Biology  by Bradford
support
AP BIOLOGY · UNIT 5 · HEREDITY

When the ratios break

Mendel's ratios are a model, and real crosses often refuse to fit it. Find out what he could not see: heterozygotes that look like neither parent, genes on the X, genes that travel together on one chromosome, one gene with many effects, DNA outside the nucleus, and one genotype that looks different in a different place.

AP Biology 5.4 and 5.54 lessons11 chaptersdry lab

Start learningRun the dry labTeach it

In 1910 one fly with white eyes turned up among Thomas Hunt Morgan's red-eyed fruit flies. Follow his cross through two generations and see which flies have white eyes, and why.
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Eleven chapters and a dry lab: how a broken ratio is spotted (chapter 1), dominance that is not complete (2), genes on the sex chromosomes (3 to 5), linked genes and gene maps (6 and 7), one gene with many effects (8), DNA outside the nucleus (9), and the environment (10 and 11). Make each prediction before you open the answer.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1A ratio that will not fit
  2. 2A heterozygote unlike either parent
  3. 3A gene on the X
  4. 4Reading the pattern from data
  5. 5Not always X and Y
  6. 6Two genes, one chromosome
  7. 7From counts to a map
  8. 8One gene, many effects
  9. 9DNA outside the nucleus
  10. 10One genotype, more than one phenotype
  11. 11Reading the environment

5.4.A When a cross does not fit

A ratio that will not fit

  • Mendel's ratios are a model. Many traits do not follow the ratios his laws predict.
  • A deviation is found by counting: the observed phenotype ratio differs statistically from the predicted one.
  • The test is chi-square. A value above the critical value means reject the null hypothesis: chance alone is unlikely to explain the difference.
  • A rejected ratio is a clue. Something about the gene, or where it sits, is outside Mendel's model.

The detail

  • Mendel's model assumes each trait is set by one gene with a dominant and a recessive allele, and that genes for different traits sit on different chromosomes.
  • The null hypothesis is always the Mendelian one: the offspring fit the predicted ratio, and any difference is chance.
  • Chi-square adds up (observed − expected)2 ÷ expected over every phenotype class. Degrees of freedom are the number of classes minus one.
  • The critical values at p = 0.05 are on the AP equations and formulas sheet: 3.84 for 1 degree of freedom, 5.99 for 2 and 7.81 for 3.

Worked example

  • Two heterozygous plants are crossed. The prediction is 3 tall : 1 short. Of 160 offspring, 100 are tall and 60 are short.
  • Expected: 120 tall and 40 short.
  • Chi-square = (100 − 120)2 ÷ 120 + (60 − 40)2 ÷ 40 = 3.33 + 10.00 = 13.33.
  • With 1 degree of freedom the critical value is 3.84. 13.33 is above it: reject the null hypothesis. These plants do not fit 3 : 1.

Watch out

  • Rejecting the null hypothesis does not say what the cause is. It says the Mendelian ratio is a poor fit, and sends you looking.
  • A value below the critical value means fail to reject. It never proves the ratio is right.

In the last guide every cross came out the way Mendel's laws said: 3 : 1, 1 : 1, 9 : 3 : 3 : 1. Those ratios are a model, built on peas and on seven traits that happened to behave. Many traits do not follow them.

You find a deviation by counting. Cross the parents, sort the offspring by phenotype, and compare what you observed with what the model expected. No brood matches exactly, so the question is whether the gap is bigger than chance would give. That is what the chi-square test answers. The null hypothesis is that the offspring fit the Mendelian ratio. If chi-square is above the critical value, you reject it.

A rejected ratio is the start of the interesting part. Something about the gene, or about where it sits in the cell, is outside the model. This guide covers five such causes, then one more thing Mendel's model leaves out: the environment. Tap each card in the figure to see where the guide is going.

  • Many traits do not follow Mendel's ratios.
  • A deviation is identified in data: observed ratios differ statistically from predicted ones.
  • Chi-square above the critical value: reject the null hypothesis.
Watch out A cross that breaks the ratio has not broken the rules of meiosis. Alleles still segregate. What changes is how the genotypes show, or which genes travel together.

A cross is predicted to give 3 purple : 1 white. Of 200 offspring, 135 are purple and 65 are white. What does a chi-square test show? (The critical value for 1 degree of freedom is 3.84.)

The counts do not fit Mendel’s ratio. Why not?Dominance isnot completeXYThe gene is on asex chromosomeTwo genes shareone chromosomeOne gene hasmany effectsDNA outsidethe nucleus

Tap a card to read how that cause changes a ratio.

5.4.A Incomplete dominance and codominance

A heterozygote unlike either parent

  • In incomplete dominance neither allele masks the other. The heterozygote's phenotype is in between the two homozygotes'.
  • In codominance both alleles' phenotypes are expressed. The heterozygote shows both, and differs from either homozygote.
  • Either way a cross of two heterozygotes gives three phenotypes, 1 : 2 : 1, not 3 : 1.
  • The alleles still segregate as Mendel said. Only the way the genotypes show has changed.

The detail

  • With complete dominance a heterozygote looks like the dominant homozygote, so two genotypes share a phenotype and the F2 is 3 : 1.
  • With incomplete dominance or codominance every genotype has its own phenotype, so the phenotype ratio is the genotype ratio: 1 : 2 : 1.
  • Since neither allele is recessive, both are written with capital letters on a shared base: CR and CW.

Examples

  • Incomplete dominance: red and white snapdragons, or four o'clock flowers, give pink offspring. One working allele makes less red pigment than two.
  • Codominance: a roan Shorthorn calf from a red parent and a white parent has red hairs and white hairs mixed through its coat. Roan × roan gives 1 red : 2 roan : 1 white.

Try it

  • In the cross tool, cross a red four o'clock with a white one, then cross two of the pink offspring. Count the phenotypes in the Punnett square.

