IB BIOLOGY · THEME D · CONTINUITY AND CHANGE

What keeps an ecosystem going

The Daintree rainforest has grown in the same place for over a hundred million years. Here is what lets an ecosystem last that long, what people do that can tip it over, and how a community rebuilds itself on bare rock.

IB Biology D4.2SL and HL4 hours SL, 6 HL15 chapters11 chapters at SLdry lab

Start learningRun the dry labTeach it

The Amazon recycles its own rain from the coast to the far west. Watch what keeps it stable, then what happens downwind when a stretch of it is cleared.
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Fifteen chapters: what makes an ecosystem stable (chapters 1 to 5), how people harvest, farm and pollute it (6 to 10), how it can be restored (11), and at higher level how communities change over time (12 to 15). Read one, play its figure through or tap its parts, and make each prediction before you open the answer.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1Some ecosystems last for millions of years
  2. 2Four things a stable ecosystem needs
  3. 3The forest that makes its own rain
  4. 4An ecosystem in a bottle
  5. 5Pull out one stone and the arch falls
  6. 6Take no more than grows back
  7. 7Can a farm keep going for ever?
  8. 8Too much of a good thing
  9. 9A pesticide that climbs the food chain
  10. 10Plastic that never goes away
  11. 11Let the land heal itself
  12. 12Communities that change in order HL
  13. 13From bare rock to forest HL
  14. 14A succession that goes round in a circle HL
  15. 15Where succession stops HL

D4.2.1 Stability as a property of natural ecosystems

Some ecosystems last for millions of years

  • Ecosystem stability: the same community, with the same processes running, over a very long time.
  • Some ecosystems have lasted millions of years: the Daintree rainforest for well over a hundred million, the Namib Desert for at least 55 million.
  • Evidence for long-term stability: fossils such as pollen, the age of the landforms, and ancient lineages still living there.
  • Stable does not mean unchanging: populations rise and fall, but the system stays within limits and recovers.

The detail

  • The Daintree grows down to the sea in the far north of Queensland, Australia. Rainforest has grown there without a break since Australia was part of the supercontinent Gondwana.
  • Many of the Daintree’s plants belong to lineages that are almost gone everywhere else.
  • The Namib, in southwest Africa across the Indian Ocean, is the oldest desert on Earth. Its animals and plants have had all that time to adapt to almost no rain.

Examples

  • Idiot fruit tree (Idiospermum australiense): among the oldest surviving groups of flowering plants. It was thought to be extinct until it was found in the Daintree again in the 1970s.
  • Fog-basking beetle (Onymacris unguicularis): stands head down on a dune at dawn so that fog condenses on its back and runs to its mouth.
  • Welwitschia mirabilis: a plant with just two leaves that grow for its whole life. It can live for more than a thousand years.

How we know

  • Fossil pollen in sediments shows which plants grew there.
  • The ages of the rocks and dunes.
  • The DNA of living species shows how long their lineages have been separate.

In the far north of Queensland, Australia, the Daintree rainforest grows down to the sea. Its trees stand where rainforest has grown, without a break, for well over a hundred million years, since Australia was part of the supercontinent Gondwana. Many of its plants belong to lineages that are almost gone everywhere else. One, the idiot fruit tree (Idiospermum australiense), is among the oldest surviving groups of flowering plants, and it was thought to be extinct until it was found there again in the 1970s.

Across the Indian Ocean, the Namib Desert in southwest Africa has been dry for at least 55 million years, which makes it the oldest desert on Earth. Its animals and plants have had all that time to adapt to almost no rain. A fog-basking beetle (Onymacris unguicularis) stands head down on a dune at dawn so that fog condenses on its back and runs to its mouth. Welwitschia mirabilis, a plant with just two leaves that grow for its whole life, can live for more than a thousand years.

Both are examples of ecosystem stability: the same community, with the same processes running, over a very long time. The evidence comes from fossils (fossil pollen in sediments shows which plants grew there), from the ages of the rocks and dunes, and from the DNA of living species, which shows how long their lineages have been separate.

Why are very old, stable ecosystems such as the Daintree so rich in species found nowhere else?

  • A stable ecosystem keeps the same community and the same processes over long periods.
  • Evidence for long-term stability: fossils such as pollen, the age of the landforms, and ancient lineages still living there.
  • Stable does not mean unchanging: populations rise and fall, but the system stays within limits and recovers.
Daintree rainforestNamib Desertcorefog from the sea

Tap a part to read about it. Not to scale.

D4.2.2 Requirements for stability in ecosystems

Four things a stable ecosystem needs

  • A stable ecosystem needs four things, and one that loses any of them starts to change.
  • A supply of energy: energy is lost as heat at every step, so it must be supplied all the time, almost always as sunlight captured by producers in photosynthesis.
  • Recycling of nutrients: the same carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus atoms go round and round, released from dead matter by saprotrophs and other decomposers.
  • Genetic diversity: variation that natural selection can act on, so a population can adapt when conditions shift.
  • Climatic variables within tolerance: temperature and rainfall staying inside the ranges the species can survive.

The detail

  • The Daintree and the Namib had all four, and that let them carry on for so long.
  • Energy flows through an ecosystem. Unlike energy, matter is not supplied from outside.
  • Decomposers break down dead matter and release the nutrients for producers to take up again.
  • A population of near-identical individuals can be wiped out by one new disease.
  • If the climate stays inside the species’ ranges, the community stays; if it moves outside them, species die out or leave.

In the exam

  • List all four: a continuous supply of energy, usually sunlight, for producers; recycling of nutrients by decomposers (saprotrophs); genetic diversity, so populations can adapt to change; climatic variables (temperature, rainfall) staying within the tolerance of the species.

What did the Daintree and the Namib have that let them carry on for so long? Four things, and an ecosystem that loses any of them starts to change.

A supply of energy. Energy flows through an ecosystem and is lost as heat at every step, so it has to be supplied all the time. Almost always it arrives as sunlight, captured by producers in photosynthesis.

The recycling of nutrients. Unlike energy, matter is not supplied from outside: the same carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus atoms go round and round. Saprotrophs and other decomposers break down dead matter and release the nutrients for producers to take up again.

Genetic diversity. A population whose members differ has the variation that natural selection can act on, so it can adapt when conditions shift. A population of near-identical individuals can be wiped out by one new disease.

Climatic variables within tolerance. Every species has a range of temperature and rainfall it can survive. If the climate stays inside those ranges, the community stays; if it moves outside them, species die out or leave.

Remember it The four requirements for stability

  • EveryEnergya constant supply, almost always sunlight
  • NestNutrientsrecycled by decomposers
  • GetsGenetic diversityvariation, so populations can adapt
  • CareClimatetemperature and rainfall within tolerance

A forest is cut and the logs are taken away every 30 years. Which requirement for stability does this put at risk most directly?

In the exam Requirements for ecosystem stability:
  1. A continuous supply of energy, usually sunlight, for producers.
  2. Recycling of nutrients by decomposers (saprotrophs).
  3. Genetic diversity, so populations can adapt to change.
  4. Climatic variables (temperature, rainfall) staying within the tolerance of the species.
light energyheat lostdecomposersrelease mineralsroots takethem upgeneticdiversityclimatewithinrange
  1. Energy. Sunlight is captured by the producers. Energy is lost as heat at every step, so it must be supplied all the time.
  2. Nutrients. Decomposers break down dead leaves and bodies and release minerals, which roots take up again. Matter is recycled.
  3. Genetic diversity. Members of each population differ, so some can survive a new disease or a change in conditions, and the population can adapt.
  4. Climate. Temperature and rainfall stay within the range the species can tolerate. Every Nest Gets Care.

