Biology  by Bradford
support
IB BIOLOGY · THEME D · CONTINUITY AND CHANGE

A planet running a fever

Carbon dioxide on Mauna Loa has climbed every year since 1958. Here is why the extra greenhouse gas warms the planet, how the warming feeds itself, and what it is already doing to penguins, reefs, forests and the timing of spring.

IB Biology D4.3SL and HL3 hours SL, 4 HL12 chapters8 chapters at SLdry lab

Start learningRun the dry labTeach it

Follow sunlight in and infrared out, then zoom into the air to watch carbon dioxide and methane catch the heat.
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Twelve chapters: what causes the warming and how it feeds itself (chapters 1 to 3), what it does to ice, oceans, mountains and reefs (4 to 7), how living things can take carbon back (8), and at higher level how it shifts the timing of the year and drives evolution (9 to 12). Read one, play its figure through or tap its parts, and make each prediction before you open the answer.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1The blanket we keep thickening
  2. 2Warming that makes more warming
  3. 3When a forest stops storing carbon
  4. 4Standing on ice that leaves early
  5. 5When the deep water stops rising
  6. 6Moving uphill to stay cool
  7. 7Two threats to a reef
  8. 8Putting carbon back in the ground
  9. 9Reading the calendar of nature HL
  10. 10Arriving after the feast HL
  11. 11A third generation of beetles HL
  12. 12Grey owls, brown owls and snow HL

D4.3.1 Anthropogenic causes of climate change

The blanket we keep thickening

  • Greenhouse gases absorb infrared given off by the warm surface and re-emit some of it back down: the greenhouse effect.
  • Climate change comes from adding to it. Anthropogenic carbon dioxide comes mostly from burning coal, oil and gas, with more from clearing and burning forests and making cement.
  • Anthropogenic methane comes from cattle and sheep, flooded rice fields, landfill sites, and leaks from gas wells and coal mines.
  • Positive correlation: both variables increase together. Negative correlation: one increases as the other decreases.
  • A correlation does not prove causation. For carbon dioxide and temperature, other evidence confirms the cause.

The detail

  • Sunlight passes through the atmosphere and warms the ground and the sea. The warm surface gives the energy off again as infrared.
  • Greenhouse gases re-emit the infrared they absorb in every direction, some of it back down.
  • Without the greenhouse effect the Earth would average about −18 °C instead of about 15 °C.
  • Microbes in the guts of cattle and sheep make their methane.
  • Methane is a far more powerful greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide molecule for molecule, but there is much less of it and it lasts only about a decade in the air.

In the exam

  • The other evidence for the cause: carbon dioxide absorbs infrared, shown in the lab and seen from satellites.

How we know

  • Charles Keeling began measuring carbon dioxide on Mauna Loa, Hawaii, in 1958. It was about 315 parts per million then and passed 420 ppm in 2023.
  • The Keeling curve rises every year, and wiggles every year as the forests of the northern hemisphere take carbon dioxide up in summer and give it back in winter.

Sunlight passes through the atmosphere and warms the ground and the sea. The warm surface gives the energy off again as infrared, and some of that infrared is absorbed by greenhouse gases, which re-emit it in every direction, some of it back down. That is the greenhouse effect, and without it the Earth would average about −18 °C instead of about 15 °C.

Climate change is the trouble we have made by adding to it. Anthropogenic carbon dioxide comes mostly from burning coal, oil and gas, with more from clearing and burning forests and from making cement. Anthropogenic methane comes from cattle and sheep (microbes in their guts make it), flooded rice fields, landfill sites, and leaks from gas wells and coal mines. Methane is a far more powerful greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide molecule for molecule, but there is much less of it and it lasts only about a decade in the air.

Charles Keeling began measuring carbon dioxide on Mauna Loa, Hawaii, in 1958. It was about 315 parts per million then and passed 420 ppm in 2023. The Keeling curve rises every year and wiggles every year as the forests of the northern hemisphere take carbon dioxide up in summer and give it back in winter.

Ice cores from Antarctica show that over 800 000 years, temperature and carbon dioxide rose and fell together. What does this correlation show on its own?

Remember it Where the extra methane comes from

  • CowsCattle and sheepmicrobes in the gut, out by belching
  • RarelyRice paddieswaterlogged soil, no oxygen
  • LeaveLandfillrotting rubbish, buried
  • GasGas and coalleaks from wells, pipes and mines
In the exam Correlation and causation:
  1. A positive correlation: both variables increase together. A negative correlation: one increases as the other decreases.
  2. A correlation does not prove that one variable causes the other.
  3. For carbon dioxide and temperature, other evidence confirms the cause: carbon dioxide absorbs infrared, shown in the lab and seen from satellites.
Watch the whole film, or pick a level of carbon dioxide and compare how much infrared comes back down.
deeperis olderabout 3 kmbubbles ofancient airAntarcticice sheetcarbon dioxide (ppm)temperature (°C vs today)180240300−8−400100200300400thousands of years agoice agewarm420today

Simplified from the shape of the Vostok and EPICA records: illustrative, not data. Today’s 420 ppm is off the top of the scale.

