Biology  by Bradford
support
IB BIOLOGY · THEME A · UNITY AND DIVERSITY

Where did the first cell come from?

Every cell alive today came from another cell, but the first one cannot have. Find out what makes something alive, what early Earth was like, what the Miller-Urey experiment showed, how membranes and RNA may have come first, and what the evidence says about LUCA, the ancestor of all life. Higher level only.

IB Biology A2.1HL only2 hours HL6 chapters

Start learningTeach it

From early Earth to a vent on the sea floor, where fatty acids close into vesicles and RNA copies itself, on to the first protocells and the last universal common ancestor.
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Six chapters, all for higher level. Read one, play its figure or the film, and make each prediction before you open the answer.

Everything in this guide so far is higher level, so there is nothing here for standard level yet.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1What counts as alive? HL
  2. 2A world without oxygen HL
  3. 3Lightning in a flask HL
  4. 4The first bubbles HL
  5. 5The RNA world HL
  6. 6LUCA, the ancestor of everything HL

A2.1.2 Cells as the smallest units of self-sustaining life A2.1.3 Challenge of explaining the spontaneous origin of cells

What counts as alive?

  • A cell is the smallest unit that carries out all the functions of life by itself: the smallest unit of self-sustaining life.
  • Viruses are usually counted as non-living: no metabolism, and copied only inside a host cell.
  • Today every cell comes from the division of an existing cell. A cell is far too complex to assemble by chance in one step.
  • The first cells needed catalysis, self-replication of molecules, self-assembly and compartmentalization.

The detail

  • The functions of life: take in nutrients, respire to release energy, excrete waste, grow, respond to their surroundings, keep their insides steady and reproduce.
  • A molecule of DNA, an enzyme or a mitochondrion taken out of a cell does none of them alone.
  • Viruses sit on the line. They have genes made of nucleic acid and they evolve.
  • Outside a host cell a virus does nothing: no metabolism, no respiration, no growth, no response.
  • Viruses have no cytoplasm and no ribosomes, so they cannot make their own proteins. They are copied only by the machinery of a cell they infect.
  • For these reasons most biologists count viruses as non-living. That makes the first cell a puzzle.

Why each requirement

  • Catalysis: so that reactions could happen fast enough.
  • Self-replication of molecules: so that information could be copied.
  • Self-assembly: of structures such as membranes.
  • Compartmentalization: so that the chemistry inside could differ from that outside.

Watch out

  • Having genes and evolving is not enough to be alive. A virus has both, yet does nothing by itself outside a cell.

Living things carry out all the functions of life: they take in nutrients, respire to release energy, excrete waste, grow, respond to their surroundings, keep their insides steady and reproduce. A cell is the smallest thing that does all of these by itself, so the cell is the smallest unit of self-sustaining life. A molecule of DNA, an enzyme or a mitochondrion taken out of a cell does none of them alone.

Viruses sit on the line. They have genes made of nucleic acid and they evolve, but outside a host cell they do nothing: no metabolism, no respiration, no growth, no response. They have no cytoplasm and no ribosomes, so they cannot make their own proteins, and they are copied only by the machinery of a cell they infect. For these reasons most biologists count viruses as non-living.

That makes the first cell a puzzle. Today every cell comes from the division of an existing cell, and a cell is far too complex to assemble by chance in one step. Before the first cell, four things had to arise: catalysis, so that reactions could happen fast enough; self-replication of molecules, so that information could be copied; self-assembly of structures such as membranes; and compartmentalization, so that the chemistry inside could differ from that outside.

  • The cell is the smallest unit that carries out all the functions of life.
  • Viruses are usually counted as non-living: no metabolism, copied only inside a host.
  • The first cells needed catalysis, self-replication, self-assembly and compartments.
Watch out Having genes and evolving is not enough to be alive. A virus has both, yet does nothing by itself outside a cell.

