Biology  by Bradford
support
AP BIOLOGY · UNIT 7 · NATURAL SELECTION

One species becomes two

A river, a mountain range or a change of fruit can split one population into two that no longer exchange genes. See what keeps them apart, how fast new species can appear, why unrelated animals end up looking alike, and then go back to the start: what the rocks say about when life began, and why RNA may have come first.

AP Biology 7.10 and 7.124 lessons9 chaptersdry lab

Start learningRun the dry labTeach it

Nothing told them to become two species. They just stopped trading genes. A river splits one population, each side changes under its own selection, and when the river dries they no longer mate with each other. The animals are made up, not a real species.
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Nine chapters and a dry lab, in two parts that stand alone. New species: what a species is (chapter 1), how gene flow stops (2), where it stops (3), what keeps species apart (4), one ancestor into many (5), many lineages into one shape (6) and how fast it all goes (7). The origins of life: the window the rocks give (8) and the RNA world (9). Make each prediction before you open the answer.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1What makes a species
  2. 2Speciation starts when gene flow stops
  3. 3Apart or in the same place
  4. 4What keeps two species apart
  5. 5One ancestor, many ways of life
  6. 6Different lineages, the same shape
  7. 7Slow and steady, or long waits and bursts
  8. 8The window the rocks give
  9. 9Why RNA may have come first

7.10.A The biological species concept

What makes a species

  • The biological species concept: a species is a group of organisms that can interbreed and exchange genes to produce viable, fertile offspring.
  • Viable means the offspring live; fertile means they can breed in turn.
  • Looking alike, or looking different, does not decide it. Breeding does.
  • The concept is for sexually reproducing organisms. It cannot be tested on organisms that reproduce asexually, or on fossils.

The detail

  • "Can interbreed" means in nature, or as they would if they met: two populations on separate islands are one species if their members would breed together and their young would be fertile.
  • Members of one species share one pool of alleles, because alleles pass between them at every mating. That shared pool is what keeps a species one thing.
  • A horse and a donkey can mate, and their mule is healthy, but a mule is sterile. Horse and donkey alleles go no further, so they are two species.

Where the concept struggles

  • Bacteria and other organisms that reproduce asexually do not interbreed, and a fossil cannot be bred. These are grouped by their structures and their DNA sequences instead.
  • Splitting takes time, so some pairs of populations are part of the way there: they interbreed a little where they meet. Whether they are one species or two is then a judgment.

Where this guide goes

  • Chapters 1 to 7: new species. What a species is, how gene flow stops (2), where (3), what keeps species apart (4), one lineage into many (5), many lineages into one shape (6) and how fast (7).
  • Chapters 8 and 9: the origin of life. They stand alone and can be read first.

A Great Dane and a Chihuahua look less alike than two meadowlarks that only an expert can tell apart, yet the dogs are one species and the birds are two. So a species is not decided by looks. The definition used most is the biological species concept: a species is a group of organisms that can interbreed and exchange genetic information to produce viable offspring (they survive) that are fertile (they can breed in turn).

Both words matter. A horse and a donkey can mate, and their mule is strong and healthy: viable. But a mule is sterile, so no horse or donkey allele passes through it to a next generation. Horses and donkeys stay separate gene pools, and that makes them separate species.

The concept has limits. It is for organisms that reproduce sexually: a bacterium that divides in two never interbreeds, and a fossil cannot be tested, so these are classed by their structures and sequences. Decide each pair in the figure, then tap it for the reasoning.

  • Species: can interbreed to produce viable, fertile offspring.
  • Viable and fertile are two separate tests of the offspring.
  • Looks do not define a species; for asexual organisms and fossils, the concept cannot be applied.
Watch out "They can mate, so they are one species" is not the test. The offspring must be viable and fertile, so that genes keep flowing between the two groups.

A horse and a donkey mate and produce a healthy mule, which is sterile. By the biological species concept, horses and donkeys are...

horse and donkey,and their muletwo meadowlarks:alike, with different songsGreat Dane and Chihuahua:very different sizeslion and tiger, anda hybrid born in a zoo horse and donkey,and their muletwo meadowlarks:alike, with different songsGreat Dane and Chihuahua:very different sizeslion and tiger, anda hybrid born in a zoo

Decide first: one species or two? Then tap a pair for the reasoning.

Four pairs. For each, decide: one species or two, and what would you need to know? The dogs are drawn to scale.

7.10.A Reproductive isolation

Speciation starts when gene flow stops

  • Speciation, one species becoming two, occurs when two populations become reproductively isolated from each other.
  • While populations interbreed, gene flow carries alleles between them and keeps their gene pools alike.
  • Once gene flow stops, each population changes on its own: different natural selection, different mutations and different chance (genetic drift).
  • Given long enough, the differences build up and the split becomes permanent.

The detail

  • A barrier does not change any animal. It stops alleles passing between the two groups. The changing is done by selection, mutation and drift, separately on each side.
  • Selection does most where the two sides differ: different food, climate or predators favor different traits (the natural selection guide).
  • Drift does most in small populations (the population genetics guide). A few migrants each generation are enough to keep two populations from diverging: gene flow prevents divergence.
  • The figure's step 4: a lineage that changes gradually but never splits has evolved, but it has added no species.