D4.2.3 Deforestation of Amazon rainforest as an example of a possible tipping point in ecosystem stability

The forest that makes its own rain

  • Amazon trees release most of the water they take up as water vapour by transpiration. It condenses and falls as rain further west, recycled several times as the air crosses the continent.
  • Transpiration also cools the land, and the moist air flows on as flying rivers, bringing rain across South America.
  • Deforestation cuts transpiration, so less rain falls downwind, dry seasons lengthen, and the remaining trees are stressed and burn more easily.
  • Below some minimum area the forest cannot make enough rain to sustain itself and could die back into dry savanna: a tipping point. That area is uncertain: estimates range from about 20% to 40% loss.
  • Assess deforestation as a percentage change from the original area: (new value − original value) ÷ original value × 100.

The detail

  • Moist air blows in from the Atlantic over the Amazon basin and drops rain on the forest. The trees take the water up through their roots.
  • The vapour rises, cools and condenses into clouds before it falls as rain.
  • A large tree can move hundreds of litres a day. The forest as a whole puts billions of tonnes of water vapour into the air each day.
  • Evaporating that water takes heat from the leaves: that is the cooling.
  • Brazilian scientists call the moist air streams flying rivers. When the Andes block them, they turn south and bring rain to the farms and cities of southern Brazil, Paraguay and Argentina.
  • Pasture and soy fields transpire far less than forest.
  • Past the tipping point the forest would die back even where no one cuts it.

Calculating percentage change

  • Compare the area of forest now with the original area.
  • Example: a region had 4.0 million km² of forest and now has 3.3 million km².
  • (3.3 − 4.0) ÷ 4.0 × 100 = −0.7 ÷ 4.0 × 100 = −17.5%.
  • The minus sign shows a decrease: 17.5% of the original forest has gone.

In the exam

  • Explain the chain in order: trees transpire large volumes of water vapour, which falls as rain further inland; transpiration cools the land and the flying rivers carry rain across South America; deforestation cuts transpiration, so rainfall falls and dry seasons lengthen.

Moist air blows in from the Atlantic over the Amazon basin and drops rain on the forest. The trees take the water up through their roots and release most of it again as water vapour by transpiration. The vapour rises, cools, condenses into clouds and falls as rain further west. The same water is recycled like this several times as the air crosses the continent, and a large tree can move hundreds of litres a day.

The forest as a whole puts billions of tonnes of water vapour into the air each day. Evaporating that water takes heat from the leaves, so transpiration also cools the land. The moist air flows on in streams that Brazilian scientists call flying rivers. When the Andes block them, they turn south and bring rain to the farms and cities of southern Brazil, Paraguay and Argentina.

Clear the forest and the chain breaks. Pasture and soy fields transpire far less, so less rain falls downwind, the dry season grows longer, and the remaining trees are stressed and burn more easily. If enough forest is lost, the rest may be unable to make enough rain to keep itself going. It would then die back into dry savanna, even where no one cuts it. That threshold is a tipping point.

Nobody knows exactly how much forest the Amazon can lose before it tips. Why is this so hard to find out?

Percentage change To measure deforestation, compare the area of forest now with the original area.
  1. Percentage change = (new value − original value) ÷ original value × 100.
  2. Example: a region had 4.0 million km² of forest and now has 3.3 million km².
  3. (3.3 − 4.0) ÷ 4.0 × 100 = −0.7 ÷ 4.0 × 100 = −17.5%.
  4. The minus sign shows a decrease: 17.5% of the original forest has gone.

A state had 1 250 000 km² of rainforest in 1970 and 1 000 000 km² in 2020. What is the percentage change in forest area?

In the exam Why the Amazon may have a tipping point:
  1. Trees transpire large volumes of water vapour, which falls as rain further inland.
  2. Transpiration cools the land, and the moist air flows (flying rivers) bring rain across South America.
  3. Deforestation cuts transpiration, so rainfall falls and dry seasons lengthen.
  4. Below some minimum area the forest cannot make enough rain to sustain itself, and could turn to savanna.
  5. That minimum area is uncertain: estimates range from about 20% to 40% loss.
AndesAtlanticcleared for pasturemoist airtranspirationrainflying river turns southless rain, longer dry season
  1. Moist air blows in from the Atlantic and forms clouds over the coast.
  2. Rain falls on the forest. Trees take up the water and release it again by transpiration, and new clouds form further west.
  3. The water is recycled several times across the continent. Blocked by the Andes, the moist air flows south as a flying river, bringing rain to southern Brazil.
  4. Clear a large area and transpiration there stops. Less rain falls downwind, the dry season lengthens and the remaining forest dries out and burns.
possible tipping pointsomewhere in here?0102030405060050100forest lost (%)rain recycled (% of today)earlier modelswith warmingand firelost so far:about a fifth

Two kinds of model, drawn to show the shape of their predictions, not real data. Where the curve drops, the forest can no longer make enough rain to sustain itself.

D4.2.4 Use of a model to investigate the effect of variables on ecosystem stability

An ecosystem in a bottle

  • A mesocosm is a model ecosystem that can be controlled and repeated, used to investigate the effect of variables on stability.
  • A sealed glass vessel is a better model than an open tank: no matter can enter or leave, so every nutrient has to be recycled inside.
  • Energy still crosses the glass, in as light and out as heat. A sealed vessel is a closed system.
  • Aquatic and microbial mesocosms tend to work better than terrestrial ones.
  • Live animals are cared for under the IB’s guidelines: use as few as possible and check them every day.

The detail

  • Mesocosms can be open tanks.
  • A jar of pond water with pondweed, a few snails and the microbes in some pond mud can stay balanced for months.
  • In the jar the pondweed makes oxygen and food, the snails eat and respire, and the microbes break down wastes and return the minerals.

Examples

  • In 1960 David Latimer, in Surrey, England, planted a spiderwort seedling in compost in a large glass bottle. He last added water in 1972 and then sealed it with a cork.
  • The plant has filled the bottle ever since. Light passes through the glass, the plant photosynthesizes, water evaporates and condenses on the inside of the bottle, and microbes in the compost recycle the fallen leaves.

Try it

  • The lab on this page lets you run the experiment as many times as you like with no snails harmed.

Watch out

  • Take animals out and return them to a pond if they show signs of stress.

In 1960, David Latimer in Surrey, England, planted a spiderwort seedling in compost in a large glass bottle. He last added water in 1972 and then sealed it with a cork. The plant has filled the bottle ever since. Light passes through the glass, the plant photosynthesizes, water evaporates and condenses on the inside of the bottle, and microbes in the compost recycle the fallen leaves.

A bottle like this is a mesocosm, a model ecosystem that can be controlled and repeated. Mesocosms can be open tanks, but a sealed glass vessel is the better model for stability: no matter can enter or leave, so every nutrient has to be recycled inside, while energy still crosses the glass, in as light and out as heat. A sealed vessel is a closed system.

Aquatic and microbial mesocosms tend to work better than terrestrial ones. A jar of pond water with pondweed, a few snails and the microbes in some pond mud can stay balanced for months: the pondweed makes oxygen and food, the snails eat and respire, and the microbes break down wastes and return the minerals.

A mesocosm is better becauseA mesocosm is worse because
its variables can be controlled and changed one at a timeit leaves out much of a real ecosystem, so the results may not apply outside
it can be replicated, with several identical jarsit cannot hold large animals, and long food chains are missing
it is small, cheap and easy to monitorsealing animals in raises ethical concerns, so their welfare must be checked

A student seals four jars with pondweed and snails and keeps one in the dark. Which jar would you expect the snails to die in first, and why?