D4.3.2 Positive feedback cycles in global warming

Warming that makes more warming

  • A positive feedback cycle: a change sets off effects that make the same change bigger, so warming becomes faster warming.
  • Snow and ice: as they melt, the dark ocean beneath absorbs the sunlight they reflected, warms, and melts more ice.
  • Deep ocean: warm water holds less dissolved carbon dioxide, so some stored in deep water returns to the air.
  • Peat and permafrost: warmer and drier, they decompose and release carbon dioxide; thawing, waterlogged permafrost releases methane.
  • Droughts and fires: hotter summers dry out forests, and more and bigger fires release the carbon in the trees and soil.

The detail

  • Global warming has several positive feedback cycles.
  • Snow and ice reflect most of the sunlight that hits them: a high albedo. The Arctic sea ice is one example.
  • Cold water holds more dissolved gas than warm water.
  • Peat is plant matter that never decomposed because it was waterlogged.
  • Permafrost holds the remains of plants frozen for thousands of years.

A positive feedback cycle is one where a change sets off effects that make the same change bigger. Global warming has several, and each one turns a warming into a faster warming.

Loss of snow and ice. Snow and ice reflect most of the sunlight that hits them (a high albedo). When the Arctic sea ice melts, the dark ocean beneath absorbs that light instead and warms, which melts more ice.

Carbon dioxide from the deep ocean. Cold water holds more dissolved gas than warm water. As the ocean warms it holds less carbon dioxide, and some that was stored in deep water returns to the air.

Peat and permafrost. Peat is plant matter that never decomposed because it was waterlogged; permafrost holds the remains of plants frozen for thousands of years. Warmer and drier, both start to decompose and release carbon dioxide, and thawing, waterlogged permafrost releases methane.

Droughts and forest fires. Hotter summers dry out forests, and more and bigger fires burn, releasing the carbon in the trees and soil.

Remember it The five feedback loops

  • IcyIce and snowless reflected, more absorbed
  • OceansOceanwarm water holds less CO₂
  • PushPeatdries out and decomposes
  • PolarPermafrostthaws, releases CO₂ and methane
  • FiresFires and droughtburn stored carbon

Why is the thawing of permafrost a positive feedback, not a negative one?

Follow each feedback loop round: sea ice, ocean, permafrost and forest fire. Each turn adds a little more warming.

D4.3.3 Change from net carbon accumulation to net loss in boreal forests as an example of a tipping point

When a forest stops storing carbon

  • For thousands of years the taiga (boreal forest) has taken in more carbon than it gives out: net carbon accumulation.
  • Warmer temperatures and less winter snow bring more drought, so primary production falls and the forest browns (forest browning).
  • Fires become more frequent and more intense, burning old carbon stores in soil and peat: legacy carbon combustion.
  • Once losses beat growth, the forest flips from a net sink to a net source of carbon: a tipping point.

The detail

  • The taiga runs in a belt across Canada, Alaska, Scandinavia and Siberia.
  • It stores carbon because the trees grow, and the cold, waterlogged soil and peat keep dead matter from decomposing.
  • It holds more carbon than any other land biome, most of it in the soil.
  • Less winter snow means less meltwater in spring, so the soil dries.
  • Drought stress cuts photosynthesis. In forest browning, stands of trees turn brown and die back.
  • Dry, dead trees burn.
  • An intense fire burns more than the trees: it burns down into the soil and peat, through organic matter that had survived earlier, lighter fires for centuries.
  • The forest loses carbon in fires and decomposition and gains it by growth.
  • At the tipping point the forest now speeds up the warming that tipped it.

The taiga, or boreal forest, runs in a belt across Canada, Alaska, Scandinavia and Siberia. For thousands of years it has taken in more carbon than it gives out: the trees grow, and the cold, waterlogged soil and peat keep dead matter from decomposing. It holds more carbon than any other land biome, most of it in the soil.

Warming changes that. Summers are hotter and winters bring less snow, so there is less meltwater in spring and the soil dries. Drought stress cuts photosynthesis, so primary production falls, and stands of trees turn brown and die back, called forest browning. Dry, dead trees burn, and fires become more frequent and more intense.

An intense fire burns more than the trees. It burns down into the soil and peat, through organic matter that had survived earlier, lighter fires for centuries. Burning that old store is called legacy carbon combustion. Once a forest loses more carbon in fires and decomposition than it gains by growth, it has flipped from a net sink to a net source of carbon. That is a tipping point: the forest now speeds up the warming that tipped it.

Fires have always burned in the taiga. Why does legacy carbon combustion matter so much?

