IB BIOLOGY · THEME C · INTERACTION AND INTERDEPENDENCE

How many, and why not more?

Nobody counts every buttercup in a meadow or every woodlouse under a log. Estimate them with quadrats and mark and recapture, grow yeast in a flask until it stops, test whether two plants grow together with chi-squared, and watch lynx and hares chase each other's numbers round a ten-year cycle.

IB Biology C4.1SL and HL5 hours SL (no HL content)9 chaptersdry lab

Start learningRun the dry labTeach it

Fly over a woodland edge to each of the six interactions, then dive down a bean root into a nodule full of Rhizobium.
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Nine chapters, all standard level. Read one, play its figure, lab or film, and make each prediction before you open the answer. The quadrat and mark and recapture benches are in chapters 2 and 3; the population growth bench is the Dry lab.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1Who counts as one population?
  2. 2Throw the square
  3. 3Mark them, catch them again
  4. 4Room for so many
  5. 5Rivals and allies
  6. 6Six ways to get along
  7. 7Newcomers and tests
  8. 8Together, apart, or chance?
  9. 9Held in check

C4.1.1 Populations as interacting groups of organisms of the same species living in an area C4.1.2 Estimation of population size by random sampling

Who counts as one population?

  • A population is a group of organisms of one species living in one area, close enough to interact and, normally, to breed with each other.
  • Reproductive isolation separates one population from another: frogs of the same species round a pond across a motorway could breed with the first group if they met, but the road keeps them apart.
  • Counting every individual is almost never possible (there are too many, they hide, or counting would damage the habitat), so ecologists take a sample and scale it up to an estimate.
  • The sample must be random: every individual, or every spot, must have the same chance of being picked.
  • Sampling error is the difference between the estimate and the true size. It shrinks as the sample grows, but never quite vanishes.

The detail

  • Frogs round one pond are a population.
  • Ecologists want to know how big a population is, and whether it is growing or shrinking, to manage a fishery, protect a rare orchid or track a pest.
  • Even a random sample gives an estimate that differs a little from the true size.

How we know

  • Nature of science: random sampling trades certainty for possibility. A sample can never give the true size, only an estimate with an error.
  • A random sample at least makes that error unbiased: as likely to be too high as too low.
  • Scientists report the error with the estimate, so others can judge how far to trust it.

Watch out

  • If you choose where to sample, you drift towards the spots that look interesting, and the estimate is biased.

A population is a group of organisms of one species living in one area, close enough to interact and, normally, to breed with each other. Frogs round one pond are a population. Frogs of the same species round a pond on the far side of a motorway are a different population: they could breed with the first group if they ever met, but the road keeps them reproductively isolated.

Ecologists want to know how big a population is, and whether it is growing or shrinking, to manage a fishery, protect a rare orchid or track a pest. Counting every individual is almost never possible: there are too many, they hide, or counting would damage the habitat. So they take a sample and scale it up to an estimate.

The sample must be random: every individual, or every spot, must have the same chance of being picked. If you choose where to sample, you drift towards the spots that look interesting, and the estimate is biased. Even a random sample gives an estimate that differs a little from the true size; that difference is the sampling error. It shrinks as the sample grows, but never quite vanishes.

  • Population: one species, one area, interbreeding.
  • Estimate from a random sample; counting all is rarely possible.
  • Sampling error: estimate minus true size. Bigger samples, smaller error.
Nature of science Random sampling trades certainty for possibility. A sample can never give the true size, only an estimate with an error, but a random one at least makes that error unbiased: as likely to be too high as too low. Scientists report the error with the estimate, so others can judge how far to trust it.

A student estimates the daisies on a field by placing quadrats wherever daisies look thickest. What will the estimate be?

♥♥one population: any two can meet and breedtwo populations: the road keeps them apart

C4.1.3 Random quadrat sampling to estimate population size for sessile organisms

Throw the square

  • A quadrat is a square frame, often 1 m on each side. It suits sessile organisms, ones that stay put.
  • Place each quadrat at random: coordinates from a random number generator on a grid of tape measures.
  • Count the individuals in many quadrats and find the mean per quadrat.
  • Population estimate = mean per m² × total area in m².
  • The standard deviation measures how much the counts vary round the mean: small if evenly spread, large if patchy.