Care of the animals An investigation with live animals follows the IB's guidelines: use as few as possible, check them every day, and take them out and return them to a pond if they show signs of stress. The lab on this page lets you run the experiment as many times as you like with no snails harmed.
light inpondweedmud andmicrobessealed lidheat outsnails

Tap a part of the jar to read what it does. Not to scale.

D4.2.5 Role of keystone species in the stability of ecosystems

Pull out one stone and the arch falls

  • A keystone species has a disproportionate effect on community structure: far bigger than its numbers would suggest.
  • Remove it and the community can collapse into a simpler one, and diversity falls.
  • Keystones work in different ways: predators that keep a dominant prey in check, ecosystem engineers that change the habitat, and mutualists that many other species depend on.
  • Sea otters eat sea urchins, which graze kelp. Remove the otters and the urchins multiply and destroy the kelp forest and the species that depend on it.

The detail

  • A keystone species is often not common.
  • The name comes from the wedge-shaped stone at the top of an arch, which holds the others in place.

Examples

  • Sea otters (Enhydra lutris) along the Pacific coast of North America were hunted for their fur until fewer than two thousand were left, by 1911.
  • Without otters to eat them, sea urchins grazed the giant kelp down to bare rock, leaving an urchin barren. The fish, crabs and seals that lived in the kelp forest went too.
  • Where otters were protected and came back, the urchins were eaten, the kelp grew back, and so did the forest’s community.

How we know

  • In 1963 the ecologist Robert Paine began prising purple sea stars (Pisaster ochraceus) off the rocks of one stretch of shore in Washington State and throwing them back into the sea.
  • Within a few years mussels, which the sea stars had been eating, had spread over the rock and crowded out almost everything else. The number of species on the rock fell from fifteen to eight.
  • Paine called the sea star a keystone species.

In 1963 the ecologist Robert Paine began prising purple sea stars (Pisaster ochraceus) off the rocks of one stretch of shore in Washington State and throwing them back into the sea. Within a few years, mussels, which the sea stars had been eating, had spread over the rock and crowded out almost everything else. The number of species on the rock fell from fifteen to eight. Paine called the sea star a keystone species, after the wedge-shaped stone at the top of an arch, which holds the others in place.

A keystone species is often not common. What matters is that its effect is disproportionate: far bigger than its numbers would suggest. Remove it and the community can collapse into a simpler one. Keystones work in different ways. Some are predators that keep a dominant prey in check, some are ecosystem engineers that change the habitat, and some are mutualists that many other species depend on.

Sea otters (Enhydra lutris) along the Pacific coast of North America were hunted for their fur until fewer than two thousand were left, by 1911. Without otters to eat them, sea urchins multiplied and grazed the giant kelp down to bare rock, leaving an urchin barren. The fish, crabs and seals that lived in the kelp forest went too. Where otters were protected and came back, the urchins were eaten, the kelp grew back, and so did the forest's community.

A seaweed is the most common organism in a rock pool. Removing it changes little. Removing a rare whelk, a predator, changes almost everything. Which is the keystone species?

In the exam Keystone species:
  1. Have a disproportionately large effect on community structure, relative to their abundance.
  2. For example, sea otters eat sea urchins, which graze kelp.
  3. Removing otters lets urchins multiply and destroy the kelp forest.
  4. The many species that depend on the kelp are lost, so diversity falls and the ecosystem can collapse.
keystonePurple sea starpredator: eats musselsBeaverengineer: builds damsBeesmutualists: pollinators

Tap the keystone or a card. A keystone species can be a predator, an engineer or a mutualist.

Follow a kelp forest over 40 years. Change how many otters there are and watch the urchins and the kelp answer.

D4.2.6 Assessing sustainability of resource harvesting from natural ecosystems

Take no more than grows back

  • Fish, timber and wild nuts are renewable resources: the population that provides them reproduces and grows.
  • Harvesting is sustainable when the rate of harvesting is lower than the rate of replacement (reproduction and growth).
  • Assess it by monitoring population size, age structure and catch per unit effort.
  • A plant on land: Brazil nuts gathered from wild trees. A fish in the sea: Atlantic cod on the Grand Banks, overharvested until the stock collapsed in 1992.

The detail

  • Take more than the rate of replacement and the population shrinks every year, and the harvest shrinks with it.
  • A population grows fastest at middle densities: a small one has few parents, and a crowded one is held back by competition.
  • The maximum sustainable yield (MSY) is the largest catch that can be taken every year without the population falling. It is taken by keeping the population at about half its carrying capacity.

The Brazil nut

  • Brazil nuts (Bertholletia excelsa) are not farmed. They are gathered from wild trees in the Amazon.
  • The trees need large orchid bees to pollinate their flowers, so they set few nuts in plantations.
  • They also need agoutis to bury the seeds, some of which the agoutis forget and which then sprout.
  • Gathering takes seeds that would have become the next trees.
  • Ecologists assess it by counting the young trees at many sites. Where people had gathered nuts heavily for decades there were very few juveniles, so the stand was ageing with nothing to replace it.
  • Where gathering was light, young trees were common.

The Atlantic cod

  • For centuries the cod (Gadus morhua) of the Grand Banks off Newfoundland seemed endless.
  • From the 1960s large factory trawlers took catches far above the replacement rate. Catches peaked in 1968, then fell.
  • In 1992 the stock had collapsed to around 1% of its former size. Canada banned the fishing, and about 35 000 people lost their work.
  • Three decades on, the stock has recovered only in part.

In the exam

  • Set quotas at or below the maximum sustainable yield, with closed seasons, minimum sizes or protected areas.

Fish, timber and wild nuts are renewable resources: the population that provides them reproduces and grows. Harvesting is sustainable when the rate of harvesting is lower than the rate of replacement. Take more than that and the population shrinks every year, and the harvest shrinks with it.

A population grows fastest at middle densities: a small one has few parents, and a crowded one is held back by competition. The largest catch that can be taken every year without the population falling is the maximum sustainable yield (MSY). It is taken by keeping the population at about half its carrying capacity.

A plant on land: the Brazil nut. Brazil nuts (Bertholletia excelsa) are not farmed. They are gathered from wild trees in the Amazon. The trees need large orchid bees to pollinate their flowers, so they set few nuts in plantations, and agoutis to bury the seeds, some of which they forget and which then sprout. Gathering takes seeds that would have become the next trees. Ecologists assess it by counting the young trees at many sites: where people had gathered nuts heavily for decades, there were very few juveniles, so the stand was ageing with nothing to replace it. Where gathering was light, young trees were common.

A fish in the sea: the Atlantic cod. For centuries the cod (Gadus morhua) of the Grand Banks off Newfoundland seemed endless. From the 1960s, large factory trawlers took catches far above the replacement rate. Catches peaked in 1968, then fell, and in 1992 the stock had collapsed to around 1% of its former size. Canada banned the fishing, and about 35 000 people lost their work. Three decades on, the stock has recovered only in part.

How harvesting is assessedWhat it shows
Surveys of population size, such as research trawls or counts of treeswhether the stock is rising or falling year on year
Age or size structure, such as the share of young trees or of mature fishwhether enough young are joining the population to replace what is taken
Catch per unit effort, the catch for each day at seaa falling catch for the same effort warns that the stock is shrinking

Fishing boats keep catching the same tonnage of cod each year, but they need more and more days at sea to do it, and the fish landed are smaller. What does this suggest?

