AP BIOLOGY · UNIT 8 · ECOLOGY

Sense a change, respond, survive

A seedling bends toward a window, a pill bug settles under a damp log and a ground squirrel whistles as a hawk passes. Find what each response is to, test one with a choice chamber and a chi-square test, and work out why behaviors that help an organism survive and reproduce are the ones a population keeps.

AP Biology 8.14 lessons8 chaptersdry lab

Start learningRun the dry labTeach it

Oat seedlings in a tray, lit first from above and then from one side. Nothing pulls them round: they grow toward the light. What did they detect, and what did they do about it?
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Eight chapters and a dry lab, in two parts. How organisms respond to a change: what a response is (chapter 1), plants (2), how animals move toward what they need and how to test it (3), and changes inside the body and messages between organisms (4). Behavior and natural selection: signals (5), innate and learned behavior (6), costs and payoffs (7) and cooperation (8). Every species named is an example to reason with, not one to memorize. Make each prediction before you open the answer or run a tool.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1Every response is to a change
  2. 2Plants respond by growing and by timing
  3. 3Toward it, or just slower there?
  4. 4Alarm inside, and news between organisms
  5. 5Five ways to send a message
  6. 6Born with it, or picked up?
  7. 7Every behavior has a cost
  8. 8Why help each other?

8.1.A Stimulus and response

Every response is to a change

On a cold morning a lizard crawls out of the shade onto a sunny rock, and a person waiting at a bus stop starts to shiver. Which describes the two responses?

  • A stimulus is a change an organism can detect, outside it (light, cold, a predator) or inside it (a fall in blood sugar, a rise in body temperature).
  • A response is what the organism then does about it.
  • A behavioral response is something the organism does: it moves, calls, hides or feeds.
  • A physiological response is a change in how its body works: it shivers, sweats or releases a hormone.
  • Both kinds keep an organism alive, and able to reproduce, in an environment that keeps changing.

The detail

  • Name the stimulus first. "The lizard basks" is half an answer; "the lizard basks because its body has cooled overnight" is the whole one.
  • Many responses are both kinds at once. A dog on a hot day pants (a physiological change in its breathing) and lies in the shade (a behavior).
  • Plants respond too, with no nerves and no muscles. They respond by growing, by opening and closing their stomata, and by timing what they do: chapter 2.
  • The exam can describe any organism and any response. You will not be asked how the nerves, hormones or genes behind a response work: the framework puts those mechanisms beyond the exam.

Links across the course

  • Responses that hold the inside of the body steady, such as shivering and sweating, are the negative feedback of Unit 4, feedback.
  • How a single cell detects a signal and passes it inward is Unit 4, cell communication.

Watch the seedlings at the top of the page. Nobody touched them, and nothing pulled them round. Light arrived from one side, the shoots detected it, and they grew toward it. That is the pattern of everything in this guide: a stimulus, which is a change the organism can detect, and a response, which is what it does next.

Responses come in two kinds. A behavioral response is an action: a cold lizard crawls onto a warm rock, a mouse freezes under a passing owl. A physiological response is a change inside: you shiver, your pupils narrow in bright light, your pancreas releases insulin after a meal. The stimulus can be outside the body, like the cold air, or inside it, like the sugar in your blood.

Why respond at all? Because conditions change by the minute, the day and the season, and an organism that does nothing about a change may overheat, starve, be eaten or fail to breed. The figure sorts six responses. Decide what each is a response to before you sort it.

Remember it Two kinds of response

  • DoesBehavioralmoves, calls, hides, feeds
  • WorksPhysiologicalshivers, sweats, releases a hormone
  • A response is always to a change: name the stimulus first.
  • Behavioral: what the organism does. Physiological: how its body's working changes. Many responses are both.
  • The stimulus can be internal or external.
Watch out A response does not have to be quick, or done by an animal. A shoot bending over hours and a plant flowering in one season are responses too.

Tap a card, then sort it.

Tap a card to sort it.

Six responses. Tap a card, then sort it twice: is it behavioral or physiological, and is the change it answers inside the body or outside it?

8.1.A Phototropism and photoperiodism

Plants respond by growing and by timing

  • Phototropism: a shoot lit from one side grows toward the light, because cells on its shaded side grow longer than cells on its lit side.
  • In a grass seedling the light is detected in one place and the bend happens in another, so a signal must pass between them.
  • Photoperiodism: many plants flower only at one time of year, cued by the lengths of the day and the night, so they flower in the right season.

The detail

  • Phototropism is growth, not movement. The lit side still grows, just more slowly than the shaded side.
  • Turned toward the light, the leaves catch more of it for photosynthesis.
  • Flowering at the right season lets plants of one kind flower together, when their pollinators are about, and set seed before the weather turns.