Example

  • Chimpanzees live north of the Congo River and bonobos south of its great bend. Neither ape swims, and the river is wide and deep.
  • Genetic evidence suggests their ancestors were divided roughly 1 to 2 million years ago.
  • The two banks differ (south of the river there are no gorillas, and plants on the forest floor are plentiful), and the two apes differ in their bodies and their groups.
  • Their genomes show that a few apes crossed long after the split, but too rarely to stop the two diverging.

One species becomes two only when its populations stop sharing alleles. While they interbreed, gene flow carries alleles back and forth and keeps their gene pools alike. Speciation occurs when two populations become reproductively isolated from each other: gene flow between them stops.

Then each population is on its own. Natural selection acts on it in its own environment, new mutations arise in one and not the other, and in a small population chance changes allele frequencies too. None of this has to push the two the same way, so they diverge. Given long enough they cannot interbreed even if they meet again, and the split is permanent.

The Congo River is a real case. Chimpanzees live north of it and bonobos south of its great bend, and neither ape can swim it. Genetic evidence suggests their ancestors were divided roughly 1 to 2 million years ago, and the two banks have selected for different bodies and behavior since. The film beside the figures plays the same idea with made-up animals: switch gene flow on, and the split never happens.

  • Speciation occurs when two populations become reproductively isolated.
  • No gene flow, then divergence by selection, mutation and drift.
  • Gene flow keeps populations alike, so it prevents divergence.
Watch out The river did not make the apes change. It stopped gene flow. Different selection on each side, with mutation and drift, did the changing.

A new canyon divides a squirrel population. Which change must happen before the two sides can be called separate species?

timenowspeciesalive now1232one speciesa barrier:gene flow stopstwo species:cannot interbreedgradual change:still one speciesa new split: +1extinct: −1
  1. One species: every population can interbreed with every other.
  2. A barrier divides it into two populations. Gene flow stops, but for now they are still one species.
  3. Each population changes separately until they cannot interbreed: two species.
  4. The lower species changes gradually but never splits: still one species, so the count stays at two.
  5. The upper species splits again: three.
  6. The lower species dies out, so the count goes back to two.
Atlantic OceanequatorCongo RiverKasai Riverancestral apesdry spell: a few crossno gene flownorth: gorillas compete,food patchiersouth: no gorillas,herbs all yearchimpanzeesnorth and west bankbonobosinside the bend1 to 2 million years
  1. Long ago: one population of ancestral apes, north of the Congo River.
  2. Perhaps in a dry spell, the river runs low and a few apes reach the south bank.
  3. The water rises. Neither side can cross: no gene flow between the populations.
  4. Different conditions on each bank: different selection favors different behavior and bodies.
  5. Over roughly 1 to 2 million years they diverge into two species: chimpanzees north, bonobos south.
The map is simplified and not to scale.
The film at the top of the page, with its controls. Switch on gene flow and run it again: a few animals crossing each generation keep them one species. Then slow the generations down.

7.10.C Allopatric and sympatric speciation

Apart or in the same place

  • Allopatric speciation occurs in populations that are geographically isolated: a sea, a mountain range, a river or distance between them.
  • Sympatric speciation occurs in populations with geographic overlap: they live in the same area, and something else stops them interbreeding.
  • Both end the same way, in reproductive isolation. They differ in geography: whether a barrier on the map started it.
  • The apple maggot fly is the case to reason with: one fly, two kinds of fruit, in the same orchards.

The detail

  • Allopatric means "other homeland"; sympatric means "same homeland".
  • In sympatric speciation, what stops gene flow can be a difference in when the populations breed, where they mate or whom they choose: anything that means members of one group mostly mate with their own group.
  • Allopatric speciation is thought to be the more common route in animals, because in one place any interbreeding mixes the gene pools again.

Example: the apple maggot fly

  • Rhagoletis pomonella laid its eggs in the fruit of native hawthorns. Apple trees were brought to North America from Europe, and in the 1860s flies were reported in apples in New York's Hudson River valley.
  • The flies meet and mate on the fruit they will lay their eggs in, usually the kind they grew up in.
  • Apples ripen weeks before hawthorn fruit, and apple flies now emerge as adults weeks earlier than hawthorn flies.
  • So the two groups share orchards but mostly mate at different times and on different fruit. Some flies still cross, so they are called host races, not yet two species.

Watch out

  • Sympatric does not mean the groups never meet. It means they could meet, and still mostly do not mate.

A barrier on the map is one way to stop gene flow. When populations are geographically isolated, by a sea, a river, a mountain range or sheer distance, the speciation that follows is allopatric speciation ("other homeland"). The bonobos of chapter 2 are allopatric.

Gene flow can also stop between populations living in the same place. That is sympatric speciation ("same homeland"). The apple maggot fly shows it under way. It laid its eggs in hawthorn fruit until apple trees came to North America, and in the 1860s flies were found in apples in New York. The flies meet and mate on the kind of fruit they will lay in, and apples ripen weeks before hawthorns. Read the calendar in the second figure: when does each race of fly come out?

