AP BIOLOGY · UNIT 7 · NATURAL SELECTION

Who leaves the most offspring?

A drought on one small island killed most of its finches in a year, and the ones left were not a random sample. Follow what selection needs (variation, inheritance, competition), what it acts on, why the same trait helps in one place and harms in another, and how people have used the same process on crops and dogs.

AP Biology 7.1 to 7.35 lessons8 chaptersdry lab

Start learningRun the dry labTeach it

One island, one dry year, and a population that was not the same afterward: watch which finches survive, which ones leave offspring, and why their chicks hatch with deeper beaks.
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Eight chapters and a dry lab: what evolution is (chapter 1), what natural selection needs (2 and 3), what fitness means (4), environments that change (5), a trait that helps in one place and harms in another (6), variation in the molecules of cells (7), and selection with people choosing (8). Make each prediction before you open the answer or run a film.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1A population changes; an individual does not
  2. 2More offspring than can survive
  3. 3Selection needs heritable differences
  4. 4Fitness is offspring, not strength
  5. 5When the environment changes, so does selection
  6. 6Helpful here, harmful there
  7. 7Variation inside the cell
  8. 8Selection with a person choosing

7.1.A Natural selection is a major mechanism of evolution

A population changes; an individual does not

  • Evolution is a change in the heritable traits of a population over generations. Populations evolve; individuals do not.
  • Natural selection is one major mechanism of evolution. Others (genetic drift, gene flow, mutation) come in the next guide.
  • Inheritance runs through the gametes, the eggs and sperm.
  • Charles Darwin, and Alfred Russel Wallace on his own, explained evolution by natural selection in 1858 and 1859.

A weightlifter builds large muscles over ten years of training. What will her children inherit from her?

The detail

  • A population is all the members of one species living in one area that can breed with each other.
  • Evolution is measured across generations. A trait that becomes more common, or less, in the young than it was in their parents is a sign that the population has evolved.
  • Only what is in the DNA of the gametes can be passed on. In an animal, a change to skin, muscle or bone stays with that body.
  • The first figure follows one real case, a population of finches through a drought, with the numbers simplified.

How we know

  • In the early 1800s Jean-Baptiste Lamarck suggested that organisms change by using or not using their parts, and pass the change on: a giraffe stretches, so its calf is born with a longer neck.
  • Darwin's On the Origin of Species (1859) gave a different mechanism, natural selection, which needs no change in any individual. Wallace had reached the same idea, and their papers were read together in 1858.
  • The evidence went Darwin's way: a change gained in life does not appear in the offspring, and the second figure shows why.

Watch out

  • Organisms do not change because they need to. Nothing in natural selection plans ahead or tries.
  • "Individuals evolve" is always wrong in an answer. Individuals are selected; populations evolve.

A medium ground finch hatches with a beak of a certain depth, and keeps that beak for life. Yet over a few generations the finches on one island can come to have deeper beaks on average. Nothing happened to any one bird's beak. The population changed, because some birds left more offspring than others and those offspring resembled their parents.

That is evolution: a change in the heritable traits of a population over generations. Natural selection is one major mechanism that causes it. Charles Darwin and, working on his own, Alfred Russel Wallace explained it in 1858 and 1859. The next guide adds the other mechanisms.

Before Darwin, Jean-Baptiste Lamarck had suggested that organisms pass on changes they gain by using their bodies: a giraffe stretching for leaves would have a calf born with a longer neck. It sounds reasonable, and it is wrong. A change made during a lifetime, like a lifter's muscle, is in body cells, not in the DNA of the gametes, so it cannot reach the next generation.