In the exam Sustainable harvesting:
  1. The rate of harvesting must be lower than the rate of replacement (reproduction and growth).
  2. Assess it by monitoring population size, age structure and catch per unit effort.
  3. Set quotas at or below the maximum sustainable yield, with closed seasons, minimum sizes or protected areas.
  4. Atlantic cod on the Grand Banks were overharvested and collapsed in 1992.
time (years)population sizecarrying capacityslowfastslowpopulation sizegrowth per yearKhalf of Kmaximum sustainable yieldcatch too high: collapsecatch below growth:sustainable
  1. A population grows in an S curve, levelling off at the carrying capacity (K) set by food and space.
  2. It grows fastest at middle sizes: a small population has few parents, and a crowded one is held back by competition.
  3. The most that can be taken every year, for ever, is the growth at the peak: the maximum sustainable yield, with the population kept at about half of K.
  4. Take more than the population can replace and it shrinks every year until it collapses. Take less than its growth and it can be harvested indefinitely.
Run a cod fishery for 40 years. Set the catch each year and find the most you can take without the stock collapsing.

D4.2.7 Factors affecting the sustainability of agriculture

Can a farm keep going for ever?

  • A farm is an ecosystem people have simplified. Whether it can go on producing food for centuries depends on five factors.
  • Soil erosion: bare, ploughed soil is washed off by rain and blown off by wind, and the fertile topsoil goes first.
  • Leaching of nutrients: nitrates and phosphates dissolved in soil water drain down past the roots and into streams.
  • Supply of fertilizers and other inputs, since every harvest removes minerals, and pollution by agrochemicals such as pesticides and herbicides.
  • Carbon footprint: the total greenhouse gas released to produce the farm’s food.

The detail

  • A farm is one crop, cleared of its competitors, harvested and carried away every year.
  • It can take centuries to form a few centimetres of soil.
  • With leaching the farm loses fertility and the rivers gain it (chapter 8).
  • Industrial nitrogen fertilizer is made with large amounts of fossil fuel, and phosphate is mined from rock that will run out.
  • Agrochemicals can kill species other than the targets, such as pollinators and the predators of pests, and some persist and build up in food chains (chapter 9).
  • Farm machinery burns diesel, fertilizer factories burn gas, ploughing releases carbon from the soil, and cattle and flooded rice fields release methane. Food that is flown across the world adds more.

What reduces each factor

  • Erosion: keeping the ground covered, ploughing along the contours of a slope, planting hedges as windbreaks, and not ploughing at all (no-till farming).
  • Leaching: adding fertilizer little and often, when the crop is growing, and keeping a cover crop in winter.
  • Inputs: growing legumes, whose root nodules hold nitrogen-fixing bacteria, and spreading manure and compost.
  • Pollution: integrated pest management uses agrochemicals only when needed.

A farm is an ecosystem that people have simplified: one crop, cleared of its competitors, harvested and carried away every year. Whether it can go on producing food for centuries depends on five things.

Soil erosion. Bare, ploughed soil is washed off by rain and blown off by wind, and the fertile topsoil goes first. It can take centuries to form a few centimetres of soil. Keeping the ground covered, ploughing along the contours of a slope, planting hedges as windbreaks and not ploughing at all (no-till farming) all reduce erosion.

Leaching of nutrients. Nitrates and phosphates dissolved in soil water drain down past the roots and into streams. The farm loses fertility and the rivers gain it (chapter 8). Adding fertilizer little and often, when the crop is growing, and keeping a cover crop in winter both cut leaching.

Supply of fertilizers and other inputs. Every harvest removes minerals, which must be replaced. Industrial nitrogen fertilizer is made with large amounts of fossil fuel, and phosphate is mined from rock that will run out. Growing legumes, whose root nodules hold nitrogen-fixing bacteria, and spreading manure and compost reduce the need for them.

Pollution by agrochemicals. Pesticides and herbicides can kill species other than the targets, such as pollinators and the predators of pests, and some persist and build up in food chains (chapter 9). Integrated pest management uses them only when needed.

Carbon footprint. Farm machinery burns diesel, fertilizer factories burn gas, ploughing releases carbon from the soil, and cattle and flooded rice fields release methane. Food that is flown across the world adds more. The carbon footprint of a farm is the total greenhouse gas released to produce its food.

A farmer grows clover in a field for one year in four, then ploughs it in before planting wheat. Which problem does this mainly reduce?

Remember it Five factors for sustainable farming

  • EveryErosionof the soil by rain and wind
  • LazyLeachingof nutrients out of the soil
  • IvyInputsfertilizers, fuel, water
  • PoisonsPollutionby agrochemicals
  • CropsCarbon footprintgreenhouse gases from farming
streamNPKfertilizerpesticide sprayerosionleachingmethane

Tap each part of the farm to read the problem and a fix.

D4.2.8 Eutrophication of aquatic and marine ecosystems due to leaching

Too much of a good thing

  • Eutrophication is the enrichment of water with nutrients, often nitrate and phosphate fertilizers leached from fields.
  • The nutrients cause an algal bloom that blocks light, so plants below cannot photosynthesize and die.
  • Bacteria decompose the dead plants and algae by aerobic respiration, multiply, and use up the dissolved oxygen.
  • The biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), the decomposers’ demand for oxygen, rises and dissolved oxygen falls.
  • Fish and other aerobic animals suffocate or swim away, and biodiversity falls.

The detail

  • Nitrate and phosphate are the minerals that most often limit the growth of algae in lakes and the sea. Leaching lifts those limits.
  • Manure or sewage reaching a river does the same.
  • The bloom turns the water green. The algae themselves are short-lived and die in huge numbers.
  • Only a few tolerant species are left.

Measuring BOD

  • A sample of water is kept sealed in the dark at 20 °C for five days, and the fall in its dissolved oxygen is measured.
  • Clean water has a low BOD. Water full of dead organic matter has a high BOD, and the higher it is, the faster the oxygen will run out.

In the exam

  • Give the steps in order: leaching, algal bloom, light blocked, plants and algae die, aerobic bacteria multiply and BOD rises, dissolved oxygen falls, fish die.

Nitrate and phosphate are the minerals that most often limit the growth of algae in lakes and the sea. When rain leaches fertilizer from fields, or manure or sewage reaches a river, those limits are lifted. The enrichment of water with nutrients is eutrophication.

Algae multiply into a bloom that turns the water green and stops light reaching the plants on the bottom, so they die. The algae themselves are short-lived and die in huge numbers. Bacteria decompose the dead plants and algae by aerobic respiration, and they multiply too, using up the dissolved oxygen. Fish and other animals that need oxygen suffocate or swim away, and only a few tolerant species are left.

The demand for oxygen from decomposers is measured as the biochemical oxygen demand (BOD). A sample of water is kept sealed in the dark at 20 °C for five days, and the fall in its dissolved oxygen is measured. Clean water has a low BOD. Water full of dead organic matter has a high BOD, and the higher it is, the faster the oxygen will run out.

A river below a farm has a high nitrate level and a high BOD. Why does adding nitrate, which is not organic matter, raise the BOD?

