Biology  by Bradford
support
IB BIOLOGY · THEME C · INTERACTION AND INTERDEPENDENCE

Energy flows, matter goes round

Sunlight comes into an ecosystem and leaves as heat; the carbon, nitrogen and every other element are used again and again. Build a food web and pull a species out of it, follow 10,000 kJ of grass down to an owl, and plot seventy years of carbon dioxide over Hawaii to read the Earth breathing in and out.

IB Biology C4.2SL and HL5 hours SL (no HL content)9 chaptersdry lab

Start learningRun the dry labTeach it

Sunlight into a meadow: the energy flows from grass to rabbit to fox and down to the decomposers, lost as heat at every step, while the carbon goes round.
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Nine chapters, all standard level. Read one, play its figure or film, and make each prediction before you open the answer. The food web builder is in chapter 3; the Keeling curve is the Dry lab.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1Light in, heat out
  2. 2Make it or take it
  3. 3Who eats whom
  4. 4Nothing goes to waste
  5. 5Where the energy goes
  6. 6Drawn to scale
  7. 7What is left to grow
  8. 8Round and round
  9. 9The Earth breathing

C4.2.1 Ecosystems as open systems in which both energy and matter can enter and exit C4.2.2 Sunlight as the principal source of energy that sustains most ecosystems

Light in, heat out

  • An ecosystem is an open system: both energy and matter cross its boundary. Most ecosystems are open.
  • In a closed system only energy crosses. A sealed jar of soil, water, plants and small animals, a mesocosm, comes close.
  • Sunlight is the energy source for almost every ecosystem, caught by plants, algae and cyanobacteria in photosynthesis.
  • The exceptions are places light never reaches, such as caves and the deep ocean below about 200 m.
  • “Sunlight sustains ecosystems” works like a law in science: a generalisation that describes a pattern seen again and again, without explaining it.

The detail

  • Draw a line round a wood, a pond or a stretch of seabed and call it an ecosystem: two kinds of thing cross that line.
  • Energy arrives, mostly as sunlight, and leaves as heat.
  • Matter crosses too: rain falls in, streams carry water and dissolved minerals out, leaves blow across, gases mix with the air above, and animals walk, swim or fly in and out.
  • In a mesocosm light still shines in and heat still escapes through the glass, but no matter gets in or out.
  • Whatever the organisms in a mesocosm need, they must recycle.

Examples

  • Caves: the animals live on what washes or falls in from the lit world outside.
  • The deep ocean: below about 200 m there is too little light to photosynthesise. Most life there feeds on a slow rain of dead matter from above.
  • Hydrothermal vents: whole communities run on bacteria that get their energy from chemicals such as hydrogen sulfide.

How we know

  • Like a law, the rule holds until an exception turns up.
  • When vent communities were found on the Galápagos Rift in 1977, thriving in total darkness, the rule had to be narrowed to “most ecosystems”.

Draw a line round a wood, a pond or a stretch of seabed and call it an ecosystem. Two kinds of thing cross that line. Energy arrives, mostly as sunlight, and leaves as heat. Matter crosses too: rain falls in and streams carry water and dissolved minerals out, leaves blow across, gases mix with the air above, and animals walk, swim or fly in and out. A system that both energy and matter can cross is an open system.

Seal some soil, water, plants and small animals in a glass jar, a mesocosm, and you have the nearest thing to a closed system: light still shines in and heat still escapes through the glass, but no matter gets in or out. Whatever the organisms in the jar need, they must recycle.

For almost every ecosystem on Earth the energy starts as sunlight, caught by plants, algae and cyanobacteria in photosynthesis. The exceptions are places light never reaches. In a cave the animals live on what washes or falls in from the lit world outside. In the deep ocean below about 200 m there is too little light to photosynthesise: most life there feeds on a slow rain of dead matter from above, and around hydrothermal vents whole communities run on bacteria that get their energy from chemicals such as hydrogen sulfide.

  • Open system: energy and matter both cross the boundary. Most ecosystems are open.
  • Closed system: only energy crosses. A sealed mesocosm comes close.
  • Sunlight powers most ecosystems; caves and the deep sea are the exceptions.
Nature of science "Sunlight sustains ecosystems" works like a law in science: a generalisation that describes a pattern seen again and again, without explaining it. Like a law, it holds until an exception turns up. When vent communities were found on the Galápagos Rift in 1977, thriving in total darkness, the rule had to be narrowed to "most ecosystems".