  • Evolution: a change in the heritable traits of a population over generations.
  • Natural selection is one major mechanism of evolution.
  • Individuals are selected; populations evolve.
  • Traits gained in a lifetime are not inherited.
Watch out Organisms do not change because they need to, and an individual never evolves. The population changes, generation by generation.
789101112Beak depth / mmone finchGeneration 1beaks vary, and chicksresemble their parentsmean 9.25mean 9.65Droughtonly big, hard seeds left:shallow beaks cannot crack them12 survivors breedtheir chicks inherit theiralleles for beak depthGeneration 2the population has changed:beaks about 4% deeper on averagegeneration 1beak depthParentchipped beakbreedsChickwhole beak
  1. Each dot is one finch. Beak depth varies, and the variation is heritable: chicks resemble their parents.
  2. A drought leaves only big, hard seeds. Most finches with shallow beaks die.
  3. The survivors reproduce and pass on their alleles, the deep-beak alleles among them.
  4. The next generation's beaks are deeper on average: the population has evolved. (Numbers simplified from the real study.)
  5. A beak chipped on a hard seed is not passed on: the chick hatches with a whole beak. A change acquired in life is not evolution.
Lamarck’s ideaearly 1800sDarwin’s idea1859: natural selectionstretches upneck lengthenspassed on?the calf expectednot inheritedborn with anordinary necknecks varylong necks leave more younggenerations later:long necks are more commona better explanationDarwin’s idea replaced Lamarck’s
  1. Lamarck's idea: a giraffe stretches for leaves, its neck lengthens, and it passes the change on.
  2. In fact the calf is born with an ordinary neck: a change gained in life is not inherited.
  3. Darwin's idea starts with variation: the necks in a herd are not all the same.
  4. Long necks reach more food in the dry season and leave more offspring. Their alleles go with them.
  5. Generations later, long necks are more common. The better explanation replaced the old one.

7.1.A Competition for limited resources

More offspring than can survive

  • Populations produce more offspring than the environment can support.
  • Resources (food, water, space, mates) are limited, so individuals compete for them.
  • The result is differential survival: some individuals live long enough to reproduce and others do not.
  • Individuals with more favorable phenotypes are more likely to survive and leave more offspring, which inherit their traits.

A female cod lays several million eggs a year, and the cod population stays about the same size from year to year. On average, how many of one pair's offspring survive to breed?

The detail

  • Every population could grow very fast if all its offspring lived: a pair of slow-breeding elephants would, within several centuries, leave millions of descendants.
  • Most populations stay roughly the same size over the long run, so most offspring die before they reproduce.
  • Competition is mostly between members of the same species, because they need exactly the same things.
  • Other causes of death (predators, disease, a cold snap) also sort individuals when the chance of dying depends on a trait.

How we know

  • The phrase "survival of the fittest" is not Darwin's. Herbert Spencer coined it in 1864, and Darwin added it to a later edition of his book. In biology it means reproductive success, as chapter 4 explains.

Remember it

  • ICE AGE is a mnemonic for the steps, not an AP term. Use the words on the back of each tile in an answer.

A female cod releases millions of eggs in a year, an oak drops thousands of acorns, and even an elephant, a slow breeder, would leave millions of descendants within several centuries if every calf lived. They do not all live. Most populations stay about the same size over the long run, so most offspring die before they can reproduce.

They die because resources are limited. There is only so much food, water, space and shelter, and the members of a population compete for it. Darwin saw that this competition does not pick at random. Individuals whose traits help them get food, avoid predators or survive the weather are more likely to live long enough to reproduce. This is differential survival, and it is the engine of natural selection.

The mnemonic below keeps the steps in order. The film runs one population through all six, and the next chapters take them apart.

Remember it The steps of natural selection: ICE AGE

  • IcyInherited variationindividuals differ, and the differences are heritable
  • CubsCompetitionmore offspring than resources can support
  • EatEnvironmental pressurea selective pressure means some survive and reproduce more
  • AnythingAdaptationfavorable traits are passed on more often
  • GrowingGenes (alleles)allele frequencies change from one generation to the next
  • EnormousEvolutionthe population has changed
  • More offspring are produced than can survive.
  • Limited resources mean competition, so survival is differential, not random.
  • Favorable phenotypes survive and reproduce more, and their offspring inherit them.
Watch out "Survival of the fittest" is Herbert Spencer's phrase, not Darwin's, and on its own it explains nothing. Write about competition for limited resources and differential survival and reproduction.
more young than places4 places with food, 4 adults12 young: far more than the places can hold4 find a place, 8 find none: food sets the limitthen a cold snapsparse patchcrowded patch2 of 4 die6 of 12 diehalf of each: the crowd makes no difference
  1. A habitat has four places with enough food, and four adults hold them.
  2. The adults raise twelve young: far more than the places can hold.
  3. The young compete. Only four find a place; eight find none. Food sets the limit, not the number born.
  4. A different pressure: two patches of seedlings, one sparse and one crowded.
  5. A cold snap kills half of each. An abiotic pressure like this one can strike whatever the crowding.
One population of beetles through the six steps, one at a time. Drag the bar back to look at any step again.

7.2.A Selection acts on phenotypic variation

Selection needs heritable differences

  • Natural selection acts on phenotypes: the traits a predator sees, or that decide who can crack a seed.
  • Selection acts on the phenotype, but what offspring receive from their parents is alleles. A trait is heritable when its differences are caused at least partly by differences in alleles.
  • New alleles arise by mutation. Meiosis (crossing over and independent assortment) and fertilization make new combinations of them.
  • Selection never makes a variation. It sorts the variation that is already there.