Allopatric and sympatric are not two kinds of isolation. Both end in reproductive isolation; what differs is whether the populations overlap on the map while it happens.

Remember it Two routes, told apart by geography

  • AwayAllopatrica barrier between them
  • SameSympatricsame place, they still split
  • Allopatric: geographically isolated populations.
  • Sympatric: populations with geographic overlap.
  • Both end in reproductive isolation; they differ in geography.
Watch out "Allopatric is geographic isolation and sympatric is reproductive isolation" is wrong. Both routes end in reproductive isolation. Allopatric populations are apart on the map; sympatric populations overlap.

Some flies of one species begin laying eggs on apples, which ripen weeks before the hawthorn fruit the others use. Flies mate on the fruit they will lay on. With no physical barrier, gene flow between the two groups will most likely...

Allopatric: "other homeland"the sea rises: a barrierbig seedssmall seedsgene flow stopscause: geographySympatric: "same homeland"no barrier: some flies switchripe Sepripe Augeach mates on its own fruitcause: timing and behavior
  1. Two populations, each of one species: finches on an island, flies on hawthorn trees.
  2. Left: the sea rises and splits the island. Right: apple trees arrive and some flies switch to them; no barrier.
  3. Left: different seeds on each side select different beaks, and gene flow stops. Right: apple flies mate earlier, on apples, so gene flow falls.
  4. Both groups diverge. What cut gene flow differs: geography, or timing and behavior in the same place.
JuneJulyAugustSeptemberOctoberapples ripehawthorn fruit ripeapple flies outhawthorn flies outFlies mate on the fruit they will lay their eggs in.
When the fruit ripens and when each race of fly is out, through one summer. Solid bars are fruit, striped bars are flies. What do you notice?

7.10.C Prezygotic and postzygotic barriers

What keeps two species apart

  • Various prezygotic and postzygotic mechanisms maintain reproductive isolation and prevent gene flow between populations.
  • Prezygotic barriers act before a zygote forms: the two never mate, or their gametes never fuse.
  • Postzygotic barriers act after: a hybrid zygote forms, but it dies, grows up weak, or is sterile.
  • Both stop alleles passing from one species into the other.

Prezygotic: no zygote forms

  • Place (habitat isolation): they live in different habitats in the same area, so they rarely meet (one garter snake mostly in water, another mostly on land).
  • Time (temporal isolation): they breed at different times of day or year (two skunks, one breeding in late winter and one in late summer).
  • Behavior (behavioral isolation): each answers only its own courtship (each firefly species flashes its own pattern).
  • Fit (mechanical isolation): their reproductive parts do not fit together (snails whose shells coil opposite ways cannot line up to mate).
  • Gametes (gametic isolation): sperm cannot bind or fuse with the other species' egg (sea urchins release both into the water, but proteins on the sperm match only their own species' eggs).

Postzygotic: a zygote forms but fails

  • The hybrid embryo stops developing (reduced hybrid viability: most embryos from a sheep and a goat die early).
  • The hybrid lives but is sterile (reduced hybrid fertility: the mule).
  • The hybrids are fertile, but their offspring are weak or sterile (hybrid breakdown: some crosses between strains of cultivated rice).

Why the mule is sterile

  • A horse has 64 chromosomes and a donkey 62, so a mule gets 32 from the horse and 31 from the donkey: 63.
  • At meiosis its horse and donkey chromosomes cannot all pair up, because they differ in number and arrangement. Its gametes get unbalanced sets and almost never work.

Once two species have formed, what stops them merging again where they meet? Various barriers do, and they fall into two groups, named by when they act: before or after a zygote, the fertilized egg, forms.

Prezygotic barriers act before. Two species may live in different habitats in one area, breed at different seasons, court in ways the other ignores, have reproductive parts that do not fit, or have gametes that cannot fuse. No zygote ever forms. Postzygotic barriers act after: a hybrid zygote forms, but the embryo dies, or the hybrid lives but is weak or sterile, like the mule.

Either way, the result is the same: no viable, fertile offspring, so no alleles pass from one species into the other. Sort the ten cases in the figure under the words, then name what kind of barrier each one is.

Remember it Pre or post: is there a zygote?

  • BeforePrezygoticno zygote ever forms
  • AfterPostzygotica zygote that fails, or a sterile hybrid
  • Prezygotic: no zygote (place, time, behavior, fit, gametes).
  • Postzygotic: a zygote forms, but the hybrid dies, is weak or is sterile.
  • Both maintain reproductive isolation and prevent gene flow.
Watch out A barrier that means no offspring is not automatically postzygotic. Ask whether a zygote ever formed. Two frogs that breed in different months never make one, so that barrier is prezygotic.

Two frog species share a pond. One breeds in early spring, the other in summer. This barrier is...