A student seals a jar with pond water, waterweed and snails and keeps it on a sunny windowsill. What must cross the glass for the jar to keep going for years?

light inheat outheat outC, N, P recycledC, O, N recycledrainstreamanimalsseedsedge of the ecosystemsealed lidopen: energy and matter crossclosed: only energy crosses

C4.2.6 Autotrophs as organisms that use external energy sources to synthesize carbon compounds from simple inorganic substances C4.2.7 Use of light as the external energy source in photoautotrophs and oxidation reactions as the energy source in chemoautotrophs C4.2.8 Heterotrophs as organisms that use carbon compounds obtained from other organisms to synthesize the carbon compounds that they require C4.2.9 Release of energy in both autotrophs and heterotrophs by oxidation of carbon compounds in cell respiration

Make it or take it

  • An autotroph makes its carbon compounds from simple inorganic substances, using an outside energy source.
  • Fixing carbon and building macromolecules are anabolic reactions, and they need energy.
  • A photoautotroph uses light. A chemoautotroph uses an oxidation reaction, such as iron-oxidising bacteria oxidising Fe²⁺ to Fe³⁺.
  • A heterotroph takes carbon compounds from other organisms, digests them, absorbs them and assimilates them into its own.
  • Autotrophs and heterotrophs alike release energy by oxidising carbon compounds in cell respiration.

The detail

  • Every organism is built of carbon compounds: carbohydrates, lipids, proteins and nucleic acids.
  • The simple inorganic substances an autotroph uses: carbon dioxide, water, and ions such as nitrate and phosphate.
  • Photoautotrophs include plants, algae and cyanobacteria.
  • Oxidising an inorganic substance releases energy: that is what a chemoautotroph runs on.
  • A heterotroph digests proteins, polysaccharides and nucleic acids into small molecules, inside its gut (animals) or outside its cells (fungi and many bacteria).
  • Assimilating means building the absorbed molecules into its own proteins, its own glycogen, its own DNA.
  • A plant respires day and night, just as a fox does.

Examples

  • Iron-oxidising bacteria are found in iron-rich streams and mine water. The iron(III) they make shows as orange rust on the stones, and they use the energy to fix carbon dioxide.

Watch out

  • Plants do not “photosynthesise instead of respiring”. They do both: photosynthesis makes the carbon compounds, and respiration releases energy from them, in every living cell, day and night.

Every organism is built of carbon compounds: carbohydrates, lipids, proteins and nucleic acids. There are two ways to get them. An autotroph makes them from simple inorganic substances: carbon dioxide, water, and ions such as nitrate and phosphate. Fixing carbon and building macromolecules are anabolic reactions, and they need energy, so an autotroph needs an outside energy source.

For a photoautotroph (plants, algae, cyanobacteria) that source is light. For a chemoautotroph it is an oxidation reaction: oxidising an inorganic substance releases energy. Iron-oxidising bacteria, found in iron-rich streams and mine water, oxidise iron(II) ions (Fe²⁺) to iron(III) (Fe³⁺), which shows as orange rust on the stones, and use the energy to fix carbon dioxide.

A heterotroph takes its carbon compounds from other organisms. It digests their proteins, polysaccharides and nucleic acids into small molecules, inside its gut (animals) or outside its cells (fungi and many bacteria), absorbs them and then assimilates them: builds them into its own proteins, its own glycogen, its own DNA.

Whichever way it got them, every organism releases energy from carbon compounds the same way: by oxidising them in cell respiration. A plant respires day and night, just as a fox does.

  • Autotroph: inorganic carbon plus outside energy. Photo- uses light; chemo- uses oxidation of inorganic chemicals.
  • Heterotroph: carbon compounds from other organisms, digested and then assimilated.
  • Both respire to release energy.
Watch out Plants do not "photosynthesise instead of respiring". They do both: photosynthesis makes the carbon compounds, and respiration releases energy from them, in every living cell, day and night.