Finches on an island differ in beak depth, but imagine that none of the difference is inherited. A drought kills most of the shallow-beaked birds. The next generation's mean beak depth will be...

The detail

  • Phenotypic variation means differences in observable traits between individuals of a population: beak depth, color, the time a plant flowers, or the enzymes in a cell.
  • Part of the variation in most traits comes from the environment (food, temperature) and part from alleles. Selection on the part caused by the environment changes nothing in the next generation.
  • Mutation is a change in the base sequence of DNA. It is the only source of new alleles, and it happens with no regard for whether the allele would help.
  • Crossing over and independent assortment in meiosis, then the random joining of gametes at fertilization, give each offspring a new mix of the alleles already in the population.

Links across the course

Watch out

  • Selection acts on the phenotype, but what is passed on is the genotype. A phenotype helps the next generation only through the alleles behind it.

A drought cannot see alleles. It sees beaks: which birds can crack the seeds that are left. Natural selection acts on phenotypic variation, the differences in traits between individuals. Some of those differences come from the environment, a bird that ate well as a chick, and some from differences in alleles.

Only the second kind matters to the next generation. A trait is heritable when offspring resemble their parents in it because they inherit their alleles. If the survivors of a drought had deep beaks only because they were well fed, their chicks would hatch with ordinary beaks, and the population would not change.

The heritable variation is supplied by three things, each from an earlier unit. Mutation changes the base sequence of DNA and is the only source of new alleles. Meiosis, by crossing over and independent assortment, deals each gamete a new combination of alleles, and fertilization joins two gametes at random. None of the three responds to need: the variation arises first, and the environment then decides which of it does well.

Remember it What selection needs: VIP

  • VeryVariationindividuals differ in a trait
  • ImportantInheritancethe differences are heritable
  • ParentsProduction of offspring is unequalsome leave more offspring than others, because of the trait
  • Selection acts on phenotypes; only heritable variation is passed on.
  • Mutation makes new alleles; meiosis and fertilization make new combinations.
  • Variation comes first. Selection sorts it.
Watch out A mutation is not caused by the need for it. An insecticide does not make the alleles that resist it, and a drought does not make deep-beak alleles.
mutation: a new alleleGACTTGCAATGCallele 1GACTTACAATGCa new allelea copying error: G changed to Ameiosis: new combinationsABAbaBaba pair, crossing overABparentalAbnewaBnewabparentalfour gametes
  1. A gene is a sequence of bases. This version is one allele of the gene.
  2. A copying error changes one base. The changed sequence is a new allele: mutation is the source of new alleles.
  3. In meiosis, crossing over swaps pieces between a pair of chromosomes that carry the alleles A, B and a, b.
  4. The gametes carry combinations that neither chromosome had before. Fertilization then joins two gametes at random.
Run it once as it is. Then switch off Color is heritable: the birds still eat the beetles that stand out, but the population stops changing.

7.1.B Evolutionary fitness is measured by reproductive success

Fitness is offspring, not strength

  • Evolutionary fitness is measured by reproductive success: how many offspring an individual leaves that survive and reproduce in their turn.
  • Surviving matters because it gives an individual the chance to reproduce.
  • Fitness belongs to a phenotype in a particular environment. The same trait can mean high fitness in one place and low in another.
  • Alleles of the individuals with the highest fitness become more common in the population.

Four birds of one species live in the same wood. Which bird has the highest evolutionary fitness?

The detail

  • Fitness is about the next generation. The offspring must themselves live to reproduce, or the alleles go no further.
  • Biologists compare fitness between phenotypes: the mean number of surviving offspring of dark moths against pale moths, say, on the same trees.
  • Many things raise reproductive success without making an animal bigger or stronger: being hard to see, breeding earlier, raising young more carefully, using less water.

Watch out

  • "Fittest" in biology never means strongest, fastest or healthiest. If an exam answer says "fitness", it should also say "offspring" or "reproductive success".
  • An animal with fitness zero can still be healthy and live for years. A sterile mule is an example.

In everyday English a fit animal is strong and quick. In biology, evolutionary fitness is measured by reproductive success: the number of offspring an individual leaves that survive to reproduce in their turn. A mule, which is almost always sterile, can live thirty healthy years and leave no offspring, so its fitness is zero.