Beyond the course

  • Some genes have more than two alleles in a population. The human ABO blood group has three: IA and IB are codominant with each other, and both are dominant to i. Choose ABO blood group in the cross tool's Trait list to try it. The course framework does not name multiple alleles, so you will not be asked to recall this.

Watch out

  • Pink is not a new allele and the alleles have not mixed. Cross two pink plants and red and white come back.

Cross a red-flowered four o'clock plant with a white one and every offspring is pink. Mendel's model says a heterozygote should look like one parent. Here it looks like neither. This is incomplete dominance: neither allele masks the other, and the heterozygote lands in between.

It can look as if the two colors have blended for good. They have not. Cross two pink plants and the offspring are 1 red : 2 pink : 1 white. The red allele and the white allele went into the pink plant, stayed separate, and came out again unchanged. Only the phenotype was in between.

Codominance is different. Both alleles are fully expressed, side by side. A roan Shorthorn cow has a coat of red hairs and white hairs mixed together. No hair is pink. Each allele shows its own phenotype in the same animal.

In both patterns each genotype has its own phenotype, so a cross of two heterozygotes gives 1 : 2 : 1. If you expected 3 : 1 and counted three kinds of offspring, this is the first cause to check.

Remember it Three kinds of dominance, told apart by the heterozygote

  • CompleteLike one parentone allele masks the other
  • IncompleteIn betweenneither allele masks the other
  • CodominantBoth at onceboth phenotypes are expressed
  • Incomplete dominance: the heterozygote is in between the two homozygotes.
  • Codominance: the heterozygote expresses both alleles' phenotypes.
  • Heterozygote × heterozygote gives 1 : 2 : 1 in phenotype as well as genotype.
Watch out Incomplete dominance blends the phenotype, not the alleles. The F2 brings both parent colors back.

Two pink four o'clock plants are crossed. Among the offspring are red, pink and white plants. What does the return of red and white show?

CR​CR​redhomozygousCR​CW​pinkheterozygousCW​CW​whitehomozygousfour o’clock flowers (Mirabilis jalapa)×pink × pinkCR​CR​CR​CW​CR​CW​CW​CW​CR​CW​CR​CW​1 red : 2 pink : 1 whiteThe phenotype ratio matches the genotype ratio.Shorthorn cattleCR​CR​redred hairs onlyCR​CW​roanboth kinds of hairCW​CW​whitewhite hairs onlyA roan coat, close up: red hairs andwhite hairs side by side. No hair is pink.Both alleles show in the heterozygote.
  1. Incomplete dominance in four o'clocks: red (CRCR), pink (CRCW) and white (CWCW). The heterozygote is in between.
  2. Cross two pink plants and the offspring are 1 red : 2 pink : 1 white. The phenotype ratio matches the genotype ratio, and red and white reappear.
  3. Codominance in Shorthorn cattle: a roan coat has red hairs and white hairs side by side. The heterozygote expresses both alleles.
P generationfemale parentCRCRred flowersmale parentCWCWwhite flowersxF1 offspringmale gametes, in pollenfemale gametesCWCWCRCRredpinkwhiteP generationfemale parentCRCRred flowersmale parentCWCWwhite flowersxF1 offspringmale gametes, in pollenfemale gametesCWCWCRCRCRCWCRCWCRCWCRCWredpinkwhite
  1. Each parent makes gametes by meiosis, one allele of each gene in each. The female parent's go down the side of the Punnett square, the male parent's along the top.
  2. Each cell joins one gamete from each parent: a possible offspring, every cell as likely as the next. The F1: genotypes all CRCW; phenotypes all pink.
Choose the parents, predict the offspring, then fill the Punnett square. Start with red × white, then cross two of the pink offspring.

5.4.A Sex-linked traits

A gene on the X

  • Sex-linked traits are set by genes on the sex chromosomes: X-linked or Y-linked.
  • An XY individual has one X, so a single recessive allele on it shows. An XX individual needs the allele on both.
  • So X-linked recessive traits appear at higher rates in XY individuals than in XX individuals.
  • A father passes his X to every daughter and his Y to every son. A Y-linked trait goes from a father to all his sons.

The detail

  • In humans and fruit flies, females are XX and males are XY. The X is large and carries many genes; the Y is small and carries few.
  • An X-linked allele is written on the X: XR and Xr. The Y is written with no allele, because it has no copy of the gene.
  • A male is neither homozygous nor heterozygous for an X-linked gene. He has one allele, and it shows.
  • A female heterozygous for a recessive X-linked allele does not show the trait but can pass it on: she is a carrier.

Morgan's flies

  • In 1910 Thomas Hunt Morgan found one white-eyed male among his red-eyed fruit flies and crossed it with a red-eyed female. The F1 had red eyes.
  • The reciprocal cross, a white-eyed female with a red-eyed male, gave red-eyed daughters and white-eyed sons. When the two ways round give different results, suspect a sex-linked gene.

Examples

  • Red-green color blindness in humans is X-linked recessive. In people of Northern European ancestry it affects about 1 male in 12 and about 1 female in 200.
  • Hemophilia A, in which the blood clots slowly, is X-linked recessive too. The cross tool uses it.
  • These are worked examples. You are not asked to recall the name of any sex-linked condition, only to work with the pattern.

Watch out

  • The higher rate in XY individuals holds for X-linked recessive traits (and for Y-linked ones, which XX individuals cannot have). An X-linked dominant allele shows in anyone who has it.
  • Sex-linked does not mean the gene has anything to do with sex. Eye color in flies is sex-linked only because of where the gene sits.

In 1910 one fruit fly with white eyes hatched among Thomas Hunt Morgan's red-eyed flies. He crossed it, and the F1 had red eyes, as Mendel would predict for a recessive trait. Then he crossed the F1 flies with each other, and the F2 gave him a puzzle that Mendel's model could not explain.

Mendel's model has no place for a trait that cares which sex it is in. Morgan's explanation put the gene somewhere particular: on the X chromosome. A trait set by a gene on a sex chromosome is sex-linked.

