Biology  by Bradford
support
AP BIOLOGY · UNIT 6 · GENE EXPRESSION AND REGULATION

Same genome, different cells

A neuron and a muscle cell hold the same DNA and read different parts of it. Find the switches: operons in bacteria, then in your own cells chemical tags that open and close the DNA, transcription factors and enhancers, and small RNAs that silence a message after it is made.

AP Biology 6.5 and 6.64 lessons9 chaptersdry lab

Start learningRun the dry labTeach it

From one body down to three of its cells, each with the same genes: watch which genes each one switches on, how tags and transcription factors decide, and how that makes a nerve cell, a muscle fiber or a beta cell.
NavigationBy the end you cantap a goal to go to its chapter

01Learn

Nine chapters and a dry lab: the question (chapter 1), what on and off mean (2), operons in bacteria (3 and 4), then the points of control in a eukaryotic cell from the DNA outward (5 to 8), and development (9). Make each prediction before you open the answer or run a tool.

NavigationChapterstap a chapter to jump to it
  1. 1Same genes, different cells
  2. 2What "on" and "off" mean
  3. 3One switch for several genes
  4. 4Where it sits explains what it does
  5. 5Tags that open and close the DNA
  6. 6The proteins that start transcription
  7. 7One signal, many genes
  8. 8Silencing a message after it is made
  9. 9Genes switched on in order

6.5.A, 6.6.B Differential gene expression

Same genes, different cells

  • Nearly every cell in your body holds the same genes. Cells differ because they express different ones.
  • A cell's phenotype is set by which genes it expresses and at what level.
  • The function and the amount of each gene product both matter.
  • Gene regulation gives differential gene expression, so cells make different products and do different jobs.

The detail

  • A gene is expressed when its product is made: it is transcribed into RNA and, for most genes, the mRNA is translated into protein.
  • Expression is not all or nothing. A gene can be transcribed a little or a lot, so two cells that both express a gene can hold very different amounts of its protein.
  • Some genes are expressed in every cell, because every cell needs their products: the enzymes of glycolysis and the proteins of ribosomes are two examples.
  • Other genes are expressed in a few kinds of cell. They code for the proteins that give a tissue its job, and those proteins are what you see when cells look different.

Watch out

  • "Nearly every" is deliberate. Mature red blood cells have no nucleus, and some cells of the immune system rearrange a few of their genes.
  • A gene that is not expressed is still there. A skin cell keeps its insulin gene for life and never uses it.

You began as one fertilized egg. That cell divided by mitosis, so the cells it gave rise to carry copies of the same DNA. Yet a neuron, a muscle cell and a cell of your pancreas look nothing alike and do different work. If the genes are the same, something else must differ.

What differs is which genes each cell uses. A gene is expressed when its product is made. A cell of the pancreas expresses the insulin gene; a skin cell holds the same gene and leaves it alone. This is differential gene expression, and it is why cells with one genome have different products and different functions.

The phenotype of a cell, and of the whole organism, comes from the combination of genes expressed and the level of each. Level matters as much as on or off: the amount of a protein, as well as what it does, decides what the cell can do. The rest of this guide is about the switches that set those levels.

  • Cells differ because they express different genes, not because they hold different genes.
  • Phenotype = which genes are expressed + how much of each product is made.
  • Gene regulation gives differential gene expression.
Watch out A cell does not lose the genes it does not use. They stay in its DNA, switched off.

A student measures mRNA from three genes in two kinds of cell from one person (invented data, in units). Gene 1: 40 and 42. Gene 2: 55 and 0. Gene 3: 0 and 61. Which claim do the data support?

the same three genes in every cellinsulinbeta-globinkeratinpancreatic beta cellinsulin granulesmakes insulinnot transcribednot transcribeddeveloping red blood cellnucleus still presentmakes beta-globinnot transcribednot transcribedskin cellkeratin filamentsmakes keratinnot transcribednot transcribedRNA polymerasemRNA
The same three genes sit in every one of these cells. Switch the cell and see which one is being transcribed.
genesmRNA madeprotein madeATP synthaseRNA polymeraseinsulinhemoglobinkeratinrhodopsinmyosinamylase8 genes3 mRNAs3 proteins3 mRNAs3 proteins3 mRNAs3 proteins
  1. A beta cell of the pancreas: the same eight genes as every other cell, but it transcribes only some of them.
  2. A red blood cell precursor: the same genes, a different set of mRNAs and proteins.
  3. A skin cell. Compare the three: which genes are on in every cell, and which in only one?
The same eight genes in three kinds of cell. Choose a cell, read which genes give mRNA and protein, then tap the genes to find the patterns.

6.5.A Regulatory sequences and regulatory proteins

What "on" and "off" mean

  • A gene is "on" when it is being transcribed and "off" when it is not.
  • Regulatory sequences are stretches of DNA. Regulatory proteins bind them and raise or lower transcription.
  • Constitutive genes are expressed all the time.
  • Inducible genes are expressed only when a signal or a substance is present.