  • Warmer temperatures and less winter snow: more drought.
  • Drought: less primary production, forest browning.
  • More frequent, more intense fires: legacy carbon combustion.
  • Net carbon accumulation flips to net carbon loss: a tipping point.
CO₂ taken inoutless taken inCO₂ given outpeat, metres deepcold, wet: slow decaypermafrostfrozen all yearpeat burnsold carbon releasedpermafrost thawsits dead matter decayssnow, cold, wetdrought, heatcarboneach yearingrowthoutdecaynet sinkingrowthoutfire,decaynet source

Switch between the forest storing carbon and the forest after it tips.

D4.3.4 Melting of landfast ice and sea ice as examples of polar habitat change

Standing on ice that leaves early

  • Landfast ice is sea ice frozen fast to the coast: the Antarctic breeding ground of the emperor penguin (Aptenodytes forsteri).
  • If it breaks out early, chicks fall into the sea before they can swim, and drown or freeze.
  • Arctic sea ice is the resting platform for walruses (Odobenus rosmarus) between feeding dives.
  • As sea ice retreats, walruses haul out on land instead, far from their food.

The detail

  • Emperor penguins breed in the depth of the Antarctic winter.
  • The female lays one egg in May or June, and the male holds it on his feet through the winter.
  • The chick must grow its waterproof feathers before the ice breaks up in December or January.
  • Emperors can move to a new site, but if the landfast ice goes from much of the coast, there is nowhere left to go.
  • Walruses feed on clams and worms on the shallow seabed.
  • Summer sea ice is retreating north, beyond the shallow feeding grounds of the Chukchi Sea.
  • On land they gather tens of thousands together, and have to swim much farther to feed. In a crowd that panics, calves are crushed.

In the exam

  • Either the common name or the scientific name is acceptable.

Examples

  • Halley Bay, then the second-largest emperor colony, failed almost completely from 2016 onwards.
  • In 2022, four of the five colonies in the central Bellingshausen Sea lost nearly every chick when the ice melted early.
  • Walruses haul out on beaches such as Point Lay in Alaska.

Emperor penguins (Aptenodytes forsteri) breed in the depth of the Antarctic winter, on landfast ice: sea ice frozen fast to the coast. The female lays one egg in May or June, the male holds it on his feet through the winter, and the chick must grow its waterproof feathers before the ice breaks up in December or January. If the ice breaks out early, the chicks fall into the sea before they can swim, and drown or freeze.

That is what happened at Halley Bay, then the second-largest colony, which failed almost completely from 2016 onwards. In 2022, four of the five colonies in the central Bellingshausen Sea lost nearly every chick when the ice melted early. Emperors can move to a new site, but if the landfast ice goes from much of the coast, there is nowhere left to go.

In the Arctic, walruses (Odobenus rosmarus) feed on clams and worms on the shallow seabed and rest on floating sea ice between dives. As summer sea ice retreats north, beyond the shallow feeding grounds of the Chukchi Sea, walruses haul out on land instead, tens of thousands together on beaches such as Point Lay in Alaska. They have to swim much farther to feed, and in a crowd that panics, calves are crushed.

Why does an early break-up of landfast ice harm emperor penguins, even if the ice forms again the next winter?

In the exam Polar habitat change:
  1. Landfast ice (Antarctic): breeding ground of the emperor penguin; early break-out drowns chicks before they fledge.
  2. Sea ice (Arctic): resting platform for walruses between feeding dives; its loss forces them onto land, far from food.
Antarctica: emperor penguinsice fast to the coastmust last into Decemberearly break-outchicks fall inice retreats northArctic: walrusesshallow seabed: fooddeep water

Tap a part to read about it. Not to scale.

D4.3.5 Changes in ocean currents altering the timing and extent of nutrient upwelling

When the deep water stops rising

  • Where winds blow surface water away from a coast, cold, nutrient-rich water rises from below: upwelling.
  • Upwelling feeds the phytoplankton, which need light near the surface and nitrate, phosphate and iron from the deep.
  • Warmer surface water is lighter, so the layers stop mixing (stratified). Upwelling can weaken, start later or stop.
  • With fewer nutrients, primary production falls and less energy flows up the food chain to fish, seabirds and mammals.

The detail

  • Nutrients sink to the deep ocean in dead organisms and droppings.
  • In stratified water, winds have to work harder to bring deep water up.

Examples

  • Upwelling supports some of the richest fisheries in the world: anchovies off Peru, sardines off California and South Africa.
  • El Niño: warm water spreads east across the Pacific, the upwelling off Peru shuts down, and the anchovy catch crashes, as it did in 1972 and 1983.

Phytoplankton need light, which they find only near the surface, and nitrate, phosphate and iron, which sink to the deep ocean in dead organisms and droppings. Where winds blow surface water away from a coast, cold, nutrient-rich water rises from below to replace it. This upwelling feeds the phytoplankton, and with them some of the richest fisheries in the world: anchovies off Peru, sardines off California and South Africa.