Remember it The steps of eutrophication

  • LittleLeachingnitrate and phosphate wash into water
  • AlgaeAlgal bloomthe algae multiply
  • LoveLight blockedplants below are shaded
  • DirtyDeaththe plants and algae die
  • DarkDecomposersbacteria multiply, BOD rises
  • DitchesDeoxygenationoxygen falls, fish die
In the exam Eutrophication:
  1. Nitrate and phosphate fertilizers leach from fields into rivers and lakes.
  2. The nutrients cause rapid growth of algae (an algal bloom).
  3. The algae block light, so plants below cannot photosynthesize and die.
  4. Dead algae and plants are decomposed by aerobic bacteria, which multiply.
  5. The biochemical oxygen demand rises and dissolved oxygen falls.
  6. Fish and other aerobic animals die, and biodiversity falls.
fieldlight blockedNPNfertilizeralgal bloombacteriaoxygenBOD
  1. Rain leaches nitrate and phosphate from the fertilized field into the lake.
  2. The nutrients were limiting the algae. Now they multiply into an algal bloom at the surface.
  3. The bloom blocks the light, so the plants on the lake bed cannot photosynthesize and die.
  4. The short-lived algae die and sink, adding to the dead plant matter.
  5. Aerobic bacteria decompose the dead matter and multiply. The biochemical oxygen demand (BOD) soars.
  6. Dissolved oxygen falls so low that fish die. Only a few low-oxygen tolerant species remain, and diversity falls.
Spread fertilizer on the field and follow the lake through a summer. Watch the algae, the dissolved oxygen and the BOD.

D4.2.9 Biomagnification of pollutants in natural ecosystems

A pesticide that climbs the food chain

  • DDT is persistent and fat-soluble, and methylmercury binds tightly to proteins, so both are kept in the body faster than they are broken down or excreted.
  • They accumulate in each organism over its life: bioaccumulation.
  • Each consumer eats many prey. Most of the prey’s biomass is used in respiration, but the pollutant stays.
  • So its concentration rises at each trophic level and is highest in top predators: biomagnification.
  • DDT thinned the eggshells of birds of prey; mercury harms the nervous system.

The detail

  • DDT is an insecticide first used widely in the 1940s, against the mosquitoes that carry malaria and the insects that eat crops.
  • It is very stable, and it dissolves in fat rather than water, so whatever an animal takes in stays in its fat for the rest of its life.
  • A small fish eats thousands of plankton in its life and keeps the DDT from all of them. A larger fish eats hundreds of small fish, and a bird of prey eats many large fish.
  • Mercury is released by burning coal and by small-scale gold mining. Bacteria in sediments turn it into methylmercury, which animals absorb and keep.

Examples

  • Thin-shelled eggs cracked when the parents sat on them. Ospreys, peregrine falcons and bald eagles declined steeply.
  • DDT is still sprayed inside houses in some countries against malaria.
  • Large, long-lived predatory fish such as swordfish, sharks and tuna carry the most mercury, so pregnant women are advised to eat little of them.
  • In the 1950s a factory in Minamata, Japan, released mercury into the bay, and thousands of people who ate the local fish were poisoned.

How we know

  • In an estuary on Long Island, New York, studied in the 1960s, the water held 0.00005 parts per million of DDT, and cormorants at the top of the food chain held over 26 ppm, about half a million times more.
  • Rachel Carson described the damage in her book Silent Spring (1962). The public outcry followed, and the United States banned DDT for farm use in 1972. The birds recovered.

DDT is an insecticide first used widely in the 1940s, against the mosquitoes that carry malaria and the insects that eat crops. It is very stable, it is not broken down in the body, and it dissolves in fat rather than water, so it is not excreted. Whatever an animal takes in stays in its fat for the rest of its life. This build-up within one organism is bioaccumulation.

A small fish eats thousands of plankton in its life and keeps the DDT from all of them. A larger fish eats hundreds of small fish, and a bird of prey eats many large fish. At each trophic level the concentration rises, because most of the biomass eaten is used in respiration while the DDT stays. This rise in concentration up a food chain is biomagnification. In an estuary on Long Island, New York, studied in the 1960s, the water held 0.00005 parts per million of DDT, and cormorants at the top of the food chain held over 26 ppm, about half a million times more.

At those levels DDT made birds of prey lay eggs with thin shells, which cracked when the parents sat on them. Ospreys, peregrine falcons and bald eagles declined steeply. Rachel Carson described the damage in her book Silent Spring (1962), the public outcry followed, and the United States banned DDT for farm use in 1972. The birds recovered. DDT is still sprayed inside houses in some countries against malaria.

Mercury biomagnifies in the same way. It is released by burning coal and by small-scale gold mining, and bacteria in sediments turn it into methylmercury, which animals absorb and keep. Large, long-lived predatory fish such as swordfish, sharks and tuna carry the most, so pregnant women are advised to eat little of them. In the 1950s, a factory in Minamata, Japan, released mercury into the bay, and thousands of people who ate the local fish were poisoned.

Why do top predators carry the highest concentration of DDT, even though they eat far less food in total than the plankton do?

In the exam Biomagnification:
  1. The pollutant (DDT, mercury) is persistent and is kept in the body faster than it is broken down or excreted.
  2. It accumulates in each organism over its life (bioaccumulation).
  3. Each consumer eats many prey, and most of the prey's biomass is lost in respiration, but the pollutant stays.
  4. So its concentration rises at each trophic level and is highest in top predators.
  5. DDT thinned eggshells of birds of prey; mercury harms the nervous system.
zooplanktonand algae0.04 ppmsmall fishsilversides0.23 ppmlarger fishneedlefish2.07 ppmcormoranttop predator26.4 ppmwater0.00005 ppmabout 500 000times the water
  1. DDT in the water is barely measurable, but plankton absorb it and keep it in their fat: bioaccumulation.
  2. Each small fish eats many plankton. Most of their biomass is respired, but their DDT stays, so it is more concentrated in the fish.
  3. Larger fish eat many small fish, and the concentration rises again.
  4. The top predator, a cormorant, carries the highest concentration of all.
  5. From water to top predator, about half a million times more concentrated: biomagnification. Values from a Long Island estuary in the 1960s.

D4.2.10 Effects of microplastic and macroplastic pollution of the oceans

Plastic that never goes away

  • Plastics are persistent: no decomposer has the enzymes to digest most of them, so they are not biodegradable.
  • Macroplastic, the debris you can see, causes entanglement and blocked guts, as in turtles, seals and albatross chicks.
  • Microplastic, debris smaller than about 5 mm, is eaten by plankton and filter feeders, and carries toxins up food chains.
  • Clear coverage of research in the media changed public opinion and led to new rules.

The detail

  • Plastic is made to last, and in the sea it does. Sunlight and waves break a bottle into smaller and smaller pieces, but the pieces are still plastic.
  • Almost every piece of plastic ever made is still somewhere on Earth.
  • Macroplastic includes bags, bottles, nets and bottle caps.
  • Sources differ on the cut-off for microplastic.
  • Microplastic includes fragments of larger items, fibres washed out of synthetic clothes, and the pellets that plastic goods are made from.
  • Zooplankton, mussels and small fish eat it, and the toxins that stick to its surface can then pass up food chains.

Examples

  • Seals, whales and turtles drown in lost fishing nets, called ghost nets.
  • A sea turtle takes a floating bag for a jellyfish, and the plastic blocks its gut, so it starves with a full stomach.
  • Midway Atoll, in the middle of the North Pacific, is home to about a million Laysan albatrosses (Phoebastria immutabilis).
  • The parents skim food off the sea surface and carry it back to their chicks, and with it they bring bottle caps, lighters and fragments. The chicks cannot bring it up again.
  • Many chicks die with stomachs packed with plastic, and the plastic stays on the beach after their bodies have rotted away.

Science and the public

  • Photographs of those chicks, and television series such as Blue Planet II in 2017, showed the effects of plastic to millions of people who had never read the research behind them.
  • Public opinion changed quickly, and that drove action: bans on plastic microbeads in cosmetics, charges for plastic bags, and many companies changing their packaging.
  • This shows scientists that clear, vivid information about their findings can change what citizens and governments do.