The detail

  • A regulatory sequence codes for nothing. It works by being a place on the DNA where a particular protein fits.
  • A regulatory protein recognizes its sequence by shape and by the bases exposed there, much as an enzyme fits its substrate.
  • Some regulatory proteins help RNA polymerase begin. Others get in its way. Chapters 3 and 6 show both kinds.

Why regulate?

  • Making mRNA and protein costs a cell energy and raw materials.
  • A cell that made every protein all the time would waste both, and would make proteins that interfere with each other.
  • So a cell keeps on the genes whose products it always needs, and switches the others on only when they are useful.

"On" and "off" are shorthand. A gene is on when RNA polymerase is transcribing it and off when it is not, and many genes sit somewhere in between. What sets the rate is a meeting of two kinds of thing. A regulatory sequence is a stretch of DNA. A regulatory protein binds to it and makes transcription more likely or less likely.

Some genes are constitutive: they are expressed all the time, because the cell always needs their products. Others are inducible: they are expressed only when a signal or a substance is present. The graph follows the mRNA of two invented genes in one cell while a substance is added. Read it before you name them.

Remember it Two kinds of gene, told apart by when they are expressed

  • ConstitutiveAlways onthe product is always needed
  • InducibleOn when neededa signal or substance switches it on
  • On = transcribed. Off = not transcribed.
  • Regulatory sequences are DNA; regulatory proteins bind them.
  • Constitutive: always expressed. Inducible: expressed when a signal or substance is present.
Watch out A regulatory sequence is not a gene for a regulatory protein. The sequence is the site on the DNA; the protein is made from a gene somewhere else.

Step through the graph. Which claim about the two genes do the data support?

mRNA in the cell (arbitrary units)02468100102030405060time (minutes)(made-up numbers)substance addedgene 1gene 2
  1. The mRNA of two genes in one cell, measured every ten minutes. At 20 minutes a substance will be added.
  2. The next 40 minutes. One line has changed and one has not. Which gene is inducible, and what is the other?

6.5.B Operons in prokaryotes

One switch for several genes

  • An operon is a group of genes with one promoter and one operator. They are transcribed together, so they are regulated together.
  • A regulatory gene elsewhere makes a repressor: a protein whose shape depends on a small molecule.
  • A repressible operon is usually on and is switched off by the product it makes. The trp operon is an example.
  • An inducible operon is usually off and is switched on by the substance it deals with. The lac operon is an example.

The detail

  • The genes of an operon are copied into one long mRNA, which is translated into separate proteins. One decision at the promoter covers them all.
  • The trp operon (an example of a repressible operon) holds five genes for the enzymes that make the amino acid tryptophan. Its repressor cannot bind the operator by itself. When tryptophan builds up, it binds the repressor, the repressor changes shape, fits the operator and blocks transcription.
  • The lac operon (an example of an inducible operon) holds three genes for proteins that take up lactose and break it down. Its repressor binds the operator by itself. When lactose is present, a molecule made from it (allolactose) binds the repressor, which changes shape and lets go.
  • In both, the repressor is a negative regulatory molecule: it lowers expression by binding DNA and blocking transcription.

Links across the course

  • A repressor changing shape when a small molecule binds it is the same idea as an enzyme changing shape when a regulator binds its allosteric site: see Unit 3, enzymes. The repressor itself is not an enzyme. It catalyzes nothing.
  • The trp operon is negative feedback: the product of a pathway shuts down the making of the pathway's own enzymes.

Beyond the course: glucose

  • E. coli uses glucose first. When glucose runs low, a small molecule called cAMP builds up and binds a protein called CAP. CAP then binds DNA beside the lac promoter and helps RNA polymerase bind, so the operon is transcribed much faster.
  • That is positive regulation: a regulatory protein that raises transcription. You do not need the names CAP and cAMP for the exam.

A mutation in the regulatory gene of the trp operon means that no repressor protein is made. What do you claim happens to the operon's genes when the cell has plenty of tryptophan?

A bacterium that needs five enzymes to make one amino acid needs all five at once or none at all. It solves this with an operon: the genes sit in a row behind a single promoter, where RNA polymerase binds, and a single operator, a regulatory sequence that works as the switch.

The switch is thrown by a repressor, a protein made from a regulatory gene that sits outside the operon. When the repressor is on the operator, RNA polymerase cannot transcribe the genes. Whether it is on the operator depends on its shape, and its shape depends on a small molecule.

The two examples run opposite ways. The trp operon makes tryptophan, and tryptophan is the molecule that lets its repressor bind: the more product, the less transcription. The lac operon deals with lactose, and a molecule made from lactose pulls its repressor off: no lactose, no need for the enzymes. Use the tool for trp first, then lac, and say what you expect before each change.