The pattern follows from who has which chromosomes. A female fly, like a woman, is XX. A male is XY, and his small Y carries no copy of most genes on the X. So a male has one allele of an X-linked gene. If it is recessive, nothing masks it. A female needs the recessive allele on both X chromosomes to show the trait, which is much less likely. That is why X-linked recessive traits turn up at higher rates in XY individuals.

It also sets who passes what to whom. A father gives his X to every daughter and his Y to every son, so he can never pass an X-linked allele to a son. A son's X always comes from his mother. A trait set by a gene on the Y, Y-linked, does the opposite: father to every son, and never to a daughter.

  • Sex-linked traits are set by genes on the sex chromosomes.
  • One recessive allele on an XY individual's only X shows.
  • Fathers give their X to daughters and their Y to sons.
Watch out A man cannot pass an X-linked trait to his son: the son has his Y. And a woman can show an X-linked recessive trait. She needs the allele on both X chromosomes.

Morgan crossed a white-eyed male fly with a red-eyed female. All the F1 had red eyes. He then crossed F1 flies with each other. Predict the F2 before you watch.

The cross that put a gene on a chromosome. Watch the F2, then switch Cross to the reciprocal cross and predict its F1 before it hatches.
XYmany genesfar fewer genesXXfemaleXYmalemother XX ×father XYgirlboygirlboyXXXYeggsspermHalf the sperm carry X and half carry Y: the sperm decides.carrier mother ×unaffected fatherXH​XH​girl, not affectedXH​Yboy, not affectedXh​XH​girl, a carrierXh​Yboy, has hemophiliaXH​Xh​XH​YeggsspermH: the working alleleh: the faulty allele
  1. The X is big and carries many genes. The Y is small and carries far fewer. In humans XX develops female and XY male.
  2. Every egg carries an X. A sperm carries X or Y, so a father's X goes to his daughters and his Y to his sons.
  3. A worked example, hemophilia: a carrier mother (XHXh) and an unaffected father (XHY). Half the sons are affected and half the daughters are carriers. No daughter is affected.
parentsmotherXHXhcarrierfatherXHYunaffectedxchildrenspermeggsXHYXHXhfemalemalehemophiliacarrierparentsmotherXHXhcarrierfatherXHYunaffectedxchildrenspermeggsXHYXHXhXHXHXHYXHXhXhYfemalemalehemophiliacarrier
  1. Each parent makes gametes by meiosis, one allele of each gene in each. The mother's go down the side of the Punnett square, the father's along the top.
  2. Each cell joins one gamete from each parent: a possible offspring, every cell as likely as the next. Sons: 1 in 2 (50%) with hemophilia. Daughters: none with hemophilia, 1 in 2 (50%) carriers.
Choose each parent's genotype, predict the share of sons affected, then fill the Punnett square. Try a carrier mother with an unaffected father, then an affected father with a mother who is not a carrier.

5.4.A Sex-linked patterns in data and pedigrees

Reading the pattern from data

  • The pattern of a sex-linked trait can often be predicted from data, pedigrees included.
  • In a cross table, look for a ratio that differs between the sexes.
  • In a pedigree, X-linked recessive shows as more males affected, affected sons of unaffected carrier mothers, and no father-to-son transmission.
  • From the pattern you can give the genotypes and phenotypes of parents and offspring.

The detail

  • In a pedigree, squares are males, circles are females and a filled shape is an affected individual. Each row is a generation.
  • Work from the people you can be sure of. An affected male is XaY. His mother carries at least one Xa. Every daughter of an affected male gets his Xa.
  • An affected female (XaXa) must have an affected father and a mother who is at least a carrier. All her sons are affected.

Ruling patterns out

  • An affected father with an affected son does not rule out X-linked by itself: the son's allele could have come from a carrier mother. But a trait passed from father to son when the mother has no copy cannot be X-linked.
  • An affected daughter of an unaffected father rules out X-linked recessive: she would need his Xa, and he would show it.
  • A trait in every son of every affected father, and in no daughter, fits Y-linked.

Watch out

  • A small family can fit more than one pattern. Say which patterns the pedigree rules out and which it only makes likely.

You will rarely be told that a gene is on the X. You will be given data and asked to work it out. Two kinds of data come up: a table of offspring from a cross, and a pedigree.

In a cross table, sort the offspring by sex as well as by phenotype. For a gene on an ordinary chromosome (an autosome) the ratio is the same in sons and daughters. If the sexes differ, as when all the daughters are unaffected and half the sons are affected, the gene is probably on the X.

In a pedigree, an X-linked recessive trait leaves three marks. More males are affected than females. Affected sons often have two unaffected parents, because the mother is a carrier. And the trait never passes from a father to his son, since a son gets his father's Y. From those marks you can write the genotype of almost everyone in the family, and predict the chance for the next child.

A cross table that points to the X
OffspringUnaffectedAffected
Daughters520
Sons2527

Remember it Three marks of an X-linked recessive trait in a pedigree

  • MalesMostly males affectedone X: a single recessive allele shows
  • MothersCarrier mothersunaffected mother, affected son
  • NeverNever father to sona son gets his father's Y, not his X
  • A ratio that differs between sons and daughters points to a sex-linked gene.
  • X-linked recessive: more males, carrier mothers, no father to son.
  • Use the pattern to give genotypes and to predict offspring.
Watch out "More males affected" is a clue, not a proof. The firm evidence is who passed the allele to whom.

The table above shows the children of many couples who all have the same pair of genotypes for one X-linked recessive condition. Which pair of parents fits the data?

IIIIII1212341234IIIIII1212341234malefemaleaffected
  1. In this family only men have had the condition, and none of their parents had it. Squares are men, circles women; a filled symbol is affected. Roman numerals number the generations.
  2. Look first at I-1, I-2 and II-1, ringed: they rule out at least one way of inheriting. Which patterns could give this tree, and which are ruled out?
One made-up family. Test each pattern of inheritance against the tree, then work out the genotypes.

