D4.3.1 Anthropogenic causes of climate change
The blanket we keep thickening
- Greenhouse gases absorb infrared given off by the warm surface and re-emit some of it back down: the greenhouse effect.
- Climate change comes from adding to it. Anthropogenic carbon dioxide comes mostly from burning coal, oil and gas, with more from clearing and burning forests and making cement.
- Anthropogenic methane comes from cattle and sheep, flooded rice fields, landfill sites, and leaks from gas wells and coal mines.
- Positive correlation: both variables increase together. Negative correlation: one increases as the other decreases.
- A correlation does not prove causation. For carbon dioxide and temperature, other evidence confirms the cause.
The detail
- Sunlight passes through the atmosphere and warms the ground and the sea. The warm surface gives the energy off again as infrared.
- Greenhouse gases re-emit the infrared they absorb in every direction, some of it back down.
- Without the greenhouse effect the Earth would average about −18 °C instead of about 15 °C.
- Microbes in the guts of cattle and sheep make their methane.
- Methane is a far more powerful greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide molecule for molecule, but there is much less of it and it lasts only about a decade in the air.
In the exam
- The other evidence for the cause: carbon dioxide absorbs infrared, shown in the lab and seen from satellites.
How we know
- Charles Keeling began measuring carbon dioxide on Mauna Loa, Hawaii, in 1958. It was about 315 parts per million then and passed 420 ppm in 2023.
- The Keeling curve rises every year, and wiggles every year as the forests of the northern hemisphere take carbon dioxide up in summer and give it back in winter.
Sunlight passes through the atmosphere and warms the ground and the sea. The warm surface gives the energy off again as infrared, and some of that infrared is absorbed by greenhouse gases, which re-emit it in every direction, some of it back down. That is the greenhouse effect, and without it the Earth would average about −18 °C instead of about 15 °C.
Climate change is the trouble we have made by adding to it. Anthropogenic carbon dioxide comes mostly from burning coal, oil and gas, with more from clearing and burning forests and from making cement. Anthropogenic methane comes from cattle and sheep (microbes in their guts make it), flooded rice fields, landfill sites, and leaks from gas wells and coal mines. Methane is a far more powerful greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide molecule for molecule, but there is much less of it and it lasts only about a decade in the air.
Charles Keeling began measuring carbon dioxide on Mauna Loa, Hawaii, in 1958. It was about 315 parts per million then and passed 420 ppm in 2023. The Keeling curve rises every year and wiggles every year as the forests of the northern hemisphere take carbon dioxide up in summer and give it back in winter.
Ice cores from Antarctica show that over 800 000 years, temperature and carbon dioxide rose and fell together. What does this correlation show on its own?
A positive correlation: as one rises, so does the other. Correlation is not causation. In the ice ages, small changes in the Earth's orbit started the warming, and warmer oceans then released carbon dioxide, which warmed the Earth further. The evidence that carbon dioxide causes warming comes from elsewhere: the physics of how it absorbs infrared, laboratory measurements, and satellites that see less infrared escaping at exactly the wavelengths carbon dioxide absorbs.
Remember it Where the extra methane comes from
- CowsCattle and sheepmicrobes in the gut, out by belching
- RarelyRice paddieswaterlogged soil, no oxygen
- LeaveLandfillrotting rubbish, buried
- GasGas and coalleaks from wells, pipes and mines
- A positive correlation: both variables increase together. A negative correlation: one increases as the other decreases.
- A correlation does not prove that one variable causes the other.
- For carbon dioxide and temperature, other evidence confirms the cause: carbon dioxide absorbs infrared, shown in the lab and seen from satellites.
Simplified from the shape of the Vostok and EPICA records: illustrative, not data. Today’s 420 ppm is off the top of the scale.