Warming the surface makes it lighter than the cold water below. The layers stop mixing (the water becomes stratified), and winds have to work harder to bring deep water up. Upwelling can weaken, start later in the season or stop altogether. With fewer nutrients, primary production falls, and less energy flows up the food chain to fish, seabirds and mammals.

An El Niño shows what this looks like. Warm water spreads east across the Pacific, the upwelling off Peru shuts down, and the anchovy catch crashes, as it did in 1972 and 1983.

Why does warm surface water reduce primary production in the sea, when warmth usually speeds photosynthesis up?

Wind pushes surface water away from the coast and deep water rises. Warm the surface and watch the upwelling weaken.

D4.3.6 Poleward and upslope range shifts of temperate species

Moving uphill to stay cool

  • Each species lives within a range of temperatures it can tolerate. As the climate warms, those places move poleward and upslope.
  • Populations follow by dispersal: they spread where the new range opens and die out where the old one closes. That is a range shift.
  • Most bird species on Mount Karimui in New Guinea moved uphill between 1965 and 2012, on average by around 100 metres.
  • Many North American trees spread north at their cold edge, but more contract at their warm edge, so their ranges shrink overall.

The detail

  • Towards the poles and up mountains is where it is cooler.
  • Karimui’s shift is about what the 0.4 °C of local warming would predict.
  • Bird species already at the summit had nowhere to go, and some had shrunk to a strip at the very top.
  • North American tree species are not moving north as neat belts. At the warm edge there are few new seedlings.
  • Trees spread slowly, by seed, one generation at a time, and the climate is moving faster.

How we know

  • Jared Diamond recorded the elevations of the birds on Mount Karimui, Papua New Guinea, in 1965. Ben and Alexandra Freeman surveyed the same slope in 2012.
  • Tree surveys compare seedlings (where trees are establishing now) with adult trees (where they established decades ago).

Every species lives within a range of temperatures it can tolerate. As the climate warms, the places within that range move: towards the poles, and up mountains, where it is cooler. Populations follow by dispersal. A species spreads where its new range opens and dies out where its old one closes. That is a range shift.

On Mount Karimui in Papua New Guinea, Jared Diamond recorded the elevations of the birds in 1965. Ben and Alexandra Freeman surveyed the same slope in 2012. Most of the species had moved uphill, on average by around 100 metres, about what the 0.4 °C of local warming would predict. Species already at the summit had nowhere to go, and some had shrunk to a strip at the very top.

In North America, tree species are not moving north as neat belts. Surveys comparing seedlings (where trees are establishing now) with adult trees (where they established decades ago) find many species spreading north at their cold edge, but more of them contracting at their warm edge, with few new seedlings there, so their ranges are shrinking overall. Trees spread slowly, by seed, one generation at a time, and the climate is moving faster.

A bird lives only near the top of a mountain in New Guinea. Why is it more at risk from warming than a bird that lives halfway up?

no higher1000 m1500 m2000 m2500 mlowmidsummitbird rangesMount Karimui, New Guinea1965: Jared Diamond surveys2012: surveyed again, +0.4 °C

Switch between the two surveys of the same slope.

D4.3.7 Threats to coral reefs as an example of potential ecosystem collapse

Two threats to a reef

  • Reefs are built by coral polyps laying down calcium carbonate skeletons. Zooxanthellae, algae in their cells, give most of the coral’s food.
  • Increased carbon dioxide: ocean acidification, fewer carbonate ions, so calcification is suppressed.
  • Increased water temperature: bleaching. The zooxanthellae are expelled and the coral starves.
  • Loss of corals: collapse of the reef ecosystem.

The detail

  • The zooxanthellae are photosynthetic. They feed the coral in return for shelter and the coral’s waste nutrients.
  • A quarter of all marine species live on reefs, in less than 1% of the ocean.
  • About a quarter of the carbon dioxide we release dissolves in the sea. There it forms carbonic acid, which lowers the pH and uses up carbonate ions.
  • Corals need carbonate ions to build their skeletons, so with fewer of them skeletons grow more slowly and are weaker.
  • The sea’s surface pH has fallen from about 8.2 to 8.1 since 1750, a rise of about 30% in hydrogen ions.
  • Bleaching starts when the water stays 1 °C or more above the usual summer maximum for weeks: the zooxanthellae are damaged, and without them the coral turns white.
  • If the heat ends soon, the algae can return; if not, the coral dies.
  • Dead coral is covered by seaweed and broken down by waves and burrowing animals. The fish and invertebrates that depended on its shelter go.

In the exam

  • Keep the two causes apart: carbon dioxide causes acidification, temperature causes bleaching.

Examples

  • The Great Barrier Reef bleached on a mass scale in 1998, 2002, 2016, 2017, 2020, 2022 and 2024.