5.4.A Sex without X and Y

Not always X and Y

  • In some species sex is not determined by X and Y chromosomes.
  • In birds the sex chromosomes are Z and W. Males are ZZ and females are ZW.
  • In bees sex is set by haplodiploidy: females grow from fertilized eggs and are diploid; males grow from unfertilized eggs and are haploid.

The detail

  • In the Z and W system the female has the two different sex chromosomes, so the egg, not the sperm, sets the sex of the offspring.
  • A recessive allele on the Z shows in a ZW female with one copy, so Z-linked recessive traits are commoner in female birds. It is the X-linked pattern with the sexes swapped.
  • A male bee has one set of chromosomes, so every allele he carries shows, and he makes sperm by mitosis, not meiosis: all his sperm are genetically identical.

Watch out

  • The rule to carry from the last two chapters is not "males show it more". It is "the sex with one copy shows it more".

X and Y are one way to set sex. They are not the only way. The reasoning of the last two chapters still works in other systems, as long as you ask which sex has only one copy of a gene. The course framework names birds and bees as examples, so apply that reasoning to them, or to an unfamiliar system, rather than memorizing the two systems.

Birds have sex chromosomes called Z and W. A male bird is ZZ and a female is ZW, so in birds it is the female who has two different sex chromosomes.

Bees, ants and wasps have no sex chromosomes at all. Their system is haplodiploidy. A queen bee can lay an egg with or without fertilizing it. A fertilized egg is diploid and develops as a female. An unfertilized egg is haploid and develops as a male. Tap each system in the figure to see how the offspring's sex is set.

  • Birds: ZZ males, ZW females.
  • Bees: diploid females from fertilized eggs, haploid males from unfertilized eggs.
Watch out Do not assume the male is the sex with two different sex chromosomes. In birds it is the female.

A male honeybee develops from an unfertilized egg. How many parents and grandparents does he have?

X and Ymammals, fruit fliesXXXYfemalemalesex chromosomesZ and WbirdsZWZZfemalemalesex chromosomesHaplodiploidyhoneybees2nnfemalemalesets of chromosomes

Tap a system to read how the sex of the offspring is set.

5.4.A Linked genes

Two genes, one chromosome

  • Genes located on the same chromosome are genetically linked. They tend to segregate together in meiosis.
  • So linked genes do not assort independently: a test cross gives many parental offspring and few recombinant offspring, not 1 : 1 : 1 : 1.
  • Only crossing over between the two genes separates their alleles.

The detail

  • Independent assortment works because different chromosome pairs line up independently in meiosis I. Two genes on one chromosome are carried on the same piece of DNA, so they go where it goes.
  • Parental offspring carry the same combinations of alleles as the chromosomes of the heterozygous parent. Recombinant offspring carry new combinations.
  • A crossover swaps matching pieces between two non-sister chromatids of a homologous pair. If the swap falls between the two genes, two of the four chromatids come out recombinant.
  • A test cross is used because the double recessive parent adds only recessive alleles, so each offspring's phenotype shows which gamete it had from the heterozygous parent.

Morgan's count

  • Morgan test crossed female flies heterozygous for body color (gray or black) and wing size (normal or vestigial) with black, vestigial-winged males.
  • Of 2,300 offspring, 965 were gray with normal wings and 944 black with vestigial wings: the two parental kinds.
  • Only 206 were gray with vestigial wings and 185 black with normal wings: the two recombinant kinds.
  • Independent assortment predicts about 575 of each.

Watch out

  • Linked is not sex-linked. Linked genes share any one chromosome. Sex-linked genes sit on a sex chromosome.

Mendel's law of independent assortment says the alleles of one gene are sorted into gametes without regard to the alleles of another. That is true when the two genes are on different chromosomes. A chromosome carries hundreds or thousands of genes, though, and two genes on the same chromosome cannot be sorted independently. They are genetically linked.

Take a parent heterozygous for two linked genes, with A and B on one chromosome and a and b on its homolog. When the homologs separate in meiosis I, A goes with B and a goes with b. Most gametes are AB or ab, the parental kinds.

The only thing that separates them is crossing over. If a crossover in prophase I falls between the two genes, it makes chromatids carrying Ab and aB. Gametes and offspring with these new combinations are recombinant. A crossover between any one pair of genes happens in only some meioses, so recombinants are the minority.

That is the mark of linkage in data: a test cross that should give 1 : 1 : 1 : 1 gives two large classes and two small ones.

  • Genes on the same chromosome are genetically linked.
  • Linked genes tend to segregate together, so they do not assort independently.
  • Recombinants come only from crossing over between the genes, and are the smaller classes.
Watch out Linked genes are not always inherited together. Crossing over separates them in some gametes, which is why the recombinant classes are small and not empty.

Morgan test crossed flies heterozygous for body color and wing size. Independent assortment predicts four kinds of offspring in equal numbers. If the two genes are on the same chromosome, what should he count?

A test cross for body color and wing size, counted as the flies hatch. Watch which piles grow fastest, then where the two genes turn out to be.
One cell with both genes on one chromosome pair, with and without a crossover between them. Name each gamete as parental or recombinant before the caption does.

5.4.A Gene mapping

From counts to a map

  • The probability that two linked genes are separated in meiosis is used to calculate the map distance between them. This is gene mapping.
  • Recombination frequency = recombinant offspring ÷ total offspring × 100.
  • 1% recombination = 1 map unit.
  • The farther apart two genes are, the more often a crossover falls between them, and the higher the recombination frequency.

The detail

  • A crossover can fall anywhere along a chromosome. Two genes that are far apart have more room between them for one to land.
  • In a test cross the recombinants are the two smallest classes. Add them together: one crossover makes one of each.
  • Alfred Sturtevant, a student in Morgan's laboratory, used this idea in 1913 to draw the first map of genes along a chromosome.