Iron-oxidising bacteria live in a mine shaft with no light. What is the source of the carbon in their proteins?

lightenergy sourceFe²⁺ to Fe³⁺oxidising iron:energy sourcefoodmade by otherorganismsCO₂, watercarbon sourcethe same foodcarbon sourcemakes carboncompoundsit needsrespirationreleases energyplants, algae, cyanobacteriairon-oxidising bacteria: no lightanimals, fungi, most bacteriaautotroph: makes its own carbon compoundsheterotroph: takes in carbon compounds

C4.2.3 Flow of chemical energy through food chains C4.2.4 Construction of food chains and food webs to represent feeding relationships in a community C4.2.10 Classification of organisms into trophic levels

Who eats whom

  • When a consumer feeds, the carbon compounds of its food, and the chemical energy in them, pass to it.
  • A food chain shows that passing along. Each arrow means “is eaten by”: it points the way energy and biomass go.
  • Each place in a chain is a trophic level: producer, primary consumer, secondary consumer, tertiary consumer.
  • Chains link up into a food web, where one animal can sit on more than one level.

The detail

  • When a caterpillar eats an oak leaf, the leaf’s carbon compounds become the caterpillar’s food.
  • Arrows always go from the food to the feeder (from the eaten to the eater), never the other way.
  • The secondary consumer eats the primary consumer; the tertiary consumer eats that.
  • Real animals rarely eat one thing, so chains link up into webs.
  • An omnivore can be on two or more levels at once.

In the exam

  • Name the trophic level for each chain, not once for the animal.

Examples

  • A chain: oak tree, caterpillar, blue tit, sparrowhawk.
  • A wood mouse eating acorns is a primary consumer; the same mouse eating a caterpillar is a secondary consumer.

Watch out

  • The commonest slip in an exam food web is an arrow pointing from the fox to the rabbit (“the fox eats the rabbit”).
  • The arrow shows where the energy goes, so it points at the fox.

When a caterpillar eats an oak leaf, the carbon compounds of the leaf become the caterpillar's food, and the chemical energy in them passes with them. A food chain shows that passing along: oak tree, caterpillar, blue tit, sparrowhawk. Each arrow means "is eaten by", so it points the way the energy and the biomass go: from the food to the feeder, never the other way.

Each place in a chain is a trophic level. The producer is first, then the primary consumer that eats it, the secondary consumer that eats that, and the tertiary consumer.

Real animals rarely eat one thing, so chains link up into a food web. In a web an animal can sit on more than one level. A wood mouse eating acorns is a primary consumer; the same mouse eating a caterpillar is a secondary consumer. Name the level for each chain, not once for the animal.

  • Arrows: from the eaten to the eater, the way energy flows.
  • Producer, primary, secondary, tertiary consumer.
  • An omnivore can be on two or more levels at once.
Watch out The commonest slip in an exam food web is an arrow pointing from the fox to the rabbit ("the fox eats the rabbit"). The arrow shows where the energy goes, so it points at the fox.

Build the woodland web below, then switch to Remove a species. Before you run it, predict: the sparrowhawk eats only blue tits. If the sparrowhawks are removed, what happens?

oak treecaterpillarblue titsparrowhawkproducer1primary consumer2secondary consumer3tertiary consumer4each arrow:“is eaten by”,the way energyflowswood mouseomnivore:levels 2, 3
  1. A food chain: each arrow means is eaten by.
  2. Each step is a trophic level.
  3. A wood mouse eats acorns and caterpillars: two levels at once.
Oak treeproducerGrassproducerBrambleproducerCaterpillarprimary cons.Aphidprimary cons.Rabbitprimary cons.Wood mouselevels 2 and 3Ladybirdsecondary cons.Spidersecondary cons.Blue titlevels 3 and 4Red foxlevels 3 and 4Tawny owllevels 3 and 4Sparrowhawklevels 4 and 5
The food web of an oak wood in England, sorted into trophic levels with producers at the bottom. Each arrow runs from a food to the organism that eats it, the way the energy flows. An omnivore sits on two levels.

C4.2.5 Supply of energy to decomposers as carbon compounds in organic matter coming from dead organisms

Nothing goes to waste

  • Dead leaves and branches, whole dead organisms and faeces are still carbon compounds, so they still hold chemical energy.
  • That energy is the food supply of the decomposers.
  • Detritivores eat dead matter and digest it inside their guts. Saprotrophs secrete enzymes and digest it outside their cells.
  • Decomposers respire, releasing carbon dioxide and heat, and leave mineral ions plants can take up again.

The detail

  • Much of what a wood makes is never eaten alive.
  • Detritivores leave the dead matter in smaller pieces.
  • Saprotrophs absorb the small molecules their enzymes release.
  • The mineral ions left behind include nitrate and phosphate.
  • Decomposers are not usually drawn on a food chain, but energy from every level reaches them.