A coral reef is built by tiny animals, coral polyps, that lay down skeletons of calcium carbonate. Inside the cells of each polyp live photosynthetic algae, zooxanthellae, which give the coral most of its food in return for shelter and the coral's waste nutrients. A quarter of all marine species live on reefs, in less than 1% of the ocean.

Ocean acidification. About a quarter of the carbon dioxide we release dissolves in the sea. There it forms carbonic acid, which lowers the pH and uses up carbonate ions. Corals need carbonate ions to build their skeletons, so with fewer of them, calcification is suppressed: skeletons grow more slowly and are weaker. The sea's surface pH has fallen from about 8.2 to 8.1 since 1750, a rise of about 30% in hydrogen ions.

Coral bleaching. When the water stays 1 °C or more above the usual summer maximum for weeks, the zooxanthellae are damaged and the coral expels them. Without them it turns white, and it starves. If the heat ends soon, the algae can return; if not, the coral dies. The Great Barrier Reef bleached on a mass scale in 1998, 2002, 2016, 2017, 2020, 2022 and 2024.

Dead coral is covered by seaweed and broken down by waves and burrowing animals. The fish and invertebrates that depended on its shelter go, and the reef ecosystem collapses.

Which change causes coral bleaching?

In the exam Keep the two causes apart:
  1. Increased carbon dioxide: ocean acidification, fewer carbonate ions, calcification suppressed.
  2. Increased water temperature: bleaching, the zooxanthellae are expelled and the coral starves.
  3. Loss of corals: collapse of the reef ecosystem.
water: normal1 °C or more above normalfor weeksthe heat lasted too longalgae smother the dead coralone polyptissue full ofzooxanthellae:algae that feed italgae expelled:white skeletonshows throughand it starvespolyp dead:seaweed growson the skeleton

Switch between a healthy reef, a bleached one and one that did not recover.

Carbon dioxide dissolves in a tropical sea and takes up carbonate ions. Compare 1750, today and two futures for 2100.

D4.3.8 Afforestation, forest regeneration and restoration of peat-forming wetlands as approaches to carbon sequestration

Putting carbon back in the ground

  • Carbon sequestration takes carbon dioxide out of the air and locks it away. Three ways use living things.
  • Afforestation: planting trees where there has been no forest for a long time. Forest regeneration: letting a forest grow back, or helping it, where it was cleared or burnt.
  • Restoring peat-forming wetlands: raising the water table again in a drained bog, often by blocking the drainage ditches.
  • Peat forms naturally in temperate and boreal zones, and very fast in some tropical swamps.
  • There is active scientific debate over whether plantations of non-native trees or rewilding with native species is the best approach.

The detail

  • Growing trees take up carbon dioxide in photosynthesis and store the carbon in wood and roots, and in the soil as their leaves decay.
  • Peat forms when plants such as Sphagnum moss die in waterlogged, acidic, oxygen-poor water, where decomposers can barely work, so their carbon builds up.
  • The temperate and boreal zones where peat forms are cool and wet.
  • Peatlands cover 3% of the land but hold about twice as much carbon as all the world’s forests.

Examples

  • Tropical swamps where peat forms very fast include those of Borneo and the Congo basin.

Carbon sequestration takes carbon dioxide out of the air and locks it away. Three ways use living things to do it.

Afforestation is planting trees where there has been no forest for a long time. Forest regeneration is letting a forest grow back, or helping it to, where it was cleared or burnt. Growing trees take up carbon dioxide in photosynthesis and store the carbon in wood and roots, and in the soil as their leaves decay.

Restoring peat-forming wetlands means raising the water table again in a drained bog, often by blocking the drainage ditches. Peat forms when plants such as Sphagnum moss die in waterlogged, acidic, oxygen-poor water, where decomposers can barely work, so their carbon builds up. Peat forms naturally in the cool, wet temperate and boreal zones, and very fast in some tropical swamps, such as those of Borneo and the Congo basin. Peatlands cover 3% of the land but hold about twice as much carbon as all the world's forests.

Plantation of fast-growing non-native treesRewilding with native species
Takes up carbon fast while young (Sitka spruce in Scotland, eucalyptus in Brazil)Grows more slowly at first, but builds a store that lasts
Often harvested every 30 to 50 years, which sends much of the carbon backLeft standing, so the carbon stays in old trees and soil
One species: little habitat, and at risk from one pest or diseaseMany species: habitat for wildlife, and more resilient
Planting on peat or grassland can release more soil carbon than the trees take upFits the soils and the ecosystem already there

Scientists still argue whether plantations or native forests are better for carbon. Why can't a quick measurement settle it?

CO₂CO₂tree guards on new saplingsAfforestationplanting new forestCO₂carbon builds in dark forest soilRegenerationletting forest returnCO₂dam in the ditchwater table raisedpeat: moss that dies but barely decaysPeat restorationrewetting a bog

Tap a landscape to read how it stores carbon.