Sampling, step by step

  • Lay two tape measures along two edges of the area to make a grid.
  • Use a random number generator for each pair of coordinates, and put the quadrat there.
  • Count the individuals inside. Decide a rule for ones on the edge, such as count it if more than half is inside.
  • Repeat for many quadrats, then work out the mean number per quadrat.

The detail

  • A large standard deviation means the plants grow in patches, so the estimate is less certain and more quadrats are needed.

In the exam

  • A calculator or spreadsheet works out the standard deviation of the counts.

Examples

  • Sessile organisms include plants, and animals such as barnacles and limpets on a rock.

A quadrat is a square frame, often 1 m on each side. It suits sessile organisms, ones that stay put: plants, and animals such as barnacles and limpets on a rock.

  1. Lay two tape measures along two edges of the area to make a grid.
  2. Use a random number generator for each pair of coordinates, and put the quadrat there.
  3. Count the individuals inside. Decide a rule for ones on the edge, such as count it if more than half is inside.
  4. Repeat for many quadrats, then work out the mean number per quadrat.
  5. Population estimate = mean per m² × total area in m².

Work out the standard deviation of the counts too (a calculator or spreadsheet does it). It measures how much the counts vary round the mean. A small standard deviation means the plants are spread evenly; a large one means they grow in patches, so the estimate is less certain and more quadrats are needed.

  • Quadrats for sessile organisms; coordinates from random numbers.
  • Estimate = mean per m² × area.
  • Standard deviation: how spread the counts are; patchy plants give a big one.

In the bench below, throw 20 random quadrats, then switch to By eye and place 10 yourself. What do you expect?

0011223344556677a meadow 8 m × 8 m: 64 m²random coordinates(0, 6)(1, 4)(3, 7)(0, 0)(2, 2)(1, 1)buttercups in each1, 1, 0, 1, 4, 5mean = 2.0 per m²× 64 m² ≈ 128real number: 120110145
  1. Two tape measures along the edges turn the meadow into a grid of 1 m squares.
  2. Random numbers give the coordinates; a quadrat goes down at each.
  3. Count the buttercups in each, take the mean and multiply by the area: close to the real number.
A meadow of buttercups, sampled by 1 m² quadrats at random coordinates. The mean count per quadrat, times the area, estimates the population.

C4.1.4 Capture–mark–release–recapture and the Lincoln index to estimate population size for motile organisms

Mark them, catch them again

  • Motile organisms move about, so they cannot be counted in a quadrat: ecologists use capture, mark, release and recapture.
  • Catch and mark M animals, release them, then catch N, of which R are marked.
  • The Lincoln index: population size ≈ M × N ÷ R.
  • It rests on assumptions: marks last and harm nothing, equal catchability, full mixing and a closed population.

Mark and recapture, step by step

  • Catch a sample, for example in pitfall traps, and count it: M.
  • Mark each one harmlessly (a dot of paint, a ring, a tag) and release it where it was caught.
  • Wait long enough for the marked ones to mix back into the population.
  • Catch a second sample: count all of it, N, and the marked ones in it, R.

The detail

  • Animals that move about walk out of a quadrat.
  • If the marked animals have mixed in evenly, the share of marked ones in the second catch, R ÷ N, should match the share in the whole population, M ÷ population. That gives the Lincoln index.

Watch out

  • The estimate fails if marks wear off or make animals easier to spot.
  • It fails if marked and unmarked animals are not equally likely to be caught, or do not mix fully between the samples.
  • It fails if births, deaths or migration change the population in between.

Animals that move about cannot be counted in a quadrat: they walk out of it. For these motile organisms ecologists use capture, mark, release and recapture.

  1. Catch a sample, for example in pitfall traps, and count it: M.
  2. Mark each one harmlessly (a dot of paint, a ring, a tag) and release it where it was caught.
  3. Wait long enough for the marked ones to mix back into the population.
  4. Catch a second sample: count all of it, N, and the marked ones in it, R.

If the marked animals have mixed in evenly, the share of marked ones in the second catch, R ÷ N, should match the share in the whole population, M ÷ population. That gives the Lincoln index:

population size ≈ M × N ÷ R

It only works if its assumptions hold: marks do not wear off or make animals easier to spot; marked and unmarked animals are equally likely to be caught; they mix fully between the samples; and no births, deaths or migration change the population in between.

