IB BIOLOGY · THEME D · CONTINUITY AND CHANGE

When a gene changes

One base out of place can change a protein, or change nothing at all. Edit a gene yourself and watch the protein, follow sickle cell from one base to a bent red blood cell, find out where mutations come from, and at higher level switch genes off, edit them with CRISPR and ask why some sequences never change.

IB Biology D1.3SL and HL3 hours SL, 2 more HL9 chapters6 chapters at SLdry lab

Start learningRun the dry labTeach it

From blood to gene and back: one base swapped in the HBB gene turns glutamic acid into valine, and a red blood cell into a sickle. Then edit a gene yourself in the guide.
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Nine chapters, the last three for higher level. Read one, play its figure or edit the gene, and make each prediction before you open the answer.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1Three ways to change a gene
  2. 2One base swapped
  3. 3Sickle cell, one base at a time
  4. 4Bases added or lost
  5. 5Where mutations come from
  6. 6Passed on, or not
  7. 7Switch a gene off HL
  8. 8Cut, then repair HL
  9. 9Sequences that stay the same HL

D1.3.1 Gene mutations as structural changes

Three ways to change a gene

  • A gene mutation is a change to the base sequence of a gene. It is structural: the DNA molecule itself is different.
  • Substitution: one base is swapped for another.
  • Insertion: one or more bases are added. Deletion: one or more bases are lost.
  • A substitution keeps the gene’s length and changes at most one codon; insertions and deletions change the length.

The detail

  • A gene is a sequence of bases, read in threes.
  • The change is base by base, and every copy made from the mutated DNA carries it.
  • The three look alike as edits, but they do very different things to the protein.
  • An insertion or a deletion moves every base after it along, so every codon after it can change.
  • Step through the figure, then try the same edits on a gene in chapter 2.

Try it

  • Read this sentence in threes: THE OLD MAN SAW THE DOG.
  • Now swap one letter for another. Then remove one letter and read on in threes. Which edit wrecks more of the sentence? Chapter 4 comes back to this.

Watch out

  • A mutation is not a whole chromosome going missing.
  • It is not “a gene turning bad”. It is any change to the bases, and many changes do nothing that anyone could notice.

A gene is a sequence of bases, read in threes. A gene mutation is a change to that sequence. It is structural: the DNA molecule itself is different, base by base, and every copy made from it carries the change.

There are three kinds. In a substitution one base is swapped for another. In an insertion one or more bases are added. In a deletion one or more bases are lost.

The three look alike as edits, but they do very different things to the protein. A substitution changes at most one codon. An insertion or a deletion moves every base after it along, so every codon after it can change. Step through the figure, then try the same edits on a gene in chapter 2.

Try it first Read this sentence in threes: THE OLD MAN SAW THE DOG. Now swap one letter for another. Then remove one letter and read on in threes. Which edit wrecks more of the sentence? Chapter 4 comes back to this.
  • A gene mutation is a change to the base sequence of a gene.
  • Substitution: one base replaced. Insertion: bases added. Deletion: bases lost.
  • A substitution keeps the gene's length; insertions and deletions change it.
Watch out A mutation is not a whole chromosome going missing, and it is not "a gene turning bad". It is any change to the bases, and many changes do nothing that anyone could notice.

A gene of 900 bases becomes 901 bases long. Which kind of mutation could this be?

one gene, three kinds of mutationthe gene: 4 codons, 4 amino acidsATGGCATTCGAAMetAlaPheGluevery mutation changesthis sequence of basessubstitution: one base swappedATGGCACTCGAAMetAlaLeuGlusame length: only one codonand one amino acid changeinsertion: one base addedATGGGCATTCGAAMetGlyIleArg...every codon after it is readone base along: a frameshiftdeletion: one base lostATGGATTCGAAMetAspSer...the C was herethe gap closes up, so everycodon after it changes too
  1. A short gene: twelve bases, read as four codons.
  2. A substitution: the T at base 7 becomes a C. Only the third codon changes.
  3. An insertion: one G added after base 4. Every base after it moves along one.
  4. A deletion: base 5 lost. The bases close up, and every codon after it is new.

D1.3.2 Consequences of base substitutions

One base swapped

  • The genetic code is degenerate: most amino acids have more than one codon, so a substitution may not change the amino acid.
  • Silent: the codon changes but the amino acid does not, and the polypeptide is exactly as it was.
  • Missense: the new codon codes for a different amino acid, so one amino acid in the chain is different.
  • Nonsense: the new codon is a stop codon, so translation ends early and the polypeptide is cut short.
  • A single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) is the result of a base substitution; it may or may not change an amino acid.

The detail

  • A substitution changes one codon, and so at most one amino acid, unless it makes a stop codon. There are three possible results.
  • The codons for one amino acid usually differ only at the third base.
  • A SNP is a base substitution found in some members of a population.
  • Any two people differ at millions of SNPs, and most SNPs lie outside genes altogether.

