7.1.A Natural selection is a major mechanism of evolution
A population changes; an individual does not
- Evolution is a change in the heritable traits of a population over generations. Populations evolve; individuals do not.
- Natural selection is one major mechanism of evolution. Others (genetic drift, gene flow, mutation) come in the next guide.
- Inheritance runs through the gametes, the eggs and sperm.
- Charles Darwin, and Alfred Russel Wallace on his own, explained evolution by natural selection in 1858 and 1859.
A weightlifter builds large muscles over ten years of training. What will her children inherit from her?
The alleles she was born with. Training changed her muscle cells, not the DNA in the cells that make her eggs, so nothing she built can reach her children. They inherit half her alleles, whatever she did with them, and they may or may not grow strong depending on their own alleles and their own lives.
The detail
- A population is all the members of one species living in one area that can breed with each other.
- Evolution is measured across generations. A trait that becomes more common, or less, in the young than it was in their parents is a sign that the population has evolved.
- Only what is in the DNA of the gametes can be passed on. In an animal, a change to skin, muscle or bone stays with that body.
- The first figure follows one real case, a population of finches through a drought, with the numbers simplified.
How we know
- In the early 1800s Jean-Baptiste Lamarck suggested that organisms change by using or not using their parts, and pass the change on: a giraffe stretches, so its calf is born with a longer neck.
- Darwin's On the Origin of Species (1859) gave a different mechanism, natural selection, which needs no change in any individual. Wallace had reached the same idea, and their papers were read together in 1858.
- The evidence went Darwin's way: a change gained in life does not appear in the offspring, and the second figure shows why.
Watch out
- Organisms do not change because they need to. Nothing in natural selection plans ahead or tries.
- "Individuals evolve" is always wrong in an answer. Individuals are selected; populations evolve.
A medium ground finch hatches with a beak of a certain depth, and keeps that beak for life. Yet over a few generations the finches on one island can come to have deeper beaks on average. Nothing happened to any one bird's beak. The population changed, because some birds left more offspring than others and those offspring resembled their parents.
That is evolution: a change in the heritable traits of a population over generations. Natural selection is one major mechanism that causes it. Charles Darwin and, working on his own, Alfred Russel Wallace explained it in 1858 and 1859. The next guide adds the other mechanisms.
Before Darwin, Jean-Baptiste Lamarck had suggested that organisms pass on changes they gain by using their bodies: a giraffe stretching for leaves would have a calf born with a longer neck. It sounds reasonable, and it is wrong. A change made during a lifetime, like a lifter's muscle, is in body cells, not in the DNA of the gametes, so it cannot reach the next generation.
- Evolution: a change in the heritable traits of a population over generations.
- Natural selection is one major mechanism of evolution.
- Individuals are selected; populations evolve.
- Traits gained in a lifetime are not inherited.
- Each dot is one finch. Beak depth varies, and the variation is heritable: chicks resemble their parents.
- A drought leaves only big, hard seeds. Most finches with shallow beaks die.
- The survivors reproduce and pass on their alleles, the deep-beak alleles among them.
- The next generation's beaks are deeper on average: the population has evolved. (Numbers simplified from the real study.)
- A beak chipped on a hard seed is not passed on: the chick hatches with a whole beak. A change acquired in life is not evolution.
- Lamarck's idea: a giraffe stretches for leaves, its neck lengthens, and it passes the change on.
- In fact the calf is born with an ordinary neck: a change gained in life is not inherited.
- Darwin's idea starts with variation: the necks in a herd are not all the same.
- Long necks reach more food in the dry season and leave more offspring. Their alleles go with them.
- Generations later, long necks are more common. The better explanation replaced the old one.