How the plant does it (beyond the exam)

  • The tip of a shoot makes a plant hormone, auxin. Lit from one side, more of it passes down the shaded side, and there it makes the cells lengthen more.
  • A light-sensitive pigment in the leaves, phytochrome, switches between two forms in red and far-red light, and so tells the plant whether it is light or dark.
  • When the nights are right, the leaves send a signal to the buds, and the buds become flowers.
  • The exam asks for none of this: the names auxin and phytochrome, and how either works, are outside the framework.

A plant cannot walk to the light or away from the cold. It responds in the two ways open to it: it grows, and it times what it does. Light from one side is the plainest case. A shoot on a windowsill grows toward the window because cells on its shaded side grow longer than cells on its lit side. That is phototropism: growth, not movement.

The classic experiments used grass seedlings, whose young shoot grows up inside a pointed sheath. Look at where the shoot bends: not at the very tip but in the growing region just below it. Before you go on, think about which part has to see the light.

The tip of an oat seedling is covered with a small foil cap, and the seedling is lit from one side. What does the shoot do?

Timing is the second way. Many plants flower only at one time of year, so that they flower together, when pollinators are about, and set seed before winter. The cue they use is the daily cycle of light and dark: photoperiodism. The tool under this chapter gives you two plants, A and B, and lets you run the experiments that showed it. Each one answers an objection to the one before. Before the third, make this prediction.

Plant A flowers when it gets 14 hours of darkness a day, and not when it gets 8. Now each 14-hour night is split in the middle by one minute of light. Does it flower?

To show that the flash is what stopped plant A flowering, which plants must you also grow?

So the cue is the length of the unbroken night. The night length a plant needs is its critical night length. Textbooks call a plant that flowers when nights are longer than its critical length a short-day plant, and one that flowers when they are shorter a long-day plant. The names are older than the night-break experiments: a short-day plant is really a long-night plant. Examples to reason with: poinsettias and chrysanthemums flower as the nights lengthen in fall, and spinach as they shorten toward summer.

  • Plants respond without nerves: by growing, and by timing.
  • Phototropism: the shaded side grows more, so the shoot grows toward the light. The tip detects; the region below it bends.
  • Photoperiodism: flowering set by the length of the night. A plant "measuring day length" is measuring the night.
Watch out "Short-day plants flower in spring" is not the rule. The names say nothing about the season: they say whether the plant needs nights longer or shorter than its critical length, and many spring flowers are long-day plants.
growing regionwhere it bendstipCells in the growing regionlightlit sideshorter cellsshaded sidelonger cells growing regionwhere it bendstipCells in the growing regionlightlit sideshorter cellsshaded sidelonger cells
Lit from one side, the shoot bends in the growing region just below its tip. Cells on the shaded side grow longer than those on the lit side, so the shoot curves toward the light. The difference in cell length is exaggerated.
The seedlings from the top of the page, with two controls. Answer the foil cap question first. Then move the light, and cap, collar or cut the tips, and watch two hours of growth.
10 hours of light, 14 hours of dark04812162024Hours from lights onPlant APlant BExperiment 1: day lengthLight (h)Dark (h)Plant APlant B816flowersleafy1212flowersleafy168leafyleafy186leafyflowersAt 16 hours of light, 8 of dark, neither flowers.Experiment 2: break the night or the dayPlantCycle (h)BreakResultA10 and 14flash at nightleafyA10 and 14dark in the dayflowersB18 and 6flash at nightflowersB18 and 6dark in the dayflowersB12 and 12flash at nightflowersB12 and 12dark in the dayleafyExperiment 3: when in the night0255075100024681012Time of the flash (hours into the night)Plants flowering (%)
  1. Plants A and B on a cycle of 10 hours of light and 14 of dark, before a run. Set the hours of light, then run four weeks and see which plant flowers.
  2. Experiment 1: plant A flowers when the days are short, plant B when they are long, and at 16 hours of light neither flowers.
  3. Experiment 2: a flash in the night changes the result for both plants; a spell of dark in the day changes nothing. The cue is the night.
  4. Experiment 3: a flash stops plant A flowering most in the middle of the night, where it leaves the longest unbroken dark shortest. Plant A is what textbooks call a short-day plant (really a long-night plant), and plant B a long-day plant.
Two plants, A and B, and a 24-hour bar of light and dark that you set. Run three experiments in order, predict before each run, and answer the question after it.

8.1.A Taxis, kinesis, and testing a response

Toward it, or just slower there?

In the dry half of a dish, pill bugs walk fast and turn often. In the damp half they slow down and turn less, and over time most of them end up there. What kind of response is this?

  • Taxis: movement directly toward or away from a stimulus.
  • Kinesis: a change in how fast an animal moves, or how often it turns, with no direction to it.
  • Both can gather animals in one place. The animal's track tells them apart.
  • Nocturnal animals are active at night and diurnal ones by day: activity timed to the cue of light and dark.
  • To test a response, change one variable, hold the rest the same, and give the animals an equal chance of ending up on either side.