Watch out

  • “Missense” does not always mean harmful. Swapping one amino acid for a similar one, on the outside of a protein, often changes nothing you could measure.
  • A change in the active site of an enzyme can stop it working.

A substitution changes one codon. What happens next depends on what that codon now codes for, and there are three possible results.

The genetic code is degenerate: most amino acids have more than one codon, and the codons for one amino acid usually differ only at the third base. So a substitution can be silent: the codon changes, the amino acid does not, and the polypeptide is exactly as it was. If the new codon codes for a different amino acid, the mutation is missense: one amino acid in the chain is different. If the new codon is a stop codon, it is nonsense: translation ends early and the polypeptide is cut short.

A base substitution that is found in some members of a population is a single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP). Any two people differ at millions of SNPs. Because the code is degenerate, a SNP may or may not change an amino acid, and most of them lie outside genes altogether.

Remember it What a swapped base can do

  • SameSilentnew codon, same amino acid
  • MistakeMissenseone amino acid different
  • StopNonsensea stop codon: chain cut short
  • A substitution changes one codon, and so at most one amino acid, unless it makes a stop codon.
  • Silent: same amino acid, because the code is degenerate. Missense: a different amino acid. Nonsense: a stop codon.
  • SNPs are the result of base substitutions; they may or may not change an amino acid.
Watch out "Missense" does not always mean harmful. Swapping one amino acid for a similar one, on the outside of a protein, often changes nothing you could measure. A change in the active site of an enzyme can stop it working.

The codon GGU codes for glycine, and so do GGC, GGA and GGG. The U is replaced by an A. What is the result?

Each codon: DNA coding strand, then mRNA, then amino acid123456789ATGCCGAAAGGTTTCGAGCATTGGCTATAAAUGCCGAAAGGUUUCGAGCAUUGGCUAUAAMetProLysGlyPheGluHisTrpLeuStopThe gene as it isATGCCGTAAGGTTTCGAGCATTGGCTATAAMetProStopGlyPheGluHisTrpLeuStopA substitution: AAA becomes TAA, a stopATGCCGAAAGGTTCGAGCATTGGCTATAAMetProLysGlySerSerIleGlyTyrA deletion: one base lost, the frame shifts
  1. A made-up gene: its coding strand in codons, the mRNA under it and the amino acid each codon codes for.
  2. One base substituted: codon 2, AAA, becomes TAA, a stop codon. Translation ends there: a nonsense mutation.
  3. One base deleted from codon 4. Every codon after it is read in a new frame, so every amino acid from there changes: a frameshift.
Tap a base, then change it, add a base after it or delete it. The tool names the result. Try the five tasks.

D1.3.2 A substitution with a known effect: sickle cell

Sickle cell, one base at a time

  • The sickle cell allele, HbS, has a base substitution: in the sixth codon of beta globin, A is replaced by T, so GAG becomes GTG.
  • It is missense: glutamic acid (charged, hydrophilic) is replaced by valine (non-polar, hydrophobic).
  • At low oxygen, haemoglobin S molecules stick together into long, stiff fibres, so red blood cells sickle.
  • Sickled cells carry less oxygen and block small blood vessels. Two copies of HbS give sickle cell disease.

The detail

  • Haemoglobin, the oxygen-carrying protein in red blood cells, is built from two kinds of polypeptide.
  • One of them, beta globin, is coded for by a gene on chromosome 11.
  • The usual allele is HbA. The sixth codon is counted from after the start codon.
  • One amino acid out of 146 is the whole difference.
  • That one amino acid matters because of its R group: valine’s sits on the outside of the molecule as a sticky patch.

In the exam

  • Write the change in both: the base (A to T) and the amino acid (glutamic acid to valine).

Links across the course

  • This is protein structure (B1.2) seen from the gene: the sequence of amino acids decides how a polypeptide folds and what it can do.
  • One substitution changes the sequence in one place, and the protein’s behaviour follows.

Watch out

  • The DNA changes in one base, not the whole gene.
  • The protein changes in one amino acid, not all of it.

Haemoglobin, the oxygen-carrying protein in red blood cells, is built from two kinds of polypeptide. One of them, beta globin, is coded for by a gene on chromosome 11. The usual allele, HbA, has GAG as its sixth codon (counting from after the start codon), and GAG codes for glutamic acid.

The sickle cell allele, HbS, differs by one base: the A in that codon is replaced by a T. GAG becomes GTG, and GTG codes for valine. It is a missense substitution, and one amino acid out of 146 is the whole difference.