Plastic is made to last, and in the sea it does. No decomposer has the enzymes to digest most plastics, so they are not biodegradable. Sunlight and waves break a bottle into smaller and smaller pieces, but the pieces are still plastic. Almost every piece of plastic ever made is still somewhere on Earth.

Macroplastic is the debris you can see, such as bags, bottles, nets and bottle caps. Animals get tangled in it, and seals, whales and turtles drown in lost fishing nets, called ghost nets. Animals also eat it: a sea turtle takes a floating bag for a jellyfish, and the plastic blocks its gut, so it starves with a full stomach.

Microplastic is debris smaller than about 5 mm (sources differ on the cut-off). It includes fragments of larger items, fibres washed out of synthetic clothes, and the pellets that plastic goods are made from. Zooplankton, mussels and small fish eat it, and the toxins that stick to its surface can then pass up food chains.

Midway Atoll, in the middle of the North Pacific, is home to about a million Laysan albatrosses (Phoebastria immutabilis). The parents skim food off the sea surface and carry it back to their chicks, and with it they bring bottle caps, lighters and fragments. The chicks cannot bring it up again. Many die with stomachs packed with plastic, and the plastic stays on the beach after their bodies have rotted away.

Photographs of those chicks, and television series such as Blue Planet II in 2017, showed the effects of plastic to millions of people who had never read the research behind them. Public opinion changed quickly, and that drove action: bans on plastic microbeads in cosmetics, charges for plastic bags, and many companies changing their packaging. This shows scientists that clear, vivid information about their findings can change what citizens and governments do.

Why does breaking macroplastic into microplastic not solve the problem?

  • Plastics are persistent because they are not biodegradable.
  • Macroplastic: entanglement and blocked guts, as in turtles, seals and albatross chicks.
  • Microplastic: eaten by plankton and filter feeders, and carries toxins up food chains.
  • Clear coverage of research in the media changed public opinion and led to new rules.
albatross chickbreaking upturtle and a bagseal in a ghost netmicroplasticmussels

Tap each part to see what plastic does there. Not to scale.

D4.2.11 Restoration of natural processes in ecosystems by rewilding

Let the land heal itself

  • Rewilding restores the processes that make an ecosystem work, then lets them run with as little human interference as possible.
  • Its methods: reintroduce apex predators and other keystone species, reconnect habitats over large areas, and minimize human impact.
  • Reconnected habitat, such as corridors and bridges and tunnels over and under roads, lets animals move, find mates and recolonize.
  • Hinewai Reserve, New Zealand: gorse left as a nurse crop, browsers kept out, native forest returning since 1987.

The detail

  • Most conservation protects what is left. Rewilding goes further.
  • Small, isolated fragments of habitat cannot hold large animals and lose species over time.
  • Minimizing human impact means stopping farming, logging and drainage, and managing the land only as much as the natural processes need.
  • That may include removing invasive animals that would stop recovery.

Hinewai Reserve

  • More than a thousand hectares of former sheep farm on Banks Peninsula, in the South Island of New Zealand.
  • Much of it was covered in gorse, a spiny shrub from Europe that farmers treat as a weed and usually burn or spray.
  • Since 1987 the botanist Hugh Wilson has managed it on a different principle: minimal interference. The gorse is left alone.
  • Gorse acts as a nurse crop, sheltering native seedlings from wind, frost and browsing animals.
  • The native trees grow up through it, overtop it and shade it out, because gorse cannot grow in shade.
  • Feral goats and deer are kept out, but nothing is planted.
  • The native forest has returned over much of the reserve, with streams running clear and native birds back.

Examples

  • Grey wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone National Park in the USA in 1995, seventy years after the last ones were killed.
  • Elk, which had browsed the young willows and aspens along the rivers, were eaten and moved more often, and in places the trees grew back. Beavers returned to build dams.
  • Ecologists still debate how much of the change was due to the wolves.

Most conservation protects what is left. Rewilding goes further: it restores the processes that make an ecosystem work and then lets them run with as little human interference as possible. It uses three main methods.

Reintroducing apex predators and other keystone species. Grey wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone National Park in the USA in 1995, seventy years after the last ones were killed. Elk, which had browsed the young willows and aspens along the rivers, were eaten and moved more often, and in places the trees grew back. Beavers returned to build dams. Ecologists still debate how much of the change was due to the wolves.

Reconnecting habitats over large areas. Small, isolated fragments of habitat cannot hold large animals and lose species over time. Corridors of habitat, and bridges and tunnels over and under roads, let animals move, find mates and recolonize.

Minimizing human impact. Stopping farming, logging and drainage, and managing the land only as much as the natural processes need. That may include removing invasive animals that would stop recovery.

Hinewai Reserve on Banks Peninsula, in the South Island of New Zealand, is more than a thousand hectares of former sheep farm. Much of it was covered in gorse, a spiny shrub from Europe that farmers treat as a weed and usually burn or spray. Since 1987, the botanist Hugh Wilson has managed it on a different principle: minimal interference. The gorse is left alone. It acts as a nurse crop, sheltering native seedlings from wind, frost and browsing animals. The native trees grow up through it, overtop it and shade it out, because gorse cannot grow in shade. Feral goats and deer are kept out, but nothing is planted. The native forest has returned over much of the reserve, with streams running clear and native birds back.

At Hinewai, why does leaving the invasive gorse alone speed up the return of native forest, rather than slowing it?

  • Rewilding restores processes, then lets them run.
  • Methods: reintroduce apex predators and keystone species, reconnect habitats, and minimize human impact.
  • Hinewai Reserve: gorse left as a nurse crop, browsers excluded, native forest returning since 1987.
gorse on a sheep farmnative seedlings in its shelternatives overtop the gorse, which dies in the shadenative forest returns
  1. 1987. A former sheep farm on Banks Peninsula, its slopes covered in gorse, a spiny shrub from Europe, and browsed by feral goats.
  2. The goats and deer are kept out and the gorse is left alone. It acts as a nurse crop, sheltering native seedlings from wind, frost and browsing.
  3. The native trees grow up through the gorse and overtop it. Gorse needs full light, so in their shade it dies back.
  4. Over much of the reserve, native forest has returned, with nothing planted. Minimal interference let natural succession do the work.

D4.2.12 Ecological succession and its causes

Communities that change in order

  • Ecological succession: over years to centuries one community replaces another in a fairly predictable sequence. Each community in it is a seral stage.
  • Succession is started by a change, which can be abiotic (to the non-living environment) or biotic (to the living community).
  • Once begun, it is driven on by the organisms themselves changing the abiotic conditions: they build soil, add nutrients, shade the ground and hold water.
  • Primary succession begins on ground with no soil. Secondary succession follows a disturbance that removes the community but leaves the soil.

The detail

  • Stable ecosystems are not the whole story. Bare ground does not stay bare, and a field left alone does not stay a field.
  • Each new arrival can make conditions better for some species and worse for others.
  • Secondary succession, as after a fire or when a field is abandoned, is faster because the soil, seeds and roots are already there.

Examples

  • Abiotic: a volcano lays down new lava, a glacier retreats from bare rock, wind piles up a new sand dune, a river drops silt in a delta. Fire, floods and landslides strip a community away.
  • Biotic: a new species arrives, a disease kills one tree species (Dutch elm disease removed millions of elms), grazing animals are added or removed, or beavers dam a stream and flood a wood.

Stable ecosystems are not the whole story. Bare ground does not stay bare, and a field left alone does not stay a field. Over years to centuries one community replaces another in a fairly predictable sequence, called ecological succession. Each community in the sequence is a seral stage.

Succession is started by a change, and the change can be abiotic or biotic.

