C3.1.17 Observations of tropic responses in seedlings
Watching seedlings grow
- A tropism is growth whose direction is set by where a stimulus comes from: towards it is positive, away from it negative.
- An annotated drawing of the seedlings gives qualitative data.
- The angle of curvature, in degrees, gives quantitative data.
- Precision is how fine and repeatable a measurement is; accuracy is how close it is to the true value.
- A slanted camera is a systematic error: it spoils accuracy, however precise the reading.
The detail
- A plant cannot walk to the light, but it can grow towards it.
- Seedlings are good for studying a tropism: they grow fast, and a young shoot lit from one side starts to turn within an hour.
- Shoots and roots respond to gravity too, but light is the one you need here.
Recording and measuring
- Drawing: draw the same tray of seedlings at set times, say 0, 6 and 24 hours, with an arrow for the direction of the light.
- Draw the shoots to scale against a scale bar, with short notes on what you see, such as how many have bent and where along the shoot the bend is.
- Angle of curvature: the angle between the vertical (the way the shoot grew before) and the line its tip now points along.
- Read it with a protractor held up to the seedling or, better, on a photograph.
- A shoot curves gradually rather than bending at a point, so where you draw the tip line is a judgement: two people, or one person twice, draw it slightly differently. That limits precision.
- So does a protractor read only to the nearest 5 degrees.
- A camera that is not square-on to the bend makes every angle look smaller or larger than it is: a systematic error, which limits accuracy however carefully you read the protractor.
- The seedlings go on growing while you measure.
Better measurements
- Take the photographs from the side, with the camera fixed square-on and a grid or ruler behind the tray.
- Draw the tip line the same way every time, say along the top 5 mm of the shoot.
- Measure every seedling, not just the neat ones.
- Use many seedlings and more than one tray, with a control tray lit evenly from above.
- Give the mean with its spread, such as a standard deviation.
- Many seedlings and repeat trays make the result more reliable.
Watch out
- “Precise means accurate.” A protractor read to half a degree on a photograph taken at a slant gives a precise reading, and a wrong one.
- Make the readings accurate by removing the systematic error (put the camera square-on), and precise by measuring finely and repeating.
A plant cannot walk to the light, but it can grow towards it. A tropism is a growth response whose direction is set by where a stimulus comes from. Growth towards the stimulus is a positive tropism, and growth away from it is a negative tropism. Seedlings are good for studying one: they grow fast, and a young shoot lit from one side starts to turn within an hour. (Shoots and roots respond to gravity too, but light is the one you need here.)
There are two ways to record what happens. A drawing gives qualitative data: draw the same tray of seedlings at set times, say 0, 6 and 24 hours, with an arrow for the direction of the light, the shoots drawn to scale against a scale bar, and short notes on what you see, such as how many have bent and where along the shoot the bend is. A measurement gives quantitative data. Here it is the angle of curvature: the angle between the vertical, the way the shoot grew before, and the line its tip now points along. You can read it with a protractor held up to the seedling or, better, on a photograph.
Every measurement has limits. Precision is how finely you measure and how closely repeats agree. Accuracy is how close a measurement is to the true value. A shoot curves gradually rather than bending at a point, so where you draw the tip line is a judgement: two people, or one person twice, draw it slightly differently. That limits precision, and so does a protractor read only to the nearest 5 degrees.
Two students measure the same seedling’s angle of curvature. One photographs it square-on from the side; the other from above and to one side. Whose angle is more accurate?
The square-on photograph. Seen at a slant, a bend is squashed in one direction: with the camera turned to one side the angle looks smaller, and from above it looks larger. That is a systematic error, and no protractor fixes it, because the picture itself is wrong. A finer scale only makes the reading more precise. In the Dry lab you can photograph the same tray with the camera square-on, turned or raised, and compare the angles.
A camera that is not square-on to the bend makes every angle look smaller or larger than it is. That is a systematic error, and it limits accuracy, however carefully you read the protractor. And the seedlings go on growing while you measure.
So take the photographs from the side, with the camera fixed square-on and a grid or ruler behind the tray. Draw the tip line the same way every time, say along the top 5 mm of the shoot. Measure every seedling, not just the neat ones. Use many seedlings and more than one tray, with a control tray lit evenly from above, and give the mean with its spread, such as a standard deviation. Many seedlings and repeat trays make the result more reliable.
- A tropism is growth whose direction is set by where a stimulus comes from: towards it is positive, away from it negative.
- An annotated drawing gives qualitative data; the angle of curvature, in degrees, gives quantitative data.
- Precision is how fine and repeatable a measurement is; accuracy is how close it is to the truth. A slanted camera is a systematic error: it spoils accuracy, however precise the reading.
- A drawing of tray A at 0 and 24 hours, lit from the left: the light’s direction, a scale bar and notes on what you see. Qualitative data.
- A side-on photograph of one seedling at 24 hours: a vertical line, a line along the top 5 mm of the shoot, and the angle between them, measured with a protractor. Quantitative data.