That one amino acid matters because of its R group. Glutamic acid's is charged and hydrophilic; valine's is non-polar and hydrophobic, so it sits on the outside of the molecule as a sticky patch. When oxygen is low, haemoglobin S molecules stick to one another and form long, stiff fibres. The red blood cells bend into a sickle shape, carry less oxygen, and block small blood vessels. People with two copies of HbS have sickle cell disease.

Link This is protein structure (B1.2) seen from the gene: the sequence of amino acids decides how a polypeptide folds and what it can do. One substitution changes the sequence in one place, and the protein's behaviour follows.
  • The sickle cell allele has a base substitution: GAG becomes GTG in the sixth codon of beta globin.
  • Glutamic acid (charged) is replaced by valine (non-polar).
  • Haemoglobin S forms fibres at low oxygen, so red blood cells sickle.
Watch out The DNA changes in one base, not the whole gene, and the protein changes in one amino acid, not all of it. Write the change in both: the base (A to T) and the amino acid (glutamic acid to valine).

A different substitution in the same codon turns GAG into GAA. What would happen to the haemoglobin?

haemoglobin Aits molecules stay separatehaemoglobin Slow oxygen: it joins into fibresDNAsixth amino acidof the beta chainGGa red blood cellAGluTValone base changed,one amino acid changedblood flowsnormal cellsflexible discs: they squeeze throughsickle cellsstiff: they jam the vesselblood flow is blockedpain, and damage to organsin a small blood vessel
  1. In a red blood cell, molecules of haemoglobin A stay separate.
  2. Molecules of haemoglobin S, at low oxygen, stick together into long fibres.
  3. The fibres bend the cell into a sickle. Sickle cells are stiff and block small vessels.
Each codon: DNA coding strand, then mRNA, then amino acid12345678910ATGGTGCATCTGACTCCTGAGGAGAAGTCTGCCAUGGUGCAUCUGACUCCUGAGGAGAAGUCUGCCMetValHisLeuThrProGluGluLysSerAla...The usual allele: codon 6 is GAG, glutamic acid12345678910ATGGTGCATCTGACTCCTGTGGAGAAGTCTGCCAUGGUGCAUCUGACUCCUGUGGAGAAGUCUGCCMetValHisLeuThrProValGluLysSerAla...Sickle cell allele: A to T, so GTG, valine
  1. The start of the beta globin gene. Codon 6 is GAG, which codes for glutamic acid.
  2. One base substituted, A to T: GAG becomes GTG, and glutamic acid becomes valine. That one amino acid is the whole difference between the two alleles.
The start of the beta globin gene. Make the sickle cell change, then find a change to the same codon that does no harm.
ThrLys+ValLeuGlnCysPheIleAsp−SerValLeuCysGlu−ThrIleAsnSerThrLys+ValLeuGlnCysPheIleAsp−SerValLeuCysValThrIleAsnSer
  1. A folded chain with glutamic acid (Glu, charged) on its surface, codon GAG. Nothing sticks to it.
  2. Codon GTG, valine: the surface now carries a non-polar patch, sticky to the same patch on another copy. The fold inside is unchanged.
Make the sickle cell substitution in codon 6, A to T, and watch the amino acid change on the surface of a folded protein. Then try G to A, the silent change. It is a toy model of a made-up chain, not a real structure of beta globin.

D1.3.3 Consequences of insertions and deletions

Bases added or lost

  • A ribosome reads mRNA in threes from the start codon; that grouping is the reading frame.
  • Inserting or deleting one or two bases shifts the frame: a frameshift. Every codon after the change can change.
  • After a frameshift an early stop codon is likely, so the polypeptide almost never works.
  • A multiple of three keeps the frame, but whole amino acids are gained or lost; large insertions or deletions usually stop the polypeptide working.

The detail

  • Nothing marks where one codon ends and the next begins.
  • After a frameshift every codon is read in a new grouping, so every amino acid after it can change.
  • A stop codon usually turns up early because three of the 64 codons are stops.
  • When three bases, or a multiple of three, are added or removed, the rest of the chain is as before.
  • That can still matter: one amino acid missing from a key place can stop a protein folding properly.
  • Large insertions or deletions, of many bases, are very likely to stop a polypeptide working, whatever the frame.

Watch out

  • The damage depends on where the change is, too.
  • A frameshift near the end of a gene leaves most of the chain as it was; one near the start leaves almost nothing.

A ribosome reads mRNA in threes from the start codon, with nothing to mark where one codon ends and the next begins. That grouping into threes is the reading frame.

Insert or delete one base and the frame shifts. Every codon after the change is read in a new grouping, so every amino acid after it can change, and a stop codon usually turns up early, because three of the 64 codons are stops. This is a frameshift, and the polypeptide it makes almost never works.

Add or remove three bases, or any multiple of three, and the frame is kept. Whole codons are gained or lost and the rest of the chain is as before. That can still matter: one amino acid missing from a key place can stop a protein folding properly. Large insertions or deletions, of many bases, are also very likely to stop a polypeptide working, whatever the frame.