Which feature of a virus is the strongest reason for calling it non-living?

a cell: the smallest unit of lifecell walland membraneDNAribosomescytoplasmfunctions of lifenutritionrespirationexcretiongrowthresponsehomeostasisreproductionall, by itselfa virus: between living and notprotein capsidnucleic acidDNA or RNAno cytoplasmno ribosomesfunctions of lifenutritionrespirationexcretiongrowthresponsehomeostasisreproductionnone on its ownbefore the first cell, four things had to arisecatalysisreactions fast enoughself-replicationinformation copiedself-assemblystructures form alonecompartmentsan inside that differs

A2.1.1 Conditions on early Earth and the pre-biotic formation of carbon compounds

A world without oxygen

  • Early Earth’s atmosphere held no free oxygen, so there was no ozone layer either.
  • Without ozone, ultraviolet light from the Sun reached the surface and the sea.
  • Far more carbon dioxide and methane, greenhouse gases, made the planet hotter.
  • Carbon compounds may have formed spontaneously, by chemical reactions that no longer happen on Earth.

The detail

  • This was Earth four billion years ago: a different planet.
  • Volcanoes erupted water vapour and gases, lightning was frequent, and hot water poured from vents on the sea floor.
  • Energy from ultraviolet light, lightning and heat could break the bonds in simple molecules such as methane, ammonia and water.
  • The fragments could join into larger ones such as amino acids and sugars.
  • With no oxygen to react with them and no living things to eat them, these compounds could build up in the sea.
  • Today oxygen breaks them down and organisms consume them, which is one reason life does not keep arising afresh.

Watch out

  • No ozone is a consequence of no oxygen: ozone (O3) is made from oxygen. They are not two separate facts.

Four billion years ago Earth was a different planet. Its atmosphere held no free oxygen, so there was no ozone layer either, and ultraviolet light from the Sun reached the surface and the sea. The air held far more carbon dioxide and methane than today, and with these greenhouse gases the planet was hotter. Volcanoes erupted water vapour and gases, lightning was frequent, and hot water poured from vents on the sea floor.

Under those conditions, carbon compounds could have formed by chemical reactions that no longer happen on Earth. Energy from ultraviolet light, lightning and heat could break the bonds in simple molecules such as methane, ammonia and water, and the fragments could join into larger ones such as amino acids and sugars. With no oxygen to react with them and no living things to eat them, these compounds could build up in the sea. Today oxygen breaks them down and organisms consume them, which is one reason life does not keep arising afresh.

  • Early Earth: no free oxygen, no ozone, more CO2 and methane, hotter.
  • UV light, lightning and heat gave energy for reactions.
  • Carbon compounds may have formed spontaneously, by chemistry that does not happen now.
Watch out No ozone is a consequence of no oxygen: ozone (O3) is made from oxygen. They are not two separate facts.

Why could amino acids build up in the early sea but not in today's?

Earth four billion years agovolcanoeshot ventslightningCO₂ CH₄ NH₃ H₂OUV lightamino acidsno oxygenso no ozone layerUV reaches the seaenergy to break bondsmore CO₂ and methanea hotter planetcompounds build upsafe from O₂ and lifeEarth todayvolcanoesventslightningN₂ 78%, O₂ 21%ozone layeroxygen, 21% of airand an ozone layerozone stops most UVhigh in the atmospherelittle CO₂ (0.04%)a cooler planetcompounds broken downby oxygen and microbes

A2.1.4 Evidence for the origin of carbon compounds

Lightning in a flask

  • In 1952 Stanley Miller and Harold Urey tested whether early Earth’s conditions could make the compounds of life.
  • Gases plus a spark plus water, cycled for a week, gave amino acids.
  • Strength: organic compounds of life can form without life, from energy and simple molecules.
  • Limits: the atmosphere may have been wrong, and amino acids are far from a cell.
  • Be able to evaluate the experiment: weigh both sides.

The apparatus

  • A sealed loop of glass held water and a mixture of methane, ammonia and hydrogen, their model of the early atmosphere.
  • The water was boiled so its vapour carried the gases round, past a spark between two electrodes in a large flask, standing in for lightning.
  • A condenser cooled the vapour so it rained back into a trap.
  • After a week the liquid had turned brown, and chromatography showed amino acids in it, glycine and alanine most of all.