Worked example

  • A test cross gives 1,000 offspring: 430 and 420 of the parental kinds, 70 and 80 of the recombinant kinds.
  • Recombinants: 70 + 80 = 150. Recombination frequency = 150 ÷ 1,000 × 100 = 15%. The genes are 15 map units apart.
  • Is that linkage, or chance? Against 1 : 1 : 1 : 1 the expected count is 250 of each. Chi-square = 129.6 + 115.6 + 129.6 + 115.6 = 490.4, far above the critical value of 7.81 for 3 degrees of freedom. Reject independent assortment.

Ordering three genes

  • Find the distance for each pair. The pair with the greatest distance sits at the two ends, and the third gene lies between them.
  • A to B is 12 map units, B to D is 5 and A to D is 17. Since 12 + 5 = 17, the order is A, B, D.
  • In real data the longest distance often comes out a little less than the sum, because two crossovers between distant genes put the alleles back together and go uncounted.

Watch out

  • A recombination frequency never goes above 50%. At 50% the four classes are equal, which is what unlinked genes give. Genes far apart on one chromosome can look unlinked.
  • A map unit is not a length in nanometers or base pairs. It is a measure of how often crossing over separates two genes.

Morgan's recombinants were more than a curiosity. Their number carries information. A crossover can fall anywhere along a chromosome, so two genes that are far apart are separated often, and two genes that are close together are separated rarely. Count how often two genes are separated, and you have a measure of how far apart they are.

That measure is the recombination frequency: the recombinant offspring divided by all the offspring, times 100. One percent recombination is defined as one map unit. Working out the order of genes and the distances between them this way is gene mapping.

Take a test cross with 1,000 offspring: 430 and 420 of two kinds, 70 and 80 of the other two. The two small classes are the recombinants, 150 in all. The recombination frequency is 150 ÷ 1,000 × 100 = 15%, so the two genes are 15 map units apart.

With three genes you can find their order. Measure each pair. If A and B are 12 map units apart, B and D are 5, and A and D are 17, then B must lie between A and D, because 12 + 5 = 17. Use the tool to practice each step with fresh numbers.

Remember it From a test cross to a map distance in three steps

  • SpotThe recombinantsthe two smallest classes
  • DivideBy the totalrecombinants ÷ all offspring
  • Times 100Map units1% is 1 map unit, never over 50
  • Recombination frequency = recombinants ÷ total × 100.
  • 1% recombination = 1 map unit.
  • Greater distance, more crossovers between the genes, more recombinants.
Watch out Add both recombinant classes before you divide. Using one of them gives half the true distance.

A test cross for two linked genes gives 800 offspring: 352 and 344 of two kinds, 54 and 50 of the other two. How far apart are the genes?

Test cross offspringA B430a b420A b70a B80total1,000recombinants: 70 + 80 = 150150 / 1,000 x 100 = 15%15% recombination = 15 map unitsThe two rare kinds are recombinantThree genes, in pairsA to B: 12B to D: 5A to D: 17distances in map unitsABD125
  1. A test cross of two genes, 1,000 offspring counted. Independent assortment would give about 250 of each kind. These are far from that: the genes are linked.
  2. The two rare kinds are the recombinants. Recombination frequency = recombinants ÷ total × 100 = 15%, and 1% is 1 map unit.
  3. With three genes, the pair farthest apart sits at the ends. A to D is 17 = 12 + 5, so B lies between A and D.
Three tasks with fresh numbers each time: find a recombination frequency from a test cross, put three or four genes in order from their map distances, and predict the offspring from a map distance.

5.4.A Pleiotropy

One gene, many effects

  • Pleiotropy: the expression of a single gene results in multiple traits or effects.
  • It happens because the gene's product acts in more than one place, or in more than one pathway.
  • The traits of a pleiotropic gene do not segregate independently. They are inherited as a set.
  • No crossover can part them, because there is only one gene.

The detail

  • A gene codes for a product, usually a protein. If that protein is used in several tissues, or early in a pathway that many things depend on, changing it changes several traits at once.
  • Follow two traits of one pleiotropic gene through a cross and they behave as one: a self-pollinated heterozygote gives two phenotype classes, 3 : 1, with the traits always together.

Telling three cases apart

  • Two genes on different chromosomes: four phenotype classes, 9 : 3 : 3 : 1 from two heterozygotes.
  • Two linked genes: four classes again, with the two recombinant classes small but present.
  • One pleiotropic gene: two classes only. However many offspring are counted, the traits never part.

Examples

  • Mendel's pea: the gene he followed as flower color also colors the seed coat and marks the leaf joints, because it switches on the pathway that makes one purple pigment. Mendel noticed that the three always went together.
  • The frizzle chicken: one allele of a feather keratin gene curls the feathers. Curled feathers hold heat poorly, and frizzle birds were found to have a raised metabolic rate.
  • In humans: the sickle cell allele, met in Unit 1, changes one protein, hemoglobin, and so affects the shape of red blood cells, oxygen delivery and resistance to malaria. It is an example only; no human disorder is content to recall here.

Watch out

  • Pleiotropy is one gene with many effects. It is not many genes with one effect.

So far a broken ratio has meant something unusual about how two alleles show, or about where a gene sits. This cause is different. Sometimes two traits that look unrelated turn out to be two effects of the same gene. When the expression of a single gene results in several traits, the gene shows pleiotropy.

Mendel met it without having a word for it. His purple-flowered pea plants always had gray-brown seed coats and a reddish mark where each leaf joins the stem. His white-flowered plants had none of the three. One gene controls whether the plant makes a purple pigment, and the pigment shows wherever it is made.

For a cross, the consequence is simple. Traits caused by one gene cannot segregate independently, because there is nothing to separate. If you treat flower color and seed coat color as two genes and expect 9 : 3 : 3 : 1, you will count two classes where you expected four. Two linked genes would still give four classes, with a few recombinants. With pleiotropy there are none, ever.

  • Pleiotropy: one gene's expression gives multiple traits.
  • Those traits do not segregate independently.
  • Unlike linked genes, they give no recombinants at all.
Watch out Pleiotropy is not two linked genes. Linked genes can be separated by a crossover between them. The traits of one gene cannot.