Surviving still matters, because the dead do not reproduce. But it matters only as a step toward offspring. The figure shows three birds: the one that lived longest is not the one whose alleles are most common in the next generation.

Fitness also depends on where an individual lives. A pale moth is hard for a bird to see on pale bark and easy to see on dark bark, so the same moth can have high fitness in one wood and low fitness in the next. Be the bird in the game below: the moths you miss leave the offspring.

  • Fitness = reproductive success: offspring that survive to reproduce.
  • A long life with no offspring is a fitness of zero.
  • Fitness depends on the environment.
Watch out The fittest is not the strongest. It is the one that leaves the most offspring that go on to reproduce.
fitness counts young that breedyears livedyoung that bred8none35The bird that lived least has the highest fitness.acquired traits stay behindgrew largeon extra foodparent’s DNAGACTAGCTpassed on unchangedchick’s DNAGACTAGCTnormal sizenot heritable
  1. Three birds, and how many years each lived.
  2. And how many offspring each raised that reached reproductive age.
  3. The bird that lived least has the highest fitness. Survival matters only because it lets an animal reproduce.
  4. A parent grew large on extra food. Its DNA bases are the same as before: the size was acquired.
  5. The chick inherits the same bases and hatches a normal size: an acquired trait is not heritable.

7.2.A, 7.1.B Selective pressures, and environments that change

When the environment changes, so does selection

  • A selective pressure is any feature of the environment that makes some phenotypes survive and reproduce better than others.
  • Pressures are abiotic (rainfall, temperature, a chemical) or biotic (predators, parasites, competitors, food organisms).
  • Environments can be stable or fluctuating. When they change, the direction and the rate of evolution can change.
  • Different genetic variations can be selected in different generations.

After the 1977 drought on Daphne Major, deeper beaks were favored. Then in 1982 and 1983 a very wet year covered the island in small, soft seeds. In the dry years that followed, which way did selection most likely push beak size?

The detail

  • On Daphne Major, a small Galápagos island, the 1977 drought killed more than four in five of the medium ground finches. The survivors' beaks were on average about half a millimeter deeper than the population's before the drought, and their offspring hatched with deeper beaks than the population had before.
  • After the wet years of 1982 and 1983, selection in the dry years that followed favored smaller birds. The same population, a few years apart, was selected in opposite directions.
  • Field mustard plants grown side by side from seed collected in southern California before and after a run of dry years flowered earlier after the drought: about 2 days earlier at one site and about 9 at the other. Flowering early lets a plant set seed before the soil dries out.
  • A stable environment usually means slow change; a sudden change, a fast one; a fluctuating one, a population that tracks it back and forth.

Examples to reason with

  • Flowering time and climate change, DDT resistance and sickle cell anemia are the examples the course names. You will be given others in the exam, so learn the reasoning, not a list.

Watch out

  • A species that looks the same for millions of years has not stopped evolving. Crocodylians have a long and varied history, with many forms now extinct, and a body plan that stays the same is still being kept the same by selection.

Beyond the course: three patterns of selection

  • The course does not name these, but your teacher may. The fold under this chapter has the film.

A selective pressure is anything in the environment that makes some phenotypes do better than others. It can be abiotic, like a drought or the cold, or biotic, like a predator, a disease or a competing species.

Environments do not stay the same. Peter and Rosemary Grant and their team have measured the finches of Daphne Major, a small Galápagos island, year after year from 1973. The 1977 drought there killed more than four in five of the island's medium ground finches. Only large, hard seeds were left, the birds with deeper beaks survived better, and their offspring hatched with deeper beaks on average than the population had before. A few years later the environment swung the other way.

Because environments can be stable or fluctuating, the direction of evolution can change, and so can its rate: fast after a sudden change, slow when little changes, back and forth when the environment swings. The graph follows one population through two turns. Plants respond as well: field mustard grown from seed collected after a run of dry years in California flowered days earlier than plants grown from seed collected before them.