Animals: the mule horse eggn = 32donkey spermn = 31mule2n = 63meiosis: pairing some cannot pair sterileunbalancedgametes
  1. A horse egg (32 chromosomes) and a donkey sperm (31) make a mule with 63. A few of each set are drawn.
  2. At meiosis, matching chromosomes pair up, but horse and donkey sets differ in number and arrangement: some cannot pair.
  3. So the gametes get unbalanced sets and do not work: the mule is sterile, a postzygotic barrier.
For each case: prezygotic or postzygotic, and which kind?two species kept apartbinkind of barrier1Two garter snakes in one area: one lives mostlyin water, the other mostly on land.2Two skunks: one breeds in late winter, theother in late summer.3Two fireflies: each species flashes its ownpattern, and females answer only their own.4Two snails whose shells coil opposite ways.5Two sea urchins release eggs and sperm into thesame water.6Two pines in one forest shed pollen a month tosix weeks apart.7Pollen lands on another species' flower, butits tube stops growing in the style.8A sheep and a goat mate; most of the embryosdie early.9A horse and a donkey give a healthy mule, whichis sterile.10Two strains of cultivated rice give fertilehybrids, but the hybrids' own offspring arefeeble or sterile.Answerstwo species kept apartbinkind of barrier1Two garter snakes in one area: one lives mostlyin water, the other mostly on land.prezygotichabitat2Two skunks: one breeds in late winter, theother in late summer.prezygotictime (temporal)3Two fireflies: each species flashes its ownpattern, and females answer only their own.prezygoticbehavior4Two snails whose shells coil opposite ways.prezygoticfit(mechanical)5Two sea urchins release eggs and sperm into thesame water.prezygoticgametes(gametic)6Two pines in one forest shed pollen a month tosix weeks apart.prezygotictime (temporal)7Pollen lands on another species' flower, butits tube stops growing in the style.prezygoticgametes(gametic)8A sheep and a goat mate; most of the embryosdie early.postzygotichybrid dies(reduced hybridviability)9A horse and a donkey give a healthy mule, whichis sterile.postzygotichybrid sterile(reduced hybridfertility)10Two strains of cultivated rice give fertilehybrids, but the hybrids' own offspring arefeeble or sterile.postzygotichybridbreakdown
Ten cases of two species kept apart. Put each in its bin, then name the kind of barrier.
A plant's shortcut: polyploidy Beyond the course

The 2025 course does not name this, and you will not be asked for it by name. It is the fastest way a new species can form, and it happens in one place, so it is a sympatric route.

A hybrid of two plant species is usually sterile for the mule's reason: its chromosomes have no partners at meiosis. But if its chromosome number doubles, every chromosome gains an identical partner, meiosis works, and the plant is fertile. It has more than two sets of chromosomes: a polyploid. Crossed back to either parent it gives offspring with an odd number of sets, which are sterile, so it is reproductively isolated from its parents in a generation or two.

Bread wheat began this way. It has six sets of chromosomes (42 in all), from two hybridizations between wild grasses, each followed by doubling. The figure shows the idea with two made-up plants of 11 chromosomes a gamete.

Plants: the way out plant An = 11plant Bn = 11hybrid2n = 22no partners: sterile doubled2n = 44every one has a partnerfertile polyploid:a new species
  1. Two plant species make a hybrid with 11 + 11 = 22 chromosomes. None has a matching partner: sterile, like the mule.
  2. The chromosome number doubles to 44: every chromosome now has an identical partner, so meiosis works.
  3. A fertile polyploid whose offspring with either parent are sterile: a new species in a generation or two.
Made-up plants; the numbers show the idea.

7.10.B Divergent evolution and adaptive radiation

One ancestor, many ways of life

  • Divergent evolution occurs when adaptation to new habitats results in phenotypic diversification: related populations grow more different as each adapts to its own habitat.
  • Speciation can be especially fast during adaptive radiation, as new habitats become available: one lineage splits into many species, each fitted to a different way of life.
  • New habitats open on new islands, in new lakes, or after the species that held them are gone.
  • Hawaiian Drosophila: from one or a very few colonist flies, on the order of a thousand species across the islands.

The detail

  • The habitats in a radiation are open because nothing else is using them, so selection favors any variant that can use one.
  • Each new population is small and isolated, on its own island, valley or host plant, so it can diverge quickly.
  • Each species ends up using different food or places, so closely related species can live side by side.

Examples to reason with

  • The Hawaiian islands formed one after another over a hot spot, so today's high islands run from oldest in the northwest (Kauai, about 5 million years) to youngest in the southeast (the island of Hawaii, under 1 million years, still growing).
  • Drosophilid flies reached the chain once, or a very few times, about 25 million years ago by molecular dating: long before Kauai, on older islands now worn down below the sea. Their descendants moved onto each new island as it formed, and have become on the order of a thousand species, many of them found on a single island.
  • Darwin's finches: about 18 species on the Galápagos, from one ancestor, each with a beak suited to its food (the first figure).

Watch out

  • The finches did not grow new beaks because they needed them. In each population, birds whose beaks happened to suit an unused food survived and bred better.

When related populations adapt to different habitats they grow apart in their phenotypes: divergent evolution. It can happen fast. When new habitats become available, one lineage can split again and again, each line adapting to a different way of life. This is adaptive radiation, and speciation during it can be especially rapid.