D4.3.9 Phenology as research into the timing of biological events

Reading the calendar of nature

  • Phenology is the study of when things happen in nature: when buds burst and leaves fall, when plants flower, when birds arrive, nest and leave.
  • Organisms time these events by cues. Photoperiod, the length of the day, is the same on a given date every year: a reliable calendar.
  • Temperature varies from year to year, but it tracks the season as it actually arrives.
  • In many deciduous trees a run of warm days sets off budburst; shortening days often trigger bud set.
  • Many birds start migrating as the days lengthen, and lay their eggs when spring warmth has arrived.

The detail

  • Bud set is in autumn, when trees stop growing and form winter buds.

How we know

  • Some of the longest records in science are phenological.
  • Robert Marsham noted the first signs of spring on his estate in Norfolk from 1736, and his family kept it up for nearly two centuries.
  • The court in Kyoto recorded the day the cherry trees flowered for over a thousand years.

Phenology is the study of when things happen in nature: when buds burst and leaves fall, when plants flower, when birds arrive, nest and leave. Some of the longest records in science are phenological. Robert Marsham noted the first signs of spring on his estate in Norfolk from 1736, and his family kept it up for nearly two centuries. The court in Kyoto recorded the day the cherry trees flowered for over a thousand years.

Organisms time these events by cues from the environment. Photoperiod, the length of the day, is the same on a given date every year, so it is a reliable calendar. Temperature varies from year to year, but it tracks the season as it actually arrives. Many deciduous trees need a run of warm days to set off budburst in spring, while bud set in autumn, when they stop growing and form winter buds, is often triggered by shortening days. Many birds start migrating as the days lengthen, and lay their eggs when spring warmth has arrived.

Which cue would let a tree burst its buds earlier in a warm spring, and later in a cold one?

JFMAMJJASONDday lengthtemperaturetwo cues through the yearthe same every year, or notbudburstwarmthgreat tits laywarmthbirds migratelonger daysbud setshorter daysbirds migratesame datebudburstearliergreat tits layearlierbud setsame datewarmer year
  1. Two cues. Day length follows the same curve every year. Temperature follows the season as it actually comes, and differs from year to year.
  2. Cued by warmth. Budburst in many trees, and egg laying in many birds, follow a run of warm days.
  3. Cued by day length. Birds start migrating as the days lengthen; trees set their winter buds as the days shorten.
  4. A warmer year. The warmth-cued events move earlier. The day-length events stay put, so the two can fall out of step.

D4.3.10 Disruption to the synchrony of phenological events by climate change

Arriving after the feast

  • Within one ecosystem, one population may time its year by temperature and another by photoperiod.
  • As the climate warms, temperature-cued events move earlier and photoperiod-cued ones stay on the same date, so they fall out of synchrony: a phenological mismatch.
  • Greenland: the Arctic mouse-ear chickweed (Cerastium arcticum) grows earlier, but reindeer (Rangifer tarandus) still arrive by day length, so fewer calves survive.
  • European oak woods: the caterpillar peak has moved earlier than great tit (Parus major) breeding, so chicks hatch after the feast.

The detail

  • While the climate was steady, the two populations kept in step.
  • In West Greenland the chickweed and other tundra plants grow in spring as the temperature rises, and grow earlier as the Arctic warms.
  • Reindeer migrate to their calving grounds timed by day length, so they arrive on the same date as before. By then the plants are past their best and the calves get less nutritious food.
  • Winter moth caterpillars hatch as the oak leaves open, timed by temperature, and reach a peak of biomass in a burst of two or three weeks.
  • Great tits need that peak to feed their chicks, and time their laying partly by day length. The mismatch shows in warm springs.

In the exam

  • Either the common name or the scientific name is acceptable.

How we know

  • Wytham Woods near Oxford, where great tits have been studied since 1947, has shown the birds laying earlier, but not always by enough.

Within one ecosystem, one population may time its year by temperature and another by photoperiod. While the climate was steady, the two kept in step. As it warms, the temperature-cued events move earlier and the photoperiod-cued ones do not, and the two drift apart: a phenological mismatch.

In West Greenland, the Arctic mouse-ear chickweed (Cerastium arcticum) and other tundra plants grow in spring as the temperature rises, and grow earlier as the Arctic warms. Reindeer (Rangifer tarandus) migrate to their calving grounds timed by day length, so they arrive on the same date as before. By then the plants are past their best, the calves get less nutritious food, and fewer survive.

In the oak woods of northern Europe, winter moth caterpillars hatch as the oak leaves open, timed by temperature, and reach a peak of biomass in a burst of two or three weeks. Great tits (Parus major) need that peak to feed their chicks, and time their laying partly by day length. In warm springs the caterpillar peak has moved earlier than the birds' breeding, and chicks hatch after the feast. Wytham Woods near Oxford, where great tits have been studied since 1947, has shown the birds laying earlier, but not always by enough.