Examples

  • Detritivores such as earthworms, woodlice and millipedes.
  • Saprotrophs: most fungi and many bacteria.

Much of what a wood makes is never eaten alive. Leaves fall, branches die, animals die whole, and every animal produces faeces. All of it is still made of carbon compounds, so it still holds chemical energy: a whole food supply for the decomposers.

There are two kinds. Detritivores such as earthworms, woodlice and millipedes eat dead matter, digest it inside their guts and leave it in smaller pieces. Saprotrophs, most fungi and many bacteria, secrete enzymes onto the dead matter and absorb the small molecules the enzymes release: their digestion happens outside their cells.

Decomposers respire the carbon compounds they take in, releasing carbon dioxide and heat, and they leave behind mineral ions such as nitrate and phosphate that plants can take up again. They are not usually drawn on a food chain, but energy from every level reaches them.

  • Dead organisms, dead parts and faeces carry energy as carbon compounds.
  • Detritivores digest inside; saprotrophs digest outside their cells.
  • Decomposers release carbon dioxide, heat and mineral ions.

A sheep eats grass, but much of the grass comes out again as faeces. Where does the energy in the faeces go next?

a wood floor: decomposers at worka dead leaf fallsits carbon compoundsstill hold energydetritivoreearthworm, eatsit in piecessaprotropha fungus: digests itoutside its cellsenzymes secretedCO₂ and heatfrom respiration−−−−−−−−mineral ionsnitrate, phosphateleft in the soil
  1. A dead leaf falls: its carbon compounds still hold energy.
  2. An earthworm, a detritivore, eats it in pieces.
  3. A fungus, a saprotroph, secretes enzymes and digests it outside its cells.
  4. Respiration releases carbon dioxide and heat; mineral ions are left in the soil.

C4.2.12 Reductions in energy availability at each successive stage in food chains due to large energy losses between trophic levels C4.2.13 Heat loss to the environment in both autotrophs and heterotrophs due to conversion of chemical energy to heat in cell respiration C4.2.14 Restrictions on the number of trophic levels in ecosystems due to energy losses

Where the energy goes

  • Only a small share of one trophic level’s energy, often about a tenth, ends up in the next.
  • Energy is lost as parts not eaten, food not absorbed (faeces) and heat from respiration.
  • No energy transfer is 100% efficient: heat is released when ATP is made and again when it is used, in plants and animals.
  • Less energy each step means fewer or smaller organisms, so less biomass, but not less energy per gram.
  • So food chains rarely have more than five levels.

The detail

  • Not eaten: roots, bark, bones and whole organisms that die uneaten go to the decomposers.
  • Not absorbed: food that passes through the gut undigested leaves as faeces, also to the decomposers.
  • Respired: most of what is absorbed is respired to keep the organism alive, and leaves as heat.
  • ATP is used for muscle contraction, for active transport, for building proteins.
  • No organism can turn heat back into chemical energy, so it is lost to the ecosystem.
  • A gram of fox holds about as much energy as a gram of rabbit: there is just much less of it.
  • After four or five steps too little is left to support a population of another level.

Watch out

  • Energy is not “used up” or “destroyed” along a food chain. It is converted to heat and leaves the ecosystem; the total is conserved.

Of the chemical energy in one trophic level, only a small share, often about a tenth, ends up in the next. The rest is lost from the chain in three ways:

  • Not eaten: roots, bark, bones and whole organisms that die uneaten go to the decomposers.
  • Not absorbed: food that passes through the gut undigested leaves as faeces, also to the decomposers.
  • Respired: most of what is absorbed is respired to keep the organism alive, and leaves as heat.

No energy transfer is 100% efficient. Some energy becomes heat when ATP is made in respiration, and more when the ATP is used: for muscle contraction, for active transport, for building proteins. This happens in plants as well as animals, and heat cannot be turned back into chemical energy by any organism, so it is lost to the ecosystem.

So each level has far less energy than the one below. There are fewer organisms at each step, or smaller ones, so less biomass. A gram of fox holds about as much energy as a gram of rabbit: the energy per gram does not fall, there is just much less of it. After four or five steps too little is left to support a population of another level. That is why food chains rarely have more than five levels.