  • Inserting or deleting one or two bases shifts the reading frame: a frameshift.
  • After a frameshift every codon changes and an early stop codon is likely, so the polypeptide is very unlikely to function.
  • A multiple of three keeps the frame, but whole amino acids are gained or lost; large insertions and deletions usually stop the polypeptide working.
Watch out The damage depends on where the change is, too. A frameshift near the end of a gene leaves most of the chain as it was; one near the start leaves almost nothing.

Three edits to the same gene: one base substituted, one base deleted, three bases in a row deleted. Which is most likely to stop the protein working?

why one letter matters more than threethe sentence, read in threesTHEOLDMANSAWTHEDOGTHEOLDMANSAWTHEDOGa ribosome reads codons the same way:three at a time, from a fixed startone letter lost: the OTHELDMANSAWTHEDOGTHELDMANSAWTHEDOGevery word after it is nonsense:a frameshiftone letter added: an XTHEOXLDMANSAWTHEDOGTHEOXLDMANSAWTHEDOGone added shifts the frame too,the other waythree letters lost: OLDTHEMANSAWTHEDOGTHEMANSAWTHEDOGone whole word gone, the restreads as before: the frame is kept
  1. A sentence of three-letter words, read in threes like codons.
  2. One letter lost. Read on in threes and every word after it is nonsense: a frameshift.
  3. One letter added: the frame shifts the other way, and again every word after it changes.
  4. Three letters lost: one whole word goes and the rest reads as before. The frame is kept.

D1.3.4 D1.3.5 Causes of mutation, and randomness

Where mutations come from

  • Some mutations come from errors in DNA replication or repair, with no outside cause.
  • Others are caused by mutagens: chemicals such as those in tobacco smoke, and radiation such as ultraviolet, X-rays and gamma rays.
  • Mutation is random: it can happen anywhere in the base sequence of a genome.
  • Some bases mutate more often than others, such as a C next to a G.
  • No natural mechanism is known by which a cell makes a deliberate change to a particular base to change a trait.

The detail

  • DNA polymerase copies billions of bases each time a cell divides and, very rarely, puts in the wrong one.
  • Proofreading and repair enzymes find and mend almost all of these errors, but not quite all, and repair can itself go wrong.
  • Mutation happens regardless of whether the change would help.
  • Some sequences, as well as some bases, mutate more often than others.

Examples

  • Chemical mutagens: benzo[a]pyrene and nitrosamines in tobacco smoke, aflatoxin made by a mould on stored nuts and grain, and mustard gas.
  • Ultraviolet light can join two thymines next to each other.
  • Ionising radiation (X-rays, gamma rays and the alpha particles from radon gas) can break DNA strands.

Watch out

  • Bacteria exposed to an antibiotic do not mutate in order to resist it.
  • The resistant mutants were already there, by chance, before the drug arrived; the drug kills the rest.

Some mutations happen with no outside cause. DNA polymerase copies billions of bases each time a cell divides and, very rarely, puts in the wrong one. Proofreading and repair enzymes find and mend almost all of these errors, but not quite all, and repair can itself go wrong. So errors in DNA replication or repair are one cause.

The other is a mutagen. Chemical mutagens include benzo[a]pyrene and nitrosamines in tobacco smoke, aflatoxin made by a mould on stored nuts and grain, and mustard gas. Mutagenic radiation includes ultraviolet light, which can join two thymines next to each other, and the ionising radiation of X-rays, gamma rays and the alpha particles from radon gas, which can break DNA strands.

Mutation is random in two senses, and not in a third. It can happen anywhere in the base sequence of a genome. It happens regardless of whether the change would help: there is no known natural mechanism by which a cell makes a deliberate change to a particular base in order to change a trait. But not every base is equally likely to change: some sequences and some bases, such as a C next to a G, mutate more often than others.

Remember it Mutagens

  • SmokeChemicalsbenzo[a]pyrene, nitrosamines, aflatoxin
  • SunUltravioletjoins two thymines
  • ScansIonising radiationX-rays, gamma rays, radon
  • Mutations are caused by errors in DNA replication or repair, and by mutagens.
  • Mutagens: chemicals (such as those in tobacco smoke) and radiation (ultraviolet, X-rays, gamma rays, alpha particles).
  • A mutation can occur anywhere, but some bases mutate more often than others; no natural mechanism makes a deliberate change to a chosen base.
Watch out Bacteria exposed to an antibiotic do not mutate in order to resist it. The resistant mutants were already there, by chance, before the drug arrived; the drug kills the rest.

