Biology  by Bradford
support
Biology by Bradford · IB Biology SL/HL · D1.3

Mutations & gene editing.SL + HL

One base out of three billion. Sometimes nothing happens. Sometimes a red blood cell folds into a crescent. The difference is worth understanding exactly.

D1.3 Mutations and gene editingSubstitution · insertion · deletion · mutagensHL: knockout · CRISPR-Cas9 · conserved sequences
Concept 01 · D1.3.1

Three ways to change a gene

A gene mutation is a structural change to a gene at the molecular level; the base sequence itself is different. Only three things can happen to a base.

Substitution

Swap one base

One nucleotide is replaced by another. The gene stays the same length, so the reading frame is untouched: at most one codon changes.

Insertion

Add bases

One or more nucleotides are added. Unless the number is a multiple of three, every codon downstream is re-read: a frameshift.

Deletion

Remove bases

One or more nucleotides are lost. Same rule: not a multiple of three means everything after it shifts.

Scale · not the same thing

Gene vs chromosome

D1.3 is about gene (small-scale) mutations. Whole-chromosome changes (non-disjunction, translocation, inversion, duplication) are a different level of organisation, covered in D2.1 and D3.2.

Signature interactive · D1.3.1 – D1.3.3 · the real HBB gene

Break a gene yourself

These are the first twelve codons of HBB, the human beta-globin gene, shown as the template strand: the one RNA polymerase reads, so the mRNA underneath is its complement, with U in place of T. Choose a tool, then tap a base. The mRNA and the polypeptide update, and the verdict tells you which kind of mutation you just made.

Tool
Mutation
NONE
original sequence
Amino acids changed
0
of 12
Gene length
36
bases

Try one

Two rules do all the work. A substitution can only reach one codon, so the damage is capped, and the degenerate code means it often does nothing at all. An insertion or deletion moves the frame, so every codon after it is read wrongly and the protein is usually junk from that point on. Try "Insert three" to see the one indel that behaves itself.

Concept 02 · D1.3.2

What a substitution can do

Four outcomes, and which one you get depends on the genetic code, not on the size of the change. Every one of these is a single base.

ONE BASE CHANGED · FOUR POSSIBLE ENDINGS

The fourth ending is the quiet one. Most of the genome is non-coding. A substitution there usually changes nothing, unless it lands in a promoter, an enhancer or a splice site, in which case the protein is fine but the cell makes the wrong amount of it, at the wrong time.

Why silent exists

The degenerate code

64 codons, 20 amino acids. Most amino acids have several codons, usually differing at the third base, so third-base substitutions are often silent. That redundancy is a built-in shock absorber.

Vocabulary · D1.3.2

SNP

A single-nucleotide polymorphism: a base substitution that has been inherited and is common in a population. SNPs are the raw material of genetic fingerprinting, ancestry tests and disease-risk studies.

Conservative or not

Not all missense is equal

Swapping one hydrophobic amino acid for another (conservative) often leaves the fold intact. Swapping a charged one for a hydrophobic one (non-conservative) can wreck it, which is exactly what happens next.

Step-through · D1.3.2 · the case study

One base, one amino acid, one crescent

Follow a single A→T substitution in HBB all the way from the double helix to a blocked capillary.

The protein

Glu → Val

Glutamic acid is negatively charged and sits happily on the outside of haemoglobin, in the water. Valine is hydrophobic. A greasy patch on the surface is a sticky patch.

The cell

Fibres, then crescents

When deoxygenated, the valine patch on one molecule slots into a pocket on another. Haemoglobin polymerises into rigid fibres that deform the cell into a sickle. Sickle cells block capillaries and are destroyed early: pain crises and anaemia.

The population

Why the allele persists

Heterozygotes (HbA/HbS) have some resistance to malaria. Where malaria is common, natural selection keeps the allele at high frequency despite the cost to homozygotes: the same mutation being harmful and helpful, depending on the environment.

Concept 03 · D1.3.3

Losing the frame

A ribosome cannot see codons. It reads three bases at a time from the start codon and never re-checks. Move one base and it keeps counting in threes: just in the wrong place.

A REPEATING GENE MAKES THE SHIFT OBVIOUS · CAT CAT CAT CAT

Why indels are usually worse than substitutions. A substitution damages at most one codon. An indel corrupts every codon downstream, and often creates a premature stop, so the polypeptide is both wrong and truncated. The exception is an indel of three (or a multiple of three): one amino acid is added or lost and the rest of the frame survives. Cystic fibrosis is most often caused by exactly that: a three-base deletion, ΔF508.

Concept 04 · D1.3.4 – D1.3.5

Where mutations come from

Two sources: mistakes the cell makes on its own, and damage from outside. Neither aims at anything.

Internal

Replication and repair errors

DNA polymerase mispairs a base roughly once in 10⁷ and proofreading catches most of it. What escapes proofreading and mismatch repair becomes a permanent mutation at the next round of replication.

