewer parts, less to fall back on
The same plant disease reaches two fields. One is planted with a single potato variety, every plant grown from a piece of the same parent. The other has six varieties in strips. Why is more of the crop lost in the first field?
Both fields hold only potatoes, so the difference is the variety inside the crop. Plants grown from pieces of one parent carry the same alleles: if one is susceptible, every plant is. Among six varieties, some may carry alleles that resist this disease, and their strips survive.
- An ecosystem's parts are its species, the variety within each species, and its abiotic factors.
- Resilience is how well an ecosystem keeps its structure through a change in the environment, or returns to it afterward.
- Natural and artificial ecosystems with fewer component parts, and with little diversity among the parts, are often less resilient to changes in the environment.
- With little variety, one change can hit every part the same way, and nothing else is left to do the same job.
The detail
- "Fewer parts": few species, as in a crop field, a timber plantation or an island with a short species list.
- "Little diversity among the parts": the individuals of a species are genetically alike, as in a crop grown from cuttings or tubers, so a disease or a change in climate that harms one harms all.
- Diversity is measured as richness and evenness together, and Simpson's Diversity Index combines the two (guide 3, 8.5): 1 − Σ(n/N)², from 0 for one species to near 1 for many species in even numbers.
- An artificial ecosystem is one people made and keep: a farm, a lawn, a fish farm, a city park.
Watch out
- "Often" matters. A diverse ecosystem can still be wiped out by a large enough change, and some simple ones (a salt marsh, a hot spring) are stable where they are.
Look at any ecosystem as a set of parts. Its species are parts. So is the variety within each species: the different alleles its members carry. So are its abiotic factors, the water, light, temperature, nutrients and oxygen that every organism there depends on.
Now change the environment: a dry year, a new disease, a hard frost. Some ecosystems keep their structure through it, or come back to it soon after. That property is resilience. It does not mean nothing changes. It means the same kinds of organisms are still doing the same jobs when the change has passed.
That is what happened in Ireland. Potato blight, caused by Phytophthora infestans (a water mold, not a true fungus), reached Europe in 1845. Most of Ireland's poor grew one variety, the Lumper, from tubers, so the plants were near clones of each other, and the crop failed year after year. About a million people died between 1845 and 1852, and at least as many emigrated. Treat it as an example to reason with: one crop, one variety, one disease.
The same reasoning holds for whole communities. In a meadow of many species, a disease of one grass leaves dozens of other plants to feed the insects and hold the soil. In a field of one crop, there is nothing else. Diversity is counted by both richness and evenness, as in the two meadows in the second figure. Simpson's Diversity Index (guide 3) puts the two in one number.
- An ecosystem's parts: its species, the variety within them, its abiotic factors.
- Resilience: keeping, or getting back, the same structure after a change.
- Fewer parts and little diversity among them: often less resilient.
- Two potato fields. On the left every plant is the same variety, grown from pieces of one parent; on the right, six varieties in strips.
- Spores of the same disease arrive on the wind and land on both fields.
- The disease kills every plant on the left, since none of them can resist it. On the right it kills the strips of the three susceptible varieties and leaves the rest.