Two operons, two examples
Repressible (trp)Inducible (lac)
Usual stateonoff
Its enzymesbuild tryptophantake up and break down lactose
The small moleculetryptophan, the productmade from lactose, the substance to use
What it does to the repressorlets it bind the operatorpulls it off the operator
Resulttranscription stopstranscription starts
  • Operon: several genes, one promoter, one operator, one mRNA.
  • Repressible: usually on, switched off by its product.
  • Inducible: usually off, switched on by the substance it deals with.
Watch out A repressor blocks transcription. It does not destroy the gene or the mRNA, and it is not an enzyme.
trpRtrpEtrpDtrpCtrpBtrpAregulatorygenepromoteroperatorgenes for tryptophan enzymesenzymes madetrpRtrpEtrpDtrpCtrpBtrpAregulatorygenepromoteroperatorgenes for tryptophan enzymesno transcriptionlacIlacZlacYlacAregulatorygenepromoteroperatorgenes for lactose enzymesenzymes made
  1. The trp operon with no tryptophan in the medium: alone, its repressor does not fit the operator, so RNA polymerase transcribes the genes and the cell makes its own tryptophan.
  2. Tryptophan builds up and binds the repressor, which now fits the operator: transcription stops.
  3. The lac operon with lactose: lactose binds its repressor, which lets go of the operator, and the genes are transcribed.
The trp operon first, then the lac operon. Say what you expect, then add tryptophan or lactose and watch the repressor and RNA polymerase.

6.5.B Location and function

Where it sits explains what it does

  • The promoter is where RNA polymerase binds, so it lies just before the genes.
  • The operator lies in the polymerase's path, so a protein bound there blocks transcription.
  • The regulatory gene can sit anywhere, because its product is a protein that travels through the cell.
  • Mutating each part gives a different result, and the position of the part predicts it.

The detail

  • A regulatory sequence acts only on the DNA it is part of. Move an operator away from its genes and it controls nothing.
  • A regulatory protein is free to move. One working copy of a regulatory gene can supply repressor to an operator anywhere in the cell.
  • That is the pattern to look for in any question: is the mutated part a site on the DNA or the gene for a protein?

Try it

  • On the tool, mutate the regulatory gene of the lac operon. With no lactose, are the genes transcribed?
  • Put that back and mutate the operator. What is the same and what is different?
  • Do the same for the trp operon with tryptophan present. Write a claim for each before you look.

Watch out

  • "The operon is on" means its genes are being transcribed. It does not mean the repressor is present or absent: check where the repressor is.

A mutation changes the operator of the lac operon so that the repressor can no longer bind it. The repressor itself is normal. What do you claim about the operon's genes?

Every part of an operon is where it is for a reason, and the reason lets you predict what a mutation will do. The promoter is where RNA polymerase binds, so it must lie at the start of the genes. Damage it so the polymerase cannot bind and the genes are never transcribed, whatever the repressor is doing.

The operator lies between the promoter and the genes, in the polymerase's path. That is the only reason a repressor bound there stops transcription. An operator that the repressor cannot bind leaves the path clear all the time.

The regulatory gene is different. It is not a site: it codes for the repressor, and a protein moves through the cytoplasm until it meets its operator. So the regulatory gene can lie far from the operon and still control it. Lose it, and no repressor is made at all.

A stretch of DNA is moved so that the lac operon's regulatory gene now lies at the far end of the chromosome. Nothing else is changed. What do you claim?

Remember it Three parts, and what losing each one does

  • PromoterPolymerase bindslost: never transcribed
  • OperatorRepressor bindslost: cannot be switched off
  • Regulatory geneMakes the repressorlost: cannot be switched off
  • Promoter: where RNA polymerase binds.
  • Operator: in the polymerase's path, so a bound repressor blocks transcription.
  • A DNA site acts where it sits; a regulatory protein travels.
Watch out Two mutations can give the same result for different reasons. No repressor, and an operator the repressor cannot bind, both leave an operon on. Say which part failed and why.
lacIlacZlacYlacAregulatorygenepromoteroperatorgenes for lactose enzymesno transcriptionlacIlacZlacYlacAregulatorygenepromoteroperatorgenes for lactose enzymesenzymes madetrpRtrpEtrpDtrpCtrpBtrpAregulatorygenepromoteroperatorgenes for tryptophan enzymesno transcription
  1. The lac operon with no lactose: the repressor sits on the operator, and RNA polymerase cannot transcribe the genes.
  2. Lactose arrives and binds the repressor, which lets go of the operator: the genes are transcribed and the enzymes made.
  3. The trp operon with tryptophan: tryptophan activates its repressor, which binds the operator and switches the genes off.
The same two operons, now with mutations. Break the regulatory gene or the operator, predict, then add the small molecule and see whether the genes can still be switched.