Physical mutagens

Radiation

UV makes adjacent thymines bond into a dimer that kinks the helix and blocks replication. Ionising radiation (X-rays, gamma, radon) breaks the sugar-phosphate backbone.

Chemical mutagens

Chemicals

Benzopyrene in tobacco smoke, mustard gas, nitrosamines; they bind to or chemically alter bases so the wrong partner is inserted. Each leaves a characteristic mutational signature in a tumour's genome.

No proofreading

Retroviruses

HIV copies RNA to DNA with reverse transcriptase, which has no proofreading. Errors accumulate fast, so the viral population varies enormously, which is why drug resistance and vaccine design are so hard.

UV PHOTON → THYMINE DIMER → MISSHAPEN HELIX → REPLICATION ERROR

D1.3.5: it can happen anywhere. Mutation is random with respect to need; no base is protected because it matters, and none is targeted because a change would help. It can land in a coding sequence, an intron, a promoter, non-coding DNA or mitochondrial DNA. What is not random is what happens next: natural selection removes the harmful and keeps the useful.

Concept 05 · D1.3.6 – D1.3.7

Which cell it happens in

The same molecular change has completely different consequences depending on whether the cell will ever become a gamete.

SAME MUTATION · DIFFERENT CELL · DIFFERENT REACH

Reach, not severity. A somatic mutation affects one cell and its descendants: a mole, a patch of tissue, or, if it hits a cell-cycle gene, a tumour. A germline mutation is copied into every cell of the offspring and every generation after, which is why it can enter the gene pool and a somatic mutation cannot.

Harmful

Most of the noticeable ones

A changed protein usually works worse: cystic fibrosis, Huntington's, or a mutation in a tumour-suppressor gene such as p53 that lets a cell divide unchecked.

Neutral

Most of them, full stop

Silent substitutions, changes in non-coding DNA, conservative missense in an unimportant part of a protein. They accumulate quietly and are the basis of molecular clocks.

Beneficial

Rare, and the reason we are here

Antibiotic resistance in bacteria; lactase persistence in adult humans; the ApoA-1 Milano variant in Limone sul Garda that protects against atherosclerosis. Beneficial in that environment.

D1.3.7

The original source

Meiosis and sexual reproduction shuffle alleles; they cannot invent one. Every allele that exists began as a mutation. No mutation, no variation, no evolution.

Concept · D1.3.8HL

Break it on purpose

To find out what a gene does, make it inoperative and see what goes wrong. Deliberate mutation as an experimental method.

ONE GENE CHANGED · ALL ELSE HELD CONSTANT CONTROL · p53 +/+ · both copies work develops normally stays tumour-free for life KNOCKOUT · p53 −/− · both disabled TUMOUR develops normally too tumours within a few months THE SAME TWO GROUPS OVER TIME ALL NONE TUMOUR-FREE 036 912 AGE IN MONTHS p53 +/+ p53 −/− shape is schematic

The control is the whole experiment. Both groups are the same strain, the same age and kept in the same conditions; the only difference is that one has both copies of p53 disabled. The knockouts are born and develop normally, so p53 is not needed to build a mouse, but tumours, most often thymic lymphoma, appear within months. That contrast is the evidence that p53's normal job is to halt the cell cycle when DNA is damaged, and it is why a mutated p53 turns up in so many human cancers.

The logic

Loss of function

Gene knockout uses genetic engineering to remove or inactivate one specific gene. The organism that develops without it is compared with normal controls; the difference is evidence of what the gene was doing.

The classic result

p53 knockout mice

Mice with p53 knocked out develop normally but grow tumours very early. That is how the gene's role as a tumour suppressor, halting the cell cycle when DNA is damaged, was established.

Model organisms

Knockout libraries

For mice, zebrafish, Drosophila, Arabidopsis and yeast, libraries of knockout strains exist; one gene disabled in each. A researcher can order the strain rather than make it.

Reading the result carefully

What "no effect" means

Knockouts often show nothing. That does not mean the gene is useless: another gene may be redundant with it, or the effect may only appear under stress. Absence of a phenotype is weak evidence.

Diagram · interactive · D1.3.9HL

Bacterial immunity, borrowed

CRISPR is a bacterial memory of past viruses. Cas9 is the enzyme that acts on it. Give Cas9 a guide RNA of your own design and it will cut wherever you like. Tap a component.

TARGET DNA CAS9 GUIDE RNA PAM CUT TAP CAS9, THE GUIDE RNA, THE PAM, THE CUT SITE OR THE DNA
Diagram

Start with the guide RNA

Tap Cas9, the single guide RNA, the PAM sequence, the double-strand cut, the unwound region or the target DNA.

Step-through · D1.3.9HL

One edit, start to finish

The cut is the easy part. What the cell does with the broken ends is what decides whether you have disabled a gene or rewritten it.