  • For motile animals: catch M, mark, release, recatch N with R marked.
  • Population ≈ M × N ÷ R.
  • Assumptions: marks last and harm nothing, equal catchability, mixing, closed population.

In the bench, choose Marks wear off and run it. Some marked woodlice lose their paint before the recapture. What happens to the estimate?

woodlice under the leaf litterfirst catchM = 20each one markedwith a dot of paintreleasedthey mix back inwith the restsecond catchN = 15marked in itR = 5population ≈M × N ÷ R= 20 × 15 ÷ 5= 60the real number: 60
  1. Catch a first sample, M = 20, and mark each one with a dot of paint.
  2. Release them where they were caught, and wait for them to mix back in.
  3. Catch again: N = 15 in the second catch, R = 5 of them marked.
  4. Lincoln index: 20 × 15 ÷ 5 = 60.
Woodlice on a patch of woodland floor. The pink-dotted ones were caught, marked and released; the circled ones are the second catch. The share of marked ones in the second catch estimates the share marked in the whole population.

C4.1.5 Carrying capacity and competition for limited resources C4.1.6 Negative feedback control of population size by density-dependent factors C4.1.7 Population growth curves C4.1.8 Modelling of the sigmoid population growth curve

Room for so many

  • Carrying capacity (K) is the largest population an environment can support long term, set by whatever resource runs short first; individuals then compete for it.
  • Density-dependent factors (competition, predation, pathogens and pests) hit harder in crowded populations and give negative feedback towards K.
  • Density-independent factors, such as a flood, frost or fire, can knock a population away from K but do not push it back.
  • The sigmoid curve has three phases: exponential, transitional and plateau.
  • Exponential growth is a straight line when numbers are plotted on a log scale against time on an ordinary scale.

The detail

  • No population grows for ever.
  • Limiting resources include food, water, light, nesting sites, space, or for plants, minerals in the soil.
  • Predators hit harder in a crowd because more prey makes hunting easier; pathogens and pests spread faster between crowded hosts.
  • Above K, births fall and deaths rise and the population drops; below K the reverse, and it climbs.
  • Density-independent factors kill a share of the population whatever its size.

The three phases

  • The sigmoid curve is followed by a population introduced into a new area with plenty of resources.
  • Exponential: resources are plentiful and little limits it, so births far exceed deaths and the population doubles in a fixed time again and again.
  • Transitional: resources start to run short, density-dependent factors grow, and the rate of growth slows.
  • Plateau: births plus immigration equal deaths plus emigration, and the population fluctuates around K.

In the exam

  • To test whether growth really is exponential, plot numbers on a log scale: a straight line means exponential.

Examples

  • Yeast or duckweed in the lab show sigmoid growth within days.
  • A case study in an ecosystem: in 1944, 29 reindeer were released on St Matthew Island in the Bering Sea, where there was plenty of lichen and no predator. By 1963 there were about 6,000: exponential growth. They had eaten out the lichen and overshot the carrying capacity, and by 1966 only 42 were left.

How we know

  • The sigmoid curve is an idealised model. Real populations overshoot, wobble and crash, but the model captures what drives them.

Watch out

  • The IB’s sigmoid curve has no lag phase at the start. If you are asked for the phases, give exponential, transitional and plateau.

No population grows for ever. The carrying capacity (K) is the largest population an environment can support long term. It is set by whatever runs short first: food, water, light, nesting sites, space, or for plants, minerals in the soil. Individuals then compete for it.

Some factors hit harder the more crowded the population is. These density-dependent factors include competition for resources, predators (more prey makes hunting easier) and pathogens and pests, which spread faster between crowded hosts. They act as negative feedback: above K, births fall and deaths rise and the population drops; below K the reverse, and it climbs. Density-independent factors, such as a flood, a frost or a fire, kill a share of the population whatever its size, and can knock it away from K, but they do not push it back.

A population introduced into a new area with plenty of resources grows along a sigmoid (S-shaped) curve with three phases:

  • Exponential: resources are plentiful and little limits it, so births far exceed deaths and the population doubles in a fixed time again and again.
  • Transitional: resources start to run short, density-dependent factors grow, and the rate of growth slows.
  • Plateau: births plus immigration equal deaths plus emigration, and the population fluctuates around K.