6.5.A Epigenetic changes

Tags that open and close the DNA

  • A eukaryote has more places to regulate a gene. The first is whether the DNA can be reached at all.
  • DNA is wound on proteins called histones. Where it is packed tightly, a gene is hard to transcribe.
  • Epigenetic changes are chemical tags on the DNA or on the histones that change gene expression.
  • The base sequence is unchanged, and the changes are reversible.

Examples

  • Acetyl groups on histones (an example). They loosen the packing, so the DNA is easier to reach. Transcription usually rises.
  • Methyl groups on DNA (an example). Added to the DNA of a promoter, they usually lower transcription of its gene.
  • Enzymes add each tag and other enzymes take it off, which is what makes the changes reversible.

Watch out

  • Say "usually". Methyl groups can also be added to histones, and there they raise transcription at some sites and lower it at others.
  • Tightly packed DNA is transcribed little or not at all. Loosely packed DNA can be transcribed, but still needs the proteins of chapter 6 to switch it on.
  • An epigenetic change is not a mutation. A mutation changes the base sequence. A tag changes whether the sequence is read.

Gene H is studied in two kinds of cell from one person (invented data). In liver cells, 4 of the 50 sites tested in its promoter carry a methyl group, and its mRNA is plentiful. In skin cells, 46 of the 50 sites carry one, and no mRNA is found. The base sequence is identical. Which claim do the data support?

Bacteria regulate most genes at one point, the start of transcription. A eukaryotic cell has that point and several more, and the figure maps them: tap each card. The first comes before any protein reaches the gene. Can the DNA be reached?

In a eukaryote the DNA is wound around proteins called histones. Where the packing is tight, RNA polymerase and its helpers cannot get at a gene. Where it is loose, they can. Cells change the packing with small chemical tags. Acetyl groups on histones are one example: they loosen the packing, and transcription usually rises. Methyl groups on the DNA of a promoter are another: they usually lower transcription.

These are epigenetic changes. Two things define them. The base sequence of the gene is untouched, so the gene still says what it always said. And the tags can be taken off again, so the change is reversible. On the tool, add and remove tags and check the sequence each time.

  • Epigenetic changes: reversible modifications of DNA or histones.
  • They change whether a gene is read, never what it says.
  • Acetyl groups on histones usually raise transcription; methyl groups on promoter DNA usually lower it.
Watch out "Methylation switches genes off" is too simple. It is true of most methyl groups on promoter DNA. It is not a rule for every methyl group everywhere.
IN THE NUCLEUSIN THE CYTOPLASM1DNA packedor open2Transcriptionstarted or blocked3RNA splicedone way or another4mRNA kept,silenced or cut up5How muchprotein is made

Tap a card to see what can change at that point, and which chapter teaches it.

Five points at which a eukaryotic cell can regulate one gene, from the DNA to the finished protein.
promotergeneDNA packed more tightlyRNA polymerase binds; mRNA madeDNA packed looselyRNA polymerase binds; mRNA madeDNA packed looselyRNA polymerase cannot bind the promoter
  1. A gene with no tags: its promoter, and DNA wound on three groups of histones. It is transcribed a little.
  2. Acetyl tags on the histones loosen the packing: more mRNA.
  3. Methyl tags on the DNA of the promoter: RNA polymerase cannot bind and the gene is off. The base sequence has not changed.
One gene, its promoter and three histone bundles. Add and remove methyl and acetyl tags, watch the transcription, and check the base sequence each time.

6.6.A Transcription factors, promoters and enhancers

The proteins that start transcription

  • RNA polymerase and transcription factors bind promoter or enhancer sequences in the DNA to start transcription.
  • These sequences can be upstream or downstream of the transcription start site.
  • Negative regulatory molecules inhibit expression by binding DNA and blocking transcription.
  • A cell expresses a gene only if it holds the right set of transcription factors.

The detail

  • In eukaryotes RNA polymerase cannot bind a promoter by itself. Transcription factors bind first and the polymerase joins them.
  • Transcription factors that raise transcription are often called activators. Many bind enhancers, regulatory sequences that can lie thousands of base pairs from the gene, on either side of it or even inside it.
  • A distant enhancer still acts because DNA bends. The DNA loops, and the activators on the enhancer are brought next to the proteins at the promoter.
  • A gene can have several enhancers, each bound by its own factors. That is how one gene can be on in several tissues for different reasons.

Try it

  • On the tool, run the gene in each cell type first. Then delete one sequence at a time and predict before every run.
  • Is deleting the downstream enhancer any different from deleting the upstream one?
  • In the film, take the transcription factor away. What does RNA polymerase do?

Watch out

  • "Upstream" and "downstream" are measured from the transcription start site: upstream is before it, downstream is after it, in the direction RNA polymerase travels.

A deletion removes an enhancer that lies 20,000 base pairs downstream of a gene's transcription start site. The promoter and the coding sequence are untouched. What do you claim?