The detail

  • Pill bugs (also called roly-polies, and woodlice) are small crustaceans that live on land. They lose water through their outer covering easily, so dry air is a danger to them.
  • Examples of taxis to reason with: many bacteria swim toward a richer supply of food (chemotaxis), and fly maggots crawl directly away from light (a negative phototaxis).
  • A moth circling a porch lamp is a poor example of taxis. Filming has shown that flying insects do not steer at the lamp: they keep their backs tilted toward the brightest light, as they would toward the open sky, and so get trapped circling a lamp.
  • Nocturnal and diurnal activity are responses to light and dark, often kept on time by an internal clock. A desert rodent that feeds at night avoids the heat of the day and many of the predators that hunt by sight.

Designing the test (practice 3.C)

  • The independent variable is the one you change on purpose. The dependent variable is the one you measure. Everything else is held constant.
  • A control is a run that differs from the test only in the variable being tested.
  • Release the animals at the join, not on one side, and use fresh animals for each trial, so that every trial is a fresh, independent chance.

A pill bug under a log is not there by accident. Lift the log on a dry day and the animals scurry, then slow down again under the next damp leaf. Animals that move about meet this question all the time: how do they end up where conditions suit them?

There are two simple ways. In taxis the animal heads somewhere: toward the stimulus or away from it. Its track points. In kinesis the animal changes how fast it moves, or how often it turns, depending on where it is. Its track wanders. Yet animals that move fast where things are bad and slow where they are good still gather where they are good, because that is where they linger.

So counting animals on each side cannot tell you which is going on. Watching one animal can. The two tracks in the figure are from two different dishes. Decide which is which, then tap to check.

That is what pill bugs do with moisture. In dry air they walk faster and turn more often; in damp air they slow and turn less. They do not head for the damp. They stay longer once they are there, and so they gather where it is damp, which is where they lose least water.

Testing a response is a design question, and it is the skill the exam ties to this topic. The dry lab is a choice chamber: two joined dishes whose sides you set, pill bugs released at the join, and a count at the end. Before you plan it, name the variables.

A student tests whether pill bugs prefer damp or dry paper in a choice chamber. Which is the dependent variable?

The control is a run with both sides damp. If the animals still pile up on one side, something other than moisture is pushing them, perhaps a draft or a light. The dry lab adds the last step: a chi-square test on the counts, to decide whether a difference between the sides is bigger than chance would give.

Remember it Taxis or kinesis

  • TaxiTaxisdrives toward or away
  • KineticKinesisspeed and turning change, no direction
  • Kinesis: faster or slower, more or fewer turns, no direction. Taxis: toward or away.
  • Both can gather animals; only the track tells them apart.
  • One variable changed, the rest held, a control with both sides the same, animals released at the join.
Watch out Kinesis is not random movement. The movement has no direction, but its speed and turning depend on the stimulus, and that is why the animals gather.
Dish 1dampdry

Dish 2lampdry all over

Each track starts at a ring. A dot marks every 2 seconds, so dots far apart mean a fast animal. Each dish is 14 cm across.

Two dishes, two tracks. Tap the dish you think shows kinesis and the one that shows taxis, then read each animal's speed and turns per minute on each half.

8.1.A Internal changes, external cues and information

Alarm inside, and news between organisms

  • A response can start with a change inside the body: a fall in blood sugar, a rise in temperature, a shortage of water.
  • Fight or flight: a threat is detected and within seconds heart rate, breathing and blood sugar rise. The physiological response readies the body for a behavioral one.
  • Organisms exchange information with each other in response to changes, and the information changes what the receiver does.
  • Examples: a warning call that sends others to cover, and a chewed plant whose untouched neighbors raise their own defenses.

The detail

  • In fight or flight the adrenal glands release the hormone epinephrine into the blood. It reaches cells all over the body: the heart beats faster and harder, the airways widen, and the liver releases glucose for the muscles.
  • All of that is physiological. What the animal then does with it, running, fighting or freezing, is behavioral.
  • Thirst is an internal change too: as the body loses water, an animal seeks water and drinks, and its kidneys release less water into the urine.

Examples to reason with

  • Vervet monkeys give different alarm calls for a leopard, an eagle and a snake, and the listeners respond to each in its own way: up a tree, under a bush, or up on their hind legs to look at the ground.

Beyond the exam

  • The route from the brain to the adrenal glands, the receptors on each organ and how each cell responds are the mechanisms the framework leaves out. The tool shows them so the story makes sense: you will not be asked for them.