Great tits in Wytham Woods now lay about two weeks earlier than in the 1960s. What does this suggest?

  • Temperature cue: the event shifts earlier as the climate warms.
  • Photoperiod cue: the event stays on the same date.
  • Two linked populations on different cues fall out of synchrony.
  • Examples: chickweed and reindeer in Greenland; caterpillars and great tits in European oak woods.
Warm the spring and watch the caterpillar peak move earlier. The great tits lay only a little earlier, so their chicks hatch later and later after the feast.

D4.3.11 Increases to the number of insect life cycles within a year due to climate change

A third generation of beetles

  • The European spruce bark beetle (Ips typographus) bores under the bark of Norway spruce; its larvae eat the living tissue and the tree dies.
  • A beetle needs a set amount of warmth to develop from egg to adult, and flies to a new tree only once spring air reaches about 16.5 °C.
  • Warmer springs start the flight earlier and long hot summers speed development, so more generations fit into a year.
  • Each generation multiplies the population, and drought weakens the spruce at the same time.

The detail

  • The females lay eggs in tunnels under the bark.
  • In a cold year, or in the far north and high in the mountains, a population fits in only one generation before autumn. In a warm year in central Europe there is time for two.
  • Beetles in the lowlands now often complete two generations and a sister brood, and in the hottest years a third.
  • Drought-weakened spruce makes less resin to drown the beetles.
  • Dead forests stop taking up carbon and begin to release it: another positive feedback.

In the exam

  • Either the common name or the scientific name is acceptable.

Examples

  • In the hottest years, such as 2018, the lowland beetles fitted in a third generation.
  • After the hot, dry summers from 2018, outbreaks killed spruce over hundreds of thousands of hectares across Germany and the Czech Republic.

The European spruce bark beetle (Ips typographus) bores under the bark of Norway spruce. The females lay eggs in tunnels, the larvae eat the living tissue under the bark and the tree dies. A beetle needs a set amount of warmth to develop from egg to adult, and it only flies to a new tree once the air is warm enough in spring, at about 16.5 °C.

In a cold year, or in the far north and high in the mountains, a population fits in only one generation before autumn. In a warm year in central Europe there is time for two. With warmer springs starting the flight earlier and long hot summers speeding development, beetles in the lowlands now often complete two generations and a sister brood, and in the hottest years, such as 2018, a third. Each generation multiplies the population.

Drought weakens the spruce at the same time, so it makes less resin to drown the beetles. After the hot, dry summers from 2018, outbreaks killed spruce over hundreds of thousands of hectares across Germany and the Czech Republic. Those dead forests stopped taking up carbon and began to release it, another positive feedback.

Why does a warmer year allow more generations of bark beetles?

MAMJJASO01020°CtemperatureA cold year, or far northone generation1st2ndcannot finishtemperatureA warm year in central Europetwo generations1st2ndtemperatureA hot year, such as 2018three generations1st2nd3rdbeetles fly above 16.5 °Cegglarvapupaadultabout 6 to 10 weeksegg to adult in summergalleries under the bark

Switch between a cold, a warm and a hot year.

D4.3.12 Evolution as a consequence of climate change

Grey owls, brown owls and snow

  • Tawny owls (Strix aluco) come in two colour variants, grey and brown, and colour is a heritable variation.
  • In snowy, cold winters grey owls have higher fitness (better survival). In mild winters with little snow the difference disappears.
  • As winters warm and snow cover shrinks, selection against brown weakens, and the brown variant becomes much more common.
  • A change in the frequency of an inherited variant in a population is evolution: here climate change drives it by changing each colour’s fitness.

The detail

  • The grey blends with snowy forest and may cope better with cold.
  • Brown owls rose from about one owl in eight in the 1960s to around four in ten.

In the exam

  • Either the common name or the scientific name is acceptable.

How we know

  • In Finland, near the northern edge of the species’ range, Patrik Karell and colleagues followed tawny owls for nearly thirty years.

Tawny owls (Strix aluco) come in two colour variants, grey and brown, and the colour is inherited. In Finland, near the northern edge of the species' range, Patrik Karell and colleagues followed tawny owls for nearly thirty years. In winters with deep snow and hard cold, grey owls survived better than brown ones: the grey blends with snowy forest and may cope better with cold. In mild winters with little snow, the difference disappeared.

As Finnish winters warmed and snow cover shrank, the selection against brown owls weakened, and the brown variant became much more common, rising from about one owl in eight in the 1960s to around four in ten. A change in the frequency of an inherited variant in a population is evolution, and here climate change has driven it by changing the fitness of each colour.

Why is the rise in brown tawny owls an example of evolution, and not just a change in the owls' plumage?