In chickens, one allele gives curled "frizzle" feathers and also a raised metabolic rate, so the birds eat more. A breeder wants frizzle feathers without the extra appetite, and plans to breed thousands of chicks and pick out a recombinant. Will it work?

Garden peaone genepurpleflowersgray-brownseed coatreddishleaf jointsFrizzle chickenone genecurledfeathersbody heatlost fasterfastermetabolismThe test: one gene or two?400 offspring of one purple-flowered pea plant, self-pollinated (made-up numbers)purple flowers,gray-brown coat301white flowers,white coat99purple flowers,white coat0white flowers,gray-brown coat0

Tap the pea, the chicken or the test.

5.4.A Non-nuclear inheritance

DNA outside the nucleus

  • Mitochondria and chloroplasts have their own DNA. Traits set by it do not follow Mendel's rules.
  • These organelles are randomly assorted to gametes and daughter cells. They are not lined up and shared out as chromosomes are.
  • In animals, mitochondria come from the egg, not the sperm, so mitochondrial traits are maternally inherited.
  • In plants, mitochondria and chloroplasts come in the ovule, not the pollen, so their traits are maternally inherited too.

The detail

  • Unit 2 gave the reason these organelles have DNA at all: they descend from free-living prokaryotes taken in by an early cell.
  • Human mitochondrial DNA is a small circle of 16,569 base pairs carrying 37 genes. The nucleus holds about 20,000 protein-coding genes.
  • A cell has many mitochondria, each with several copies of its DNA. When the cell divides they are shared out by chance, so two daughter cells can get different mixes.
  • A mother passes her mitochondrial DNA to all her children, sons and daughters. Only her daughters pass it on again.

Examples

  • In 1909 Carl Correns crossed four o'clock plants that had green, white and variegated branches. Seeds from flowers on a green branch grew into green seedlings and seeds from a white branch into white ones, whichever branch the pollen came from.
  • Seeds from a variegated branch gave green, white and variegated seedlings in no fixed ratio. Each ovule had been dealt its own mix of chloroplasts by chance.
  • Four o'clocks serve two chapters. Flower color in chapter 2 is set by a gene in the nucleus. Leaf color here is set by DNA in the chloroplasts.

Watch out

  • Maternal inheritance is not X-linked inheritance. An X-linked trait can come from a father to his daughters. A mitochondrial trait cannot come from a father at all.

Every cross so far has been about genes on chromosomes in the nucleus. A little of a eukaryotic cell's DNA is elsewhere: in its mitochondria and, in plants and algae, its chloroplasts. Inheritance of traits set by that DNA is called non-nuclear inheritance, and it breaks Mendel's rules in two ways.

First, there is no orderly segregation. Chromosomes are paired, lined up and pulled apart in meiosis, which is what gives Mendel's ratios. Organelles float in the cytoplasm and are shared out by chance when a cell divides. So a trait set by organelle DNA gives no 3 : 1 and no 1 : 1.

Second, the two parents do not contribute equally. An egg is a large cell full of mitochondria. A sperm is tiny, and the few mitochondria it has are not passed on. So in animals mitochondrial DNA usually comes from the mother alone: it is maternally inherited. In plants the organelles come in the ovule and not the pollen, so traits set by chloroplast or mitochondrial DNA follow the mother plant too.

In a pedigree this has a clear look. An affected mother can pass the trait to any of her children, sons or daughters. An affected father passes it to none.

  • Mitochondria and chloroplasts are assorted at random, so their traits follow no Mendelian ratio.
  • Animals: mitochondria come from the egg.
  • Plants: mitochondria and chloroplasts come in the ovule.
Watch out Mitochondrial inheritance follows the mother and reaches sons and daughters alike. It is not X-linked.

A man has a condition caused by a change in his mitochondrial DNA. His partner does not have it. What do you predict for their children?

Before fertilizationeggmany mitochondria,each with its own DNAsperma few mitochondriain its midpiece: theyare not passed onAfter fertilization: the zygotenuclear DNA:half from each parentmitochondria:all from the eggFour o’clock plant: leaf colorovule from agreen branch×pollen from awhite branchevery seedlinggreenThe seedlings follow the branch that bore the ovule.Four o’clock plant: leaf colorovule from awhite branch×pollen from agreen branchevery seedlingwhiteSwap the parents and the result swaps too.
  1. An egg is large and holds many mitochondria. A sperm is small, and its few mitochondria are not passed on.
  2. The zygote's nuclear DNA is half from each parent. Its mitochondria, and their DNA, are all from the egg.
  3. Chloroplasts follow the same rule. An ovule from a green branch of a four o'clock gives green seedlings, even with pollen from a white branch.
  4. The reciprocal cross: an ovule from a white branch gives white seedlings. The trait follows the mother, with no Mendelian ratio.

5.5.A Phenotypic plasticity

One genotype, more than one phenotype

  • Environmental conditions influence gene expression.
  • So the same genotype can result in different phenotypes under different conditions. This is phenotypic plasticity.
  • The DNA sequence does not change. What changes is which genes are expressed, and how much.
  • The change happens within one individual's life and is not passed on in its alleles.

The detail

  • A phenotype is the product of a genotype and an environment. Mendel grew his peas side by side in one garden, which kept the environment out of his results.
  • Cells sense their surroundings: temperature, light, nutrients, signals from other cells. Those signals reach the nucleus by the pathways of Unit 4 and switch genes on or off. Unit 6 covers how.
  • Many plastic changes are reversible. Some, like the sex of a turtle, are fixed once development has passed a certain point.

Try it

  • In the film, choose one organism and then each environment in turn. For each, finish the sentence "Same DNA, different ...".

Watch out

  • Plasticity is not evolution. Evolution is a change in the alleles of a population over generations. Plasticity is a change in one individual with its alleles untouched.
  • The ability to respond is itself inherited, and can evolve. The response is not.