Islands show it best. The Hawaiian islands rose out of the sea one after another, so the oldest of today's high islands, Kauai, is about 5 million years old and the island of Hawaii is under 1 million. Drosophilid flies arrived once, or a very few times, long before Kauai, on older islands of the chain that have since worn down below the sea, and every new island offered empty forests, fungi, rotting plants and flowers. Today there are on the order of a thousand species, many found on a single island. Darwin's finches did the same on the Galápagos: about 18 species from one ancestor, each with a beak suited to its food.

Treat the flies and finches as examples to reason with, not lists to learn: what makes a radiation is a lineage, new habitats with no one using them, and isolation between the pieces.

  • Divergent evolution: adaptation to new habitats gives phenotypic diversification.
  • Adaptive radiation: one lineage, many niches, fast, as new habitats open.
  • Hawaiian Drosophila and Darwin's finches are the classic cases.
Watch out Radiation is not convergence. In a radiation, one lineage becomes many different forms. In convergence (next chapter), different lineages come to look alike.

One fly species reached newly formed volcanic islands with many empty habitats and no competitors. Over millions of years you would expect...

seed-eating ancestorfrom the mainlandinsectsbig seedssmall seedscactus flowersbuds and fruitgrubs in woodvacant niches: foods no bird usesground finchestree finchesWarbler finchLarge groundSmall groundCactus finchVegetarianWoodpecker finchlittle competition: six side by side
  1. A seed-eating finch arrives on islands where foods stand unused: open habitats.
  2. The first split: one line takes to eating insects, with a thin, pointed beak.
  3. The rest split into ground finches and tree finches.
  4. Each line splits again, each species with a beak suited to its food.
  5. Different foods mean little competition: many related species live side by side.
Six of the species are drawn.
Kauaiabout 5 million yearsOahuabout 3Mauiabout 1Hawaiiunder 1older islands, now under the seaon the order ofa thousand species
  1. One or a very few flies reached the chain long ago, on older islands now worn below the sea. Their descendants colonized Kauai as it formed.
  2. As each new island forms, flies from an older one colonize it and split into new species.
  3. Each lineage steps down the chain, from older islands to younger.
  4. On the order of a thousand species, many found on a single island.
A simplified tree: the real one has hundreds of tips. Each fly at a tip is a species living on the island below it. The islands are not to scale.

7.10.B Convergent evolution

Different lineages, the same shape

  • Convergent evolution occurs when similar selective pressures result in similar phenotypic adaptations in different populations or species.
  • The similar traits arose separately, not from a shared ancestor that had them: they are analogous, not homologous.
  • Caribbean Anolis lizards are the case to reason with: each large island has much the same set of lizard forms, one for each kind of perch.
  • So looking alike is weak evidence of relatedness. DNA sorts out who is related to whom.

The detail

  • A narrow twig is best moved along slowly, with a grip, on short legs. A broad trunk is best run up fast, on long legs. The perch is the selective pressure.
  • Homologous traits are shared because of a shared ancestor (the evidence and phylogeny guide). Analogous traits are shared because of similar selection.
  • A shark is a fish and a dolphin is a mammal, but both have a streamlined body and fins: water at speed selects for that shape.

Examples to reason with

  • On Cuba, Hispaniola, Jamaica and Puerto Rico, anoles have evolved the same set of forms, usually named as six (twig, trunk, trunk-ground, trunk-crown, crown-giant and grass-bush), though not every island has all six.
  • DNA shows that the twig anoles of the different islands are not each other's closest relatives: each is most closely related to other anoles on its own island.
  • Cacti in American deserts and some euphorbias in African deserts are both fleshy, spiny and leafless, from unrelated families.

Chapter 5 was one lineage becoming many forms. This is the opposite: different lineages becoming one form. Convergent evolution occurs when similar selective pressures result in similar adaptations in different populations or species. The traits look alike, but they arose separately: they are analogous, not homologous.

Caribbean anoles are the case to know. On each of the four largest islands there are slim, short-legged anoles that creep along twigs, long-legged ones that sprint up broad trunks, big ones in the canopy, and others between. You might guess the twig anoles are one species that spread from island to island. The DNA says otherwise: look at the lizards on two islands in the figure, answer the prediction, and then let it redraw them as a tree.

A shark and a dolphin are the same story in the sea: a fish and a mammal with the same streamlined body, because water at speed selects for it.

  • Convergent: different lineages, similar pressure, similar form.
  • The similar traits are analogous: they arose separately.
  • Looking alike does not mean closely related.
Watch out "Animals that look alike are closely related" fails for convergence. A dolphin looks more like a shark than like a cow, but it is a mammal, and its closest living relatives are hoofed mammals.

On four Caribbean islands there is a long-legged anole on tree trunks and a short-legged anole on twigs. DNA shows the twig anoles on different islands are not each other's closest relatives. The short legs...

island 1canopytrunktwigisland 2canopytrunktwigshort legs: a slow grip on a narrow perchlong legs: a fast run up a broad trunkisland 1island 2twigtrunkcanopytwigtrunkcanopyShort legs evolved twice: once on each island. island 1island 2twigtrunkcanopytwigtrunkcanopyShort legs evolved twice: once on each island.