A student says: "A population of insects in a hotter climate will mutate so that it can cope with heat." What is wrong with this?

three causes of mutationGCATTAGCACGTGATCGT5'3'3'5'DNA polymerasebuilding the lower strandG put opposite Tproofreading and repair catch mostcopying errors, but not quite allGCATTAGCACGTAATCGT5'3'3'5'two thymines side by sidejoined into onecopying past the joinmakes errorsGCATTAGCACGTAATCGT5'3'3'5'a chemical mutagensuch as one in tobacco smokebound to a G, the base is misreadwhen the DNA is next copied
  1. An error in replication: a G is put opposite a T. Repair enzymes catch most such errors.
  2. Ultraviolet light joins two thymines next to each other. Copying past the join makes mistakes.
  3. A chemical mutagen binds to a base, which is then misread when the DNA is copied.

D1.3.6 D1.3.7 Germ cells, somatic cells and variation

Passed on, or not

  • A mutation in a germ cell can end up in a gamete and the zygote, so it is in every cell of the offspring and can be inherited.
  • A mutation in a somatic cell is copied only into that cell’s descendants and is not inherited.
  • Somatic mutations in genes that control cell division can lead to cancer.
  • Mutation is the original source of all genetic variation: every allele of every gene began as one.
  • Most mutations are neutral or harmful for one organism, but for a species they are essential for evolution by natural selection.

The detail

  • Every cell in your body descends from one zygote. Most are somatic cells, body cells; a few lines of cells, the germ cells, make the gametes.
  • A somatic mutation usually does nothing, and it ends with the person.
  • If it hits genes that control cell division, that cell’s descendants can divide without control and form a tumour. Cancer often needs several mutations in one line of cells.
  • A germline mutation is in the child’s germ cells too, so it can be passed on again. This is how a new allele enters a family.
  • For one organism, few mutations are beneficial.
  • Without new alleles there would be no variation for natural selection to act on, and no evolution (D4.1).

Nature of science

  • Commercial genetic tests read a person’s SNPs from a saliva sample and report risks of future disease.
  • Without expert interpretation the results can mislead: a raised risk is not a diagnosis.
  • A test may look only at a few variants of a gene, and a clear result can reassure someone who still has other risks.

Watch out

  • “Most mutations are harmful” is about one organism at a time.
  • For a species, mutation is the only way new alleles arise, so without it natural selection would run out of variation to act on.

Every cell in your body descends from one zygote. Most are somatic cells, body cells. A few lines of cells, the germ cells, make the gametes.

A mutation in a somatic cell is copied into every cell descended from it, and nowhere else. Usually it does nothing. But if it hits genes that control cell division, that cell's descendants can divide without control and form a tumour: cancer begins with mutations in somatic cells, often several in one line of cells. A somatic mutation is not inherited: it ends with the person.

A mutation in a germ cell can end up in a gamete. If that gamete is used in fertilisation, the mutation is in the zygote, so it is in every cell of the child, germ cells included, and it can be passed on again. This is how a new allele enters a family.

Every allele of every gene began as a mutation, so mutation is the original source of all genetic variation. For one organism, most mutations are neutral or harmful, and few are beneficial. For a species, over a long time, they are essential: without new alleles there would be no variation for natural selection to act on, and no evolution (D4.1).

Nature of science Commercial genetic tests read a person's SNPs from a saliva sample and report risks of future disease. Without expert interpretation the results can mislead: a raised risk is not a diagnosis, a test may look only at a few variants of a gene, and a clear result can reassure someone who still has other risks.
  • A mutation in a germ cell can be inherited: it is in every cell of the offspring.
  • A mutation in a somatic cell is not inherited; it can lead to cancer.
  • Mutation is the original source of all genetic variation; most mutations are harmful or neutral, but they are essential for evolution.
Watch out "Most mutations are harmful" is about one organism at a time. For a species, mutation is the only way new alleles arise, so without it natural selection would run out of variation to act on.

A man has a mutation in a lung cell after years of smoking. Could his children inherit it?

where a mutation happens matterszygotebody cellssomaticgerm cellsin an ovaryor a testismore body cellseggsperma tumourin its descendants only:not inheritedevery cell of the childcarries it: inherited
  1. All the cells of a body descend from one zygote: somatic cells on one side, germ cells on the other.
  2. A mutation in a somatic cell is in its descendants only. It can lead to a tumour, and it is not inherited.
  3. A mutation in a germ cell can reach an egg or a sperm, and so every cell of a child.

D1.3.8 Gene knockout

Switch a gene off

  • In a gene knockout, a gene is changed so that it can no longer make a working product.
  • The knocked-out organism is compared with a normal one; whatever is different points to what the gene does.
  • Knockouts are made in model organisms such as mice, zebrafish, fruit flies, yeast and the plant Arabidopsis.
  • Libraries of knockouts are available for some model species: one strain for each of thousands of genes.