To test whether growth really is exponential, plot the numbers on a log scale against time on an ordinary scale: exponential growth is then a straight line. The sigmoid curve is an idealised model. Real populations overshoot, wobble and crash, but the model captures what drives them. Yeast or duckweed in the lab show it within days.

A case study in an ecosystem: in 1944, 29 reindeer were released on St Matthew Island in the Bering Sea, where there was plenty of lichen and no predator. By 1963 there were about 6,000, which is exponential growth. They had eaten out the lichen and overshot the carrying capacity, and by 1966 only 42 were left. The island could not support 6,000 for long: that is what carrying capacity means.

  • Carrying capacity: the most an environment supports, set by limited resources.
  • Density-dependent factors (competition, predation, disease) give negative feedback towards K.
  • Sigmoid curve: exponential, transitional, plateau. Exponential is straight on a log scale.
Watch out The IB's sigmoid curve has no lag phase at the start. If you are asked for the phases, give exponential, transitional and plateau.

In the population growth bench (the Dry lab), you double the sugar in the flask. What happens?

crowdedabove Kless food,more predators,more diseasefewer born,more dienumbers fallback to Knegative feedbackKabove Kbelow Knumber in the population, over the yearsroom to sparebelow Kmore food,fewer predators,less diseasemore born,fewer dienumbers riseup to Knegative feedbackKabove Kbelow Knumber in the population, over the years

C4.1.9 Competition versus cooperation in intraspecific relationships

Rivals and allies

  • Members of one species need exactly the same things, so they compete more fiercely than with any other species: intraspecific competition.
  • They compete for food, water, light, territory, nest sites or mates.
  • Members of a species also cooperate when working together gains each one more than it costs.
  • Both happen in most populations; which wins depends on the resource and the situation.

The detail

  • Competition is fiercest when something is in short supply.

Rivals and allies

  • Competition: seedlings of one tree species shade each other out.
  • Competition: male red deer fight in the autumn rut for the chance to mate.
  • Competition: great tits defend feeding territories in spring, and birds without one often fail to breed.
  • Cooperation: emperor penguins huddle through the Antarctic winter in thousands, shuffling so that each takes a turn on the cold outside.
  • Cooperation: wolves hunt large prey in packs.
  • Cooperation: meerkats take turns on sentry duty and call when they see a predator.
  • Cooperation: honeybee workers raise their sisters rather than breeding themselves.

Members of one species need exactly the same things, so when something is in short supply they compete for it more fiercely than with any other species. Intraspecific competition can be for food, water, light, territory, nest sites or mates. Seedlings of one tree species shade each other out; male red deer fight in the autumn rut for the chance to mate; great tits defend feeding territories in spring, and birds without one often fail to breed.

Members of a species also cooperate, when working together gains each one more than it costs. Emperor penguins huddle through the Antarctic winter in thousands, shuffling so that each takes a turn on the cold outside. Wolves hunt large prey in packs. Meerkats take turns on sentry duty and call when they see a predator. Honeybee workers raise their sisters rather than breeding themselves.

  • Competition within a species: for food, water, light, space, mates.
  • Cooperation: huddling, group hunting, sentries, shared care of young.
  • Both happen in most populations; which wins depends on the resource and the situation.

Why is competition usually fiercer within a species than between two different species?

lightshadewatermineralsseedlings of one species compete for light, waterand minerals: the tallest shade the resticy windtake turnson the outsideemperor penguins huddle through the polar winter,sharing warmth: cooperation within a species

C4.1.10 A community as all of the interacting organisms in an ecosystem C4.1.11 Herbivory, predation, interspecific competition, mutualism, parasitism and pathogenicity as categories of interspecific relationship within communities C4.1.12 Mutualism as an interspecific relationship that benefits both species

Six ways to get along

  • A community is every population living in an area together: the plants, animals, fungi and bacteria, all interacting.
  • Interactions between species fall into six kinds: herbivory, predation, parasitism, pathogenicity (+/−), competition (−/−) and mutualism (+/+).
  • In mutualism both species benefit.
  • Know three mutualisms, with what each partner gains: legume root nodules, orchid mycorrhizae and coral zooxanthellae.

The detail

  • Each kind of interaction is marked by whether it helps (+), harms (−) or does nothing (0) to each species.