  • Selective pressures are abiotic or biotic.
  • A changing environment changes the direction and rate of evolution.
  • The variation selected can differ from one generation to the next.
Watch out Evolution has not stopped in species that look unchanged. Selection that keeps a body plan the same is still selection.
1975198019851990YearA sketch of the pattern in the published record. Not to scale.Mean beak depth (mm)Rainfall (mm)deepershallower1977 droughtwet years, 1982 to 1983mean beak depthmean beak depthrainfallWhat happened next?Answer the Check first.
  1. Mean beak depth of the medium ground finches on Daphne Major, year by year, with the rainfall behind it. After the 1977 drought, the line rises. Answer the predict box before you step on. The graph is a sketch of the pattern in the published record, not a plot of measured values.
  2. The wet years of 1982 and 1983 left the island full of small, soft seeds. In the dry years that followed, the line turned down: selection had changed direction. A sketch of the pattern, not a plot of measured values.
Population 1seed collected 1997seed collected 2004first flowers open, day by dayabout 2 days earlierPopulation 2seed collected 1997seed collected 2004first flowers open, day by dayabout 9 days earlierdrought years between the two collectionsEach pair of rows is drawn at one moment. The days are relative; plants not to scale.
Field mustard grown side by side, in the same conditions, from seed collected before (1997) and after (2004) a run of dry years in southern California. Plants from the later seed flowered about 2 days earlier for one population and about 9 days earlier for the other.
Beyond the coursethree patterns of selection, and mate choice

The CED does not name these. Your teacher may. Biologists sort selection on a trait such as beak depth into three patterns, by which part of the range of phenotypes does best.

Directional selection favors one end of the range, so the mean moves. The Daphne Major finches in 1977 are an example: deeper beaks did best, and the mean beak depth rose.

Stabilizing selection favors the middle and removes both ends, so the spread narrows. Human birth mass has been the classic example: babies much lighter or much heavier than average were less likely to survive, though modern medicine has weakened this.

Disruptive selection favors both ends over the middle, so the range splits. In the black-bellied seedcracker, an African finch, birds with small bills feed well on soft seeds and birds with large bills on hard seeds, and birds in between do worse at both.

One more pattern you may meet: sexual selection, where a trait spreads because it helps an individual win mates, even when it costs it survival.

number of birdsbeak depthsmallmediumlargebeforeafterDirectional selectionone tail is removed: the curve shiftsremovedshare of alleles for S small, M medium, L largebeforeS 25%M 50%L 25%afterSM 48%L 40%Stabilizing selectionboth tails are removed: the curve narrowsremovedremovedshare of alleles for S small, M medium, L largebeforeS 25%M 50%L 25%afterSM 76%LDisruptive selectionthe middle is removed: the curve splitsremovedshare of alleles for S small, M medium, L largebeforeS 25%M 50%L 25%afterS 40%M 20%L 40%
  1. Directional: one tail of the curve is removed, and the whole curve shifts. Alleles for large beaks become more common.
  2. Stabilizing: both tails are removed and the curve narrows. Alleles for the extremes become rarer.
  3. Disruptive: the middle is removed and the curve splits in two. Alleles for both extremes become more common.
The same population of finches selected three ways, with the share of one allele shifting under the curve each time.
ICEAGElarge jawsslender jawsa wet yearHow common each version of the jaw gene islarge-jaw versionslender-jaw versionwhere it startedgeneration 1ICEAGEdrought: only tough seedsHow common each version of the jaw gene islarge-jaw versionslender-jaw versionwhere it startedgeneration 1ICEAGEthree dry years onHow common each version of the jaw gene islarge-jaw versionslender-jaw versionwhere it startedgeneration 1generation 2generation 3generation 4
  1. Generation 1: the beetles' jaws vary, slender to large, and each carries two copies of the jaw gene (the pips: pink for large, green for slender). Which letter is this?
  2. A drought leaves only tough seeds: who cracks them, and who starves? Predict before you run it.
  3. Three dry years on. What has happened to the population, and to any one beetle?

7.2.A A variation raises or lowers fitness in a particular environment

Helpful here, harmful there

  • Some phenotypic variations can raise or lower the fitness of an organism in a particular environment.
  • Whether a variation is favorable depends on the environment, not on the variation itself.
  • DDT resistance: resistance alleles arise by chance mutation, not because of DDT. DDT killed the susceptible mosquitoes, so the resistant ones left more offspring.
  • The sickle cell allele is the human example: it raises survival where malaria is common and costs where it is not.

A village stops spraying DDT for twenty years. The resistance allele often costs a mosquito something when there is no DDT around. Its frequency in the village's mosquitoes most likely...

The detail

  • DDT was first made in 1874. Its use as an insecticide was found in 1939, and the chemist who found it won a Nobel Prize in 1948. It was sprayed widely against the mosquitoes that carry malaria.
  • Within a few years of heavy spraying, resistant mosquito populations were being reported in many places. Spraying did not cause the mutations: it changed which mosquitoes survived to reproduce.
  • In the malaria mosquito Anopheles funestus, one resistance allele changes a single amino acid in a detoxifying enzyme called GSTe2. The change widens the site where DDT binds, so the enzyme breaks DDT down, and resistant mosquitoes also make more of the enzyme.
  • The United States banned DDT by an order of June 1972 that took effect at the end of that year, because of its effects on wildlife and concerns for human health.
  • A resistance allele often has a cost when the insecticide is absent: the changed enzyme may do its usual work less well, or making extra enzyme may take energy.

