Biology  by Bradford
support
← Moderation

Example A · 17 · Example B · 14 vs 13 · Example C · 13

Example B · a real HL script, names removed

The annotated script.

Caffeine and amylase (HL)“What is the effect of caffeine quantity in the range of 0 mg to 200 mg by increments of 50 mg on starch-amylase hydrolysis as measured by the absorbance value (Au)?”

Page 1 of 16

Page 1 of the script
  1. Research design · first strand

    The range and increments of the independent variable are given. The source of the amylase and the wavelength are not.

Page 2 of 16

Page 2 of the script
  1. Research design · first strand

    This source does not appear in the works cited.

  2. Research design · first strand

    Relevant mechanism from a published source, explained in some detail.

Page 3 of 16

Page 3 of the script
  1. Research design · second strand

    The pilot with plant extracts is described and the reason for abandoning it is given. A positive point.

Page 4 of 16

Page 4 of the script
  1. Research design · second strand

    Some justification for the upper limit of the range.

Page 5 of 16

Page 5 of the script
  1. Research design · third strand

    The bath is set at 34 °C but the justification refers to 37 °C.

  2. Research design · third strand

    The materials list 0.025% iodine and 3 drops. Which was used?

  3. Research design · second strand

    Over 6 g of tablet powder in 3 ml of starch solution. Most of the tablet is filler, and no control for the filler is included.

Page 6 of 16

Page 6 of the script
  1. Research design · second strand

    The choice of wavelength is not justified (about 599 nm is stated later).

Page 7 of 16

Page 7 of the script

Page 8 of 16

Page 8 of the script
  1. Data analysis · first strand

    3.000 appears to be the upper limit of the instrument. Several before readings are off scale, so the changes calculated from them are underestimates.

  2. Data analysis · first strand

    The caption does not match the method, where B is read before the 10 minute incubation.

Page 9 of 16

Page 9 of the script

Page 10 of 16

Page 10 of the script
  1. Data analysis · first strand

    Appropriate graph with SD bars identified. The y-axis shows change in absorbance, not absorbance, and the unit is missing.

Page 11 of 16

Page 11 of the script

Page 12 of 16

Page 12 of the script
  1. Data analysis · third strand

    A post-hoc Tukey test follows the ANOVA and the calculation reproduces. A good point.

Page 13 of 16

Page 13 of the script
  1. Data analysis · third strand/conclusion, first strand

    No pairwise difference is significant, so the null hypothesis is not rejected.

  2. Data analysis · third strand

    Ten uncorrected t-tests after a Tukey test do not confirm it. The values are p-values, not critical values.

Page 14 of 16

Page 14 of the script
  1. Conclusion · first strand

    A misunderstanding of the significance level.

  2. Conclusion · first strand/second strand

    This contradicts the previous paragraph, and the source of the amylase is not stated anywhere in the method.

Page 15 of 16

Page 15 of the script
  1. Evaluation · second strand

    A specific improvement linked to the sample size used in the analysis.

  2. Evaluation · first strand

    A relevant weakness specific to this method, with its effect on the readings explained.

  3. Evaluation · first strand

    Not a methodological weakness.

Page 16 of 16

Page 16 of the script

Moderate one of yours

Your marks checked blind, the criterion comments written, and the script annotated like this one. Your first moderation is free.

Try it on a script →