Three mutualisms

  • Root nodules in legumes (beans, peas, clover): Rhizobium bacteria in the nodules fix nitrogen from the air into ammonium that the plant uses for amino acids.
  • The legume gives the bacteria sugars and a low-oxygen home.
  • Mycorrhizae in orchids: orchid seeds are dust-like, with almost no food store, and germinate only when a fungus infects them and supplies sugars and minerals.
  • Many adult orchids pass sugars back to the fungus.
  • Zooxanthellae in hard corals: these algae live inside the coral’s cells and give it most of its food, sugars and oxygen from photosynthesis.
  • The coral gives the algae shelter in clear sunlit water, carbon dioxide and nitrogen compounds from its waste.

A community is every population living in an area together: the plants, animals, fungi and bacteria, all interacting. Those interactions between species fall into six kinds, each marked by whether it helps (+), harms (−) or does nothing (0) to each species.

One deserves a closer look. In mutualism both species benefit:

  • Root nodules in legumes (beans, peas, clover): Rhizobium bacteria in the nodules fix nitrogen from the air into ammonium that the plant uses for amino acids; the plant gives them sugars and a low-oxygen home.
  • Mycorrhizae in orchids: orchid seeds are dust-like, with almost no food store, and germinate only when a fungus infects them and supplies sugars and minerals. Many adult orchids pass sugars back to the fungus.
  • Zooxanthellae in hard corals: these algae live inside the coral's cells and give it most of its food, sugars and oxygen from photosynthesis; the coral gives them shelter in clear sunlit water, carbon dioxide and nitrogen compounds from its waste.
  • Community: all the populations in an area.
  • Herbivory, predation, parasitism, pathogenicity (+/−); competition (−/−); mutualism (+/+).
  • Mutualism examples: legume nodules, orchid mycorrhizae, coral zooxanthellae.

Sea water warms and corals expel their zooxanthellae ("bleaching"). Why do bleached corals often die?

herbivory+ / −rabbitsgraze grasspredation+ / −a fox killsa rabbitcompetition− / −red and greysquirrelsmutualism+ / +beans andRhizobiumparasitism+ / −a tick ona deerpathogenicity+ / −a virus infectsa host

Tap an interaction to see what it is.

Rhizobium insidebean plantthe plant givessugars fromphotosynthesisRhizobium givesammonium: nitrogenfixed from the airfungal coilsorchidthe fungus givessugars and mineralsto the young seedlingthe orchid givessugars back once ithas green leavesalgae inits tissuea hard coralzooxanthellae givesugars and oxygenfrom photosynthesisthe coral givesshelter, CO₂ andnitrogen compounds

C4.1.13 Resource competition between endemic and invasive species C4.1.14 Tests for interspecific competition

Newcomers and tests

  • An endemic species is native to a place. An invasive species has been brought in from elsewhere, spreads, and harms what was there.
  • Invasive species often win by taking a shared resource more efficiently.
  • Tests for interspecific competition: laboratory experiments, field observations by random sampling, and field manipulation by removing one species.
  • If one species does better when another is absent, competition is indicated, but not proved.

Examples

  • Grey squirrels, brought to Britain from North America in the 1800s, can digest acorns while they are still full of tannins, which red squirrels cannot.
  • In oak woods the greys get to the food first, and the reds have largely disappeared from England and Wales.
  • Cane toads were released in Australia in 1935 to eat beetles in sugar cane.
  • They ate the insects native frogs and lizards needed, bred fast in the same ponds, and have no natural predators there that can survive their poison.

Three ways to test

  • Laboratory experiments: grow two species alone and together under controlled conditions.
  • Field observations: random sampling shows whether two species are found together less often than chance would predict.
  • Field manipulation: remove one species from plots and see whether the other does better.

How we know

  • Gause’s two Paramecium species each thrived alone; together, one always died out.
  • Joseph Connell scraped the large barnacle Balanus off rocks in Scotland, and the small barnacle Chthamalus then lived lower on the shore than before.
  • Nature of science: hypotheses can be tested by experiments and by observations.
  • In an experiment the scientist changes one factor (removing Balanus) and controls others; in an observation they record what happens naturally (which quadrats hold both species).
  • Experiments show cause more clearly; observations show what happens in real, uncontrolled communities.

Links across the course

  • The chi-squared test for field observations is in chapter 8.