In the exam Evolution from climate change:
  1. Colour (grey or brown) is a heritable variation.
  2. Snowy winters: grey owls have higher fitness (better survival).
  3. Less snow as winters warm: selection against brown weakens.
  4. The frequency of brown owls rises: evolution.
greybrownbrown stands out against snowgreybrownboth blend inwinter survivalsnowy, cold wintergreybrownwinter survivalmild wintergreybrownillustrativeillustrativeTawny owls in southern Finland1960s1 in 8 brown2010s4 in 10 brownshorter, milder winterswith less snow covergreybrowncolour is inherited

Switch between a snowy winter, a mild winter and the change over fifty years.

02Dry lab: Reading an ice core

Drill down through 400 000 years of Antarctic ice. Take samples, read the carbon dioxide trapped in each bubble and the temperature when the snow fell, plot them and test the correlation.

1 km2 km3 kmCO₂ in air276ppmtemperature+0.6°CICE SHEETCORE LAB9 of 21 cut2 326 m · 240 000 y agobubbles of airgas analyserthe ice itselfisotope ratio
The bench: the drill works down through 400 000 years of Antarctic ice. Each sample gives the carbon dioxide in its air bubbles and, from the ice itself, the temperature when the snow fell.
Your questionDo carbon dioxide and temperature rise and fall together over the ice ages, and does that prove one causes the other? Snow that falls on Antarctica each year is buried and turned to ice, trapping bubbles of the air of the time.
What you can changeWhich stretch of the core to sample, all 400 000 years or the last warming, and how closely to space the samples. Add the present-day reading from the air at the end.
What to recordThe depth, the age, the carbon dioxide in parts per million and the temperature compared with today for each sample. The graph plots both against age, and a scatter graph tests the correlation. Download the CSV to plot your own.

Find out

  • The whole record. Sample the core every 20 000 years from the top to 400 000 years. Describe the pattern of carbon dioxide and of temperature, and count the ice ages.
  • Test the correlation. Look at the scatter graph of carbon dioxide against temperature. Is the correlation positive or negative, and how strong is it (the value of r)?
  • Zoom into a warming. Sample the last deglaciation, from 20 000 to 10 000 years ago, every 1000 years. Which rises first, temperature or carbon dioxide?
  • Today. Add the present-day carbon dioxide reading. How far is it outside the range of the last 400 000 years?
  • Back to the climate. Why does your correlation not prove that carbon dioxide causes warming, and how could carbon dioxide released by a warming ocean still have added to it?

Record

  • The depth, the age, the carbon dioxide (ppm) and the temperature difference from today (°C) for every sample.
  • The highest and lowest carbon dioxide and temperature in the record, and the dates of each warm interglacial.
  • The correlation coefficient shown under the scatter graph, and whether it is positive or negative.
  • Download the CSV to plot your own graphs.

The scatter graph shows a strong positive correlation between carbon dioxide and temperature. Which conclusion is justified by this data alone?

In the zoomed record, Antarctic temperature starts to rise a few centuries before carbon dioxide does. How can carbon dioxide still have contributed to the warming?

Back to the climate

Your scatter graph shows a strong positive correlation. Why does that not prove that carbon dioxide causes warming, and how could carbon dioxide still have added to the warming at the end of an ice age?

03Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in.

Exam practice

Exam questions on D4.3, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

D4.3 revision mapD4.3 exam questionsD4.3 multiple choice quizD4.3 pub quizD4.3 Tarsia puzzleD4.3 dominoesBack: D4.2 stability and changeLinked: C4.2 the carbon cycle and the Keeling curveLinked: D4.1 natural selection

04Downloads

Take the guide with you, or into a classroom with no internet.

05Teacher resources

The guide as three one-hour lessons, and one more at higher level. Each has a plan to print (the timings, what to project and where to stop, the activities with what they need, what students get wrong) and slides to teach it from, in the same order, with the teacher's moves in the notes.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1Causes and feedbacks D4.3.1, D4.3.260 min How carbon dioxide and methane from human activity warm the planet, correlation and causation in the ice core record, and the positive feedbacks that speed the warming 1, 2, dry lab Lesson planPDF 697 KB SlidesPPTX 9.1 MB
2Forests, ice and oceans D4.3.3 to D4.3.560 min The boreal forest as a tipping point, melting landfast ice and sea ice, and how warmer surface water cuts nutrient upwelling 3, 4, 5 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 629 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 4.0 MB
3Range shifts, reefs and sequestration D4.3.6 to D4.3.860 min Upslope and poleward range shifts, the two threats to coral reefs, and the debate over how best to lock carbon away 6, 7, 8 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 653 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 3.8 MB
4Timing and evolution HL HL D4.3.9 to D4.3.1260 min Phenology and its cues, mismatch between linked species, extra generations of bark beetles, and climate-driven evolution in tawny owls 9, 10, 11, 12 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 661 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 3.9 MB

Lesson 1 is free with a free account. The other plans and slides, for every guide, come with the Teacher pass.

The note template, the revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTISE AND REVISE

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for D4.3

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.