In a eukaryote, open DNA is not enough. RNA polymerase needs transcription factors to start. Some bind the promoter, the stretch of DNA at the start of the gene, and RNA polymerase joins them there. With those alone, transcription is slow.

Other transcription factors bind an enhancer. An enhancer can be far from its gene, and it can be upstream or downstream of the transcription start site. It works because the DNA loops, bringing the factors on the enhancer to the promoter. Transcription then runs much faster. A negative regulatory molecule does the opposite: it binds the DNA and blocks transcription, as the repressor did in an operon.

Put those together and you have the answer to chapter 1. Every cell has the gene, its promoter and its enhancers. Only some cells hold the transcription factors that fit them. A gene is on in the cells with the right set, and off, or barely on, in the rest.

  • Transcription factors are proteins; promoters and enhancers are DNA.
  • An enhancer need not be next to its gene, and can be on either side of the start site.
  • Negative regulatory molecules bind DNA and block transcription.
Watch out An enhancer does not make anything. It is a place on the DNA. The activator that binds it is the protein, made from a gene of its own.
enhancerpromotergeneenhancerpromotergenemRNA madenothing bound: no transcriptionmRNA madetranscription factorsRNA polymerasemRNA madeactivatorpromotergeneenhancermRNA maderepressorkept offNUCLEUS
  1. A gene with its promoter, and an enhancer further along the DNA.
  2. Transcription factors bind the promoter and RNA polymerase joins them.
  3. An activator binds the enhancer and the DNA loops: far more mRNA.
  4. A repressor, a negative regulatory molecule, binds near the promoter: RNA polymerase is kept off.
promoternot transcribedgenetranscribedRNA polymerasetranscription factorscannot bindtranscription factors boundRNA beginsRNA polymerase
The promoter (pale pink band) is DNA just before the gene. Its bumps are where transcription factors fit.
ABRgeneenhancer 1enhancer 2promoterrepressor sitestart siteIn the nucleus of cell type 1RNA polymerasemRNA made: ?ABRgeneenhancer 1enhancer 2promoterrepressor sitestart siteIn the nucleus of cell type 1mRNA made: 5ABRgeneenhancer 1enhancer 2promoterrepressor sitestart siteIn the nucleus of cell type 3RNA polymerasemRNA made: ?
  1. One invented gene, as a model: a promoter at its start, an enhancer far upstream and another far downstream, and a site for a repressor. Cell type 1 makes activators A and B.
  2. Each activator binds its own enhancer, the DNA loops, and both help RNA polymerase start at the promoter: a lot of mRNA.
  3. Cell type 3 makes both activators and a repressor that fits the site beside the promoter. Predict: is the gene off, barely on, low or high?
A model gene with a promoter and two enhancers, in three kinds of cell. Predict how strongly each cell expresses it, run it, then delete a sequence or a factor and predict again.
Transcription from the guide on 6.3, with one control. Take the transcription factor away and watch RNA polymerase at the promoter.

6.5.B Coordinate regulation in eukaryotes

One signal, many genes

  • Prokaryotes and eukaryotes both have groups of genes that are regulated together.
  • Eukaryotic genes are not grouped in operons. Each gene has its own promoter.
  • Genes that share a regulatory sequence answer to the same transcription factor, wherever they are in the genome.
  • So one signal can switch on a whole set of genes at once.

The detail

  • The genes of a set can lie on different chromosomes. What they share is a copy of the same short sequence in an enhancer or near the promoter.
  • When the transcription factor that fits that sequence becomes active, it binds every copy, and every gene in the set is transcribed.
  • Location still explains function: the shared sequence sits where a bound factor can act on that gene's promoter.

Examples

  • A steroid hormone (an example, in the figure). Estrogen passes through the cell membrane and binds a receptor protein inside the cell. Hormone and receptor together act as a transcription factor.
  • Only cells that make the receptor respond, and in those cells every gene with the matching sequence responds.

Links across the course

  • Most signals never enter the cell. They bind a receptor in the membrane, and a signal transduction pathway carries the message inward. Many pathways end at a transcription factor: see Unit 4, cell communication.

Genes P, Q and R lie on three different chromosomes. P and R each have a copy of the same enhancer sequence; Q does not. A signal activates the transcription factor that binds that sequence. What do you predict?

An operon switches several genes at once by putting them behind one promoter. Eukaryotes regulate genes in groups too, in a different way. Their genes each have a promoter of their own and may lie on different chromosomes. What the genes of a group share is a regulatory sequence that fits the same transcription factor.

When that factor becomes active, it binds every copy of the sequence, and all the genes with a copy are transcribed. One signal, one factor, many genes. The figure shows one way a signal reaches the DNA: a steroid hormone enters the cell and binds a receptor, and the pair acts as a transcription factor.

This is how a cell changes many things together. A cell that receives a hormone does not switch on one gene. It switches on a set, and the set is written into the DNA as copies of one sequence.