Watch out

  • Showing that two species compete is harder than it looks. Each test gives evidence, not proof.
  • Something else, such as a different predator or a difference in the soil, might explain why one species does better without the other.

An endemic species is native to a place. An invasive species has been brought in from elsewhere, spreads, and harms what was there. Often it wins because it takes a shared resource more efficiently. Grey squirrels, brought to Britain from North America in the 1800s, can digest acorns while they are still full of tannins, which red squirrels cannot. In oak woods the greys get to the food first, and the reds have largely disappeared from England and Wales. Cane toads, released in Australia in 1935 to eat beetles in sugar cane, ate the insects native frogs and lizards needed, bred fast in the same ponds, and have no natural predators there that can survive their poison.

Showing that two species compete is harder than it looks. There are three approaches:

  • Laboratory experiments: grow two species alone and together under controlled conditions. Gause's two Paramecium species each thrived alone; together, one always died out.
  • Field observations: random sampling shows whether two species are found together less often than chance would predict (the chi-squared test, chapter 8).
  • Field manipulation: remove one species from plots and see whether the other does better. Joseph Connell scraped the large barnacle Balanus off rocks in Scotland, and the small barnacle Chthamalus then lived lower on the shore than before.

Each gives evidence, not proof. If one species does better when another is absent, competition is indicated, but something else, such as a different predator or a difference in the soil, might explain it.

  • Invasive species often win by taking a shared resource more efficiently.
  • Tests: lab experiments, field observations, removal from plots.
  • Better without the other species indicates competition but does not prove it.
Nature of science Hypotheses can be tested by experiments and by observations. In an experiment the scientist changes one factor (removing Balanus) and controls others; in an observation they record what happens naturally (which quadrats hold both species). Experiments show cause more clearly; observations show what happens in real, uncontrolled communities.

In Connell's experiment, what was the purpose of leaving some plots with Balanus untouched?

high tidelow tideChthamalussmall, highBalanuslarge, lowBalanus scraped off this patchChthamalus now lives lower down
  1. On the shore, small Chthamalus lives high up and larger Balanus lower down.
  2. Connell scraped Balanus off patches of rock.
  3. There Chthamalus grew lower than before: Balanus had been keeping it out.

C4.1.15 Use of the chi-squared test for association between two species

Together, apart, or chance?

  • Record the presence or absence of two species in random quadrats, then make a 2 × 2 table of observed counts.
  • Together more often than chance is a positive association; less often is a negative association.
  • Expected value = row total × column total ÷ grand total; then χ² = Σ (O − E)² ÷ E over the four cells.
  • With 1 degree of freedom, χ² larger than 3.84 (p = 0.05) means a significant association.

The detail

  • A positive association: perhaps they need the same conditions, or one helps the other.
  • A negative association: perhaps they need different conditions, or they compete.
  • The chi-squared test tells you whether the difference from chance is big enough to be real.

The test, step by step

  • State the hypotheses. H₀: the two species are distributed independently. H₁: they are associated.
  • Make a 2 × 2 table of observed counts: both present, A only, B only, neither.
  • Work out each expected value: row total × column total ÷ grand total.
  • χ² = Σ (O − E)² ÷ E, over all four cells.
  • Degrees of freedom = (rows − 1) × (columns − 1) = 1. The critical value at p = 0.05 is 3.84.
  • If χ² is larger than 3.84, reject H₀: the association is significant. Compare O with E for “both present” to see whether it is positive or negative.

Watch out

  • A significant negative association does not prove competition. Two species might simply need different soils, as heather and creeping buttercup do.
  • It is a clue, to be tested with a removal experiment.

Throw quadrats at random and record whether each of two species is present. If they grow together more often than chance predicts, there is a positive association: perhaps they need the same conditions, or one helps the other. If they occur together less often, a negative association: perhaps they need different conditions, or they compete. The chi-squared test tells you whether the difference from chance is big enough to be real.

  1. State the hypotheses. H₀: the two species are distributed independently. H₁: they are associated.
  2. Make a 2 × 2 table of observed counts: both present, A only, B only, neither.
  3. Work out each expected value: row total × column total ÷ grand total.
  4. χ² = Σ (O − E)² ÷ E, over all four cells.
  5. Degrees of freedom = (rows − 1) × (columns − 1) = 1. The critical value at p = 0.05 is 3.84.
  6. If χ² is larger than 3.84, reject H₀: the association is significant. Compare O with E for "both present" to see whether it is positive or negative.
  • Presence and absence in random quadrats, then a 2 × 2 table.
  • Expected = row total × column total ÷ grand total.
  • χ² > 3.84 (1 df, p = 0.05): significant association.
Watch out A significant negative association does not prove competition. Two species might simply need different soils, as heather and creeping buttercup do. It is a clue, to be tested with a removal experiment.