Mendel's model runs from genotype straight to phenotype: know the alleles and you know the plant. For many traits that leaves something out. Two individuals with exactly the same genotype can look different if they grow up in different conditions.

The reason is that environmental conditions influence gene expression. A gene is a stretch of DNA, and having it is not the same as using it. Cells respond to temperature, light, food and signals by expressing some genes more and others less. When the same genotype gives different phenotypes in different environments, the organism shows phenotypic plasticity.

Notice what does not change: the DNA sequence. A plant grown in shade has the same alleles as its clone grown in sun. No mutation has happened, and the offspring of either plant will inherit the same alleles. Plasticity changes how a genotype is read. It does not edit the genotype.

  • Environmental conditions influence gene expression.
  • Phenotypic plasticity: the same genotype, different phenotypes in different conditions.
  • The DNA sequence is unchanged, so the change is not inherited.
Watch out Plasticity is not mutation. If the environment changed the phenotype and the alleles are the same, no DNA was altered.

An arctic fox grows a white coat every winter and a brown-gray one every summer. A fox that mated in its white winter coat has pups in spring. What coat do the pups grow for their first summer?

Six organisms, each shown in two or three environments. In every pair the DNA is the same. Watch what the environment changes.
one parent plantwith its allelestwo cuttingsthe same alleles in bothcutting Acutting Bparent plantsame alleles, different plantsgrown in full sungrown in shadeshort and sturdy, small thick leavestall, with broad thin leavesmoved into the sunthe change is reversiblegrown in full sunmoved into the sunnew growthlike the sun plant
  1. One parent plant, with its alleles.
  2. Two cuttings from it carry exactly the same alleles: one genotype.
  3. One cutting grows in sun and one in shade. The same alleles, expressed differently, make a short, sturdy plant and a tall one with broad leaves.
  4. Move the shaded plant into the sun and its new growth comes in like the sun plant's. The alleles never changed.

5.5.A Plasticity in six organisms

Reading the environment

  • Height and weight in humans depend on nutrition as well as genotype.
  • Flower color in some plants depends on soil pH.
  • Seasonal fur color in arctic animals changes with the time of year.
  • Sex determination in reptiles can depend on the temperature of the nest.
  • Increased UV raises melanin production in animals.
  • The presence of the opposite mating type sets off pheromone production in yeast and other fungi.

The six, one by one

  • Humans: identical twins have the same genotype. Raised on different diets, they can differ in adult height and weight.
  • Hydrangea: one variety flowers blue in acidic soil and pink in alkaline soil. In acidic soil the roots can take up aluminum, which turns the flower pigment blue.
  • Arctic fox, snowshoe hare: shortening days in autumn set off a molt, and the new coat grows in white. Lengthening days bring the brown coat back.
  • Turtles: red-eared slider eggs kept at 26 °C hatch mainly as males, and at 31 °C mainly as females. Other reptiles have other patterns: in the American alligator, both cooler and hotter nests give females.
  • Skin: ultraviolet light raises the expression of the genes for making melanin, the dark pigment that shields DNA. The tan fades when the UV does.
  • Yeast: a yeast cell that detects the pheromone of the opposite mating type expresses its mating genes, makes more pheromone of its own and grows toward its partner. Unit 4 met this signal.

One more

  • A Himalayan rabbit is white with dark ears, nose, feet and tail. Its pigment enzyme works only in cooler skin. Raised in the warm, a rabbit with the same alleles is white all over. Choose it in the film's Organism list.

Reading the data

  • In a graph of a trait against an environment, each line is one genotype. A sloping line shows plasticity. Lines with different slopes show that genotypes respond differently.
  • To explain a result, name the environmental condition, say how the phenotype responded (usually through a change in gene expression) and say that the genotype did not change.

Beyond the course

  • Human height also has no simple ratio for a second reason: it is influenced by many genes, each adding a little. A trait like that, with the environment on top, spreads into a smooth curve with no separate classes. The last figure shows the idea with skin color. The course framework for this unit does not name traits built by many genes, so you will not be asked about them here.

Watch out

  • Do not write that the environment "changes the genes". It changes their expression. The sequence stays the same.

The course framework lists six examples of the same genotype giving different phenotypes. You do not need more detail than the figure and the list give, but you should be able to take any one of them, or an unfamiliar case, and explain it in the same three moves: the genotype is the same, an environmental condition differs, and the phenotype responds, usually through a change in gene expression. Hydrangea is the exception: its pigment is the same in both soils, and what differs is the aluminum the roots take up.

Some responses are reversible within days or months: skin tans and fades, a fox molts twice a year, a yeast cell stops making pheromone when no partner is near. Others are set once during development and stay: a turtle's sex is fixed by the temperature of the nest in the middle part of incubation, and a child short of food for years may never reach the height its genotype allowed.

Data on plasticity usually come as a table or a graph of a trait in two or more environments. Read each genotype separately. If its phenotype differs between environments, that genotype is plastic for that trait. If two genotypes differ in how much they respond, say so: the response itself depends on the genotype.

Remember it Six environments, six responses

  • NutritionHumansheight and weight
  • Soil pHFlowersblue or pink
  • SeasonArctic animalswhite or brown fur
  • Nest heatReptilesmale or female
  • UVAnimalsmore melanin
  • Mate nearbyYeast, fungiopposite mating type: pheromone made
  • Six examples: nutrition, soil pH, season, nest temperature, UV, mating type.
  • Each time: same genotype, different conditions, different phenotype, usually through a change in gene expression (hydrangea is the exception).
Watch out Plasticity is not natural selection. Selection changes which alleles are common in a population over generations. Plasticity changes one individual, now.

A beach where red-eared slider turtles nest is planted with trees, and the shaded nests now stay near 26 °C where they used to reach 31 °C. What happens to the hatchlings, and why?