Weighing it up

  • It showed that amino acids can form from simple molecules with no life present.
  • A run without the spark, as a control, showed that the energy was needed.
  • Later analysis of Miller’s stored samples found more than twenty amino acids.
  • Geologists now think the early atmosphere was mostly carbon dioxide and nitrogen, which give far less; the gases in the apparatus were chosen to work.
  • The experiment makes no proteins, no nucleic acids and no membranes.

How we know

  • Nature of science: a claim in science must be testable.
  • The origin of life is hard to test: the conditions on pre-biotic Earth cannot be replicated exactly, and the first protocells did not fossilize.
  • Scientists test the parts they can, such as whether amino acids form, whether fatty acids make vesicles and whether RNA can copy itself.
  • They treat the whole story as a set of hypotheses still being tested.

In 1952 Stanley Miller and Harold Urey tested whether early Earth's conditions could make the compounds of life. A sealed loop of glass held water and a mixture of methane, ammonia and hydrogen, their model of the early atmosphere. The water was boiled so its vapour carried the gases round, past a spark between two electrodes in a large flask, standing in for lightning. A condenser cooled the vapour so it rained back into a trap. After a week the liquid had turned brown, and chromatography showed amino acids in it, glycine and alanine most of all.

Evaluating it means weighing both sides. It showed that amino acids can form from simple molecules with no life present, and with a run without the spark as a control, that the energy was needed. Later analysis of Miller's stored samples found more than twenty amino acids. But geologists now think the early atmosphere was mostly carbon dioxide and nitrogen, which give far less; the gases in the apparatus were chosen to work. And amino acids are a long way from a cell: the experiment makes no proteins, no nucleic acids and no membranes.

  • Gases plus a spark plus water, cycled for a week, gave amino acids.
  • Strength: organic compounds of life can form without life, from energy and simple molecules.
  • Limits: the atmosphere may have been wrong, and amino acids are far from a cell.
Nature of science A claim in science must be testable. The origin of life is hard to test: the conditions on pre-biotic Earth cannot be replicated exactly, and the first protocells did not fossilize. Scientists test the parts they can, such as whether amino acids form, whether fatty acids make vesicles and whether RNA can copy itself, and treat the whole story as a set of hypotheses still being tested.

The experiment is repeated with nitrogen, carbon dioxide and water instead of methane, ammonia and hydrogen. What would you predict?

Watch a week of the experiment, then turn the spark off for the control, or swap Miller's gases for today's air, and compare what ends up in the trap.

A2.1.5 Spontaneous formation of vesicles by coalescence of fatty acids into spherical bilayers

The first bubbles

  • A membrane-bound compartment lets the chemistry inside differ from that outside.
  • Fatty acids are amphipathic: a hydrophilic head and a hydrophobic tail.
  • In water they form micelles, then, at higher concentrations, coalesce into bilayers.
  • A bilayer curls round and closes into a sphere, a vesicle, so no tails are left exposed.

The detail

  • A cell needs an inside. Without a boundary, any useful molecules made by chance would drift away, and the chemistry in one place could never differ from that around it.
  • A compartment lets the inside build up its own concentrations and its own reactions.
  • Fatty acids can make one by themselves. They are amphipathic like phospholipids.
  • Micelles: small balls with the tails hidden inside.
  • A flat sheet of bilayer leaves tails exposed at its edges, which is why it closes into a sphere.
  • Vesicles like these form readily in the laboratory, can trap molecules such as RNA inside, take in more fatty acids, grow and split.

Watch out

  • A vesicle of fatty acids is not a cell. It has a boundary but no genes, no enzymes and no metabolism.
  • It is one of the four requirements, not all of them.

A cell needs an inside. Without a boundary, any useful molecules made by chance would drift away, and the chemistry in one place could never differ from that around it. A membrane-bound compartment lets the inside build up its own concentrations and its own reactions.

Fatty acids can make one by themselves. Like phospholipids they are amphipathic: a hydrophilic head and a hydrophobic tail. In water they first gather into small balls, micelles, with their tails hidden inside. At higher concentrations they coalesce into bilayers. A flat sheet of bilayer leaves tails exposed at its edges, so it curls round and closes into a sphere: a vesicle. Vesicles like these form readily in the laboratory, can trap molecules such as RNA inside, take in more fatty acids, grow and split.