Repair route 1

NHEJ · knockout

Non-homologous end joining glues the ends back together and is error-prone: it usually loses or gains a few bases. That indel causes a frameshift and the gene is dead, which is how CRISPR makes a knockout.

Repair route 2

HDR · rewrite

Supply a DNA template with the sequence you want and homology-directed repair copies it in. This is how a mutation is corrected or a new gene inserted: precise, but far less efficient than NHEJ.

The natural version

Where it comes from

Bacteria store fragments of past viral DNA as spacers between CRISPR repeats. Transcribed into crRNA, these guide Cas9 to destroy that virus if it returns. An adaptive immune system in a prokaryote.

The limitation

Off-target cuts

A 20-base guide can partially match sequences elsewhere in a genome of billions of bases. Off-target cuts put indels in genes nobody intended to touch: the central safety problem, and the reason newer base and prime editors avoid cutting both strands.

Real world · D1.3.9HL

The first CRISPR medicine

You met this mutation in section 02. In 2023 a CRISPR therapy for it was approved in the UK and the US. It never touches the mutation.

BEFORE · THE SWITCH IS HELD DOWN BCL11A ENHANCER INTACT BCL11A represses γ-GLOBIN GENE OFF only HbS is made, so it polymerises and the cell sickles AFTER · THE ENHANCER IS BROKEN CUT, THEN PATCHED BY NHEJ INDEL NOT MADE nothing holding it γ-GLOBIN GENE ON fetal haemoglobin returns and dilutes HbS below sickling

The mutation is still there. Casgevy does not repair HBB. The A→T is untouched, the gene still codes valine, and the patient still makes HbS. What the edit breaks is a switch: an enhancer that turns on BCL11A, the protein that shuts down fetal haemoglobin shortly after birth. Break the enhancer and the fetal gene comes back on, and HbF is enough to stop HbS polymerising. A disease caused by a mutation, treated by adding another one on purpose.

What actually happens

Out, edited, back in

Blood stem cells are taken from the patient’s own bone marrow, cut by Cas9 in the lab, and returned. Somatic and one patient only: nothing is inherited, because no gamete is ever involved.

Why break, not fix

NHEJ is the reliable edit

Correcting HBB would need HDR, which is far less efficient in stem cells. NHEJ knockouts work. So the designers went looking for a target where breaking something is the cure, and found the off-switch for fetal haemoglobin.

The honest cost

Not a pill

The marrow has to be cleared with chemotherapy before the edited cells are put back, with everything that carries. Add a price of over two million dollars and you have the ethics discussion below, in one real case.

A note from me

What the exam wants

Nobody will ask you for BCL11A. They may ask for an example of gene editing used therapeutically, and why somatic editing is permitted where germline is not. This is that example, and the detail is only here so the answer isn’t hand-waving.

Discussion · D1.3.9HL

What it is for, and what it costs

Tap a claim to see the strongest reply from the other side. Exam answers that only give one column don't reach the top band.

Somatic vs germline

The line most countries draw

Somatic editing treats one patient and stops there: Casgevy, approved in 2023, edits a patient's own bone-marrow cells to treat sickle cell disease. Germline editing changes embryos, so the change is inherited by everyone after. Most jurisdictions permit the first and prohibit the second.

Beyond medicine

Crops, models, biofactories

Disease-resistant and higher-yield crops; animal models of human disease; microbes engineered to make drugs, enzymes and fuels. Gene drives could suppress malarial mosquitoes, and could not be recalled.

Concept · D1.3.10HL

The sequences that never change

Compare the same gene across species and some stretches are nearly identical in a mouse, a fly and you. Two hypotheses compete to explain why, and you are asked for both.

Hypothesis 1 · selection

Change is not tolerated

The sequence codes for something essential, so almost any mutation is harmful or lethal and its carrier leaves fewer offspring. The variant is removed as fast as it appears: purifying selection. Histone genes, rRNA genes and homeobox genes are the standard examples.

Hypothesis 2 · mutation rate

Change rarely arrives

Some regions simply mutate less often: local sequence context, chromatin state and more efficient repair all lower the rate. The sequence looks conserved without selection having done the work.

Telling them apart

How you would test it

Compare the region with a nearby non-functional stretch of similar composition. If both are unchanged, the mutation rate is low. If only the functional one is unchanged, selection is doing it.

Why it matters here

Conservation predicts function

Conserved non-coding sequences are usually regulatory. Researchers use conservation to decide which regions are worth knocking out or editing: the two techniques above depend on this one.

Concept map · interactive

How it all hangs together

Tap a node to light up its links. The pink dashed link is the sentence that connects this whole topic to evolution.

Retrieval · drag and drop

Fill the gaps

Drag a term into a gap, or tap a term and then tap a gap. Two terms belong nowhere.

Check yourself · Paper 1 style

Twelve questions

Single best answer. You get the reasoning as soon as you commit. HL items are marked.

Score: 0 / 0