7.10.A The biological species concept
What makes a species
- The biological species concept: a species is a group of organisms that can interbreed and exchange genes to produce viable, fertile offspring.
- Viable means the offspring live; fertile means they can breed in turn.
- Looking alike, or looking different, does not decide it. Breeding does.
- The concept is for sexually reproducing organisms. It cannot be tested on organisms that reproduce asexually, or on fossils.
The detail
- "Can interbreed" means in nature, or as they would if they met: two populations on separate islands are one species if their members would breed together and their young would be fertile.
- Members of one species share one pool of alleles, because alleles pass between them at every mating. That shared pool is what keeps a species one thing.
- A horse and a donkey can mate, and their mule is healthy, but a mule is sterile. Horse and donkey alleles go no further, so they are two species.
Where the concept struggles
- Bacteria and other organisms that reproduce asexually do not interbreed, and a fossil cannot be bred. These are grouped by their structures and their DNA sequences instead.
- Splitting takes time, so some pairs of populations are part of the way there: they interbreed a little where they meet. Whether they are one species or two is then a judgment.
Where this guide goes
- Chapters 1 to 7: new species. What a species is, how gene flow stops (2), where (3), what keeps species apart (4), one lineage into many (5), many lineages into one shape (6) and how fast (7).
- Chapters 8 and 9: the origin of life. They stand alone and can be read first.
A Great Dane and a Chihuahua look less alike than two meadowlarks that only an expert can tell apart, yet the dogs are one species and the birds are two. So a species is not decided by looks. The definition used most is the biological species concept: a species is a group of organisms that can interbreed and exchange genetic information to produce viable offspring (they survive) that are fertile (they can breed in turn).
Both words matter. A horse and a donkey can mate, and their mule is strong and healthy: viable. But a mule is sterile, so no horse or donkey allele passes through it to a next generation. Horses and donkeys stay separate gene pools, and that makes them separate species.
The concept has limits. It is for organisms that reproduce sexually: a bacterium that divides in two never interbreeds, and a fossil cannot be tested, so these are classed by their structures and sequences. Decide each pair in the figure, then tap it for the reasoning.
- Species: can interbreed to produce viable, fertile offspring.
- Viable and fertile are two separate tests of the offspring.
- Looks do not define a species; for asexual organisms and fossils, the concept cannot be applied.
A horse and a donkey mate and produce a healthy mule, which is sterile. By the biological species concept, horses and donkeys are...
Two species. The mule is viable but not fertile, so no allele from a horse or a donkey passes through it to another generation: the two gene pools stay apart. Mating, or a healthy offspring, is not enough. The concept applies to any sexually reproducing organism, wild or domestic.
Decide first: one species or two? Then tap a pair for the reasoning.
- Horse and donkey: two species. The mule is viable but sterile, so no alleles pass on through it.
- The two meadowlarks: two species. They look alike but do not interbreed: each answers only its own song.
- Great Dane and Chihuahua: one species. Very different, but they interbreed and their pups are fertile.
- Lion and tiger: two species. In the wild they do not meet or interbreed; most zoo hybrid males are sterile. Looks and a zoo are not the test.