Links across the course

  • The sickle cell allele, and why it is common where malaria is, is the last chapter of the next guide, on population genetics.

Watch out

  • "DDT caused the mosquitoes to mutate" is wrong. The resistance alleles arose by chance mutation, before or during spraying; DDT changed who survived.
  • A resistant mosquito is the same species as a susceptible one. It differs in one or a few alleles.

There is no such thing as a good allele or a bad one in general. A variation raises fitness in one environment and lowers it in another, and the same variation can make a large difference to an individual's survival, and to whether a population survives at all, depending on where it lives.

DDT shows it plainly. When spraying against malaria mosquitoes began in the 1940s, a few mosquitoes carried alleles that let them survive it, alleles that arise by chance mutation whether or not there is DDT around. Spraying killed the rest, the resistant ones left the offspring, and within years whole populations were resistant. In one malaria mosquito the allele changes one amino acid in a detoxifying enzyme, so that it binds DDT and breaks it down.

In a village that never sprays, the same allele helps nothing, and it usually costs something. The figure puts the two villages side by side: answer the predict box, then switch the environment. The human example of the same idea is the sickle cell allele, which helps a carrier survive where malaria is common and brings harm where malaria is absent. The next guide tells that story in full.

  • A variation's effect on fitness depends on the environment.
  • DDT did not cause resistance; it selected resistance alleles already present.
  • Remove the pressure and a costly allele becomes less common.
Watch out DDT does not cause resistance mutations. The alleles arise by chance; DDT changed who survived to reproduce.
resistantsusceptibleSprayed villagesprayed with DDT for yearsDDT IN THE AIRNO DDT IN THE AIRFitnessoffspring per mosquitoresistant1.0susceptible0.2resistant0.9susceptible1.0illustrative valuesanswer the Check firstUnsprayed villagenever sprayed with DDTDDT IN THE AIRNO DDT IN THE AIRFitnessoffspring per mosquitoresistant1.0susceptible0.2resistant0.9susceptible1.0illustrative valuesanswer the Check first
Two villages, one sprayed with DDT for years and one never sprayed, each with resistant and susceptible mosquitoes. Answer the predict box, then switch between DDT present and no DDT today to see each kind's fitness. The fitness values are illustrative.

7.2.B Variation in the number and types of molecules within cells

Variation inside the cell

  • Individuals and populations vary in the number and the types of molecules in their cells, not only in traits you can see.
  • That variation gives a population a greater ability to survive and reproduce in different environments.
  • Number: more copies of a gene can mean more of its enzyme, as in insects that break down an insecticide.
  • Types: different fatty acids in membrane lipids, or different versions of a protein such as hemoglobin, suit different conditions.

Two populations of one fish species live in warm water and in cold water. Which difference in their cells would you expect to help the cold-water fish?

The detail

  • More copies. Some mosquitoes and aphids resistant to organophosphate insecticides carry many copies of a gene for an esterase, an enzyme that breaks the insecticide down. More copies, more enzyme, faster detoxifying.
  • Different types. The kinks in unsaturated fatty acid tails keep a membrane fluid in the cold. Fish in cold water tend to have a higher share of unsaturated fatty acids in their membranes. Part of this changes within one fish's life as the water cools, and part differs between populations in their alleles; selection acts on the inherited part.
  • Another version of a protein. Deer mice living high in the mountains of North America carry hemoglobin alleles whose proteins bind oxygen more tightly than those of lowland deer mice, which helps where the air holds less oxygen.
  • The DDT-resistant malaria mosquitoes of chapter 6 have both: a changed enzyme (a different type) and more of it (a greater number).

Links across the course

Watch out

  • A population with more variation in its molecules is not "better" in every place. It has more variations for a changed environment to favor.

Not all variation is on the outside. Individuals differ in the molecules inside their cells: in how many copies of a protein they make, and in which types of molecule they make. This variation is heritable like any other, and it gives a population a greater ability to survive and reproduce in different environments.