  • Prokaryotes: operons, inducible or repressible.
  • Eukaryotes: genes with the same regulatory sequence are influenced by the same transcription factor.
  • One transcription factor can switch on many genes at once.
Watch out Eukaryotic genes that are regulated together do not have to be next to each other, and they are not transcribed as one mRNA.
promotergeneBLOODNUCLEUSestrogena steroidmembranea proteinreceptortranscription factorgene on
  1. Estrogen, a steroid, passes through the cell membrane.
  2. It binds a receptor protein inside the cell.
  3. Together they act as a transcription factor: they bind DNA and switch the gene on.
ABRgeneenhancer 1enhancer 2promoterrepressor sitestart siteIn the nucleus of cell type 1RNA polymerasemRNA made: ?ABRgeneenhancer 1enhancer 2promoterrepressor sitestart siteIn the nucleus of cell type 1mRNA made: 5ABRgeneenhancer 1enhancer 2promoterrepressor sitestart siteIn the nucleus of cell type 3RNA polymerasemRNA made: ?
  1. One invented gene, as a model: a promoter at its start, an enhancer far upstream and another far downstream, and a site for a repressor. Cell type 1 makes activators A and B.
  2. Each activator binds its own enhancer, the DNA loops, and both help RNA polymerase start at the promoter: a lot of mRNA.
  3. Cell type 3 makes both activators and a repressor that fits the site beside the promoter. Predict: is the gene off, barely on, low or high?
Three model genes on three chromosomes. Tick the genes you expect to respond, then add the signal.

6.6.B Regulation after transcription

Silencing a message after it is made

  • Gene regulation gives differential gene expression and so changes a cell's products and functions.
  • Regulation does not end at transcription. An mRNA can be spliced in different ways, and can last a long or a short time.
  • Certain small RNA molecules have roles in regulating gene expression.
  • A small RNA can pair with a matching mRNA, which is then broken down or not translated: less protein from the same transcription.

The detail

  • Alternative splicing, met with transcription in topic 6.3: the exons of one pre-mRNA can be joined in different combinations, so one gene can give different proteins in different cells.
  • How long an mRNA lasts: an mRNA is translated again and again until it is broken down. One that lasts for hours gives far more protein than one that lasts for minutes.

Examples

  • MicroRNAs (an example of small RNAs) are about 22 nucleotides long. Each is held by proteins and pairs with mRNAs that carry a matching sequence.
  • If the match is close, the mRNA is cut. If it is partial, the mRNA is translated less and is usually broken down sooner.
  • The discovery that double-stranded RNA silences a matching gene (RNA interference) won Andrew Fire and Craig Mello the Nobel Prize in 2006, and the discovery of microRNAs won Victor Ambros and Gary Ruvkun the prize in 2024.

Reading the data

  • mRNA differs between two cells: look for regulation at transcription (or in how long the mRNA lasts).
  • mRNA is the same and protein differs: the regulation is after transcription.

A transcribed gene is not yet an expressed one. Between the mRNA and the protein there are more points of control, and they are cards 3 to 5 on the map in chapter 5. The pre-mRNA can be spliced in more than one way. The finished mRNA can last minutes or days, and the longer it lasts, the more times it is translated.

The cell can also silence an mRNA it has already made. Certain small RNA molecules do not code for any protein. A small RNA, held in a protein complex, pairs with an mRNA that has a matching stretch of bases. That mRNA is then cut up, or it stays whole and ribosomes do not translate it. Either way the gene has been transcribed and little protein appears.

This gives you a way to find where a gene is regulated. Measure both its mRNA and its protein. If two cells differ in mRNA, look at transcription. If the mRNA is the same and the protein is not, the control comes later.

  • Certain small RNA molecules regulate gene expression.
  • A small RNA pairs with a matching mRNA: the mRNA is broken down or left untranslated.
  • Equal mRNA and unequal protein means regulation after transcription.
Watch out A small RNA does not switch the gene off. The gene is still transcribed. What changes is how much protein comes from each mRNA.

Two kinds of cell are compared for gene R (invented data, in units). mRNA: 10.2 in the first and 10.0 in the second. Protein: 9.8 in the first and 2.1 in the second. Which claim do the data support?

An mRNA being translatedmRNAribosomeproteinmadeA small RNA finds its matchmRNAsmall RNA, held ina protein complexits bases pair with a matchingstretch of the mRNAThen one of two things happensThe mRNA is cut andbroken down.Or the mRNA stays wholeand is not translated.Either way, less protein from the same mRNA.
  1. An mRNA in the cytoplasm. Ribosomes move along it and each makes a copy of the protein.
  2. A small RNA, held in a protein complex, pairs with a stretch of the mRNA whose bases match it.
  3. The mRNA is cut and broken down, or it stays whole and is not translated. Less protein is made.
how long an mRNA lasts05010001224mRNA left (%)hours after the gene is switched offhalf gonein 12 hourshalf gonein 30 minutesprotein made12 h30 min
  1. After a gene is switched off, one mRNA is half gone in 30 minutes, the other only after 12 hours.
  2. Protein is made the whole time an mRNA lasts: far more from the long-lived one.