Make the chapter's prediction to unlock the tree from their DNA.

The lizards on two islands, by the perch each uses. After the prediction, see them on the tree their DNA gives.

7.10.B Punctuated equilibrium and gradualism

Slow and steady, or long waits and bursts

  • Gradualism: evolution occurs slowly, over hundreds of thousands or millions of years.
  • Punctuated equilibrium: evolution occurs rapidly after a long period of stasis, little or no change.
  • Both are patterns seen in the fossil record, and both happen: different lineages, and different times, show each.
  • "Rapid" is rapid for the rocks: a burst of thousands to tens of thousands of years, many generations, never one.

The detail

  • Gradualism predicts that a well-sampled lineage in successive rock layers shows a steady series of in-between forms.
  • Punctuated equilibrium predicts long runs of layers with one form, then a new form appearing in a short span of layers, often beside the old one, which may carry on unchanged.
  • The idea was put forward by Eldredge and Gould in 1972. A small population that splits off (chapter 2) can change fast, and in the rocks its few, short-lived in-between forms are rarely found.
  • Rapid change fits times when new habitats become available, as in an adaptive radiation (chapter 5). Long stasis fits a lineage whose environment stays much the same, with selection keeping it as it is.

Watch out

  • Gaps in the fossil record are not the evidence for punctuated equilibrium. The evidence is long stasis in lineages with many fossils, layer after layer.

How fast does evolution go? The fossil record shows two patterns. In one, a lineage changes slowly and steadily, over hundreds of thousands or millions of years: gradualism. In the other, a lineage stays almost the same for a very long time, a period of stasis, and then changes in a short burst: punctuated equilibrium.

Rapid here means rapid for a geologist: a burst may be a few thousand years, short beside two million years of stasis but still many generations. Neither pattern is the one true rate. Each describes some lineages at some times, and the ecology helps decide which: a lineage in an unchanging environment can sit in stasis, while new habitats opening can set off a burst.

The figure draws the same split of one species into two both ways. Under each is what the fossils in successive rock layers would look like. Which strip is which?

  • Gradualism: slow change over hundreds of thousands to millions of years.
  • Punctuated equilibrium: rapid change after a long period of stasis.
  • "Rapid" is thousands of years, not one generation.
Watch out "Punctuated equilibrium means evolution happens in a generation" is wrong. A burst is quick against millions of years of stasis, but it still takes thousands of years and many generations of selection.

A fossil snail lineage shows almost no change for two million years, then a new form within a few thousand years. This pattern fits...

gradualismtimeformpunctuated equilibriumtimeformstasisstasisrapid changefossil strip 1rock layers, oldest at the bottomfossil strip 2rock layers, oldest at the bottom gradualismtimeformpunctuated equilibriumtimeformstasisstasisrapid changefossil strip 1rock layers, oldest at the bottomfossil strip 2rock layers, oldest at the bottom

Form against time for one species splitting into two, drawn two ways, and two strips of fossils from successive rock layers. Decide which strip fits which pattern, then press Match. "Rapid" is rapid for the rocks: a jog may be thousands of years.

7.12.A Geological evidence for the origin of life

The window the rocks give

  • The origin of life on Earth is supported by scientific evidence, and geological evidence reinforces the models.
  • Earth formed about 4.6 billion years ago (bya).
  • The environment was too hostile for life until about 3.9 bya.
  • The earliest fossil evidence for life dates to about 3.5 bya.
  • Taken together, these give a plausible range of dates for the origin of life.

The detail

  • Rocks are dated by the decay of radioactive isotopes in them, at known rates (the evidence and phylogeny guide). The oldest rocks on Earth, and meteorites formed with the solar system, give Earth's age.
  • Early Earth was hot, and it was hit by large objects from space, often enough to boil seas. The figure of 3.9 bya for when this eased comes from the ages of rocks and of craters on the Moon; how long the bombardment lasted is still debated.
  • The oldest widely accepted fossils are stromatolites, layered mounds built by mats of microbes, about 3.48 billion years old, in rocks in the Pilbara of Western Australia.

What the rocks cannot say

  • The window gives when, not how. Life may have begun earlier and left no fossil, or the oldest fossils may yet be found.
  • Fossils of microbes are small and simple, so claims of older ones are argued over.

These two chapters stand alone: they need only the nucleic acids of Unit 1. When did life begin? We cannot watch it happen, so the evidence is in the rocks. Rocks are dated by the radioactive isotopes in them, which decay at known rates, and they give three dates. Earth formed about 4.6 billion years ago (bya). For several hundred million years its surface was too hostile for life: hot, and struck by large objects from space. The course puts the end of that at about 3.9 bya, a date based on rocks and on craters on the Moon, and still argued over. And the earliest fossil evidence of life, mounds built by microbes called stromatolites, is about 3.5 billion years old.

Put the three together and they make a window. Life could not have started before the surface allowed it, and it must have started before it left fossils. Work out how wide the window is in the prediction, then shade it on the timeline.