Abiotic changes are changes to the non-living environment. A volcano lays down new lava, a glacier retreats from bare rock, wind piles up a new sand dune, a river drops silt in a delta. Fire, floods and landslides strip a community away. Once begun, succession is driven on by the organisms themselves changing the abiotic conditions: they build soil, add nutrients, shade the ground and hold water.

Biotic changes are changes to the living community. A new species arrives, a disease kills one tree species (Dutch elm disease removed millions of elms), grazing animals are added or removed, or beavers dam a stream and flood a wood. Each new arrival can make conditions better for some species and worse for others.

Where succession begins on ground with no soil, it is primary succession. Where a disturbance removes the community but leaves the soil, as after a fire or when a field is abandoned, it is secondary succession, which is faster because the soil, seeds and roots are already there.

A forest fire burns a wood to the ground. A new lava flow covers another. Which will be forest again first, and why?

abiotic triggersbiotic triggersnew lava flowno soil: primaryretreating glacierno soil: primarynew sand duneno soil: primaryfire or floodsoil left: secondarybeavers build a damfloodingdisease kills a treea gap opensgrazers come or goseedlings eaten or spareda new species arriveschanges the community

Tap a trigger to read how it starts a succession.

D4.2.13 Changes occurring during primary succession

From bare rock to forest

  • Primary succession starts on bare ground with no soil, such as rock left by a retreating glacier.
  • Pioneer species (cyanobacteria, lichens, mosses) colonize, weather the rock and add organic matter, so a thin soil forms.
  • Each seral stage changes conditions so other species can grow and replace it, until it ends in a climax community.
  • Five things increase: the size of the plants, primary production, species diversity, the complexity of food webs and nutrient cycling.

What increases, and why

  • The same five things increase in any primary succession on land.
  • Size: from mats of lichen to tall trees.
  • Primary production: more and bigger plants capture more light energy.
  • Species diversity: more kinds of plants give more habitats and food for animals.
  • Food webs: more producers and consumers, with more links between them.
  • Nutrient cycling: a deeper soil, more dead matter and more decomposers, so more nutrients cycle faster.
  • Diversity often peaks shortly before the end. In the final stage a few large, long-lived species can dominate and shade out some of the others.

Examples

  • The glaciers of Glacier Bay in Alaska melted back from the 1750s on, leaving bare rock and gravel. Ecologists have followed what happened since.
  • Because the ice retreated gradually, a walk from the ice front to the mouth of the bay is also a walk through two hundred years of succession.
  • The pioneers can grip bare rock and survive drought and cold. They trap dust and, as they die, add the first organic matter.
  • Then come small plants such as mountain avens (Dryas), which, like the alder that follows, has nitrogen-fixing bacteria in its roots and enriches the soil.
  • Shrubs follow, then Sitka spruce, which shades out the alder, and after about two centuries a forest of spruce and hemlock.

When the glaciers of Glacier Bay in Alaska melted back, from the 1750s on, they left bare rock and gravel. Ecologists have followed what happened since, and because the ice retreated gradually, a walk from the ice front to the mouth of the bay is also a walk through two hundred years of succession.

The first colonizers are pioneer species: cyanobacteria, lichens and mosses that can grip bare rock and survive drought and cold. They weather the rock, trap dust and, as they die, add the first organic matter. A thin soil forms. Then come small plants such as mountain avens (Dryas), which, like the alder that follows, has nitrogen-fixing bacteria in its roots and enriches the soil. Shrubs follow, then Sitka spruce, which shades out the alder, and after about two centuries a forest of spruce and hemlock.

The same five things increase in any primary succession on land.

  • The size of the plants: from mats of lichen to tall trees.
  • Primary production: more and bigger plants capture more light energy.
  • Species diversity: more kinds of plants give more habitats and food for animals.
  • The complexity of food webs: more producers and consumers, with more links between them.
  • Nutrient cycling: a deeper soil, more dead matter and more decomposers, so more nutrients cycle faster.

Diversity often peaks shortly before the end. In the final stage a few large, long-lived species can dominate and shade out some of the others.

Remember it What increases in primary succession

  • SlowlySizeof the plants
  • PlantsProductionprimary production rises
  • SpreadSpecies diversitymore species
  • FeedingFood websmore complex
  • NatureNutrient cyclingmore, and faster

Why does soil depth increase as succession goes on?

In the exam Primary succession:
  1. Starts on bare ground with no soil, such as rock after a glacier retreats.
  2. Pioneer species (lichens, mosses) colonize, weather the rock and add organic matter, so soil forms.
  3. Each seral stage changes conditions so other species can grow and replace it.
  4. Plant size, primary production, species diversity, food web complexity and nutrient cycling all increase.
  5. Ends in a climax community.
soil a few mmsoil a few cmsoil deepersoil deepbare rock: no soilpioneers: lichens and mossesabout 20 years: small plantsabout 50 years: alder thicketsabout 200 years: spruce and hemlock forest
  1. The ice has retreated and left bare rock and gravel: no soil, no seeds.
  2. Pioneer species arrive: cyanobacteria, lichens and mosses. They weather the rock and, as they die, add organic matter. A thin soil begins.
  3. Small plants such as mountain avens (Dryas) and grasses colonize. Bacteria in the roots of Dryas fix nitrogen, and the soil deepens.
  4. Alder shrubs, also nitrogen fixers, form thickets. More dead leaves and roots, more decomposers, deeper and richer soil.
  5. Sitka spruce shades out the alder, and after about two centuries a climax forest of spruce and hemlock stands where the ice was.

D4.2.14 Cyclical succession in ecosystems

A succession that goes round in a circle

  • Succession is often drawn as a line that ends in one unchanging community. In some ecosystems it is a loop instead.
  • In cyclical succession a series of communities replace each other and then the first one comes back.
  • Heather (Calluna vulgaris) on the heaths and moors of Britain goes through four phases over about 30 years: pioneer, building, mature and degenerate.
  • Across a moor, patches are at every phase at once, so the moor as a whole stays the same while each patch keeps changing.

The heather cycle

  • Pioneer: a seedling grows among grasses, mosses and lichens.
  • Building: it forms a dense dome that shades out almost everything beneath.
  • Mature: the centre of the bush begins to open up.
  • Degenerate: the old stems die and fall outwards, leaving a gap where lichens, mosses and grasses grow again.
  • Then a new heather seedling starts the cycle.

Examples

  • Fire can drive cycles too. Some heaths, grasslands and dry shrublands burn every few decades, and the community that grows back after the fire replaces the one that burned until the next fire.

How we know

  • The heather cycle is the classic example, described by the ecologist Alex Watt in 1947.

Succession is often drawn as a line that ends in one unchanging community. In some ecosystems it is a loop instead: a series of communities replace each other and then the first one comes back. This is cyclical succession.

The classic example is heather (Calluna vulgaris) on the heaths and moors of Britain, described by the ecologist Alex Watt in 1947. Each heather bush goes through four phases over about 30 years. In the pioneer phase a seedling grows among grasses, mosses and lichens. In the building phase it forms a dense dome that shades out almost everything beneath. In the mature phase the centre of the bush begins to open up. In the degenerate phase the old stems die and fall outwards, leaving a gap where lichens, mosses and grasses grow again, and then a new heather seedling starts the cycle. Across a moor, patches are at every phase at once, so the moor as a whole stays the same while each patch keeps changing.

Fire can drive cycles too. Some heaths, grasslands and dry shrublands burn every few decades, and the community that grows back after the fire replaces the one that burned until the next fire.