Not every stimulus comes from outside. When your blood sugar falls hours after a meal, your pancreas releases a hormone that makes your liver release glucose, and you start to feel hungry. When your body heats up, you sweat and you look for shade. The stimulus is internal; the responses are physiological and behavioral at once.

The best-known case is the response to danger. A sudden noise or a looming shape is detected, and within seconds the heart races, breathing deepens and glucose floods the blood. This fight-or-flight response is physiological, but it exists for the behavior that follows: running, fighting or hiding. Startle the person in the tool and follow the signal.

A hiker sees a bear. Within seconds her heart rate rises and her liver releases glucose into her blood. Then she backs slowly away. Which part of this is a behavioral response?

Organisms also pass information to each other, and the information changes what the receiver does. A bird that spots a hawk calls, and the whole flock dives for cover. Plants do something like it. Make this prediction before you step through the figure.

A caterpillar chews the leaves of one plant. A plant of the same kind a meter downwind, never touched, starts making more of its defensive chemicals. What most likely reached it?

Two studies are examples to reason with. Maize seedlings chewed by caterpillars release a blend of chemicals into the air, and parasitic wasps that lay their eggs in caterpillars follow that smell to find them. And wild tobacco growing beside sagebrush that had been clipped, as if grazed, suffered less insect damage than tobacco beside unclipped sagebrush. The chewed plant gains nothing from its neighbor's defenses; the neighbor gains by detecting the chemicals and responding.

  • Stimuli can be internal (blood sugar, temperature, water) or external (light, a predator).
  • Fight or flight: a physiological response that readies the body for a behavioral one.
  • Information passed between organisms changes the receiver's behavior: a warning call, a chewed plant's chemicals.
Watch out A plant that "warns" its neighbors is not trying to help them. Its chemicals are released when it is damaged, and neighbors that detect them gain by responding. Who gains, and why, is chapters 7 and 8.
patient's rightpatient's leftnerve impulseepinephrine, a hormoneartery, oxygen-richvein, oxygen-poor, dashedepinephrine in the blood0246810time (minutes)highlowheartrate and force of the beatresting rateairwayswidth of the bronchiolesresting widthliverglycogen broken down to glucoseat restblood flowshare of the blood: muscle, gutmusclegutmuscleat restgutat restheartrate and force of the beatfaster, strongerairwayswidth of the bronchiolesmuch widerliverglycogen broken down to glucosemuch more outblood flowshare of the blood: muscle, gutmusclegutmusclemuch moregutmuch lessepinephrine in the blood0246810time (minutes)highlowhypothalamuspituitary glandpineal glandfrontbackthe brain from the side, enlargedthyroidadrenal glandon the kidneypancreasovariesor testes, lowerheart patient's right12345678nerve impulseepinephrineartery, oxygen-richvein, oxygen-poor, dashed1hypothalamus2pituitary gland3pineal gland4thyroid gland5adrenal glandon each kidney6pancreas7ovariesor, in a male, thetestes, lower down8heartnot a gland: theblood's pumpepinephrine in the blood0246810time (minutes)highlowheartresting rateairwaysresting widthliverat restblood flowmusclegutat restat restheartfasterairwaysmuch widerlivermuch more outblood flowmusclegutmuch moremuch lessepinephrine in the blood0246810time (minutes)highlow
  1. A person at rest. The hypothalamus, at the base of the brain, and the adrenal glands on the kidneys; four of the hormone's targets, at rest.
  2. Danger, or a sprint: the hypothalamus sends nerve impulses down the spinal cord to the adrenal glands.
  3. The adrenal glands secrete epinephrine into the blood, which carries it everywhere: the heart beats faster and harder, the airways widen, the liver releases glucose, and more blood goes to the muscles and less to the gut.
Choose Startled and follow the signal: nerve impulses to the adrenal glands, then epinephrine in the blood to the heart, the airways, the liver and the muscles. Watch the level of the hormone rise in seconds and fall over minutes.
breezeairbornechemicalsdefensesraiseda parasitic wasp
  1. A caterpillar chews the leaves of one plant. Its neighbor downwind is untouched.
  2. The damaged leaves release a blend of airborne chemicals, carried on the breeze.
  3. The neighbor detects them and raises its own defenses, and parasitic wasps follow the smell to the caterpillar.

8.1.B Communication and signals

Five ways to send a message

  • Communication: one organism makes a signal, another detects it, and the receiver's behavior changes.
  • Signals are visual, audible, tactile, electrical or chemical.
  • Each kind suits some places and some distances better than others.
  • Animals use signals to show dominance, find food, hold a territory and win a mate.
  • A signal can lead to differential reproductive success: senders and receivers that respond well leave more offspring.