Number. Some insecticide-resistant mosquitoes and aphids carry many copies of a gene for an enzyme that breaks the insecticide down, so their cells make far more of it. Type. The fatty acid tails of membrane phospholipids differ: unsaturated tails, with their kinks, keep a membrane fluid in the cold, and fish in cold water tend to have more of them. Another version. Deer mice high in the mountains carry hemoglobin alleles whose protein binds oxygen more tightly, where the air is thin.

Tap each card in the figure for the molecule, the environment it suits, and why. A population that holds a range of such variations has more for a changed environment to favor.

  • Molecules vary in number and type between individuals and populations.
  • That variation lets a population survive and reproduce in different environments.
  • Examples to reason with: extra enzyme gene copies, membrane fatty acids, hemoglobin versions.
Watch out The cold does not make a fish's genes change. Fish whose alleles gave them more fluid membranes in the cold survived and reproduced more.
More copiesof one geneone gene copymany copiesgeneenzymeinsecticideDifferent typesof one kind of moleculePopulation Asaturated tailsPopulation Bunsaturated tails,with kinksmembrane phospholipidsAnother versionof one proteinlowland deer mousehighland deer mouseoxygensame low oxygen in both

Tap a card: what varies, and where it helps.

Three kinds of variation in the molecules of cells. The drawings are not to scale.

7.3.A Artificial selection

Selection with a person choosing

  • In artificial selection, humans choose which individuals reproduce, so humans are the selective pressure.
  • The mechanism is the same as natural selection: heritable variation, unequal reproduction, a change in the population over generations.
  • Humans affect the variation in other species this way: one wild cabbage gave kale, cabbage, broccoli and more; dogs come in hundreds of breeds.
  • Breeders can choose only among the variation that already exists.

Farmers breed only from their highest-yielding cows for 50 years. Compared with the starting herd, the genetic variation in the herd is most likely...

The detail

  • Wild cabbage (Brassica oleracea) grows on sea cliffs in Europe. Selecting for leaves, the terminal bud, side buds, the stem or the flower heads gave kale, cabbage, Brussels sprouts, kohlrabi, broccoli and cauliflower. All six are still one species.
  • Maize was bred from a wild grass, teosinte, starting about 9,000 years ago in the Balsas River valley of southern Mexico. Teosinte has a few hard seeds on a small spike; selection gave the large cob.
  • In Illinois, maize has been selected for high and for low oil content every year since 1896, more than 100 generations, and the lines still respond.
  • Compare an antibiotic: it is a pressure people add, but nobody chooses which bacteria live, so resistance spreading through bacteria is natural selection (the second half of the second figure).

The cost

  • A breed or crop variety comes from a few chosen parents, so many alleles of the wild population are missing from it: artificial selection often lowers genetic variation.
  • Low variation can mean more inherited disorders in some dog breeds, and a whole crop open to one new disease. The next guide returns to this.

Watch out

  • Humans choosing does not make the alleles. Breeders can only choose among the variation that mutation and meiosis have supplied.

A breeder who keeps seed only from the biggest cobs, or breeds only the gentlest dogs, is doing what a drought does to finches: deciding who reproduces. In artificial selection the selective pressure is a person's choice. Everything else is the same: heritable variation, unequal reproduction, and a population that changes over generations.

Humans have changed the variation in other species enormously this way. One wild plant, the wild cabbage of European sea cliffs, became six vegetables, each selected for a different part of the plant. Maize was bred from teosinte, a wild grass, starting about 9,000 years ago in southern Mexico, and selection in Illinois has changed the oil content of maize every year since 1896.

Choosing a few parents has a price. Each breed or variety carries only the alleles of the individuals chosen to found it, so its genetic variation is often lower than the wild population's. A dog breed can carry more inherited disorders, and a crop of near-identical plants can be wiped out by one disease. The dry lab lets you do the selecting.

  • Artificial selection: humans choose the parents.
  • Same mechanism as natural selection; a human selective pressure.
  • It can lower genetic variation within a breed or crop.
Watch out Selection, natural or artificial, never makes new alleles. It can only favor alleles that already exist.
terminal budleavesflowersside budsstemWild cabbageBrassica oleraceaon a sea cliffartificial selectionKaleleavesCabbageterminal budBrussels sproutsside budsKohlrabistemBroccoliflower stalksCauliflowerflower budsall one species
  1. Wild cabbage: leaves, buds at the tip and along the stem, and yellow flowers.
  2. Selected for leaves: kale. Selected for a big terminal bud: cabbage.
  3. Selected for side buds: Brussels sprouts. Selected for a swollen stem: kohlrabi.
  4. Selected for flower stalks and buds: broccoli and cauliflower. All six can still interbreed: one species.
artificial selection: people choose the parentsgen 1the largest are pickedgen 2gen 3the cobs get biggerbacteria in a dishone resistant cell among manyadd anantibioticthe susceptible die; the resistant multiplynobody chose it: natural selection
  1. A crop varies in the size of its cobs. Each plant's size is partly heritable.
  2. The breeder picks the largest and lets only those reproduce.
  3. Repeat for a few generations: the cobs get steadily bigger, as the alleles for size become more common.
  4. A dish of bacteria with one resistant cell among many susceptible ones.
  5. Add an antibiotic: the susceptible cells die, the resistant one multiplies. Nobody chose it, so this is natural selection.