One organism at a time. Choose it, then switch Environment and say what stayed the same and what changed.
Plant height (cm)020406080poor soilrich soilwhere the plants were grown(made-up numbers)genotype 1genotype 2Each line is one genotype in two places.Genotype 1 responds far more than genotype 2.
  1. Plants of one genotype grown in poor soil and in rich soil. The same alleles give a different height in each.
  2. A second genotype in the same two soils. It changes too, but much less.
  3. Each line is one genotype in two environments. The slope shows the plasticity; different slopes show that genotypes respond differently.
blood group of 30 students (made-up numbers)11A4B2AB13OSeparate groups: nobody is halfway between two.six alleles, each lighter or darker (a simple model)01020combinations out of 641615201561the six alleles: how many are the darker kindThree of each is commonest; the extremes are rare.add the environment: sun, diet and morelighterdarkerskin colorMany shades and no steps: continuous variation.
  1. Beyond the course. Some traits fall into separate classes: nobody is halfway between two blood groups.
  2. Beyond the course. A simple model of a trait influenced by many genes: six alleles, each lighter or darker. Middling combinations are commonest and the extremes are rare.
  3. Beyond the course. Add the environment and the steps blur into a smooth spread, as for human height.

02Dry lab: Fly crosses: linked or not?

Cross flies that carry two invented genes, count each brood and use a chi-square test to decide whether the genes assort independently or travel together. For a linked pair, work out the recombination frequency and the map distance. Then try the mystery pairs.

WwRrwwrrOFFSPRINGno brood yet0000
Fly crosses. Cross a fly heterozygous for two invented genes, breed a brood, count each phenotype and test the counts with chi-square against the ratio independent assortment predicts. Record each brood's counts, its chi-square value and your decision. The genes and flies are made up for practice: not real fruit fly data.
Your questionDo two genes on the same chromosome assort independently, as genes on different chromosomes do? Start with one pair of genes and one cross, work out the ratio you expect if they are unlinked, then see what a real brood gives you.
What you can changeWhether the two genes sit on different chromosomes or are linked at 40, 20 or 5 percent recombination, the cross (a test cross or F1 by F1), and the size of the brood (100, 200, 500 or 1000). The genes are invented and are not real fruit fly data. Change one thing at a time.
What to recordFor each brood: the settings, the count of each of the four phenotypes, for each test cross brood the recombination frequency as a percentage, the expected counts, your chi-square value, the degrees of freedom, and your decision to reject or fail to reject the null hypothesis. Repeat each set-up at least three times: broods scatter, as real ones do.

Find out

  • What do unlinked genes give? Set the two genes on different chromosomes, make a test cross and breed 200 offspring. Write down the ratio you expect before you breed. How close is the brood to it?
  • What does linkage do to the ratio? Repeat with the genes linked at 40, then 20, then 5 percent recombination. Which two kinds grow, which two shrink, and which kinds are the recombinants?
  • How far apart? For each linked brood, work out the recombination frequency (recombinants ÷ all offspring × 100) and write it as a map distance in map units. Do three broods of one pair agree?
  • Does the size of the brood matter? Use 100, then 500, then 1000 offspring for the same linked pair. At what size does the chi-square test reject the unlinked ratio every time?
  • Linked or not? Switch to the mystery. You get hidden pairs of genes. Breed as many broods as you need, give your verdict, and see how often you are right.

Record

  • For every brood: the two genes, how they are placed (different chromosomes or linked, and how far), the cross and the number of offspring.
  • The count of each of the four phenotypes, the recombination frequency as a percentage for each test cross brood, and the expected count of each kind if the genes are unlinked.
  • Your null hypothesis, your chi-square value, the degrees of freedom, the critical value at p = 0.05, and your decision to reject or fail to reject the null hypothesis.
  • Change one setting at a time. Repeat each set-up at least three times: no two broods match, because chance decides which gametes meet.
  • Use the live graph to compare observed and expected bars, or download the CSV and plot your own. The genes here are invented, so no result is a fact about real flies.

You make a test cross with two genes on different chromosomes and breed 200 offspring. What do you expect for the four phenotypes?

A test cross of two linked genes gives 500 offspring: 212 and 208 of the two common kinds, 41 and 39 of the two rare kinds. How far apart are the genes?

A brood from a test cross gives a chi-square value above the critical value for the 1 : 1 : 1 : 1 ratio. What should you conclude?

Back to linked genes

Use your results to explain why linked genes give more parental offspring than recombinants, while genes on different chromosomes give all four kinds in about equal numbers. For one linked pair, give its recombination frequency and its map distance.

03Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in.

Exam practice

Exam questions on 5.4 and 5.5, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

Quiz: non-Mendelian geneticsQuiz: the environment and chromosomesUnit 5 escape roomGrass skirts: non-Mendelian genetics and the environmentRevision map: non-Mendelian geneticsRevision map: environmental effects on phenotypeBlurting diagrams: linked and sex-linked genesUnit 5 pub quizUnit 5 practice questions

04Downloads

Take the guide with you, or into a classroom with no internet.

05Teacher resources

The guide as four one-hour lessons: what each covers, its focus and the chapters it uses.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1Dominance and the sex chromosomes 5.4.A60 min How a deviation from a Mendelian ratio is spotted, incomplete dominance and codominance, sex-linked traits and Morgan's flies, an X-linked pedigree, and sex set without X and Y 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
2Linked genes and maps 5.4.A60 min Genetically linked genes, parental and recombinant offspring, crossing over, recombination frequency and map units, with the fly cross lab and chi-square 6, 7, dry lab
3One gene with many effects, and DNA outside the nucleus 5.4.A60 min Pleiotropy and why its traits do not segregate independently, non-nuclear inheritance through mitochondria and chloroplasts, and chi-square practice on crosses that depart from Mendel 1, 8, 9
4Genotype and environment 5.5.A60 min Phenotypic plasticity: environmental conditions change gene expression, so one genotype gives different phenotypes, with the six examples, data on them and a unit close 10, 11

The revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTICE AND REVIEW

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for Unit 5

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.