The detail

  • A signal only counts as communication if a receiver detects it and changes what it does. A bright flower is a signal to a bee; to a cow walking past, it is just a flower.
  • Many signals carry more than one message. A male songbird's song keeps other males out of his territory and draws females in.
  • Plants signal too: the color and scent of a flower bring pollinators, and the color of a ripe fruit brings animals that eat it and spread the seeds.

Examples to reason with

  • Visual: male fireflies flash in a pattern of their own species, and females answer with their own flash.
  • Audible: a songbird sings from a high perch at the edge of its territory.
  • Tactile: in the dark of the hive, honeybees follow a dancing forager by touch.
  • Electrical: weakly electric fish, which live in muddy rivers, signal to each other with pulses of an electric field.
  • Chemical: an ant that finds food lays a trail of scent back to the nest, and other ants follow it. Mammals mark the edges of a territory with urine or scent.
  • Bacteria exchange chemical signals too, and change their behavior when enough of them are present: quorum sensing, in Unit 4, cell communication.

Beyond the exam

  • How each signal is produced and detected, and what code a signal uses, are left out of the framework. The honeybee dance below is one worked case of a signal for finding food, not a code to learn.

Chapter 4 ended with a bird calling as a hawk passed. That call is a signal, and the flock diving for cover is the point of it. Communication is that whole chain: a sender, a signal, a receiver, and a change in what the receiver does.

Signals come in five kinds: visual, audible, tactile, electrical and chemical. Each suits some places better than others. Think about what each one needs to reach a receiver before you try this.

Which signal would still reach another animal at night, in a dense forest, a kilometer away?

So each kind has its place. Color needs light and a clear line of sight. Sound carries in the dark and round obstacles. A touch works only up close. An electric pulse carries through water too muddy to see in. A chemical stays after the sender has gone, so it can mark a trail or a boundary. The gallery has one sender of each kind.

What do animals signal about? The framework names four uses. They show dominance, so a contest can be settled without a fight. They help others find food. They hold a territory, by song or scent at its edges. And they find and win a mate. In each case the signal changes what the receiver does, and that can change who survives and who leaves offspring: differential reproductive success, which is natural selection at work.

Remember it The five kinds of signal

  • VeryVisualcolor, flashes, displays
  • ActiveAudiblecalls and songs
  • ToadsTactiletouch, up close
  • EatElectricalpulses in murky water
  • CricketsChemicalscents, trails, marks
  • Communication needs a receiver that changes its behavior.
  • Visual, audible, tactile, electrical, chemical: each suits a place and a distance.
  • Signals show dominance, find food, hold territory and win mates, and so affect reproductive success.
Watch out A signal is not the same as a response. A pill bug slowing on damp paper responds to a stimulus, but nothing signaled to it. Communication needs a sender as well as a receiver.
Visual
Audible
Tactile
Electrical
Chemical

Tap a scene: who sends, who receives, and what the receiver does.

Five senders and five receivers. Tap each to read the signal and why that kind suits the place. Then switch to By purpose and sort them by what each signal is for.
INSIDE THE HIVEstraight up40 degreesdance 1: about 1 s of waggling90 degreesdance 2: about 2.5 sMAP, FROM ABOVEthe sunhive40 degreesPQRS1 km

One case of a signal for finding food: the code is beyond the exam. Here 1 second of waggling stands for about 1 km; the real scale differs between colonies.

  1. A forager back from a flower patch dances on the vertical comb. The straight, waggling part of the dance points at an angle from straight up.
  2. Outside, that is the angle of the food from the direction of the sun. The bees following her by touch learn which way to fly.
  3. The longer each waggling run lasts, the farther away the food is. Read the two dances and pick the patch each one points to.

8.1.B Innate and learned behavior

Born with it, or picked up?

  • Innate behavior appears without experience, in much the same form in every member of a species.
  • Learned behavior changes with experience.
  • Most behavior has parts of both.
  • Either kind is favored by natural selection when it raises survival and reproductive success.
  • To separate the two, raise young without the experience (apart from adults, for example) and compare them with young raised normally.

The detail

  • Innate behavior is useful where there is no time or chance to learn: a newly hatched chick pecks at food, and a baby mammal sucks.
  • Learned behavior is useful where conditions vary: which foods are safe here, where the water is this year, which neighbor is a threat.
  • Learning needs the ability to learn, and that ability is inherited, so even learned behavior has a genetic basis.

A real case: bird song

  • Young male white-crowned sparrows raised in isolation, hearing no adult of their kind, grow up to sing a simplified, abnormal song, though it keeps some features of the normal one.
  • To sing it properly they must hear their own species' song early in life, in a sensitive period that lasts roughly from 10 to 50 days after hatching.
  • So the answer to "innate or learned?" is both: a built-in template, filled in by listening.