02Dry lab: Select for hairy plants

Count the hairs on the first true leaf of forty fast-growing mustard seedlings, let only the hairiest tenth breed, and grow their offspring. Then grow the same plants with parents chosen at random, and compare.

GENERATION 1plant 1 of 40: 0 counted04808162432number of plantshairs on the first true leafgen 1linegenerationnmeanSEparents’ mean
The bench: a tray of forty seedlings, one leaf under the lens with the hairs on its margin to count, and the histogram and results table to fill in, generation by generation.
Your questionDoes choosing the hairiest plants as parents, generation after generation, change the number of hairs in the population? Make a prediction for each run before you grow it, including the run with parents chosen at random.
What you can changeHow the parents are chosen (the hairiest tenth, or at random as the control), how many generations you grow, and how heritable the hair count is. Each new tray is a new sample of plants, so growing again is how you repeat.
What to recordFor each generation, the hair count of every plant you count, the mean and the standard error, and the mean of the parents you chose. The plants and their counts are a model, set to behave as the real fast plants do in the classroom investigation.

Find out

  • Count the first tray. Count the hairs on the first true leaf of the plants in your sample and plot the histogram. Describe the spread before you choose anything.
  • Select. Let only the hairiest tenth reproduce, grow their offspring, and count again. Repeat for three or four generations.
  • The control. Grow the same starting plants with parents chosen at random. Does the mean move?
  • No inheritance. Set heritability to zero and select the hairiest again. What happens to the mean, and why?
  • Claim and evidence. Write one sentence of claim about what caused the change in hair number, then two sentences of evidence from both runs.

Record

  • For each generation: the hair count of each plant you counted. The table fills as you count, and the histogram shows each generation over the last.
  • The mean and the standard error of each generation, and the mean of the parents you chose.
  • The same for the control run, side by side, so the two can be compared generation by generation.
  • Download the CSV to keep your table and draw your own graph of the mean against generation.

The plants in a tray have a mean of 12 hairs. The parents you choose have a mean of 20, and the heritability of hair number is set at 0.5. What mean do you expect in their offspring?

After four generations, the selected line's mean has risen and the line with random parents has not. What does the control line add to your claim?

The selected line rises fast at first and more slowly by generation 4. Which explanation fits best?

Claim and evidence

Make a claim about whether choosing the parents caused the change in hair number. Support it with evidence from both of your runs.

03Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in. It opens on biologybybradford.com, so it needs the internet.

Exam practice

Exam questions on 7.1 to 7.3, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

04Downloads

This file is the guide, saved to run without the internet.

Saved from biologybybradford.com/guides/ap-biology-unit-7-natural-and-artificial-selection, where the guide is kept up to date with the notes, the revision sheet and, for the teacher, the lesson plans and slides.

05Teacher resources

The guide as five one-hour lessons: what each covers, its focus and the chapters it uses.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1What evolution is, and the struggle 7.1.A60 min Evolution as change in a population, acquired traits not inherited, and the struggle: more offspring than resources can support, competition and differential survival 1, 2
2Variation and fitness 7.2.A, 7.1.B60 min Selection acts on phenotypic variation, only heritable variation changes the next generation, and fitness is reproductive success 3, 4
3Selective pressures and changing environments 7.2.A, 7.1.B60 min Selective pressures, biotic and abiotic, and how a fluctuating environment changes the direction and rate of evolution, read from data 5
4It depends on the environment; molecules 7.2.A, 7.2.B60 min A variation that raises fitness in one environment and lowers it in another, DDT resistance, and variation in the number and types of molecules in cells 6, 7
5Artificial selection and the dry lab 7.3.A, 7.1.B60 min Artificial selection as humans choosing the parents, its effect on variation, and a selection experiment with a control 8, dry lab

The revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTICE AND REVIEW

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for Unit 7

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.