6.5.A Differentiation and development

Genes switched on in order

  • Cell differentiation can be seen: it results from the expression of genes for tissue-specific proteins.
  • During development, transcription factors are induced one after another.
  • Each factor switches on genes that include the next factor, so genes are expressed in sequence.
  • The function and the amount of the gene products determine the phenotype.

The detail

  • A cell in an embryo receives signals from its neighbors. A signal induces a transcription factor: the gene for the factor is switched on.
  • That factor binds the regulatory sequences of a set of genes. One of the set codes for another transcription factor, which switches on the next set.
  • The last sets are the genes for the proteins that do the tissue's work. Once a cell is making them it looks and behaves like that tissue.

Examples

  • Muscle (an example, and the model in the figure). In embryos a transcription factor called MyoD commits a cell to become muscle. It switches on genes for other muscle transcription factors, and these switch on the genes for the proteins that let a muscle cell contract. You do not need the name for the exam.

Beyond the course

  • Homeotic genes code for transcription factors that set which structure forms where along the body of an animal. Work on them in fruit flies won the Nobel Prize in 1995.
  • Apoptosis, programmed cell death, shapes parts of an embryo. Your fingers and toes are separate because the cells between them died on schedule.

In the model in the figure, a signal induces transcription factor 1, factor 1 switches on the gene for factor 2, and factor 2 switches on the genes for muscle proteins. A mutation destroys the gene for factor 2. What do you claim happens when the signal arrives?

Chapter 1 asked how one fertilized egg gives a neuron and a muscle cell. Here is the answer in full. Differentiation is something you can observe, because it is the cell making the proteins of its tissue: contractile proteins in muscle, hemoglobin in a developing red blood cell. Those proteins appear because their genes are switched on.

They are switched on in order. Early in development a signal induces a transcription factor in some cells and not in others. That factor switches on a set of genes, and one of them codes for a second transcription factor, which switches on the next set. Step through the model: each step depends on the one before, so the genes are expressed in sequence.

The stages map returns under the model, this time with a question on each card. If you can answer all five, you can explain how cells with the same genome end up with different amounts of different proteins, and why that sets their phenotype.

Remember it Five places a eukaryotic cell can regulate a gene, in order

  • PackingCan it be reached?tags open or close the DNA
  • TranscriptionDoes it start?factors start it or block it
  • SplicingWhich mRNA?one gene, more than one mRNA
  • The mRNADoes it last?kept, silenced or broken down
  • ProteinHow much?function and amount set the phenotype
  • Differentiation: cells expressing genes for tissue-specific proteins.
  • Induced transcription factors give sequential gene expression in development.
  • The function and amount of gene products determine the phenotype.
Watch out A differentiated cell has not thrown genes away. It still holds the genes for every other tissue, switched off.
From a fertilized egg to a ball of cells, then signals switch on different genes in different cells and three kinds of cell appear.
day 0: a zygotedays 1 to 3: it dividesday 5: a blastocysta signal spreadscells differentiatezona pellucidanucleusa set from eachparentday 01234day 5twofoureight cellsall alike: unspecializedday 01234day 5inner cell masswill form the bodyouter layerhelps form theplacentacavityday 01234day 5signal: highlowsourcegene A ongene B ongene C onevery cell has genes A, B and Ceach switches on what its signal level saysgene A ongene B ongene C onnervecellmusclecellred bloodcell
  1. A zygote: one cell, with one set of chromosomes from each parent.
  2. It divides by mitosis. The first cells are all alike: unspecialized.
  3. About five days on, a hollow ball of cells. The inner cells will form the body.
  4. A signal spreads from one end. Each cell reads its concentration and switches on different genes.
  5. Different genes, different cells: they differentiate into nerve, muscle and blood cells.
One cell, followed through time(a model)signalgene for factor 1factor 1genegenegene for factor 2genegenegene for factor 2factor 2genegenegenegenegenegenemuscle proteinsprecursor cellit looks like no tissue in particular yetmuscle celllong, striped, able to contract
  1. A model. A signal reaches a precursor cell and induces transcription factor 1. The genes below are present and still off.
  2. Factor 1 switches on a set of genes. One of them codes for transcription factor 2.
  3. Factor 2 switches on the genes for the tissue's own proteins: here, muscle proteins.
  4. Full of those proteins, the cell is now visibly a muscle cell. In real muscle, MyoD is an early factor of this kind.
IN THE NUCLEUSIN THE CYTOPLASM1DNA packedor open2Transcriptionstarted or blocked3RNA splicedone way or another4mRNA kept,silenced or cut up5How muchprotein is made

Tap a card for a question. Answer it aloud or on paper before you tap the next.