  • Losses: parts not eaten, food not absorbed (faeces), heat from respiration.
  • Heat is released when ATP is made and when it is used.
  • Less energy each step, so less biomass, so few levels.
Watch out Energy is not "used up" or "destroyed" along a food chain. It is converted to heat and leaves the ecosystem; the total is conserved.

Turn the film's efficiency down from 10% to 5%. What happens to the owl?

where the rabbits’ food goes100 kJeatenin grass30 kJnever absorbed,to decomposers60 kJrespired,heat lost10 kJnew tissue,all a fox gets
  1. Rabbits eat grass holding 100 kJ of chemical energy. Follow it.
  2. About 30 kJ is never absorbed: it leaves in faeces, food for decomposers.
  3. About 60 kJ is used in respiration and released as heat, lost from the ecosystem.
  4. Only about 10 kJ ends up in new rabbit tissue: all a fox can get.
10,000 kJ in the grass, then grasshopper, shrew and owl. Watch where the rest goes at every step, then change the efficiency, bring in a drought or show the decomposers.

C4.2.11 Construction of energy pyramids

Drawn to scale

  • A pyramid of energy stacks the trophic levels from the producers up, one bar a level.
  • Each bar is as wide as the energy passing through that level, drawn to scale.
  • Units are energy per area per time, usually kJ m⁻² a year (kJ m⁻² y⁻¹).
  • Efficiency of transfer = energy at a level ÷ energy at the level below × 100.

Building one

  • Pick a scale that fits the biggest bar (here 87,100 kJ to 340 units).
  • Divide the other values by the same factor.
  • Centre each bar on the one below.
  • Label each bar with its level and its value.

How we know

  • The figure’s data are from Howard Odum’s study of Silver Springs, a clear spring-fed river in Florida, in the 1950s: one of the first ecosystems measured from top to bottom.
  • Drawn to scale, the shape tells the story: the producers’ bar is enormous, the herbivores’ a sixth of it, and the top carnivores’ a thin line.

A pyramid of energy stacks the trophic levels from the producers up, each bar as wide as the energy passing through that level. The units are energy per area per time, usually kJ m⁻² a year (kJ m⁻² y⁻¹).

The data in the figure are from Howard Odum's study of Silver Springs, a clear spring-fed river in Florida, in the 1950s, one of the first ecosystems measured from top to bottom. Draw the bars to scale and the shape tells the story: the producers' bar is enormous, the herbivores' a sixth of it, and the top carnivores' a thin line.

To build one, pick a scale that fits the biggest bar (here 87,100 kJ to 340 units), divide the others by the same factor, and centre each bar on the one below. Label each bar with its level and its value. Working out each level as a percentage of the one below gives its efficiency of transfer.

  • One bar a level, producers at the bottom, width in proportion to energy.
  • Units: kJ m⁻² a year.
  • Efficiency = energy at a level ÷ energy at the level below × 100.

A pyramid of numbers for an oak wood can be upside down: one tree feeds thousands of caterpillars. Can a pyramid of energy ever be upside down?

Silver Springs, Floridaenergy in each level, kJ m⁻² a yearproducerseelgrass, algae87,100herbivoresturtles, fish, insects14,100carnivoressmall fish, insects1,600top carnivoresbass, gar88producers87,100herbivores14,100carnivores1,600top carnivores88widths drawn to scale
  1. The data: energy at each level, kJ m⁻² a year.
  2. The same data as a pyramid of energy, to scale.

C4.2.15 Primary production as accumulation of carbon compounds in biomass by autotrophs C4.2.16 Secondary production as accumulation of carbon compounds in biomass by heterotrophs

What is left to grow

  • Primary production is the building up of carbon compounds in biomass by autotrophs.
  • Gross primary production is all the carbon fixed; net primary production is what is left after the plant’s own respiration.
  • Measured as mass per area per time, usually g m⁻² a year. Biomes differ hugely.
  • Secondary production is the biomass heterotrophs build as they grow and reproduce. It is always lower than primary production.

The detail

  • Net primary production is new leaves, wood, roots and seeds: what herbivores and decomposers can use.
  • Net production = gross production − respiration.
  • Secondary production is lower because heterotrophs can only build from what autotrophs made, and they turn much of what they eat into carbon dioxide and water in respiration.

Examples

  • A tropical rainforest, warm, wet and lit all year, makes over 2,000 g m⁻² a year.
  • A hot desert, short of water, makes under 100. Deserts and tundra are lowest.
  • The open ocean makes little per square metre, but there is so much of it that it adds up to nearly half of all the world’s production.