On the Hillside in the bench, heather and creeping buttercup are found together in fewer quadrats than expected, and χ² = 11.2. What should you conclude?

soft rushcreeping buttercupbuttercupno buttercuprushno rushtotal1864122218(13.2)(10.8)(8.8)(7.2)χ² = 9.70 > 3.84: a significant positive association
  1. Forty random quadrats in a wet meadow: is soft rush there, is creeping buttercup there?
  2. The observed counts go in a 2 × 2 table.
  3. The expected counts come from the totals. χ² = 9.70, above 3.84: the two grow together more than chance predicts.
Two species on a hillside, sampled by random quadrats: each quadrat records whether each species is present.

C4.1.16 Predator–prey relationships as an example of density-dependent control of animal populations C4.1.17 Top-down and bottom-up control of populations in communities C4.1.18 Allelopathy and secretion of antibiotics

Held in check

  • Predation is density-dependent: the more prey there are, the more are eaten, which pulls their numbers back.
  • Top-down control comes from predators; bottom-up control comes from the food, nutrients and producers below. Both act, but one usually dominates.
  • In allelopathy a plant releases substances that stop others growing near it, such as juglone from black walnut.
  • Microorganisms secrete antibiotics: Penicillium secretes penicillin, which kills bacteria competing with it for the same food.

Lynx and hare

  • For nearly a century the Hudson’s Bay Company bought furs from trappers across Canada.
  • Its records show snowshoe hares and the Canada lynx that hunt them rising and falling together, about every ten years, the lynx a year or two behind.
  • When hares are plentiful, lynx catch more and rear more kittens.
  • As lynx increase, they eat hares faster than hares breed, and the hares crash.
  • Then the lynx starve, and with few lynx the hares recover.

Examples

  • Top-down: when sea otters were hunted out along the Pacific coast, sea urchins (their prey) multiplied and grazed kelp forests to bare rock.
  • Bottom-up: when fertiliser washes into a lake, the algae bloom, and everything above them changes.
  • Black walnut trees release juglone from their roots, leaves and nut husks, and many plants wilt and die near them.
  • Allelopathy and antibiotics are both ways some organisms fight competitors with chemicals.

For nearly a century the Hudson's Bay Company bought furs from trappers across Canada, and its records show snowshoe hares and the Canada lynx that hunt them rising and falling together, about every ten years, the lynx a year or two behind. When hares are plentiful, lynx catch more and rear more kittens. As lynx increase, they eat hares faster than hares breed, and the hares crash. Then the lynx starve, and with few lynx the hares recover. Predation is density-dependent: the more hares there are, the more are eaten, which pulls their numbers back.

A population can be held back from above or from below. Top-down control comes from predators; bottom-up control comes from the food, nutrients and producers below. Both act in most communities, but one usually dominates. When sea otters were hunted out along the Pacific coast, sea urchins (their prey) multiplied and grazed kelp forests to bare rock: top-down. When fertiliser washes into a lake, the algae bloom, and everything above them changes: bottom-up.

Some organisms fight competitors with chemicals. In allelopathy a plant releases substances that stop others growing near it: black walnut trees release juglone from their roots, leaves and nut husks, and many plants wilt and die near them. Microorganisms secrete antibiotics: the mould Penicillium secretes penicillin, which kills bacteria competing with it for the same food.

  • Predator-prey cycles: lynx and hare, about ten years, predators lag behind.
  • Top-down (predators) and bottom-up (resources); one usually dominates.
  • Allelopathy (black walnut, juglone) and antibiotics (Penicillium, penicillin) deter competitors.

In the film, choose Lynx trapped out. What happens to the hares after year 20?

seedlings wiltout of reach:they growblack walnutjuglone leaks from itsroots, leaves and husksjuglone in the soilPenicilliuma mouldclear zoneno bacteria growbacteriaa lawn on the agar
Forty years of snowshoe hares and lynx, one year a second. Watch which population peaks first, then trap out the lynx or give the hares more food at year 20.