The detail

  • Sequencing a genome tells you where its genes are, not what they do. One way to find out is to break a gene on purpose.
  • Differences can be in development, the body, behaviour or chemistry.
  • Model organisms are species that are easy to keep and breed and that share many genes with humans.
  • With a library, a researcher can order a strain with the gene they study already switched off.
  • Yeast has a library for nearly all of its genes, and there are large collections for mice and for Arabidopsis.

In the exam

  • The methods have changed over the years, and you do not need to know them.

Links across the course

  • CRISPR, in the next chapter, is now the usual way: a cut repaired with a few bases lost gives a frameshift, and the gene is knocked out.

Watch out

  • No visible change does not mean the gene does nothing. Another gene may do the same job.
  • The effect may show only in certain conditions, such as cold, disease or old age.

Sequencing a genome tells you where its genes are, not what they do. One way to find out is to break a gene on purpose. In a gene knockout, a gene is changed so that it can no longer make a working product. The knocked-out organism is then compared with a normal one. Whatever is different, in its development, its body, its behaviour or its chemistry, points to what the gene does.

Knockouts are made in model organisms: species that are easy to keep and breed and that share many genes with humans, such as mice, zebrafish, fruit flies, yeast and the plant Arabidopsis. For some of them, scientists have built libraries of knockouts: collections with one strain for each of thousands of genes, so that a researcher can order a strain with the gene they study already switched off. Yeast has one for nearly all of its genes, and there are large collections for mice and for Arabidopsis.

The methods have changed over the years, and you do not need to know them. CRISPR, in the next chapter, is now the usual way: a cut repaired with a few bases lost gives a frameshift, and the gene is knocked out.

  • A knockout makes a gene inoperative, so that its function can be worked out from what changes.
  • It is done in model organisms such as mice, zebrafish, yeast and Arabidopsis.
  • Libraries of knockout organisms are available for some model species.
Watch out No visible change does not mean the gene does nothing. Another gene may do the same job, or the effect may show only in certain conditions, such as cold, disease or old age.

A gene is knocked out in mice and the mice cannot smell. What is the best conclusion?

a gene knockoutnormalthe geneits proteinknocked outthe geneno proteinthe difference shows what the gene does:here, it is needed for the stripes
  1. A normal gene makes its protein, and the fish develops its stripes.
  2. The same gene knocked out: no working protein, and no stripes.
  3. Compare the two. The difference shows what the gene does. The fish and the gene are drawn to show the idea.

D1.3.9 Gene editing with CRISPR and Cas9

Cut, then repair

  • Cas9 is an enzyme that cuts DNA; it carries a guide RNA of about 20 bases that match the target gene.
  • Where every base of the guide pairs, next to a short sequence called the PAM, Cas9 cuts both strands.
  • If the cell repairs the break by joining the ends, a few bases are often lost or added: a frameshift that knocks the gene out.
  • If a piece of DNA with the wanted sequence is supplied, the cell can copy it across the break: an edit, such as one chosen base changed.
  • Example: edited blood stem cells treat sickle cell disease. Ethical issues and differing regulation must be settled.

The detail

  • Scientists make the guide RNA; it decides where Cas9 cuts.
  • Cas9 moves along the DNA, opens the double helix where it finds a PAM, and checks whether the guide pairs.
  • The system is named after the CRISPR sequences in bacteria, where it was found.
  • The change is made when the cell repairs the break.

Treating sickle cell disease

  • A patient’s own blood stem cells are collected and edited with CRISPR-Cas9, outside the body.
  • The edited cells make fetal haemoglobin again, which does not sickle. The cells are returned to the patient.
  • Approved in the UK and the USA in 2023, the treatment has freed most patients in its trials from the painful crises of the disease.

Nature of science

  • Some uses of CRISPR raise ethical issues that must be settled before they are used.
  • Countries regulate gene editing differently, and work banned in one may be allowed in another, so there is an international effort to harmonise the rules.
  • In 2018 a scientist in China edited human embryos, and twins were born; he was widely condemned, and was jailed.

Watch out

  • Cas9 does not “know” the gene. It cuts wherever the guide pairs next to a PAM.
  • That is why a site that differs from the target by one or two bases can be cut by mistake.

Cas9 is an enzyme that cuts DNA. It carries a guide RNA, and the guide RNA decides where it cuts. Scientists make a guide RNA with about 20 bases that match the gene they want to change. Cas9 moves along the DNA, opens the double helix where it finds a short sequence called the PAM, and checks whether the guide pairs. Where every base pairs, it cuts both strands. The system is named after the CRISPR sequences in bacteria, where it was found.

The cell then repairs the break, and this is where the change is made. Usually it simply joins the ends, often losing or adding a few bases: a frameshift that knocks the gene out. If scientists also supply a piece of DNA with the sequence they want, the cell can copy it across the break: an edit, such as one chosen base changed.