A window is evidence of when, not of how. The rocks cannot say what the first living things were, only that something living had built mounds by 3.5 bya. For the how, the next chapter turns to a molecule.

Remember it Three dates, counting down

  • 4.6Earth formsbillion years ago
  • 3.9Hostile no longerlife becomes possible
  • 3.5First fossilsstromatolites
  • Earth about 4.6 bya; too hostile until about 3.9 bya; earliest fossils about 3.5 bya.
  • Together, these dates mark out the window in which life most likely began.
  • Geological evidence gives dates, not the mechanism.
Watch out The age of the oldest fossils is not the age of life. It is the latest date by which life had begun: the first living things may have left no trace.

Earth is about 4.6 billion years old and the oldest accepted fossils about 3.5 billion. If the surface was too hostile until about 3.9 billion years ago, life had at most about how long to begin?

too hostilebillion years ago (bya)now4.63.93.5the window: life most likely began hereabout 0.4 billion years

Tap a date for its evidence.

4.6 billion years, to scale. Tap each date for its evidence; the window is shaded once you have made the prediction.

7.12.A The RNA world hypothesis

Why RNA may have come first

  • The RNA world hypothesis proposes that RNA could have been the earliest genetic material.
  • RNA can store information in its sequence of bases, and some RNA molecules can catalyze reactions: ribozymes.
  • It rests on three assumptions: genetic continuity was once kept by the replication of RNA; base pairing is necessary for that replication; and genetically encoded proteins were not involved as catalysts.
  • It is a hypothesis: no RNA that fully copies itself has yet been made or found.

The detail

  • In cells today DNA stores the genes and proteins do the catalysis, and each needs the other: proteins are made from DNA's information, and DNA is copied and transcribed by protein enzymes. RNA can do both jobs, so it offers a way in.
  • Base pairing (A with U, G with C) lets one strand serve as a template for its complement, and that complement as a template for a copy of the first.
  • Ribozymes were discovered in the early 1980s; Thomas Cech and Sidney Altman shared the 1989 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for it.
  • In every cell's ribosome, the peptide bond between amino acids is formed by the ribosome's RNA, not its proteins: a trace that fits an RNA world.
  • Ribozymes made in the laboratory can join nucleotides on an RNA template and copy short stretches, but none yet copies a whole RNA as long as itself.

Each assumption as a test

  • If RNA once replicated itself, RNA should be able to act as both template and catalyst.
  • If replication needs base pairing, a template strand should give its complement, and the complement the original.
  • If no encoded proteins were catalysts, RNA alone must be able to catalyze the key reactions, as the ribosome's RNA does.

Cells today have a puzzle at their core. DNA holds the genes, but it is copied by protein enzymes; the proteins are made from DNA's information. Each needs the other, so which came first? The RNA world hypothesis proposes that RNA did: RNA could have been the earliest genetic material.

RNA can do both jobs. Its sequence of bases stores information, and that sequence can be copied by base pairing, A with U and G with C: one strand makes its complement, and the complement makes the original again. And some RNA molecules fold into shapes that catalyze reactions. These are ribozymes, discovered in the early 1980s. In every ribosome, it is RNA that joins amino acids into a chain.

The hypothesis rests on three assumptions: at some point genetic continuity was assured by the replication of RNA; base pairing is necessary for that replication; and genetically encoded proteins were not involved as catalysts. They are assumptions, which is why each can be turned into a test: what would we expect to find if it were true? Pair the bases in the second figure to see the first two at work. No RNA that fully copies itself has been made yet, so the hypothesis is still open.

Remember it The RNA world's three assumptions

  • CopiesRNA replicationkept genetic continuity
  • PairsBase pairingneeded to replicate
  • No proteinsNo encoded proteinsas the catalysts
  • RNA world: RNA as the earliest genetic material.
  • RNA can store information and catalyze.
  • Three assumptions: RNA replication, base pairing, no encoded protein catalysts.
Watch out "The RNA world is a proven account of how life began" is wrong. It is a hypothesis resting on assumptions, which is why the course lists them. What supports it is what RNA can do today.

A laboratory makes an RNA molecule that joins two short RNA strands together, with no protein present. Which assumption of the RNA world hypothesis does this support most directly?

RNA: a gene and an enzyme in oneAUGCCUAGsugar-phosphatebackbonethe information:its sequence of basesUACGGAUCa new bondfree nucleotidesA pairs with U,G pairs with CGCCGAUGCUAa pocket: twomolecules joinedfolded RNA:a ribozymebase pairs hold the folda geneits sequence is copieda geneits sequence is copiedan enzymeit folds and catalyzesan enzymeit folds and catalyzesin every ribosome today, RNA still joins the amino acids
  1. A strand of RNA: information in its sequence of bases.
  2. Free nucleotides pair with it to make a complementary copy.
  3. Folded on itself, RNA can catalyze a reaction: a ribozyme.
ROUND 1: THE TEMPLATEYOUR COPY: THE BASE THAT PAIRS WITH EACH ONEAUGCCAGUROUND 2: YOUR COPY IS NOW THE TEMPLATETHE COPY OF YOUR COPYAnswersRound 1, the copyUACGGUCARound 2, its copyAUGCCAGUthe original sequence again
Add the base that pairs with each one, then use your copy as the template in turn. No RNA that fully copies itself has been made yet.
How we know: the spark experiment Skill 3.B

The 2025 course does not list this experiment, but it is a clean example of the skill this topic asks for: stating a hypothesis and predicting the results of an experiment. In 1953 Stanley Miller, working with Harold Urey, published the result of a week of sparks through a sealed loop of gases and boiling water. The question was whether the carbon compounds of life could form from simple molecules with no life present.