  • A compartment lets the chemistry inside differ from that outside.
  • Fatty acids are amphipathic: micelles, then bilayers.
  • A bilayer closes into a vesicle so no tails are left exposed.
Watch out A vesicle of fatty acids is not a cell. It has a boundary but no genes, no enzymes and no metabolism. It is one of the four requirements, not all of them.

Why would a flat sheet of bilayer close up into a sphere?

fatty acids assemble by themselveshydrophilic headhydrophobic tailwaterfatty acids, at randommicelles: tails hidden in a balltails meet waterat this edgeand at this onea bilayer sheeta vesicle:a closed bilayerinside:its own mixin the lab:growsand splits
  1. Fatty acids scattered in water.
  2. They gather into micelles, tails inward.
  3. At higher concentrations they form a bilayer, but its edges leave tails exposed.
  4. The bilayer closes into a vesicle, and the inside can hold different molecules from the outside.

A2.1.6 RNA as a presumed first genetic material

The RNA world

  • RNA stores information in its sequence of bases, and can be copied by complementary base pairing.
  • RNA can fold into shapes that catalyse reactions: ribozymes.
  • So the first living systems may have used RNA as both genes and enzymes: the RNA world hypothesis.
  • In the ribosome, RNA, not protein, still catalyses the peptide bonds during protein synthesis.

The detail

  • In cells today, DNA stores genes and proteins do the catalysis, and each needs the other.
  • Proteins are made from the information in DNA, and DNA is copied by protein enzymes. So which came first?
  • RNA offers a way out, because it can do both jobs.
  • The ribosome is a trace of the RNA world that remains in every cell.

Watch out

  • The RNA world is a hypothesis. No self-replicating RNA from early Earth has been found; the evidence is what RNA can do today.

In cells today, DNA stores genes and proteins do the catalysis, and each needs the other: proteins are made from the information in DNA, and DNA is copied by protein enzymes. So which came first? RNA offers a way out, because it can do both jobs.

RNA stores information in its sequence of bases, and that sequence can be copied by complementary base pairing. RNA can also fold into shapes that catalyse reactions; such RNA catalysts are ribozymes. So the first living systems may have used RNA as both their genes and their enzymes: the RNA world hypothesis. A trace of it remains in every cell: in the ribosome, it is RNA, not protein, that catalyses the peptide bonds between amino acids during protein synthesis.

  • RNA can store information and be copied by base pairing.
  • RNA can catalyse reactions: ribozymes.
  • The ribosome's peptide bonds are still made by RNA.
Watch out The RNA world is a hypothesis. No self-replicating RNA from early Earth has been found; the evidence is what RNA can do today.

Why is the ribosome taken as evidence for the RNA world?

RNA: a gene and an enzyme in oneAUGCCUAGsugar-phosphatebackbonethe information:its sequence of basesUACGGAUCa new bondfree nucleotidesA pairs with U,G pairs with CGCCGAUGCUAa pocket: twomolecules joinedfolded RNA:a ribozymebase pairs hold the folda geneits sequence is copieda geneits sequence is copiedan enzymeit folds and catalysesan enzymeit folds and catalysesin every ribosome today, RNA still joins the amino acids
  1. A strand of RNA: information in its sequence of bases.
  2. Free nucleotides pair with it to make a complementary copy.
  3. Folded on itself, RNA can catalyse a reaction: a ribozyme.

A2.1.7 Evidence for a last universal common ancestor A2.1.8 Approaches used to estimate dates of the first living cells and the last universal common ancestor A2.1.9 Evidence for the evolution of the last universal common ancestor in the vicinity of hydrothermal vents

LUCA, the ancestor of everything

  • One universal genetic code and genes shared by all organisms are evidence for a last universal common ancestor (LUCA).
  • Other forms of life probably evolved too, but went extinct, perhaps outcompeted by LUCA and its descendants.
  • Dates come from fossils in rock dated by radioactive isotopes, and from a molecular clock.
  • Life has been evolving for almost all of Earth’s 4.5 billion years: recent estimates put LUCA at around 4.2 billion years ago.
  • Vents: conserved genes for heat, no oxygen and H2, and fossils from ancient sea-floor hydrothermal vents.