Names your textbook uses (beyond the exam)

  • Proximate and ultimate causes: how a behavior is produced (the stimulus, the nerves, the hormones) and why it evolved (how it raised the fitness of ancestors).
  • Fixed action pattern: an innate sequence that runs to the end once started. A graylag goose rolls an egg that has slipped out of the nest back in with its bill, and goes on making the movement even if the egg is taken away. What sets it off is called a sign stimulus.
  • Imprinting: learning in a short window early in life. Young geese follow the first moving object they meet, usually their mother.
  • Habituation (ceasing to respond to a harmless stimulus), associative learning (linking one stimulus or action with another), spatial learning (a digger wasp finding its nest by the landmarks round it) and social learning (learning by watching others).

A spider spins its first web, perfectly, without ever seeing another spider spin one. A crow learns which garbage cans in a street are worth opening. The first is innate behavior: present without practice, alike in every member of the species. The second is learned behavior: it changes with what the animal meets.

Neither kind is better. Innate behavior works first time, which matters when a mistake kills. Learned behavior can fit a world that changes. Either one is kept by natural selection when the animals that show it survive and reproduce better than those that do not. And most behavior is a mix: a template the animal is born with, adjusted by experience.

How would you find out which a behavior is? The figure gives you the cards of an experiment on bird song. Arrange them, decide what each group of chicks is for, and then say which result would support "learned" and which "innate".

Chicks of a bird species are raised in a quiet room and never hear an adult. As adults they still give the species' normal alarm call. What does this suggest, and what would the opposite result have shown?

  • Innate: appears without experience. Learned: changes with experience. Most behavior is both.
  • Either kind is favored by selection when it raises survival and reproduction.
  • Test it by removing the experience: raise young apart from adults and compare.
Watch out Innate does not mean fixed for life, and learned does not mean free of genes. The white-crowned sparrow is born ready to learn one kind of song, and learns it by listening.

Put the cards in order. Tap two cards to swap them, or move a card with the arrow keys.

Two possible results: one sound trace for each group as adults, pitch against time.

Result 1

This result supports

Result 2

This result supports

Design the experiment: put the four cards in order and say what each group of chicks is for. Then read the two possible results and decide which would support learned and which innate.

8.1.B Behavior, fitness and natural selection

Every behavior has a cost

  • A behavior costs energy, time and risk, and pays in food, mates or safety.
  • Individuals whose behavior pays best leave more offspring, so the behavior, and the alleles behind it, become more common: differential reproductive success.
  • Cases: foraging that gains the most energy for the least work, courtship signals that a mate chooses by, and parents and offspring, as when parents feed the young that beg.

The detail

  • Fitness is how many surviving offspring an individual leaves, compared with others in its population.
  • A behavior can only be favored if it is at least partly inherited. Its alleles spread because the individuals carrying them leave more offspring.
  • Selection does not need the animal to know any of this. A crow does not work out the best height; crows that happened to drop from near it got more food for less work, and left more young.

Examples to reason with

  • Foraging: northwestern crows on the Pacific coast of Canada fly up and drop whelks (sea snails) onto rocks to break them. The crows were studied in the 1970s; the figure uses their case.
  • Courtship: in many birds, females choose males by a display or a long tail. A male with a costly signal can still leave the most offspring, if the extra mates outweigh the extra risk.
  • Parents and offspring: chicks beg by calling and gaping, and parents feed the chicks that beg hardest. Feeding young costs the parents, but young that survive carry their alleles.
  • Foraging by bees: a honeybee that dances for a rich patch sends her nestmates to it, so the colony gathers more food for each trip.

Try it

  • The guppy bench in the Unit 7 guide on natural selection runs a case where bright colors win mates and cost lives: change the predators and watch the colors change over generations.

A crow standing on a beach with a whelk has a choice to make, whether or not it thinks of it that way. A whelk is food inside a hard shell. The crow flies up and drops it onto the rocks, picks it up and tries again until the shell breaks. Each climb costs energy. Drop from too low and the shell takes many drops; climb much higher and each drop costs more than it saves.

That is the pattern of every behavior. It costs energy, time and risk, and it pays in food, safety or mates. Individuals whose behavior pays best for what it costs survive better and leave more offspring, and if the behavior is inherited, it spreads. That is natural selection acting on behavior. The figure starts with the number of drops a shell needs at each height. Make your prediction before you step on.

A crow can drop a whelk from 2 m (where it may take about 20 drops to break), from 5 m, or from 15 m (where it may break in about 3). Each climb costs energy. Which height should selection favor?

The same reasoning works for courtship. A long tail or a loud song costs the male energy and makes him easier for a predator to find. It persists because females choose by it, so males with the signal leave more offspring than males without. And it works for parents: feeding chicks is costly, but chicks that survive carry the parents' alleles. Step through the mate choice figure and find the cost.