The stages map again, as a check. Each card asks a question that the guide has answered.

02Dry lab: Twins and tags

Identical twins share every base of their DNA. Test their methyl tags at different ages, for twins who grew up together and twins who lived apart, then compare children breathing low and high air pollution.

ABLIVED APARTAGE 30ABbloodCG SITESmethyl tagABsites differ18.0 %
The bench: identical twins, and on the reader a stretch of each twin's DNA. A pink bead is a methylated CG site; yellow marks a site where the twins differ. Test pairs of each age, together and apart, and compare.
Your questionDo the methyl tags of identical twins grow more different as they age, and more so if they live apart? Does air pollution change the tags on one immune-system gene? Make a prediction for each before you test.
What you can changeFor the twins, their age and whether they lived most of their lives together or apart. For the children, how much air pollution they live with. Each Test is a new sample of five, so testing again is how you repeat.
What to recordFor each pair, the percentage of tested sites where the twins differ; for each child, the percentage of promoter sites methylated. Then the mean for each group. The results are invented to show the method, following the patterns of the real studies.

Find out

  • Twins and age. Test at least five pairs at each age who lived together. How does the percentage of differing sites change as the twins get older?
  • Together or apart. At 15, 30 and 50, test five pairs who lived apart. Is the difference between together and apart bigger in older twins?
  • Air pollution. Test ten children from each level of air pollution. Is the promoter more methylated where pollution is high, and by how much?
  • How sure? Look at the spread in each group. Do the ranges overlap? Test more until you can say whether a difference is real.
  • Claim and evidence. Write one sentence of claim about the environment and gene expression, then two sentences of evidence from your own table.

Record

  • For each pair or child: the group and the percentage. The table fills as you test, and the graph shows every point with the group's mean as a bar.
  • A mean for each group, and the range.
  • What the data show, and what they cannot show by themselves: the twins' base sequences are the same throughout, and a link with pollution is not yet proof that pollution causes the tags.
  • Download the CSV to keep your table and plot your own graph.

Twin pairs aged 3 differ at about 3 percent of sites, and pairs aged 50 at about 15 percent. Which claim do those data support best?

Why does testing identical twins, and not any two people of the same age, make the effect of the environment clear?

Children in high air pollution have more methyl groups on the promoter of one immune gene. What would you expect of the gene's expression?

Claim and evidence

Make a claim about whether the environment can change the expression of a gene without changing its base sequence. Support it with evidence from your results.

03Check

A fresh paper from the exam bank on this guide's topics each time: past-paper style questions, marked as you go, and saved to your Exam practice progress when you are signed in.

Exam practice

Exam questions on 6.5 and 6.6, marked

Start 15 marks of exam questionsYour exam practice

Quiz: gene regulationUnit 6 escape roomGrass skirts: regulating gene expressionRevision map: regulation of gene expressionRevision map: gene expression and cell specializationBlurting diagrams: an inducible operon, eukaryotic gene regulationUnit 6 pub quizGuide: enzymes and allosteric regulationGuide: cell communicationUnit 6 practice questions

04Downloads

Take the guide with you, or into a classroom with no internet.

05Teacher resources

The guide as four one-hour lessons: what each covers, its focus and the chapters it uses.

LessonCoversFocusChaptersLesson planSlides
1Switches and operons 6.5.A, 6.5.B60 min Differential gene expression, constitutive and inducible genes, regulatory sequences and proteins, and the repressible and inducible operons 1, 2, 3
2An operon in your hands, then opening the DNA 6.5.B, 6.5.A60 min How the location of the promoter, the operator and the regulatory gene explains what each does, mutations of each, and epigenetic changes to DNA and histones 4, 5
3Tags as evidence, then transcription factors 6.5.A, 6.6.A60 min Methylation data as evidence for a claim, then transcription factors, promoters and enhancers upstream or downstream of the start site, and negative regulatory molecules 6, dry lab
4One signal, after transcription, development 6.5.B, 6.6.B, 6.5.A60 min Genes that share a transcription factor, regulation after transcription and small RNAs read from mRNA and protein data, sequential gene expression in development, and a map of the whole topic 7, 8, 9

The revision sheet and the offline copy are in Downloads, for you and the class.

PRACTICE AND REVIEW

Make it for your class, or set it

Build for your class

Already on the site for Unit 6

Card sets on splycr

Open a set to host it as a class game, or make a copy to edit.

How this was made. The course structure, the activities and the teaching choices come from my own classroom, my presentations and my years of teaching IB and AP Biology. I use Claude, an AI, to help write and build the interactive guides, lesson plans, slides and practice questions, and to draw the diagrams and code the interactives. I direct the work and review it against the IB and AP specifications before it goes live. Sources and acknowledgements.