Primary production is the building up of carbon compounds in biomass by autotrophs. All the carbon a plant fixes by photosynthesis is its gross primary production. It respires some of that straight away to stay alive, and what is left is its net primary production: new leaves, wood, roots, seeds. Net production is what herbivores and decomposers can use. It is measured as mass per area per time, usually g m⁻² a year.

Biomes differ hugely. A tropical rainforest, warm, wet and lit all year, makes over 2,000 g m⁻² a year; a hot desert, short of water, under 100. The open ocean makes little per square metre, but there is so much of it that it adds up to nearly half of all the world's production.

Secondary production is the same thing for heterotrophs: biomass they build as they grow and reproduce. It is always lower than primary production, because heterotrophs can only build from what autotrophs made, and they turn much of what they eat into carbon dioxide and water in respiration.

  • Net production = gross production − respiration.
  • Units: g m⁻² a year. Rainforests highest, deserts and tundra lowest.
  • Secondary production is lower than primary production.

Why does a tropical rainforest have a much higher net primary production than the tundra?

one tree, one yeargross productionall it fixesrespirationlost as heatnet productionnew shoots, woodgross production: all the carbon it fixesrespiration, about halfnet: new biomassnet = gross minus respirationnet primary production, g m⁻² a yeardesert scrub90open ocean125tundra140temperate grassland600boreal forest800savanna900temperate forest1,200estuary1,500tropical rainforest2,200typical valueswarm, wet and lit all year: highestshort of water or cold: lowest

C4.2.17 Constructing carbon cycle diagrams C4.2.18 Ecosystems as carbon sinks and carbon sources C4.2.19 Release of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere during combustion of biomass, peat, coal, oil and natural gas

Round and round

  • Energy flows through an ecosystem once; carbon goes round.
  • Photosynthesis fixes carbon dioxide, feeding passes carbon compounds on, and respiration turns them back into carbon dioxide.
  • A carbon cycle diagram shows the stores and the processes between them, each arrow labelled.
  • Photosynthesis greater than respiration: a carbon sink. Respiration greater: a carbon source.
  • Combustion of biomass, peat, coal, oil and natural gas oxidises their carbon to carbon dioxide.

The detail

  • Photosynthesis takes carbon dioxide from the air (or from water).
  • Feeding passes compounds to consumers; death and egestion pass them to decomposers.
  • Producers, consumers and decomposers alike respire.
  • A sink takes carbon dioxide out of the air.
  • Old sinks can be burned.
  • Lightning has always set some forests and peat alight, but humans now burn fossil fuels and biomass far faster than any natural process.

When each store formed

  • Wood: in years.
  • Peat: over thousands of years.
  • Coal: mostly around 300 million years ago, from swamp forests.
  • Oil and gas: from marine plankton, over tens to hundreds of millions of years.

Examples

  • Sinks: a growing forest, and a peat bog, where waterlogged, acidic soil slows decomposition so much that dead moss piles up for thousands of years.
  • Sources: a drained bog, or a forest after a fire.

Energy flows through an ecosystem once; carbon goes round. Photosynthesis takes carbon dioxide from the air (or from water) and fixes it into carbon compounds. Feeding passes those compounds to consumers, and death and egestion pass them to decomposers. Respiration, by producers, consumers and decomposers alike, turns them back into carbon dioxide. A carbon cycle diagram shows those stores and the processes that move carbon between them, each arrow labelled.

If an ecosystem fixes more carbon by photosynthesis than it releases by respiration, it takes carbon dioxide out of the air: it is a carbon sink. A growing forest is a sink, and so is a peat bog, where waterlogged, acidic soil slows decomposition so much that dead moss piles up for thousands of years. If respiration wins, it is a carbon source: a drained bog, or a forest after a fire.

Old sinks can be burned. Combustion of wood and other biomass, peat, coal, oil and natural gas oxidises their carbon to carbon dioxide. These stores formed at very different times: wood in years, peat over thousands of years, coal mostly around 300 million years ago from swamp forests, and oil and gas from marine plankton over tens to hundreds of millions of years. Lightning has always set some forests and peat alight, but humans now burn fossil fuels and biomass far faster than any natural process.

  • Photosynthesis removes CO₂; respiration and combustion return it.
  • Sink: photosynthesis > respiration. Source: respiration > photosynthesis.
  • Biomass, peat, coal, oil and gas: sinks of different ages, released by burning.