A heather moor has patches at all four phases. Why does the moor still look much the same from year to year?

pioneerup to about 6 yearsbuildingabout 6 to 15 yearsmatureabout 15 to 25 yearsdegenerateover 25 yearsabout 30 yearsround the cycle
  1. Pioneer. A heather seedling grows in a gap among grasses, mosses and lichens.
  2. Building. The heather forms a dense dome that flowers well and shades out almost everything beneath it.
  3. Mature. The bush is at its largest, and its centre starts to open up as the old stems spread.
  4. Degenerate. The old stems die and fall outwards. Lichens, mosses and grasses grow in the gap, and a new seedling starts the cycle again.

D4.2.15 Climax communities and arrested succession

Where succession stops

  • Succession tends towards a climax community: the community that is stable under the climate and soil of that place.
  • Given the same conditions, succession tends to end in the same type of climax.
  • Arrested succession: people stop succession before it gets there. The community left is sometimes called a plagioclimax.
  • Grazing by farm livestock: sheep and cattle eat tree seedlings along with the grass, so the trees never get started.
  • Drainage of wetlands stops their succession and holds the land as farmland.

The detail

  • Which climax a place reaches depends on the conditions. In most of lowland Britain it is broadleaf woodland of oak and ash; where it is colder or wetter it may be pine forest, and where it is very dry, grassland.
  • Ploughing, mowing and regular burning arrest succession too.

Examples

  • Many of the open hills of Britain and New Zealand would be woodland if the sheep were taken off them, as at Hinewai (chapter 11).
  • A fen or marsh naturally fills with dead plant matter over time and slowly becomes wet woodland.
  • Most of the Fens of eastern England were drained for farming from the 1600s on. The peat dries and shrinks, the wetland species die out, and the land is held as farmland.

Succession tends towards a climax community: the community that is stable under the climate and soil of that place. Which community that is depends on the conditions. In most of lowland Britain it is broadleaf woodland of oak and ash; where it is colder or wetter it may be pine forest, and where it is very dry, grassland. Given the same conditions, succession tends to end in the same type of climax.

People often stop succession before it gets there. This is arrested succession, and the community it leaves is sometimes called a plagioclimax.

Grazing by farm livestock. Sheep and cattle eat tree seedlings along with the grass, so the trees never get started. Many of the open hills of Britain and New Zealand would be woodland if the sheep were taken off them, as at Hinewai (chapter 11).

Drainage of wetlands. A fen or marsh naturally fills with dead plant matter over time and slowly becomes wet woodland. Drained for farming, as most of the Fens of eastern England were from the 1600s on, the peat dries and shrinks, the wetland species die out, and the land is held as farmland. Ploughing, mowing and regular burning arrest succession too.

A sheep farm on a hillside in lowland Britain is abandoned. What would you expect to grow there after a hundred years?

In the exam Climax and arrested succession:
  1. Under given environmental conditions, succession tends to lead to one type of climax community.
  2. Human activity can stop succession before the climax: arrested succession.
  3. Grazing livestock eat seedlings, so grassland does not become woodland.
  4. Draining wetlands stops their succession and holds the land as farmland.
drainage ditchpeat shrinksoak woodland on the hill, fen and wet woodland in the valleysheep eat the tree seedlings: grassland staysthe valley is drained: farmland stays

Switch between the land left alone and the two ways people arrest its succession.

02Dry lab: Life in a sealed jar

A sealed jar of pond water with pondweed, snails and the microbes in its mud. Change the light, the number of snails, the amount of pondweed and the lid, and follow the oxygen for 30 days to find which jars stay stable.

8.5mg/L12 hlight a dayDAY  0/304 of 4 aliveSEALED JARO₂ METER
The bench: a sealed jar of pond water with pondweed, snails and mud, under a lamp on a timer. A probe through the lid reads the dissolved oxygen. Run the month and see whether the jar stays stable.
Your questionWhat does a sealed jar need to keep its animals alive? Light passes through the glass but no matter gets in or out, so the plants, animals and microbes inside must balance each other. Pick one variable to change and keep the rest the same.
What you can changeThe light each day (hours of light), the number of snails, the mass of pondweed and whether the jar is sealed or open. A sealed jar is the model the IB prefers: energy can enter as light, but no matter can enter or leave.
What to recordThe dissolved oxygen in each jar every day, in milligrams per litre, and the day any snail dies. Repeat each jar at least three times, because every run varies a little, and use the mean. Download the CSV to plot your own graph.

Find out

  • Is the starting jar stable? Run 12 hours of light, 10 g of pondweed and 4 snails, sealed, three times. Does the oxygen hold and do the snails live?
  • How much light does it need? Keep everything else the same and run 0, 6, 12 and 18 hours. Which light setting is the least that keeps every snail alive?
  • Producers against consumers. At 6 hours of light, raise the snails from 0 to 10. At what number does the jar tip over, and does more pondweed rescue it?
  • Why seal it? Repeat one jar that failed with the lid open. What does the open lid let in, and why does that spoil the experiment as a model of a closed ecosystem?

Record

  • The hours of light, the pondweed, the snails and the lid for every run (the independent and controlled variables).
  • The dissolved oxygen on day 30 and the snails alive (the dependent variables), and the day the first snail died.
  • At least three runs at each setting, because cloud and warmth change a little from day to day.
  • The graph in your results shows oxygen through the month for your last six runs. Download the CSV to plot your own.

A sealed jar has 10 g of pondweed and 4 snails. In the dark, the snails die within a few days. Why?

A student finds that a jar with the lid open stays stable with 10 snails, but the sealed one does not. What should they conclude?

Back to ecosystems

Use your results to explain what a sealed mesocosm needs to stay stable, and why it is sealed rather than left open.

03Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in. It opens on biologybybradford.com, so it needs the internet.

Exam practice

Exam questions on D4.2, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

04Downloads

This file is the guide, saved to run without the internet.

Saved from biologybybradford.com/guides/ib-biology-d4-2-stability-and-change, where the guide is kept up to date with the notes, the revision sheet and, for the teacher, the lesson plans and slides.

05Teacher resources

The guide as four one-hour lessons, and two more at higher level. Each has a plan to print (the timings, what to project and where to stop, the activities with what they need, what students get wrong) and slides to teach it from, in the same order, with the teacher's moves in the notes.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1Stability and tipping points D4.2.1 to D4.2.460 min What makes an ecosystem stable for millions of years, the Amazon as a possible tipping point, and sealed mesocosms as a model 1, 2, 3, 4, dry lab Lesson planPDF 683 KB SlidesPPTX 1.2 MB
2Keystones and harvesting D4.2.5, D4.2.660 min Keystone species and the sea otter, and how to judge whether harvesting a wild species is sustainable 5, 6 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 666 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 3.6 MB
3Farming, eutrophication and biomagnification D4.2.7 to D4.2.960 min What makes farming sustainable, and how leached fertilizer and persistent pesticides harm the water and the top of the food chain 7, 8, 9 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 685 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 2.3 MB
4Plastics and rewilding D4.2.10, D4.2.1160 min Macroplastic and microplastic in the oceans, how media coverage changed public action, and rewilding at Hinewai 10, 11 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 608 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 555 KB
5Succession HL D4.2.12, D4.2.1360 min What starts a succession, and the changes from bare rock to forest in primary succession 12, 13 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 599 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 654 KB
6Cycles, climax and review HL D4.2.14, D4.2.1560 min Cyclical succession in heather, climax communities and how grazing and drainage arrest succession, then a review of D4.2 14, 15 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 591 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 710 KB

Lesson 1 is free with a free account. The other plans and slides, for every guide, come with the Teacher pass.

The note template, the revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTISE AND REVISE

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for D4.2

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.