One successful use treats sickle cell disease. A patient's own blood stem cells are collected and edited with CRISPR-Cas9, outside the body, so that the cells make fetal haemoglobin again, which does not sickle. The cells are returned to the patient. Approved in the UK and the USA in 2023, the treatment has freed most patients in its trials from the painful crises of the disease.

For editing

  • Can cure diseases caused by one gene, such as sickle cell disease.
  • Faster, cheaper and more precise than earlier methods.
  • Knockouts reveal what genes do, in research.

Questions to settle first

  • Off-target cuts at sites that nearly match the guide.
  • Editing germ cells or embryos changes every later generation, who cannot consent.
  • Cost: who gets a treatment that costs over a million dollars?
Nature of science Some uses of CRISPR raise ethical issues that must be settled before they are used. Countries regulate gene editing differently, and work banned in one may be allowed in another, so there is an international effort to harmonise the rules. In 2018 a scientist in China edited human embryos, and twins were born; he was widely condemned, and was jailed.
  • A guide RNA matching the target leads Cas9 to it; Cas9 cuts both strands.
  • Repair by joining the ends knocks a gene out; repair from a template makes a chosen edit.
  • Example: edited blood stem cells treat sickle cell disease. Ethical issues and differing regulation need settling.
Watch out Cas9 does not "know" the gene. It cuts wherever the guide pairs next to a PAM, which is why a site that differs from the target by one or two bases can be cut by mistake.

Scientists want to change one base in a gene, not knock the gene out. What must they add besides Cas9 and a guide RNA?

Watch Cas9 test two sites, cut at its target, and the two ways the cell repairs the cut.

D1.3.10 Conserved and highly conserved sequences

Sequences that stay the same

  • A conserved sequence is identical or similar across a species or a group of species.
  • A highly conserved sequence has stayed the same over long periods of evolution.
  • Function hypothesis: the gene product needs the sequence to work, so natural selection removes mutations there.
  • Slower mutation hypothesis: some sequences may simply mutate less often, so fewer changes arise there.
  • Silent changes tell the two apart: under function they still build up; under slower mutation every kind of change is rare.

The detail

  • Line up the same gene from different species and most of it differs. Some stretches do not.
  • The histone H4 protein of a pea and of a cow differ in only two of about a hundred amino acids.
  • Under the function hypothesis, a mutation there makes an organism less likely to survive and reproduce, so the sequence stays as it was.
  • Changes that do not alter the protein, such as most changes at a third codon base, are not removed.

Testing the hypotheses

  • The two predict different patterns, and that is how to test them.
  • If function is the reason, third bases vary while the amino acids stay the same.
  • A second test is a knockout or an edit: change a conserved stretch and see whether the protein still works.

Try it

  • Try the first test in the Dry lab.

Watch out

  • A conserved sequence has not been protected from mutation.
  • Under the function hypothesis, mutations happen there as often as anywhere; the organisms carrying them are removed by selection.

Line up the same gene from different species and most of it differs. Some stretches do not. A conserved sequence is identical or similar across a species or a group of species. A highly conserved sequence has stayed the same over long periods of evolution: the histone H4 protein of a pea and of a cow differ in only two of about a hundred amino acids.

Why would a sequence not change, when mutations happen everywhere? There are two hypotheses.

Function. The gene's product needs that sequence to work. A mutation there makes an organism less likely to survive and reproduce, so natural selection removes it, and the sequence stays as it was. Changes that do not alter the protein, such as most changes at a third codon base, are not removed.

Slower mutation. Some sequences may simply mutate less often, so fewer changes arise there in the first place.

The two predict different patterns, and that is how to test them. If function is the reason, silent changes still build up: third bases vary while the amino acids stay the same. If slower mutation is the reason, every kind of change is rare, silent ones included. A second test is a knockout or an edit: change a conserved stretch and see whether the protein still works. Try the first test in the Dry lab.

  • Conserved: the same or similar across species. Highly conserved: the same over long periods of evolution.
  • Hypothesis 1: the gene product's function needs the sequence, so selection removes changes.
  • Hypothesis 2: the sequence mutates more slowly. Silent changes tell the two apart.
Watch out A conserved sequence has not been protected from mutation. Under the function hypothesis, mutations happen there as often as anywhere; the organisms carrying them are removed by selection.

In a conserved region of a gene, the amino acids are the same in ten species but the third bases of the codons differ. Which hypothesis does this support?

a gene lined up across four speciesPQRSregion XGCTTGGGCATGGGCCTGGGCGTGGAlaTrpregion YCATAAGCATAAGCATAAGCATAAGHisLysfour species, P, Q, R and S:the same gene, the same two placesX: the third base varies, the amino aciddoes not. GCT, GCA, GCC, GCG all mean AlaY: nothing varies, not even third bases:slower mutation here, or strong selection?
  1. Two regions of one gene in four species, with the amino acids each codes for.
  2. Region X: a third base varies but the amino acids do not. That fits the function hypothesis.
  3. Region Y: nothing varies, not even third bases. That fits slower mutation, or very strong selection.

