A2.1.2 Cells as the smallest units of self-sustaining life A2.1.3 Challenge of explaining the spontaneous origin of cells
What counts as alive?
- A cell is the smallest unit that carries out all the functions of life by itself: the smallest unit of self-sustaining life.
- Viruses are usually counted as non-living: no metabolism, and copied only inside a host cell.
- Today every cell comes from the division of an existing cell. A cell is far too complex to assemble by chance in one step.
- The first cells needed catalysis, self-replication of molecules, self-assembly and compartmentalization.
The detail
- The functions of life: take in nutrients, respire to release energy, excrete waste, grow, respond to their surroundings, keep their insides steady and reproduce.
- A molecule of DNA, an enzyme or a mitochondrion taken out of a cell does none of them alone.
- Viruses sit on the line. They have genes made of nucleic acid and they evolve.
- Outside a host cell a virus does nothing: no metabolism, no respiration, no growth, no response.
- Viruses have no cytoplasm and no ribosomes, so they cannot make their own proteins. They are copied only by the machinery of a cell they infect.
- For these reasons most biologists count viruses as non-living. That makes the first cell a puzzle.
Why each requirement
- Catalysis: so that reactions could happen fast enough.
- Self-replication of molecules: so that information could be copied.
- Self-assembly: of structures such as membranes.
- Compartmentalization: so that the chemistry inside could differ from that outside.
Watch out
- Having genes and evolving is not enough to be alive. A virus has both, yet does nothing by itself outside a cell.
Living things carry out all the functions of life: they take in nutrients, respire to release energy, excrete waste, grow, respond to their surroundings, keep their insides steady and reproduce. A cell is the smallest thing that does all of these by itself, so the cell is the smallest unit of self-sustaining life. A molecule of DNA, an enzyme or a mitochondrion taken out of a cell does none of them alone.
Viruses sit on the line. They have genes made of nucleic acid and they evolve, but outside a host cell they do nothing: no metabolism, no respiration, no growth, no response. They have no cytoplasm and no ribosomes, so they cannot make their own proteins, and they are copied only by the machinery of a cell they infect. For these reasons most biologists count viruses as non-living.
That makes the first cell a puzzle. Today every cell comes from the division of an existing cell, and a cell is far too complex to assemble by chance in one step. Before the first cell, four things had to arise: catalysis, so that reactions could happen fast enough; self-replication of molecules, so that information could be copied; self-assembly of structures such as membranes; and compartmentalization, so that the chemistry inside could differ from that outside.
- The cell is the smallest unit that carries out all the functions of life.
- Viruses are usually counted as non-living: no metabolism, copied only inside a host.
- The first cells needed catalysis, self-replication, self-assembly and compartments.
Which feature of a virus is the strongest reason for calling it non-living?
Size is not the test, and the kind of nucleic acid says nothing about being alive. What a virus lacks is the self-sustaining part: no respiration, no protein synthesis, no growth, nothing at all until it is inside a cell.