Every November the same post turns up in the teacher groups: has anyone mapped the questions to the topics yet? Someone always plans to. So I did, for every session the new course has had: the specimen papers, May 2025 (three time zones), November 2025 (two), May 2026 and November 2026. Eight sets of papers, every question part, SL and HL, matched to the syllabus statement it tests. That’s 1,367 parts and about 2,100 marks, and the totals are all on one page now: What the IB set.
I went in hoping to find a pattern I could teach to. I came out with a picture I can’t unsee. Someone pins the specimen paper to the wall, turns round, and fires a shotgun at it. Wherever the pellets land, that’s this year’s paper. Nobody actually does that, of course. It’s a picture, not a method. But the pellets below are real: each one is about two marks, on the subtopic the IB really set them.
That’s a little unfair. It’s also not that unfair. Here’s why.
Steady from a distance, chaos up close.
From the back of the room, the five sessions look reassuringly similar. Each carries about 265 marks across SL and HL. Between 34% and 42% of the marks sit under a figure, graph or table every time, and AO3 (analyse, evaluate, suggest) takes 38% to 47%. If you’ve been teaching students to read the picture before the biology, keep going: that’s the one thing every paper has rewarded.
The themes drift a little. Year by year, Continuity and change (theme D) has gone 27%, 31%, 28%, 31%, 34% of the marks, while Unity and diversity (theme A) has slid from 23% in the specimen to 18% and 19% in 2025 and 15% in both 2026 sessions. Fine. Papers have to lean somewhere.
Then you zoom in to the subtopics, and it gets silly.
Adaptation to environment went from nothing at all in the specimen to 16 marks in November 2026, by way of 5, 15 and 6. Photosynthesis, which you’d think was a fixture, was absent from the specimen and peaked at 17 marks in May 2026. Nucleic acids had 18 marks in the specimen and has scraped 3 in the two 2026 sessions put together.
And it isn’t only session to session. In November 2025 the two time zones sat different papers on the same days. One gave adaptation to environment 27 marks. The other gave it 3. Same course, same week, a 24-mark difference depending on which side of the world your school is on.
It’s the same at the level of the syllabus statements. Each set of papers touches roughly a quarter of the guide’s 549 statements, 23% to 31%. Only 14 statements have come up in all five sessions, and only one in all eight sets of papers. After five sessions, 103 statements have never been the focus of a single question part, and 44 of those are on the SL course.
A fair caveat: five sessions is still a small sample, the specimen isn’t a live exam, and no paper of this length could ever touch 549 statements. Sampling is what exams do. So the question isn’t whether the IB samples the syllabus. It’s how, and whether we’re allowed to know.
What that feels like from the front of the room.
Take action potentials. “Nerve impulses as action potentials that are propagated along nerve fibres” is on the SL course. It’s one of the hardest ideas in the guide to get across: gradients, channels, a wave that isn’t really a wave. You spend a week on it. A student who has fought with it all term finally gets it, and can explain it beautifully.
In eight sets of papers, that statement hasn’t been the focus of a single question part. Not one. When SL papers have gone near nerves at all, they’ve asked about the speed of an impulse. HL students have had better luck: depolarisation and repolarisation came up in five of the eight sets. But an SL student who mastered action potentials has, so far, had nowhere to show it.
That’s the bit that stings. To get a 7 in IB Biology you have to be good at biology, yes. You also need near-forensic attention to detail, a run through the syllabus with a fine-tooth comb, and then, on top of all that, some luck. When a subtopic can be worth 27 marks in one time zone and 3 in the other, the draw matters.
And then there’s the single word. A question turns on plastid: a word the student skimmed past in revision, and, if we’re honest, maybe a word their teacher skimmed past in October. Is that testing biology? Or is it testing whether we all read every line of the guide with a highlighter?
Hard, absolutely. A guessing game, no.
I don’t think anyone at the IB sets out to catch teachers out. But that’s what it can feel like. There’s a kind of prestige that comes from an exam being hard to predict, and I’m not convinced it’s the same thing as rigour. An externally moderated exam should be something you can prepare a student for.
Meanwhile, across the Atlantic.
I teach AP Biology too, and the contrast is hard to ignore. The College Board publishes a weighting for every unit. You know roughly how much of the exam each unit will be before you’ve planned a single lesson.
The free-response section is just as open about itself. Six questions, always the same six types: two long ones (interpreting and evaluating experimental results, once with graphing and once without), then a scientific investigation, a conceptual analysis, an analysis of a model or visual, and an analysis of data. You can teach a student what each type wants, practise it, and watch them get better at it.
And getting a 5 is still hard. Telling teachers what’s coming hasn’t made the exam easy. It’s made it fair. The students who do well are the ones who know the biology and can use it, not the ones who happened to revise the right subtopic.
I’m not saying the AP is better. The IB does things I’d fight to keep: a whole data-based paper, extended responses that ask students to build an argument, and an IA that makes them do real science. I’m saying one exam board has decided that telling teachers the rules makes for a better exam, and the other hasn’t.
Some questions I’d love answered.
- Would the IB lose anything by publishing a rough weighting per theme, the way the College Board does per unit?
- If a subtopic can be worth 27 marks in one time zone and 3 in the other, how much of a 7 is biology and how much is the draw?
- When a question turns on one word, is it testing understanding, or testing whether the class proofread the guide?
- Is a hard-to-predict exam the same thing as a rigorous one?
- Who does the vagueness actually help?
I don’t have the answers. I do have the data, and I’ll keep adding to it every session.
One caveat, the same one I put at the top of that page: this is one input, not a forecast. It’s part of what went into building the exam practice and the question bank on this site, which is written from every statement in the guide, the dusty corners included, precisely because you can’t predict where the pellets will land. Don’t use it to drop a topic. Use it to see how the IB asks.
Mapped these papers yourself and you’d put a question somewhere else? Tell me on LinkedIn. I’d rather be corrected than confidently wrong.