A peat bog is drained for farming. Air gets into the peat. What happens to the bog's carbon?

CO₂ in the airproducersconsumersdeadmatteroceanspeat, soilfossil fuelsphoto-synthesisrespirationdecayslow decaymillions of yearscombustiondiffusion

Tap a store or an arrow to see what it is.

One carbon atom from the air, into a leaf, into a sugar, eaten by an animal and breathed back out. One turn of the carbon cycle, close up.

C4.2.20 Analysis of the Keeling Curve in terms of photosynthesis, respiration and combustion C4.2.21 Dependence of aerobic respiration on atmospheric oxygen produced by photosynthesis, and of photosynthesis on atmospheric carbon dioxide produced by respiration C4.2.22 Recycling of all chemical elements required by living organisms in ecosystems

The Earth breathing

  • The Keeling curve is the monthly record of carbon dioxide in the air on Mauna Loa, Hawaii, since 1958.
  • The yearly wiggle: northern summer photosynthesis lowers CO₂; in winter respiration, decay and burning raise it.
  • The long rise: combustion of fossil fuels, with deforestation, releases carbon faster than it is taken back.
  • Aerobic respiration depends on oxygen from photosynthesis, and photosynthesis on carbon dioxide from respiration.
  • Every element living things use is recycled, and decomposers return them for producers to use again.

The detail

  • Mauna Loa is a volcano far from any city or forest.
  • The concentration peaks in about May and falls to a low in about September or October.
  • Most of the land and its forests are in the northern hemisphere. In the northern summer photosynthesis there takes up more carbon dioxide than respiration and decay release.
  • In the winter photosynthesis almost stops.
  • Every year ends higher than the one before: from about 315 ppm in 1958 to over 420 ppm now, and the rise is getting faster.
  • Photosynthesis and the oceans take carbon back, but more slowly than it is released.
  • Each year about a hundred billion tonnes of carbon go each way on land alone: a huge two-way trade.
  • Carbon is not special: nitrogen, phosphorus, sulfur, the lot, are recycled, returned by decomposers to the soil and water.

How we know

  • Charles David Keeling began the measurements in 1958, and the record has run every month since.

Watch out

  • The wiggle is not caused by people burning more fuel to keep warm in winter.
  • Combustion adds to the long rise; the wiggle is the northern forests photosynthesising in summer and not in winter.

In 1958 Charles David Keeling began measuring carbon dioxide in the air on Mauna Loa, a volcano in Hawaii, far from any city or forest. The record has run every month since, and its graph is the Keeling curve. It shows two patterns.

The yearly wiggle. Each year the concentration peaks in about May and falls to a low in about September or October. Most of the land and its forests are in the northern hemisphere. In the northern summer, photosynthesis there takes up more carbon dioxide than respiration and decay release, so the level falls. In the winter photosynthesis almost stops, while respiration, decay and burning go on, so it rises again.

The long rise. Every year ends higher than the one before: from about 315 ppm in 1958 to over 420 ppm now, and the rise is getting faster. The main cause is combustion of fossil fuels, with forests cleared and burned, releasing carbon faster than photosynthesis and the oceans take it back.

Behind the wiggle is a huge two-way trade. Every aerobic organism depends on the oxygen that photosynthesis puts into the air, and photosynthesis depends on the carbon dioxide that respiration puts back. Each year about a hundred billion tonnes of carbon go each way on land alone. Carbon is not special: every element living things use, nitrogen, phosphorus, sulfur, the lot, is recycled, and decomposers are what return them to the soil and water for producers to use again.

  • Wiggle: northern summer photosynthesis lowers CO₂; winter respiration raises it.
  • Rise: combustion of fossil fuels and deforestation.
  • Photosynthesis and respiration supply each other; all elements are recycled.
Watch out The wiggle is not caused by people burning more fuel to keep warm in winter. Combustion adds to the long rise; the wiggle is the northern forests photosynthesising in summer and not in winter.