  • Behavior has a cost and a payoff. Selection favors the behavior that pays best for what it costs.
  • Differential reproductive success: individuals whose behavior pays best leave more offspring.
  • Foraging, courtship and parental care are all shaped this way.
Watch out Animals do not choose a behavior because it is best for them, and selection does not plan ahead. Behaviors that happened to pay better left more offspring, generation after generation.
05101520250246810121416Drops needed to break a whelkDrop height (m)010203040500246810121416Height climbed per whelk (m)Drop height (m)least climbingthe crows' mean drop height
  1. The number of drops a whelk needs before it breaks, at each drop height. Higher drops break it sooner, but the gain flattens out. Make the prediction before you step on.
  2. Multiply each height by its drops: the total height climbed per whelk. It is least near 5 m, close to where the crows dropped from. The numbers show the pattern and are rounded, not the study's own.
males differ in plume lengthfemaleyoung sirednonehis young inherit his alleles for a long plumeshe chooses the longest plumebut a long plumehas a costextra youngextra riska hawk seeshim sooner
  1. Four males of one species, with plumes of different lengths.
  2. A female looks them over, and chooses the longest plume.
  3. The male she chooses sires the most young, and they inherit his alleles for a long plume.
  4. But a long plume has a cost: it spreads only while the extra young outweigh the extra risk.

8.1.B Cooperative behavior

Why help each other?

  • Cooperative behavior: hunting as a pack; moving as a herd, flock or school; living as a colony; warning others of a predator.
  • Cooperation tends to raise the fitness of the individual and the survival of the population.
  • A warning call puts the caller at risk. Which callers gain from it explains why it persists.

The detail

  • A wolf in a pack can bring down prey far bigger than one wolf could, and shares the meat.
  • A fish in a school, a bird in a flock or a zebra in a herd is less likely to be the one taken when a predator strikes, and many eyes spot the predator sooner.
  • In a honeybee or ant colony most workers never reproduce. They raise the offspring of their mother, the queen, who is their close relative.
  • Cooperation is not always free: a pack shares the kill, and a large school is easier to find. It is favored where the gain to each member outweighs the cost.

An example to reason with: alarm calls

  • Belding's ground squirrels live in colonies in the mountain meadows of the western United States. Daughters stay near where they were born, so a female's neighbors are often her mother, sisters and daughters; young males move away.
  • They were watched for four summers in the 1970s, through 102 encounters with predators such as coyotes, badgers and weasels.

The zebras at a water hole drink while one stands apart and watches. Wolves hunt together and share the kill. A school of small fish turns as one. Cooperative behavior like this is everywhere, and it usually pays each member: more food than it could catch alone, a smaller chance of being the one taken, an earlier warning. Because each member gains, cooperation tends to raise the fitness of the individual, and with it the survival of the population.

Competition happens inside a species too, and it is not the opposite of cooperation. The same seedlings that compete for light can share a pollinator; the penguins in the figure huddle together through the winter and still compete for food. Switch between the two.

Some cooperation is harder to explain. An alarm call warns others but draws the predator's eye to the caller. How could a behavior that puts the caller at risk be favored? The answer lies in who hears it.

A ground squirrel that gives an alarm call when a predator appears is more likely to be chased than one that keeps quiet. Which squirrels would you expect to call most often?

Helping relatives at a cost to yourself can be favored because relatives carry many of the same alleles: kin selection, one example of how cooperation can spread. The figure shows the squirrels' pattern. It is the pattern expected if calls protect relatives; another reading, that mothers call to protect their own young, has also been argued, and either way the callers' alleles gain.

  • Pack, herd, flock, school, colony, warning call: cooperation tends to raise individual fitness and population survival.
  • A costly warning is favored when it saves relatives, who carry the caller's alleles (kin selection).
  • Behaviors are not kept "for the good of the species".
Watch out A behavior that helps others is not favored because it helps the population. Selection keeps it when the individuals doing it, or their relatives, leave more offspring than those that do not.
lightshadewatermineralsseedlings of one species compete for light, waterand minerals: the tallest shade the resticy windtake turnson the outsideemperor penguins huddle through the polar winter,sharing warmth: cooperation within a species
Within one species. Switch between seedlings competing for light, water and minerals, and penguins sharing warmth in a huddle, taking turns on the cold outside.
more callsadult females,close relativesnearbyadult females,no closerelatives nearbyadult malesobservedexpected by chanceThe pattern in Sherman's data, not his values
Belding's ground squirrels: how often each group called when a predator came, against how often it would if every squirrel present were equally likely to call. Write the claim the bars support, with one piece of evidence.

02Dry lab: Pill bugs in a choice chamber

Plan a test, set the two sides of a choice chamber, release pill bugs at the join and count where they end up. Then test the counts with chi-square, and follow one animal to see how it got there.