Evidence for LUCA

  • The same codons stand for the same amino acids in bacteria, plants and people.
  • All living things use DNA, RNA, ribosomes and ATP.
  • Some genes are found, in recognisable versions, in every organism.
  • The simplest explanation is that all life descends from one population of cells, LUCA.

Dating and the vents

  • Rocks are dated by the decay of radioactive isotopes, so fossils in them can be dated.
  • Stromatolites, layered mounds built by microbes, go back about 3.5 billion years, and possible microfossils are older.
  • A molecular clock uses the differences between genes shared by all life, with a rate of change calibrated against dated fossils, to estimate when the lineages split.
  • Genes conserved across bacteria and archaea were probably in LUCA. They include ones for living without oxygen, at high temperature, and on hydrogen and carbon dioxide, which is how chemistry works at hydrothermal vents.
  • Some of the oldest possible fossils are threads and tubes of iron minerals in rock that formed around ancient sea-floor vents.

Watch out

  • LUCA was not the first living thing, and not the only life of its time.
  • It is the last ancestor that everything alive today shares.

All living things share the same genetic code: the same codons stand for the same amino acids in bacteria, plants and people. All use DNA, RNA, ribosomes and ATP, and some genes are found, in recognisable versions, in every organism. The simplest explanation is that all life descends from one population of cells, the last universal common ancestor (LUCA). LUCA was not the first life: other forms probably evolved too, but went extinct, perhaps outcompeted by LUCA and its descendants.

Dates come from several approaches. Rocks are dated by the decay of radioactive isotopes, so fossils in them can be dated: stromatolites, layered mounds built by microbes, go back about 3.5 billion years, and possible microfossils are older. A molecular clock uses the differences between genes shared by all life, with a rate of change calibrated against dated fossils, to estimate when the lineages split; recent estimates put LUCA at around 4.2 billion years ago. Life has been evolving for almost all of Earth's 4.5 billion years.

Where did LUCA live? Genes that are conserved across bacteria and archaea, and so were probably in LUCA, include ones for living without oxygen, at high temperature, and on hydrogen and carbon dioxide, which is how chemistry works at hydrothermal vents. And some of the oldest possible fossils are threads and tubes of iron minerals in rock that formed around ancient sea-floor vents.

  • One genetic code and shared genes: evidence for LUCA.
  • Dates from fossils in dated rock and from molecular clocks.
  • Vents: conserved genes for heat, no oxygen and H2, and vent fossils.
Watch out LUCA was not the first living thing, and not the only life of its time. It is the last ancestor that everything alive today shares.

Which finding would most strongly challenge the idea of a single LUCA?

four and a half billion years of life4.64321nowbillion years agono free oxygenoxygen in the airtap a cardEarthformsventfossils?O₂oxygenbuilds upanimalfossilsLUCAby clockstromatolites

Tap a mark on the timeline to see the evidence.

02Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in.

Exam practice

Exam questions on A2.1, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

A2.1 revision mapA2.1 exam questionsA2.1 multiple choice quizA2.1 pub quizA2.1 Tarsia puzzleNext: A2.2 cell structureNext: A2.3 virusesSee also: B2.1 membranes

03Downloads

Take the guide with you, or into a classroom with no internet.

04Teacher resources

The guide as two one-hour lessons. Each has a plan to print (the timings, what to project and where to stop, the activities with what they need, what students get wrong) and slides to teach it from, in the same order, with the teacher's moves in the notes.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1Before life HL A2.1.1 to A2.1.460 min Living and non-living, why viruses are counted as non-living, conditions on early Earth and the Miller-Urey experiment 1, 2, 3 Lesson planPDF 633 KB SlidesPPTX 3.0 MB
2From molecules to LUCA HL A2.1.3, A2.1.5 to A2.1.960 min The challenge of explaining the first cells, vesicles from fatty acids, the RNA world, and the evidence for LUCA, its date and its home 4, 5, 6 Teacher pass: Lesson planPDF 636 KB Teacher pass: SlidesPPTX 882 KB

Lesson 1 is free with a free account. The other plans and slides, for every guide, come with the Teacher pass.

The note template, the revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTISE AND REVISE

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for A2.1

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.