A station in New Zealand, in the southern hemisphere, also measures carbon dioxide. What would you expect its wiggle to look like?

northern summerMay to Septemberphotosynthesis takes inmore CO₂ than respirationgives out: CO₂ fallsnorthern winterOctober to Aprilrespiration, decay andburning go on, littlephotosynthesis: CO₂ rises

02Dry lab: The Keeling curve

Plot every monthly mean of carbon dioxide in the air at Mauna Loa, Hawaii, from 1958 to now. Read the yearly wiggle, then measure how fast the long rise is climbing, decade by decade.

air intakePacific OceanMAUNA LOACO₂ IN AIR353.9ppmJAN 1990samplingANALYSER32042019582026PLOTTER
The bench: air drawn in high on Mauna Loa, Hawaii, far out in the Pacific, goes to an analyser that reads its carbon dioxide, and a plotter draws the record month by month from 1958. Plot it to 2026, then read the yearly wiggle and the long rise.
Your questionWhy does the carbon dioxide in the air go up and down every year, and why does each year end higher than the last? Predict first: in which month of the year is it highest at Mauna Loa?
What you can doPlot the whole record and add a trend line; zoom to any two years and read their peaks and troughs; and work out the rate of rise for each decade, in ppm a year.
What to recordThe month of the yearly peak and trough and the size of the wiggle; the rate of rise for each decade; and a sentence explaining each pattern with photosynthesis, respiration and combustion. The data are the real monthly means measured at Mauna Loa Observatory (NOAA and Scripps), public domain.

Find out

  • The whole record. Plot every month from 1958, then add the trend line. Describe the two patterns you see, one in a sentence each.
  • The wiggle. Zoom to two years. In which month is carbon dioxide highest, and in which lowest? How big is the swing in ppm? Compare 1959 with 2024: has the swing changed?
  • The rise. Work out the rate of rise for every decade. Is the rise steady, or getting faster? By how many times has it sped up since the 1960s?
  • Explain it. Explain the wiggle with photosynthesis and respiration in the northern hemisphere, and the rise with combustion.

Record

  • For two years: the month and value of each peak and trough, and the swing between them.
  • For each decade: its first and last yearly means and the rate of rise in ppm a year.
  • A bar chart of the rate of rise against decade, and a sentence on its trend.
  • Download the CSV to keep every month.

In 2024 Mauna Loa read about 427 ppm in May and 422 ppm in September. Why is it lower in September?

The rate of rise was about 0.9 ppm a year in the 1960s and about 2.4 ppm a year in the 2010s. What does this show?

Why was the observatory put on Mauna Loa, over 3,000 m up a volcano in the middle of the Pacific?

Back to the carbon cycle

Use your results to explain the yearly swing with photosynthesis and respiration, and the long rise with combustion.

03Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in.

Exam practice

Exam questions on C4.2, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

C4.2 revision mapC4.2 exam questionsC4.2 multiple choice quizC4.2 pub quizC4.2 Tarsia puzzleC4.2 dominoesNext: A4.2 conservation of biodiversityBack: C1.3 photosynthesisBack: C1.2 cell respiration

04Downloads

Take the guide with you, or into a classroom with no internet.

05Teacher resources

The guide as five one-hour lessons. Each has a plan to print (the timings, what to project and where to stop, the activities with what they need, what students get wrong) and slides to teach it from, in the same order, with the teacher's moves in the notes.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1Light in, heat out C4.2.1, C4.2.2, C4.2.6 to C4.2.960 min Open and closed systems, sunlight and its exceptions, autotrophs (photo and chemo), heterotrophs and respiration in all of them 1, 2 Lesson planPDF 539 KB SlidesPPTX 535 KB
2Who eats whom C4.2.3, C4.2.4, C4.2.1060 min Food chains and webs, arrows as energy flow, trophic levels and omnivores, and predicting the knock-on effects of removing a species 3 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 571 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 576 KB
3Where the energy goes C4.2.5, C4.2.11 to C4.2.1460 min Decomposers, the three energy losses between levels, heat from ATP, why chains are short, and pyramids of energy to scale 4, 5, 6 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 669 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 4.9 MB
4Round and round C4.2.15 to C4.2.1960 min Gross and net primary production, comparing biomes, secondary production, the carbon cycle, sinks and sources and combustion 7, 8 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 601 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 4.1 MB
5The Earth breathing C4.2.20 to C4.2.2260 min The Keeling curve dry lab, its yearly wiggle and its long rise, the interdependence of photosynthesis and respiration, and recycling of elements 9, dry lab Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 554 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 329 KB

Lesson 1 is free with a free account. The other plans and slides, for every guide, come with the Teacher pass.

The note template, the revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTISE AND REVISE

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for C4.2

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.