02Dry lab: Conserved or not?

One gene, lined up across six species. Find the stretches that never change, then test two hypotheses for why: does the protein need them, or do those bases simply mutate less? This bench is for higher level.

GENEABCD910111213141516codonPQRSTUTCGAACAGGATGGGTACGCTTGTCTCCAACAGGATGGGAACGCTAGTCTCCAACAGGATGGGAACGCTAGTATCCAACCGGATGGGAACGCTGGTCTCCAACAGAATGGGAACGCTAGTCTCCAACAGGATGGGAACGCTGGTA123123123123123123123123REGION Bevery positioncodons 9 to 16000of 24
The bench: one invented gene lined up across six species, a region at a time. Count the positions that differ in each region, at first and second codon positions and at third positions, and plot them.
Your questionWhy are some parts of a gene the same in every species? If the protein needs them, changes there are removed by selection, but silent changes should still build up. If those bases mutate less, every kind of change should be rare there. Which does the data support?
What you can changeThe region of the gene you look at, the species you include, and the kind of position you count: every position, first and second codon positions (which mostly change the amino acid) or third positions (which mostly do not). The gene and species are invented to show the method.
What to recordFor each region: the number of positions compared, the number that differ between the species, and the percentage, counted separately for the two kinds of position. Graph the two percentages for each region and decide which hypothesis each region supports.

Find out

  • Which regions are conserved? Count every position in each of the four regions with all six species. Which regions differ least?
  • Function or slower mutation? For each region, count first and second positions, then third positions. A region where only third positions vary fits the function hypothesis; one where neither varies fits slower mutation.
  • Look at the amino acids. Show each region as amino acids. In which regions are the amino acids the same in every species, and are the bases the same there too?
  • Repeat with other species. Count each region again with three species at a time (P, Q, R, then S, T, U). Do the regions keep their order? How much do the percentages scatter?

Record

  • For every count: the region, the positions counted, the species included, the number of positions compared and the number that differ, and the percentage.
  • At least three counts for each region and kind of position, each with a different set of species. The graph shows each count as a point and the mean as a bar.
  • For each region, write which hypothesis the data support, and why. Say what other evidence would test it further.
  • Download the CSV to keep your table. Standard level students can do the tasks in the gene editing tool in chapter 2 instead.

In region B the first and second positions hardly ever differ, but third positions often do. Which hypothesis do the data support?

Region C differs little at every kind of position, even at the third positions where region B varies freely. Why can the data not settle, on their own, why it is conserved?

Why does a count with three species usually find fewer differing positions than the same count with six?

Back to the genetic code

Use the genetic code and natural selection to explain what your counts suggest about why regions A, B and C are, or are not, conserved.

03Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in. It opens on biologybybradford.com, so it needs the internet.

Exam practice

Exam questions on D1.3, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

04Downloads

This file is the guide, saved to run without the internet.

Saved from biologybybradford.com/guides/ib-biology-d1-3-mutation-and-gene-editing, where the guide is kept up to date with the notes, the revision sheet and, for the teacher, the lesson plans and slides.

05Teacher resources

The guide as three one-hour lessons, and two more at higher level. Each has a plan to print (the timings, what to project and where to stop, the activities with what they need, what students get wrong) and slides to teach it from, in the same order, with the teacher's moves in the notes.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1Three edits, and what a swapped base does D1.3.1 and D1.3.260 min Substitutions, insertions and deletions as changes to the base sequence, and why a substitution may be silent, missense or nonsense 1, 2 Lesson planPDF 628 KB SlidesPPTX 864 KB
2Sickle cell, and the shifted frame D1.3.2 and D1.3.360 min Sickle cell anaemia as a base substitution with a known effect, and why insertions and deletions usually stop a polypeptide working 3, 4 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 634 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 1.1 MB
3Causes, randomness and who inherits it D1.3.4 to D1.3.760 min Mutagens and copying errors, the sense in which mutation is random, germ and somatic mutations, and mutation as the source of variation 5, 6 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 632 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 689 KB
4Knock it out, cut it, edit it HL D1.3.8 and D1.3.960 min Gene knockout to find what a gene does, model organisms and knockout libraries, CRISPR-Cas9 and its use in sickle cell disease, and the ethics of editing 7, 8 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 662 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 4.2 MB
5Why some sequences never change HL D1.3.1060 min Conserved and highly conserved sequences, the function and slower mutation hypotheses, and testing them with sequence data 9, dry lab Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 592 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 610 KB

Lesson 1 is free with a free account. The other plans and slides, for every guide, come with the Teacher pass.

The note template, the revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTISE AND REVISE

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for D1.3

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.