Play it once with the spark and the first mix of gases. Then switch the spark off, and then swap the gases for a mix like today's air, and compare what the trap holds.

Use the film to answer:

1. State a hypothesis the experiment tests, in the form "If ..., then ...".
2. Name the independent variable when you switch the spark off, and the dependent variable.
3. What is the run with no spark for?
4. What does the result show, and what does it not show, about the origin of life?

Answers. 1. If energy like lightning passes through these gases over water, then amino acids will form. 2. Whether there is a spark; the amino acids found in the trap. 3. It is the control: everything else is the same, so if amino acids form only with the spark, the spark's energy made them. 4. It shows that amino acids can form from simple molecules without living things. It does not show that the early atmosphere had these gases (it probably held more carbon dioxide and nitrogen, which give far less), or how amino acids became proteins, RNA or a cell.

02Dry lab: Finches on islands

Split a population of finches with the sea, give each island its own seeds, run the generations, then let them meet and test whether you have made two species. Then let a few birds cross each generation and run it again.

ISLAND AISLAND B0of 200generationsmutation onA10.6mmB10.6mm
The bench: one population of ground finches split by the sea into two. Big hard seeds on island A, small soft ones on island B. Run the generations, then lower the sea and see who pairs with whom.
Your questionWhen does one population become two species? Is stopping gene flow enough, or do the islands also need different food? And what do a few migrants each generation do to the split?
What you can changeThe scenario (split by the sea, a control with the same food on both islands, or one island with two foods), the difference in food, the number of birds, how many birds cross each generation, how much females choose mates by song, mutation, and how many generations to run.
What to recordFor each run: the settings, the mean beak depth on each island and the difference when you stop, and the isolation index and verdict when you test them. Change one setting at a time, and repeat each setup at least three times: the runs scatter, as real populations do.

Find out

  • Apart, with different food. Keep Split by the sea, set Birds crossing each generation to 0 and run 200 generations. Record each island's mean beak depth, then test them. One species or two?
  • The control. Choose Same food both sides and run it the same way. What does isolation do on its own, with no difference in selection?
  • Let a few cross. Back to Split by the sea. Run it with 1, 3 and then 5 birds crossing each generation, everything else the same. At what number does the split fail?
  • When have they diverged? Watch the graph of mean beak depth. Decide before you test when you would call the two populations diverged, and say what you used.
  • In one place. Try One island, two foods, with mate choice by song high and then low. Can a population split with no sea between?

Record

  • For each run: the scenario, the difference in food, the birds crossing, the generations, each island's mean beak depth and the difference.
  • The isolation index and the verdict from the test.
  • At least three runs of each setup: the runs scatter, as real populations do. Download CSV keeps every row.
  • One sentence for each comparison: what changed, what happened to the beaks, and why, in terms of gene flow and selection.

In the control the sea splits the population and no birds cross, but the same seeds grow on both islands. After 200 generations, what do you expect?

Now five birds cross each way every generation, with different seeds on each island. What do you expect after 200 generations, and why?

Back to speciation

Use your results to explain the conditions under which the finches became two species, and why birds crossing between the islands changed the outcome.

03Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in.

Exam practice

Exam questions on 7.10 and 7.12, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

Quiz: phylogeny and speciationUnit 7 escape roomGrass skirts: phylogeny, speciation and originsGrass skirts: the whole of Unit 7Revision map: speciationRevision map: origins of life on EarthBlurting diagrams: speciation, reproductive isolationUnit 7 pub quizGuide: lipids and nucleic acids (RNA and base pairing)Unit 7 practice questions

04Downloads

Take the guide with you, or into a classroom with no internet.

05Teacher resources

The guide as four one-hour lessons: what each covers, its focus and the chapters it uses.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1What a species is, and how one becomes two 7.10.A60 min The biological species concept, and speciation as reproductive isolation followed by divergence 1, 2
2Where, and what keeps them apart 7.10.C60 min Allopatric and sympatric speciation, and the prezygotic and postzygotic barriers that keep species apart 3, 4
3The island lab, radiation and convergence 7.10.A, 7.10.B60 min Gene flow and divergence in the island dry lab, then adaptive radiation and convergent evolution 5, 6, dry lab
4Pace, and the origin of life 7.10.B, 7.12.A60 min Gradualism and punctuated equilibrium, then the geological window for the origin of life and the RNA world hypothesis 7, 8, 9

The revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTICE AND REVIEW

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for Unit 7

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.