DAMPDRY0:00DAMPDRY10:006 here4 hereFour trials of ten, pooledDamp sideDry sideTotalObserved (O)291140Expected (E)202040(O − E)² ÷ E4.054.05χ² = 8.101 degree of freedom: critical value 3.84 at p = 0.05.8.10 is above 3.84: reject the null hypothesis.
  1. The chamber set damp on the left and dry on the right, ten pill bugs released at the join.
  2. After ten minutes of bench time: the counts on each side, and the path of the one tracked animal.
  3. Four trials of ten fresh animals, pooled and tested against equal numbers on each side with chi-square.
Your questionDo pill bugs gather on one side of a chamber when the two sides differ in moisture, light, temperature or a chemical? Write your plan first: the independent variable, the dependent variable, two things you hold constant and the null hypothesis.
What you can changeOne factor at a time for each side: damp or dry filter paper, lit or covered, cool or room temperature, water or dilute vinegar on the paper. Ten or twenty pill bugs, released at the join. A run with both sides the same is your control. Each trial uses fresh animals.
What to recordThe number on each side after ten minutes of bench time, for every trial; then the pooled counts and your chi-square value. For one tracked animal, its speed and the number of turns it made on each side. The animals and their numbers are simulated: a model with a real pattern, not data from real pill bugs.

Find out

  • Plan first. Before the first run, write the independent variable, the dependent variable, two things you will hold constant and the null hypothesis.
  • The control. Run the chamber with both sides the same. Are the counts close to equal?
  • Moisture. Damp paper on one side, dry on the other. Four trials of ten fresh pill bugs, released at the join. Pool the counts.
  • Chi-square. Test the pooled counts against equal numbers on each side, with 1 degree of freedom and the critical value 3.84 at p = 0.05. Reject, or fail to reject, the null hypothesis.
  • How did they get there? Follow one tracked animal. Compare its speed and its turns per minute on each side. Is it taxis or kinesis?
  • Another factor. Try light, temperature or the vinegar. Does any of them give a track that points?

Record

  • For each trial: the settings, and the number on each side after ten minutes. The table fills as you run.
  • The pooled observed counts, the expected counts, each (O − E)² ÷ E, and the chi-square value.
  • For the tracked animal: its speed and its turns per minute on each side.
  • The graph of how many are on each side minute by minute shows them settling. Use it to describe the run, and only the final counts of fresh animals for the test.
  • Download the CSV to keep your table. The pill bugs are simulated: a model with a real pattern, not data from real animals.
A worked example: four trials of ten fresh pill bugs, pooled
Damp sideDry sideTotal
Observed (O)291140
Expected (E)202040
(O − E)² ÷ E81 ÷ 20 = 4.0581 ÷ 20 = 4.05χ² = 8.10

In the worked example chi-square is 8.10, with 1 degree of freedom, and the critical value at p = 0.05 is 3.84. What can you conclude?

The control run, both sides damp, gives 23 and 17 pill bugs. Chi-square is (3² ÷ 20) + (3² ÷ 20) = 0.90. What does the control tell you?

A student counts the same ten pill bugs every minute for ten minutes and adds the ten counts: 72 on the damp side and 28 on the dry. Why should they not run a chi-square test on 72 and 28?

In one data set, 34 of 40 pill bugs ended on the damp side. The notes show they were all put down on the damp side, not at the join. Why can the result not be trusted?

Claim and evidence

Make a claim about how pill bugs respond to moisture. Support it with your pooled counts and your chi-square result, then use your tracked animal to say whether the response is taxis or kinesis.

03Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in. It opens on biologybybradford.com, so it needs the internet.

Exam practice

Exam questions on 8.1, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

04Downloads

This file is the guide, saved to run without the internet.

Saved from biologybybradford.com/guides/ap-biology-unit-8-responses-to-the-environment, where the guide is kept up to date with the notes, the revision sheet and, for the teacher, the lesson plans and slides.

05Teacher resources

The guide as four one-hour lessons: what each covers, its focus and the chapters it uses.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1A response to a change; plants 8.1.A60 min Stimulus and response, behavioral and physiological responses to internal and external changes, phototropism and photoperiodism as responses, and the night-break experiments as experimental design 1, 2
2Testing a response 8.1.A60 min Taxis and kinesis, nocturnal and diurnal activity, and designing, running and testing a choice chamber experiment with chi-square 3, dry lab
3Information, signals, innate and learned 8.1.A, 8.1.B60 min Internal changes and fight or flight, information passed between organisms, the five kinds of signal and their uses, and designing an experiment to separate innate from learned behavior 4, 5, 6
4Behavior and fitness; cooperation 8.1.B60 min Costs and payoffs of behavior and differential reproductive success in foraging, courtship and parental care, and cooperative behavior, kin selection and the fitness of the individual and the population 7, 8

The revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTICE AND REVIEW

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for Unit 8

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.