02Dry lab: The population growth bench

Grow yeast in a flask of sugar solution and count it every two hours. Change the birth rate, the death rate and the sugar, add a cold shock, and watch the J curve bend into an S.

births 0.6deaths 0.1sugar: some12 htime72.8million /cm³dead50 µmFLASKCOUNTING CHAMBER
The bench: yeast in a flask of sugar solution, counted every 2 hours on a counting chamber under the microscope. Set the births, the deaths and the sugar, and watch what the count does over 30 hours.
Your questionHow does a population of yeast grow in a flask, and what makes it stop? Predict first: if you double the sugar, will the population grow faster at the start, level off higher, or both?
What you can changeBirths per cell per hour, deaths per cell per hour, and the sugar in the flask, which sets the carrying capacity. You can also chill the flask at 14 hours, a density-independent knock.
What to recordThe count every two hours, the hour each phase begins, and the plateau. Plot the counts on a normal scale and on a log scale. The yeast is a model with invented numbers; the pattern is what real yeast and duckweed cultures show.

Find out

  • The S curve. Run 30 hours with the middle settings. Turn on Show the phases and name each one: where is the population growing fastest, and where has it stopped?
  • Births and deaths. Open Births and deaths. At what population do the two lines cross, and how does that number compare with the carrying capacity line?
  • Food sets the ceiling. Run Little, Some and Lots of sugar. Does the carrying capacity change, the speed of growth, or both?
  • The birth rate. Keep the sugar the same and try each birth rate. Which part of the curve moves, and which stays put?
  • A cold shock. Add the cold shock at 14 hours. Is the cold density dependent or density independent? How long does the flask take to get back to the plateau?
  • Log scale. Switch it on. Which phase becomes a straight line, and why?
  • Back to biology. Using your results, explain why the population follows an S curve, and what decides the level it holds at.

Record

  • A table of the carrying capacity and the time to reach half of it for each amount of sugar.
  • A sketch of one S curve with the exponential, transitional and plateau phases labelled.
  • For the cold shock: the number before and after it, and the time to recover.
  • Download the CSV to keep every reading.

The yeast in the flask has reached its plateau. A student says the cells have stopped reproducing. Are they right?

Raising the sugar from Little to Lots, what happens to the plateau?

The cold shock kills 60% of the cells whatever the population. What kind of factor is it?

Back to biology

Using your results, explain why the yeast population followed an S-shaped curve, and what decides the level it finally holds at.

03Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in. It opens on biologybybradford.com, so it needs the internet.

Exam practice

Exam questions on C4.1, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

04Downloads

This file is the guide, saved to run without the internet.

Saved from biologybybradford.com/guides/ib-biology-c4-1-populations-and-communities, where the guide is kept up to date with the notes, the revision sheet and, for the teacher, the lesson plans and slides.

05Teacher resources

The guide as five one-hour lessons. Each has a plan to print (the timings, what to project and where to stop, the activities with what they need, what students get wrong) and slides to teach it from, in the same order, with the teacher's moves in the notes.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1Throw the square C4.1.1 to C4.1.360 min Populations as interbreeding groups in an area, why we sample at random, and estimating a sessile population with random quadrats 1, 2 Lesson planPDF 574 KB SlidesPPTX 638 KB
2Mark them, catch them again C4.1.4 to C4.1.660 min The Lincoln index and its assumptions, carrying capacity, and density-dependent factors as negative feedback 3, 4 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 590 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 967 KB
3Grow it till it stops C4.1.7 to C4.1.960 min The phases of a sigmoid growth curve, the exponential phase on a log scale, modelling yeast growth, and competition against cooperation within a species 5, dry lab Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 529 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 339 KB
4Six ways to get along C4.1.10 to C4.1.1460 min Communities, the six interspecific relationships, three mutualisms, invasive species and the tests for competition 6, 7 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 591 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 706 KB
5Held in check C4.1.15 to C4.1.1860 min Chi-squared for association, predator and prey cycles, top-down and bottom-up control, allelopathy and antibiotics 8, 9 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 648 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 1.8 MB

Lesson 1 is free with a free account. The other plans and slides, for every guide, come with the Teacher pass.

The note template, the revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTISE AND REVISE

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for C4.1

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.